Did Moses Exist?

Moses
70 followers
14 Video Views·Dec 21, 2022
Welcome to a very special collaboration between Useful Charts, Let's Talk Religion,
and Al-Muqaddimah. In this series of three videos, we will be exploring whether or not the following
three religious figures existed in real life – Moses, Jesus, and Muhammad. In this video,
I'll be discussing Moses, Let's Talk Religion will be discussing Jesus, and Al-Muqaddimah will
be discussing Muhammad. In each case, we'll be looking at things from a historical perspective
and focusing on what evidence is available for each religious figure outside of religious
tradition. So, after watching this video, I recommend that you check out the other two
videos as well. I'll leave a link in the description or you can simply click on the
next video at the end of this one. Intro
Let's start by asking the question, how do we know that anyone in history really existed?
Well, the best evidence would be, of course, to find a person's physical remains. So,
take for example, King Richard III of England. According to the historical record, he died in
1485 during the Battle of Bosworth Field, after which he was supposedly buried at a small church
in the nearby town of Leicester. However, over time, the exact location was forgotten
and thus became unknown. That is, until 2012, when researchers found his skeleton under a
parking lot. Using radiocarbon dating, DNA tests, and other forms of analysis, scientists were able
to conclude beyond any reasonable doubt that the bones were in fact those of Richard III.
But what about someone from much further back? Say, for example, Alexander the Great,
who supposedly died in 323 BCE. Unfortunately, the exact location of Alexander's tomb
has become lost to history and therefore we do not have his physical remains. However,
in the case of Alexander, we have the next best thing, which is solid archaeological evidence
for his existence. For example, we have many sculptures of his face, some of which date very
close to his lifetime or are exact copies of now-lost originals that were made when he was
still alive. We also have coins with his face on them, which were minted during his lifetime.
We also have inscriptions, like this one from the Temple of Athena in Prienne, Greece,
that dates from when he visited the location. It reads,
King Alexander dedicated this to Athena Polias. We even have foreign sources, like this one
written in Babylonian cuneiform and dated to his lifetime, which records Alexander's victory over
the Persian king Darius III. So, even though we do not have the physical remains of Alexander the
can still say, beyond any reasonable doubt, that he did in fact exist.
But what about cases where we don't have any archaeological evidence dating from when the
person was still alive? All three of the religious figures in this series – Moses, Jesus, and
Muhammad – fall into this category. In these cases, we have to rely entirely on textual sources.
And by textual sources, I don't mean a few words carved into stone. I mean lengthy works of
literature, usually written first on parchment and then later copied onto paper and made into books.
This is where things get a bit tricky because when it comes to ancient history, we often get
textual sources that differ from one another when it comes to what actually happened.
This leads some people to conclude that there's no way of knowing the truth and that it's just
a matter of arbitrarily choosing who you want to believe. But this is not the case. Scholars
have developed a method, called the historical method, for determining which sources are more
likely than others to be true. Here are some of the things that they consider.
First, does the source match the archaeological record? So, for example, if a text claims that
King So-and-So had an army with one million soldiers but archaeologists dig up that king's
main cities and discover that they were much too small to support a number that large,
the accuracy of that textual source is definitely going to come into question.
Two, are there multiple sources that all tell the same story? Say we have 10 different sources
that all state that the Greeks beat the Persians in a particular battle but only one source that
states that the Persians beat the Greeks. In a case like this, it's probably safe to assume
that the 10 are right and the 1 is wrong. Three, is there any chance that the source is biased?
It's quite obvious from ancient sources that rulers liked to boast about their accomplishments
and often exaggerated things. So, if we happen to have an account written by a neutral third party
who just happened to be living nearby, there's a greater chance that their account is going to be
more accurate. Four, how much time passed between the event and the written account of the event?
This one's easy. Basically, if a text was written very close to an event, it's far more likely to
be accurate than a text that was written many centuries later. Finally, number five,
what genre of writing was used? Another assumption that a lot of people make,
but are wrong in making, is that all ancient people wrote history in the same way that we
write it today. Nowadays, history falls very clearly into the category of non-fiction and
tends to be written in a very straightforward, linear fashion, focusing on facts and figures
with utmost accuracy. But history was not always written like this. The further back in time you go,
you'll find that for ancient people, history was more of a story and the main point of the story
was far more important to them than all the nitty gritty details. If we come across a text that
clearly uses literary tropes that were common at the time, we need to consider whether or not
the details in that text should be considered in a literal or a figurative way. Let's now turn our
attention to Moses and go through these five questions again, this time with Moses in mind.
