David RICARDO : vie et œuvre (Bio)
THE ECONOMIC ECHO OF THE 19TH CENTURY
On April 18, 1772, David Ricardo was born in London,
one of the most influential English theorists of the 19th century classical economy school.
He is the father of comparative advantages theory,
which is devoted to the superiority of free exchange over protectionism.
His economic analyses have had a great influence
both on the liberals and on the Marxists.
As a continuator of Adam Smith,
he deepened the theory of labor value,
provided a theory of income, salary and profit,
and prophesied the advent of a stationary economic state, among other contributions.
We know that the Ricardo family lived for a time in Spain,
or maybe in Portugal,
before emigrating to Holland at the end of the 15th century
in order to escape the persecution of the Jews.
David was the third child of a Jewish family, of which there were 17.
His grandfather worked in Amsterdam as an exchange agent,
and his father, Abraham, settled in London to carry out the same activity.
David was therefore well surrounded to learn the rudiments of business,
and in particular the functioning of the stock exchange.
At the age of 11, he went to join his uncle in Amsterdam,
where he began his learning of the things of the stock exchange.
At the age of 14, he was already employed by his father at the stock exchange in London.
He went to school only for a few months during his stay in Amsterdam.
The rest of the time, he was educated by preceptors.
In 1793, he decided to marry a quaker named Priscilla Ann Wilkinson.
His parents sought in vain to oppose this union with a non-Jew.
His father chased him out of the family business,
so that David went to settle with his wife in the district of Lambeth, in London.
He also converted to Christianity by embracing Unitarianism,
a theological doctrine that considers that God is one and the same spirit and not a trinity.
His father denied it, and his mother never again spoke to him after this episode.
Now relying only on him to meet his own needs,
he started his account as a broker or courtier in good French.
His activity consists of advising and passing on the stock exchange orders of his clients,
by touching a commission based on the amount of transactions.
Only later, after having succeeded in developing his business,
did he speculate in the stock exchange with his own deniers.
After his mother's death in 1801, he ended up reconciling with his father.
In 1815, he attempted a speculative operation that looked like a real poker game.
He bought back British stocks that had lost a lot of value
due to the threat that Napoleon's return would weigh heavily on the British Empire.
He was lucky.
After Napoleon's defeat at Waterloo,
the stocks he had amassed saw their value double
and Ricardo was able to make a real fortune by reselling them.
He then decided to retire and devote part of his wealth to the purchase of several lands.
In a few years, he became a rich landowner,
a category that he would later call, in his writings, a rentier.
Nevertheless, he diversified his positions to avoid bad surprises.
Apart from these lands, Ricardo owned various financial titles.
At his death in 1823, he left his wife and seven of his eight children,
a daughter, Fanny, who died in 1820,
a fortune estimated at about £725,000,
knowing that at the time a doctor earned about £200 a year.
Ricardo did not really have the leisure to go to school.
He had to work very early to meet the needs of his family.
The debates and intellectual problems that occupied the high spheres of British aristocracy were foreign to him.
However, at the age of 25, having already done well in business and driven by his curiosity,
he began to take an interest in more serious subjects.
He then read various articles dealing with mathematics, chemistry and geology.
He was also a member of the London Geological Society, which he helped to found in 1807.
He discovered the economy quite by chance in 1799.
While he was on holiday in Bath, a seaside town in the south-west of England,
he came across a copy of Adam Smith's The Wealth of Nations,
which he found in a library.
It was a revelation for him.
It was the book that gave him the desire to study economics,
as he later wrote to one of his friends.
From that moment on, he left his other centres of intellectual interest
to delve into economic issues.
He mainly debated with his friends.
He wrote notes, but did not publish anything until 1809.
On August 29 of that year,
an unsigned article entitled The Price of Gold appeared in the Morning Chronicle.
It was his first essay on the monetary economy.
During the summer, the price of gold had increased significantly
and the book had lost its value, which had not happened for a few years.
In his article, and those that followed until 1811,
Ricardo explained this phenomenon by the quantitative theory of currency
and sided with the bullionists.
To understand Ricardo's thesis,
it is necessary to recall the economic context of the time.
In 1797, due to the war with France,
the English panicked and rushed to the banks
to obtain the conversion of their gold notes.
The Bank of England then decided to suspend the convertibility
in order to stop the movement.
