Did People Used To Look Older

Matters That Matter
38 followers
Jan 6, 2025 #Education
Hey Vsauce. Michael here. At the age of 18, Carl Sagan looked like a teenager.
But it doesn't take long in an old high school yearbook to find teenagers who look surprisingly
old. These people are all in their 20s. But so are these people. This is Elizabeth Taylor
when she was just 17. And here are some high school students from the 70s.
Did people used to look older? Brandon McCarthy asked on Twitter and evidence poured in. People
shared photos of their parents in their early 20s, their dad at 21, their mom at 18 or 19,
their dad at 45. One user shared their husband at 27 and what his father looked like at 23.
And there's pretty much an entire subculture around how old footballers looked decades ago.
24, 31, 33, 29, 27. It's not uncommon to think that there's something more grown up about the
way people used to be. To look back and think that people seemed older at a younger age than they do
now. Let's call it retrospective aging. It doesn't happen to everyone. People do not and never have
aged similarly. And there's even the opposite observation that kids these days grow up too fast.
But it's a popular question and subject of numerous memes. So, is it real? Or is it an illusion
fueled by cherry-picked examples that feeds rosy nostalgia for a time when people were
tough and didn't have it as easy as you kids have it now? Well, as it turns out,
both. Humans today really are aging more slowly than their historic counterparts.
Changes in lifestyle, nutrition, smoking habits, health care, early life conditions and skin care,
particularly the use of sunscreen, are a huge part of it. By comparing measures of metabolic,
cardiovascular, inflammatory, kidney, liver and lung function across time, researchers at Yale
and USC have found that we are, in fact, staying younger for longer than we used to. So, does that
mean that 60 is the new 50? Almost. Their results suggest that between the early 90s and the late
2000s, 60 became the new 56, 40 became the new 37 and a half and 20 became the new 19. Oh, also,
during the last century, dentistry and orthodontics have played a huge cosmetic role in the kinds of
faces we see in parts of the world. But, interestingly, when faces in magazines are
measured from the 1930s to today, the only significant change has been that across all
ethnicities, the media is now exposing us to larger lips. Also, retroactive aging can occur
over short time spans. When I was a freshman, the seniors in my high school seemed so old to me.
But by the time I was a senior myself, I looked in the mirror and at my peers and I was like,
we're them now, but we don't seem as old as they did. What's going on isn't just about bodies.
First of all, the seniors I looked at when I was a freshman truly were older than me at that time.
They graduated and went away. And later, when I was a senior, I saw myself as I was. But in my
mind's eye, I saw the earlier seniors as they appeared to me when I was younger. Retrospective
aging seems to also be about perspective. Let's go back to this tweet. This is George Wendt playing
Norm on the TV show Cheers. Now, when Cheers premiered, Wendt was indeed 34, but I looked it
up and this image is actually from episode 24 of season 5 when Wendt was 38. So we're not comparing
apples to apples here. However, this is an image of George Wendt at 34 and Ashley Fairbanks made
some alterations and a good point. However, here's the rub. These alterations don't make Wendt look
more like a 30-40 year old. They make him look more like a 30-40 year old today. Similarly, giving
the golden girls modern day hairstyles and makeup drops their apparent age a lot. Superficial styles
and mannerisms can often make not just a big difference, but all the difference. Which supports
the hypothesis that retrospective aging is often an illusion. Modes of self-expression are always
changing. Clothing, hairstyles, accessories, makeup, mannerisms, language, body language.
Now, modes can come back, but never exactly. The context is always a little bit different.
And from what's available or acceptable at any one time, we each draw ways of appearing or being in
the world. And even if you don't care about how you look or think about how you act, what options
you even have are dictated by what's currently popular or normal or being pushed on people like
you. Few of us stay at the stream, drawing what's new all our lives. For various reasons, we often
wander away with our catch. Perhaps it's because we settle into an identity we're comfortable with
or fear the taboo of not dressing our age or simply run out of time to care. But when we're gone,
the stream keeps changing and we get older and continue to use the mannerisms and styles we
grabbed a while back. Eventually, to whatever those styles initially evoked, a new connotation
is added. Old person. Not because the look or behavior is intrinsically for the elderly,
but because those who use it, us, became old ourselves. If you wanna look older, what do you do?
Well, you can dress the way older people dress. And the thing is, that's often how they used to
dress too. We think people looked older in the past because they look the way old people do today.
Dale Irby, a gym teacher at Preston Wood Elementary School in Dallas, Texas, posed for his first
yearbook photo in 1973. The following year, he accidentally wore the same outfit again.
He says he was embarrassed at first, but his wife Kathy challenged him to do it again.