But first, I'd like to take this opportunity to point out that, in addition to being a history
educator, I also happen to be Jewish. So, if you don't like my conclusions, please don't assume
that I came to these conclusions simply because I'm anti-religious. Cause, well, I'm not. Anyway,
the oldest source we have for the life of Moses is, as you might have guessed, the Bible. In
particular, the Torah, which refers to the first five books of the Bible. According to the Torah,
Moses was born in Egypt during a time when his people, the Israelites, were slaves there.
As a baby, Moses was placed in a basket in the Nile River, where he was then found by
one of Pharaoh's daughters. After growing up in the royal palace, Moses then commits murder as
an adult and has to escape to the land of Midian, where he then has a spiritual experience in which
God speaks to him in the form of a burning bush. There, God instructs Moses to return to Egypt
and to lead his enslaved people out of that country and into Canaan, the Promised Land,
which he then does, after God sends a series of ten plagues on Egypt.
From there, we get the famous parting of the Red Sea story, the receiving of the Ten Commandments,
and the Israelites wandering in the desert for 40 years. At the end of the biblical account,
Moses is not allowed to enter the Promised Land. So, it is his successor Joshua that takes over
and conquers most of the land of Canaan in a very dramatic fashion.
Okay, so let's first consider whether or not this account lines up with the archaeological record.
According to the Bible, the number of male slaves who left Egypt with Moses was 600,000,
meaning that the total number of Israelites, counting women and children, was likely around
2 million. Also, according to the Bible, Moses would have lived somewhere between 1500 and 1200
BCE. The exact date depends on one's interpretation of the chronological data and there are a lot of
conflicting theories on that that I won't go into. Suffice to say, it was somewhere around
1500 to 1200 BCE. Well, there is nothing in the archaeological record for that time period,
or any other time period for that matter, to suggest a sudden population drop of 2 million
people within Egypt, nor 2 million people traveling through the Sinai Peninsula,
nor 2 million people suddenly arriving in Canaan and replacing the existing population there.
Even if the Egyptians tried to cover up their embarrassing defeat in their records and
monuments, there would have been no way to cover up all the physical evidence that would have
resulted from the movement of that many people. However, this doesn't prove that there was never
a guy named Moses that left Egypt. It simply indicates that he didn't leave Egypt with 2
million people. There's still the possibility that there might have been some sort of exodus,
led by some sort of Moses-like figure, but that it was simply on a much smaller scale.
This is what Hebrew scholar Richard Friedman suggests in his book The Exodus. He points out
that members of the tribe of Levi often had Egyptian-sounding names but that other Israelites
did not. Names like Hophni and Phineas and even Moses – all of these Levite names have Egyptian
origins. So maybe, out of the 12 tribes, it was only the tribe of Levi that came from Egypt.
As I mentioned earlier, the Moses story is also closely associated with a place called Midian and
according to the archaeological record, we know that there was a people group living in that area
around that time called the Shasu who happened to have been, sometimes, enslaved by the Egyptians
and who happened to have worshipped a god with a very similar name to the god that the Israelites
ended up worshipping. So there's also the possibility that Moses was actually a Midianite
or a member of the Shasu and that he became an important figure in Israelite history because
he was the one who introduced them to Hashem. Moving on, let's now consider the second question.
How does the source, in this case the Bible, compare to other textual sources? Well, you might
be surprised to find out that there were actually many different versions of the Moses story floating
about in the ancient world. For example, in some Hellenistic versions, he's mostly remembered for
building a city or establishing a temple, often within Egypt itself, not in Israel. In others,
he's the one who invented the alphabet through the guidance of Thoth or the one who first
introduced the Egyptians to the idea of written laws. According to the famous Roman historian
Tacitus, Moses did leave Egypt to colonize Canaan but according to that version, the Israelites were
in the desert for only six days, arriving in Canaan with Moses on the 7th. But perhaps the most
interesting variant is the one written by Manetho, who was an Egyptian priest and historian living in
the Ptolemaic period. It is primarily from Manetho that we learn about an Asiatic people,
called the Hyksos, who temporarily ruled Lower Egypt just prior to the time of Moses,
before getting kicked out and forced back to Canaan. However, Manetho also tells a story
about an Egyptian priest named Osarseph, who lived just after the Hyksos period. In this story,
the pharaoh enslaves a group of lepers but then Osarseph unites the lepers with the help of the
Hyksos and forms an army, defeating the pharaoh. Osarseph then goes on to rule Egypt for 13 years,
destroying all other temples except his own, before finally being defeated by the returning
pharaoh and forced out of the country. At this point, Osarseph changes his name to Moses.