In addition, the following harvests were bad
and England had to import more and more cereals,
which degraded the balance of payments and led to a price rise.
A controversy ensued over the reason for this price rise,
called the bullionist controversy.
Bullion, meaning lingo in English.
Those called bullionists considered that the price rise
and depreciation of the book
were the result of the non-convertibility of gold notes.
They estimated that, free of any constraint of convertibility,
the Bank of England had issued too many banknotes
without real wealth counterpart,
which had led to a price rise.
The anti-bullionists, on the other hand,
thought that this evolution was only due to real factors.
The bad harvests, the rise in military spending,
government aid paid to the allies of England,
were enough to explain, according to them,
both the deficit of foreign trade,
the depreciation of currency and the price rise.
They thought that the Bank of England
only issued banknotes to meet the real needs of the economy.
In short, for them,
the monetary mass was only following the evolution of the economy.
However, the first article of Ricardo
attracted little attention,
which is not the case of the one he published in January 1810,
entitled The High Price of Lingo.
A parliamentary commission,
chaired by Francis Horner,
was then created to decide
whether or not to restore the convertibility of gold banknotes.
The economist Henry Thornton,
a specialist in monetary issues,
was a member of this commission.
Finally, the commission voted in favour
of the recovery of convertibility in a report,
the Bullion Report,
which was submitted to the Parliament.
The vote, which had to decide
whether or not to restore convertibility,
was nevertheless postponed to the next parliamentary session.
The debates between supporters and opponents of convertibility
continued in the press
until the Parliament's vote in the spring of 1811
against the recovery of convertibility,
at the Grand-Dame de Ricardo.
It was not until 1819
that it was finally restored
following the recommendations of the Robert Peel Committee.
It must be said that after 1812,
the problem of Great Britain was rather the deflation
and economic debates focused on the Corn Laws,
a series of laws whose aim was to regulate
the foreign trade of cereals.
Ricardo's first articles in 1809 and 1810
allowed him to establish his reputation as an economist
and to attract the attention of some great names
in the political economy,
such as James Mill and Thomas Malthus,
with whom Ricardo became friends.
James Mill's role,
the father of the economist John Stuart Mill in particular,
is fundamental.
Without the permanent encouragement
and the advised advice of Mill,
Ricardo would probably not have published much in economics,
either out of laziness
or out of fear of having nothing to say that was worth it.
He preferred to debate orally,
informally and with his friends.
Mill's intervention probably allowed the writing
of the Principles of Political Economy and Tax,
Ricardo's major work
and one of the most authentic works of economic thought.
It was at his request that Thomas Robert Malthus
had met David Ricardo in June 1811
and had proposed to him to hold a correspondence
on certain economic issues.
A true friendship,
teeming with a deep respect,
was going to be forged between the two men,
although their point of view often diverged
on economic issues,
as are the many letters
they exchanged from 1811
until the death of Ricardo.
Their main divergent subjects
were based on the economic consequences
of protectionism and free trade,
illustrated by the Corn Laws,
and on the possibility of a general overproduction
or, to put it another way,
an insufficiency of the general demand
as an explanation for the economic crisis.
On this last point,
the Law of the Outflow,
commonly known as the Law of C,
gave rise to an exchange of abundant letters
between the two men.
The French economist Jean-Baptiste C
is also another important contemporary
with whom Ricardo will have a regular correspondence
beyond the sleeve.
However, they met twice.
Once in London in 1814
and one last time in Paris in 1822.
The two economists never agreed
on the question of the origin of the value of goods.
For C, this value came from the utility of goods,
while for Ricardo,
it resulted from the quantity of work
used to manufacture it.
Businessman and then economist,
Ricardo stopped politics from 1819
and was elected deputy on February 20
in the circunscription of Port Arlington in Ireland.
He did not belong to any party.
His only ambition was the defense of the general interest,
but he quickly realized, while regretting it,
that private interests often prevailed
over the collective interest in political debates.
He fought until the end of his life
for the abolition of the Corn Laws
and the restoration of the convertibility of gold bills.
He defended his point of view in the House of Commons,
but also in many articles in newspapers and magazines.
There is also his correspondence with Mill and Malthus,
which helps to better understand the background
and the development of Ricardo's thought.