So he did. And he never stopped. What he gave us is a great, exaggerated example of how what
once connoted youth comes to be associated with old age. The people we keep seeing a style on
get older and older themselves until we think of the style itself as being for old people.
Retrospective aging, then, is double-pronged, both real and illusory. People in the past
really did age faster than us because of differences in nutrition and lifestyle and
medicine. But much, if not most, can be chalked up to the fact that we think people like this
are dressed like old people. But that's an anachronism. They're dressed like old people
from the future. The old people they would become. Has anyone ever dressed like a young
person from the future? Well, it happened in 1941 at the reopening of the South Fork Bridge
in Canada. A crowd came out to celebrate and photos were taken. In 2010, the photos were
digitized and placed online. That's when this guy was noticed. A time traveling hipster.
Why a time traveler wouldn't bother to blend in and why, with all of history to visit,
he chose the reopening of a bridge in the 40s? No one knew. The photo was confirmed
to be undoctored and researchers put forward the idea that this man was not, in fact, a time traveler.
That his shirt wasn't an ironic screen print but simply bore the logo of the Montreal Maroons,
a nearby hockey team at the time. They said his sunglasses and knit sweater were not unusual for
the 40s, nor was his portable camera. The only thing that was unusual about him was how casual
his attire was. And they're probably right. But this all raises the exciting possibility that
someone out there right now, possibly even you, is unknowingly dressed like people in the future
will. And your appearance in photos will someday freak them out. You know, it might be fun to start
dressing even more casually or in some other odd way on the off chance that you happen to nail it
and years from now you are worshipped as a time traveler. Oh, that reminds me of today's sponsor.
Hi, I'm Michael Stephens. Would you like to look like you're from the future? Well, every season
those who subscribe to Vsauce's Curiosity Box receive a box full of delicious brain food that
we have made that very few people have. Yet. This year our summer box contains our moiré illusion
cards, a bunch of other things I won't spoil, and this. A Pythagorean cup. Supposedly invented by
Pythagoras himself, it is widely considered the earliest known practical joke. It works just like
a normal cup. Fill it up, carry it around, take a drink. Refreshing. But it punishes greed. If you
pour yourself too much, the internal siphon will drain the entire contents. Greed is good, more like
greed is wet. A portion of all proceeds from the Vsauce Curiosity Box go directly to Alzheimer's
research. So this box isn't just good for your brain, it's good for everyone's brain. And we've
got a special treat for you. While supplies last, if you subscribe to the Curiosity Box, you can
choose a bundle of some of our favorite items from past boxes that we will throw in for free. Just pay
shipping. If you're not subscribed yet, I'm ready for you. With open arms and open neurons. Wow.
Whoa! Who's that guy? Does he look like a Bill, a Mark, a Justin, or a Josh? Pause right now if
you'd like to think about it. According to research from Millsaps College in Miami University,
this is Mark. Or, at least, this is what we think people named Mark look like. By asking people to
make and rate digitally created faces, researchers were able to put together prototypical faces for
a number of different names. This is apparently what we think a Josh looks like. A Bill, a Justin,
a Dan, a Brian, a Tom, an Andy. The idea that names might conjure certain face shapes in our minds
isn't that strange. For example, there's Wolfgang Kohler's famous finding that when asked which of
these shapes is named Booba and which is named Kiki, people of all different ages and cultures
and languages overwhelmingly assign Kiki to the spiky one and Booba to the blobby one. And sure
enough, it certainly seems to work with names too. Which one of these men is Tim and which is Bob?
Well, almost unanimously people feel like this is Tim and this is Bob. But are these men actually
named Tim and Bob? Well, there's the rub. Just because we associate certain names, certain
sounds with certain shapes doesn't mean we're right. There's no such thing as a biological
name. If a person still goes by the same name they were given as a baby, long before anyone
knew what they would look like as an adult, well, surely there won't be a connection.
But as it turns out, there is. Believe it or not, in a multiple choice setting, people can guess a
stranger's name just by looking at their face. More often than we would expect from luck alone.
It's called the face name matching effect. Here's a stimulus from Zwebner's research.
Do you think this man is named Jacob, Dan, Joseph, or Nathaniel? By just randomly picking a name,
people should get this right 25% of the time. But Zwebner found that people picked the correct
answer, Dan, nearly 40% of the time. What's going on? Can names actually cause us to grow to look
a certain way? Well, apparently they can. It has been called a Dorian Gray effect. In Oscar Wilde's
The Picture of Dorian Gray, a portrait of the protagonist ages and grotesquely reflects his
evil deeds while he himself remains young and pure-looking. In a similar way, it seems that in
some cases, our own appearance can come to reflect the name we were given. But I kind of think it's
really more of a reverse Dorian Gray effect. I mean, in the book, Dorian's reality affects the
appearance of his portrait. But the face name matching effect goes the other way. A inanimate
sign, a name, influences our actual physical appearance. Well, anyway, it's not news that a
person's name can lead others to have certain expectations of them and treat them accordingly.
