Delicious homemade ice cream sandwich recipe for any occasion

Bigger Bolder Baking with Gemma Stafford
2 followers
1 Video View·Nov 11, 2026
Hi Bold Bakers, when I was a kid I used
to love those ice cream sandwiches that they
sell in the shop.
They've got vanilla ice cream in the middle and they're nice and cakey.
Well today in true Bigger Bolder Baking fashion I
am going to show you how you can recreate
the exact same sandwiches at home.
So let's get baking.
Before we get started the recipe for these can
be found on BiggerBolderBaking.com and as always
do not forget to tap that subscribe button
so you don't miss out on any of my fun upcoming videos
for the summer. Okay now let's talk ice cream sandwiches.
We are going to start out in a large
bowl we're going to make the brownie layer.
This is such a nice chocolatey decadent layer and it's
really really easy to make.
So into our bowl we're going to add some butter and chocolate.
Then all you want to do is pop these into the microwave
or put it over a bain marie
and just let the two ingredients melt gently together.
Okay so our chocolate has melted,
now be careful you always want to keep a close eye on chocolate
if it's in the microwave because you don't want it to burn.
I've burnt many a bar of chocolate so just keep a close eye on it.
So now into our chocolate
to cool it down we're gonna add in some sugar.
And then all you want to do is just whisk it in.
Now the reason that we add in the sugar now
is because we want the sugar to cool down
the chocolate before we add in the eggs.
So next we're going to crack in some eggs,
and then add a little bit of salt, and of
course some vanilla extract because you know I love vanilla extract.
In you go.
And then just swiftly give it a whisk all together.
So when I was a kid on a Sunday we used to go
to the shop with our pocket money and everybody
used to get an ice cream
and my dad's favorite one was an ice burger which is actually very
very similar to this one
and it had kind of like chocolatey on the outside, soft and cakey
and then vanilla ice cream in the middle.
It was so good.
Unlike today though when I was growing up ice creams
were like 50p so they were very
very cheap.
Okay lovely, our eggs are all mixed in,
set this aside and we're gonna mix together our
dry ingredients.
So in a large bowl lined with a sieve,
I'm going to add in my flour, cocoa powder, and
baking soda.
And then all you want to do is sift all these together.
The reason I always sift cocoa powder
is because it's notorious for having big lumps in it
and it's hard to work them out if you don't sieve them.
So I'm gonna bring back in my wet ingredients,
my lovely chocolatey mix, and then I'm gonna
add in my dry ingredients to that.
And then all you want to do is just
whisk it until it all comes together.
Now one thing about baking with chocolate
that I'll always tell you is use good quality
chocolate.
Somebody asked me the other day about cocoa percentages,
and what you want to do is make
sure the chocolate you're baking with has
a cocoa solid percentage, be it 50, 70, 72,
that will make all the difference to your dessert, believe me.
You see how thick this is?
It's gonna be delicious brownie, right,
that's it, all mixed up, now it's time to go into
our tin.
So here I have a nice big tray lined
with parchment paper, now it is roughly around
12 inches by 14 inches,
if yours is a little bit smaller or bigger that's totally fine.
Now I'm just gonna take my brownie mix,
and then I'm just going to spread it into my tray.
Spread it as evenly as you can, I know it's kinda hard.
Now this should spread out with a spatula
but if you can't get it to move around so
easily get in there with your hands
and push it into all the corners, that'll work perfectly
fine too.
Now that it's the summer take that time
that you have, the little bit extra to do
some baking, get into the kitchen, get creative,
I have so many recipes on my website and videos
so make sure you go and check them out, there's lots there for you.
Okay lovely, he's all spread out,
looking fantastic, now it's time to bake them off.
Bake your brownie off at 350°F
or 180°C for roughly 12-15 minutes.
Our brownies are done and they look gorgeous.
You can tell when they're perfectly cooked
because if you press in the middle it's nice
and firm.
Now I did bake these for like an extra 5 minutes
because I just want them to firm up a little
bit more so they probably will take roughly around 20 minutes.
Ok now I'm just gonna set this aside and let it cool down completely.
So once your brownie is nice and cold,
we're going to cut it in half, because we're going
to sandwich the two layers together.
So smack down the middle, just give it a nice big cut, lovely.
So we're gonna pick up our one piece of brownie,
and then flop him over into the tray.
Now the fresher he is the more he might crumble,
don't worry if it crumbles we can just mush
it back together.
And then when he's in the tray just push him over
into the edge, because we're gonna
want to get those flush sides to make our sandwich.
Okay great, now for the ice cream.
So here I have some of my two ingredient no machine ice cream,
now you can also use store
bought vanilla ice cream, and you don't even have to use vanilla,
you can use peanut butter,
raspberry swirl, whatever you like,
something that goes well with chocolate.
So all you want to do now is be really generous here,
and we're gonna put huge big scoops
on top of our brownie layer.
You wanna make sure it's nice and thick
because you want a nice big sandwich.
Okay, lovely.
And then when all your ice cream is there,
it's handy if you leave it out on room temperature
for around 10 minutes to let it get a little bit soft,
and then go in with your clean hand,
and then just pat down your ice cream
and get a nice thick layer until it's nice and
even.
As even as it can be.
Okay, great, I think that's enough ice cream,
now we're gonna go on with our last layer.
So to top it off we're gonna take our other layer of brownie
and then very carefully slide
it on top of the ice cream.
Now take your time, you don't want it to break.
And if it does break, mush it back together like I said.
Now just pat the top down nice and firm,
we want to sandwich it well together.
And then bring over your cling wrap
and just make him nice and snug in there.
Ok perfect.
Now I'm gonna pop this guy into the freezer for around 2 hours
and let him freeze totally
solid.
So as they say in television, here is one I prepared earlier.
Now this ice cream sandwich is really rock hard
so now I'm going to cut it up into
its portions.
So I have a nice serrated knife here,
and then all I'm going to do is just trim the
sides and just get them nice and even.
Just to make it look pretty.
Now don't worry, this bit will get eaten as well.
Now I'm gonna go ahead and cut this guy right down the middle.
If you need to use a hot knife to get through
that ice cream, that's a good idea.
Lovely.
Now you can make your sandwiches any size
that you want, obviously the bigger and bolder
the better.
So I'm gonna cut nice big rectangles,
around 2 inches in width, all the way down.
These sandwiches are great for like parties,
sleepovers, really fun to make, easy, and
they taste delicious.
Oh my gosh, I think I was pretty generous
because I cut them really big.
Check that out.
Now to give it a big bite, mmm, oh man,
cakey brownie sandwichy stuff with vanilla ice cream
in the middle, you really can't go wrong.
It actually tastes just like the ones I had growing up, so good.
I really hope you try this, put it
on your baking list for this summer, and I'll see
you back here really soon for more Bigger Bolder Baking.
