David Ricardo Vs Adam Smith (Why do countries Trade?)
Friends, in this video we'll be learning the theories of international trade,
the theory of absolute cost, comparative cost and the Heckscher-Ohlin theory.
We'll study them together so that we get the differences between them.
Let's ask the question friends, why do countries trade with each other?
The theory of absolute advantage was given by Adam Smith. It is pretty easy to understand.
Every country in the world specializes in making one or the other commodity.
Companies with huge amount of capital will specialize in making capital-intensive goods,
meaning goods which require more amount of capital.
Example, transportation companies or telecommunication companies.
And companies with lesser amount of capital, mostly developing countries,
will produce labor-intensive goods which require more amount of labor.
For example, mining, agriculture, etc.
So let's think of two countries, India and the United States.
Now look at this table. You can see that India produces more of good X by using one day of labor
than that of the United States. However, United States produces more of good Y
by using one day of labor. You can see that India has an absolute advantage in producing good X,
while US has an advantage in producing good Y.
Now as both the countries have an absolute advantage in producing one good,
Adam Smith argues that trade between the two countries would prove to be beneficial.
This is because if India were to trade good X for good Y within the country,
then it would have to give two Xs for one Y.
Similarly, the US would require two Ys for one X.
However, if they trade X and Y with one another, then they'll get one X for one Y.
Hence, it is advisable for India to specialize in good X and for the US to specialize in good Y.
That's absolute advantage for y'all.
However, there's a catch. Say for example, the countries have an equal difference in cost,
then it won't make sense to have a trade with each other.
To illustrate this, let us look at the following schedule.
Here it takes 20 units of cost for India to produce good X and 10 units to produce good Y.
And the US requires 10 units of cost to produce good X and 5 for Y.
Now see carefully, if India trades X for Y within the country,
then it will require two Ys for one X. Even the US will require two Ys for one X.
But if they trade X for Y with each other, then India might ask for four Ys to supply one X,
which is nowhere better than the internal exchange cost.
We can see that when the difference in cost of production
is equal, trade won't take place. For the trade to take place,
it is very important to have absolute difference in cost.
Now let's move on to the theory of comparative cost advantage.
The theory of absolute advantage was taken further by David Ricardo.
His theory is referred to as the Ricardian theory of comparative cost.
What Ricardo argued was that it is not compulsory for a country to have absolute advantage for trade
to take place. Trade can exist even if there is a comparative advantage.
To understand this, look at the following schedule.
We have two countries and two products to deal with.
Here, England takes 120 hours to produce one unit of wine. We call it 120 labour hours.
And Portugal takes 80 labour hours to produce one unit of wine.
Similarly, England takes 100 labour hours to produce one unit of cloth.
And Portugal takes 90 labour hours to produce the same.
First pause the video and understand this schedule.
Okay? Alright.
As you can see that Portugal has an absolute advantage in producing both wine and cloth.
Hence, according to Adam Smith, trade should not be possible.
However, let's understand Ricardo's perspective on this.
We can clearly see from the table that Portugal has a more of an advantage in producing wine
than in producing cloth. Hence, Portugal should produce wine and leave cloth for England.
Here's why. If England produces wine and cloth, then the internal exchange rate
would be 1.2 units of cloth for one unit of wine.
Let's understand this first.
See, England produces wine by working for 120 hours and cloth by working for 100 hours.
So, the producer will be like, I work 20 hours more than you. So, you should pay me more.
Hence, the cloth maker will have to pay him 1.2 units of cloth to get one unit of wine.
Similarly, Portugal's internal rate of trade would be 0.89 units of cloth for one unit of wine.
This is because in Portugal, the cloth makers are working harder.
So, they'll pay less of cloth for one unit of wine.
Now, think of this. Instead of trading within the country,
if Portugal trades one unit of cloth with one unit of wine with England,
then it would be beneficial for both. Look from Portugal's perspective.
Portugal was paying one unit of wine and getting 0.89 unit of cloth.
But now, it is getting one full unit of cloth.
From England's perspective, it had to give 1.2 units of cloth for one unit of wine.
But now, it just have to give one unit of cloth.
Both the countries win from this trade.
Thank you so much Mr. Ricardo.
But wait, this theory assumes that labor is the only factor of production that influences production.
This might not be true.
Hence, in 1919, a Swedish economist by the name Heckscher bought some alternative
explanation to the theory of comparative cost.
Later, Bertil Ohlin, a student of Heckscher,
brought further improvement in Heckscher's work, thus giving rise to the Heckscher-Ohlin theory.
I'll soon put a video on Heckscher-Ohlin theory.
I hope you liked this video. If you did, then please share it with your friends.
If not, mention it in the comments how the Sagaraut channel can improve itself.
And do like and subscribe.
Until then, adios, hasta la vista.