It's been found, for example, that multiracial faces given European names are rated as looking
more European than the same faces are when presented with non-European names. The expectations
a name carries with it may create a self-fulfilling prophecy, whereby, as a person grows up, they're
motivated to fulfill those expectations, carry themselves in ways people think someone with
their name should, and even like, dislike, accentuate, hide, use, and avoid different parts
of their face and body depending on whether or not those parts match their name. It's been found
that faces and names that match are emotionally liked more than faces and names that don't.
Analysis of voting data has shown that senatorial candidates earn 10% more votes when their names
fit their faces very well than when they fit very poorly. Now, with that in mind, part of the effect
could literally come from the fact that although parents don't know what their kid will look like
as an adult, the parents do know what they look like and, without knowing it, tend to prefer names
that match their faces, which are likely to resemble their child's face as well. But not always.
If the dissonance is too great, a person can always change their name either completely or by
simply choosing a nickname. If I had been just a little bit different, I, Michael, could have always
gone by Mike. The fact that people can adjust their names to fit them, of course, merely strengthens
the face name matching effect. By studying whether the correct name could be guessed
when different parts of a face were occluded, researchers were able to develop heat maps
showing which parts of the face different names are most characteristically associated with.
Apparently, looking like an Anne is all about the tip of the nose. It's the bridge of the nose for
Arthurs and the philtrum, or snot trough, for Benjamins. Aurelis are recognized by their face
spiders. Let's go back to old people. How old is an old person? 73.7. That's according to results
published in the Journal of American Geriatrics last year. It's the average age people gave when
asked, when does old age begin? People under 65 on average said 71 and people over 65 on average
said 77. Women said old age began three years later than men did. White people said it began
eight years later than non-whites did and people who felt healthy placed old age later in life
than those who felt less healthy. But how old do people want to be? Well, that depends on how old
they already are. In America, the only people who are the age they would like to be are 21-year-olds.
People younger than 21 wish they were older and people older than 21 wish they were younger.
People who are 40 wish they were 30. People who are 60 wish they were 40 and people who are 90
wish they were 60. When people are asked if they could be one age forever, the average American
picks 36, which is actually how old I am right now, funny enough. Here's something else that's funny.
Old people are more likely to think they dream in black and white. Not because it's part of the
aging process but because they are veterans of the great black and white dream epidemic
of the 20th century. Prior to the 1900s, Aristotle, Descartes, Freud, everyone who wrote about the
topic reported that dreams contained color. But as humanity moved into the 20th century, the number
of people reporting color in their dreams dropped just as quickly as the popularity of new black
and white movies and TV rose. By the 60s, as color TV and movies became more and more common, reports
of colored dreams started going back up. And today, people who grew up with black and white TV
continue to report more black and white dreams than those who didn't. And later studies across
China found the same thing. The frequency of black and white dreaming correlated strongly
with how common black and white TV was in a person's area. So, did black and white movies
and TV literally change our dreams? Well, first of all, it's not clear whether dreams themselves
actually changed or if people just started thinking differently about their dreams.
We're trying but we still haven't found a way to get direct access to dream content. Eric
Switchtable has pointed out that as far as we know, dreams may not be in color or black and white
or sepia or anything. They may be primarily indeterminate in color as they happen and only
later, during recall, do we confabulate details about color. He compares dreaming to reading.
Is a novel in color or black and white? As you read a story, what do you see in your mind?
It might be the case that dreams, vaporous as they are, are something we simply have a terrible
grip on and that movies and TV shows have given us the illusion of understanding them. In fact,
Switchtable has speculated that smells and touch sensations are rare in dreams today but future
people with smelly, touchy-feely VR shows might think that they dream with lots of textures and
odors and find it strange. Maybe even frightening that few of us seem to. But why would we think
that dreams were like moving pictures and not normal waking life? Well, no one knows. It might
be that motion pictures are just simply the closest thing we have to dreaming that isn't
dreaming. Unlike still images, paintings, photographs, tapestries, motion pictures and
dreams can contain movement and narrative and cause and effect. And, unlike stage plays or
real life, motion pictures and dreams are not made of anything that is even remotely similar
to what they depict. They're both made of phantoms. Images are uncanny things. A person in an image
is frozen in time but yet can seem to grow old. Our own image can depend on what we are called
and they're the closest thing we have to what our mind does when we're away.
Do you get the picture? Or does the picture get you? And, as always, thanks for watching.