Obviously, this story about Moses has some parallels to the biblical story about Moses
but it also has some major differences. On top of this, Manetho's account and the biblical account
both seem to have parallels to the reign of a historically verified pharaoh named Akhenaten,
who lived around the same time as Moses and is mostly remembered for having promoted an early
type of monotheism. But the bottom line is this. There are many different versions of the Moses
story out there in the historical record but none of them seem to line up nicely. The only
common thread seems to be that he was some sort of renegade leader who introduced some bold ideas.
In other words, based on other textual sources, there is nothing available that could be used to
demonstrate that the details given in the Bible about Moses' life are historical.
The third thing we need to consider is the possibility of bias in our various sources.
And here, unfortunately, I think it is fair to say that no unbiased sources of Moses' life
exist. The biblical account is obviously biased because the main point of the Bible is to promote
a particular religious worldview. However, the non-biblical accounts are just as biased.
Most of them were written during the Hellenistic period, a time when anti-Jewish propaganda was
common. So, it's quite possible that the non-biblical versions of the Moses story were
deliberately crafted to put some sort of a political twist on the Jewish version of the Moses
story. What about the time difference for the various sources? As Al-Muqaddimah points out in
his video about Muhammad, the amount of time between the death of Muhammad and the first
mention of his name in a non-Islamic source is 8 years. And as Let's Talk Religion points out in
his video about Jesus, the amount of time between the death of Jesus and the first mention of his
name in a non-Christian source is 63 years. For Moses, it's a completely different story.
Using round numbers, the amount of time between the death of Moses and the first mention of his
name in a non-Jewish source is approximately 1,000 years. And even the time difference between the
and the earliest stage of the Torah's development is around 750 years.
So, considering the fact that the archaeological evidence contradicts the biblical account of
Moses and that there are numerous conflicting accounts of Moses' life in the various other
textual sources and that all of these textual sources are likely biased and were written many,
many centuries after he supposedly lived, I think the only conclusion we can come to is that Moses
is more of a legendary figure than a historical one. Now, this doesn't mean that he for sure
didn't exist. It simply means that the information we have about him is probably a mix of truth and
fiction and we have no way of knowing how much is truth and how much is fiction. Unless, of course,
we rely solely on religious faith. But there's one more question that we haven't yet considered
and that is, what genre of writing was used in the biblical account of Moses?
Like I said, ancient people did not always write history in the way that we write it today. For
them, historical accounts were often far more literary in nature and they mixed facts with
embellishments in order to craft an overall story that made an important point, not one that simply
recorded exactly what happened and when. There are many clear examples of literary tropes in
the biblical story of Moses. For example, although he was born into a low-class family, he ended up
being adopted into royalty. This is a common theme found in many ancient stories, as well
as several modern ones. Even the fact that he was placed into a basket in a river was a common theme.
One legend, a source for which is older than the Torah, states the following about Sargon of Akkad,
who lived over 1,000 years before Moses and is well attested in the historical record.
My mother, the high priestess, conceived. In secret she bore me. She set me in a basket of
rushes. With bitumen she sealed my lid. She cast me into the river which rose over me.
Then there's the familiar trope of the prince or princess who wanders out of the palace one day,
only to discover how hard life is for the everyday folk. Or the hero who has to go on the run,
only to come back and accomplish some major feat at some later point.
Even the parting of the Red Sea has much in common with ancient hero stories.
Long before the Bible started to be written, crossing an important body of water was often
used as a metaphor for leaving behind an old life and beginning a new one.
I could go on but my point is this. The biblical story of Moses is a beautifully crafted
work of literature that took common themes and images used at the time and wove them together
to create a new story – one that explained Israel's origins and defended their most
deeply held beliefs. Think of it this way. There are many Americans today
whose ancestors were not at Plymouth Rock or around during the American Revolution
but they still celebrate Thanksgiving and the Fourth of July. Likewise, even if the ancestors
of most ancient Israelites weren't involved in a major exodus from Egypt or even if the exodus
never happened at all, the point is that the story and what it symbolized to them became
an important part of their national identity. And not only that, the story of Moses also
went on to inspire people in other parts of the world as well.
So, in my view, the fact that it is not 100% historical doesn't lessen its value at all.
For well over 2,000 years, the story of Moses has both inspired those who have been oppressed
and instructed those with power not to do the oppressing.
A common theme found throughout the Torah is this one.
You shall not wrong a stranger or oppress him, for you were once strangers in the land of Egypt.
Considering the fact that racism and xenophobia are still major problems in the world today,
I think a more important question than did Moses exist is
are we going to take to heart the main lesson from his story?
As a reminder, be sure to check out the videos on Jesus and Muhammad as well.
You can find the links in the description or you can simply click on the next video right now.
Thanks for watching.