Whatever the undeniable interest of these different writings,
it remains that Ricardo's main economic concepts
are developed in what is recognized
as his masterpiece of economic analysis,
published in 1817 under the title
The Principles of Political Economy and Tax.
The book was a great success
thanks to a favorable article by the Scottish economist
John Ramsey McCullough in the Edinburgh Review.
The same McCullough greatly contributed
to the posterity of Ricardo's works
by publishing all his works in 1846
and by disseminating his thought in his courses,
since he was the first to occupy
the Chair of Political Economy founded by Ricardo
at the University of London.
In the preface to The Principles,
Ricardo indicates that the ambition of his book
is to fill the gaps of his predecessors
such as Turgot, Smith or Say
on the subject of income, profit and wages.
The analytical method used by Ricardo in his book
is based on a meticulous reduction
of economic complexity to key variables
and on the establishment of causal relations
between these variables.
This approach allows the mathematical formalization
of his ideas.
In this book, which offers a global view
of the English economy of his time,
Ricardo develops a theory of labor value,
of the distribution of income
and of international exchanges.
Differential reasoning for the first time
appears through the law of decreasing yields
applied to agriculture.
The role of taxation in the economy
is also discussed throughout the book.
Principles of political economy and tax
open up on the thorny question
of the origin of the value of goods.
Like Adam Smith,
Ricardo distinguishes two meanings of value.
He writes thus
Ricardo, like Adam Smith,
considers that the utility of a good
is not enough to explain the exchange value
and resumes the famous comparison
between water and diamond to show it.
Water has a very great utility
and it is almost free.
The diamond has very little utility
and yet it is very expensive.
It takes a lot of goods in exchange
to buy it.
Therefore, the only utility of these two goods,
water and diamond,
does not explain their exchange value.
Smith had suggested that water was not expensive
because it was easy to obtain
while the diamond required more effort,
more work.
To solve the paradox of water and diamond,
Ricardo distinguishes two types of goods.
Reproducible goods,
whose quantity can be increased
by the work of man,
and non-reproducible goods,
whose quantity cannot or hardly
be increased by the work of man.
The value of non-reproducible goods,
like water and diamond,
depends on their relative rarity
while the value of reproducible goods
depends on the relative quantity of work
used to make them.
When a good is made by direct work
and capital,
it is always made by work
because capital has also been made
by work.
A good is therefore always made
by work, whether it is direct
or indirect, through capital.
This theory of the value of work,
even studied by Ricardo,
poses several difficulties.
First of all, two goods
that have the same amount of work
can not have the same value
if the production process is different
and therefore the time to make them
is not the same,
or, in other words,
the production is more or less capitalistic.
Then, there is the modification
of the distribution between salary and profit
which induces a variation
of the exchange value of the goods
even if the incorporated work
remains identical.
This phenomenon is well identified
by Ricardo, but he will
consider it marginal.
Ricardo then looks for a standard
of value that is invariable
to measure the value of work
whose evolution depends
only on the technical progress.
The problem of the price of the good
as a measure of the value of work
is that it can fluctuate
depending on the supply
and demand of the good,
the variations of the salary rate
or the quantity of cash in circulation.
He considers that gold
has the necessary qualities
to serve as a standard of value.
Marx will largely take up
Ricardo's analysis of the value of work
by adding some additional refinements.
From the Marginalist Revolution
which explains that the value
depends on the marginal utility of the good,
the theory of the value of work
has however been totally abandoned
or almost.
The Italian economist Piero Sraffa
has indeed tried to rehabilitate it
by deepening it in the 1960s.
If we remember today
Ricardo's name,
it is mainly for his theory
of comparative advantages
supposed to justify the superiority
of free trade over protectionism.
This theory is still the reference
nowadays.
Ricardo begins by pointing out
an error of analysis in Adam Smith,
also a supporter of free trade.
Smith explained in
The Wealth of Nations
that a country had an interest
in specializing in what it knew
to do best and to exchange
its production with that of other countries
to the extent of its needs.
This is the theory of absolute advantages.
However, what happens
if a country has absolute advantages
to produce all existing goods and services?
Other countries would then have
no interest in producing anything
if we follow Adam Smith's theory.
Ricardo will then objectively demonstrate
that international trade
will be profitable to all countries
even if one of them
is more efficient in all areas.
For this, he uses
the fictitious example of Portugal
which would be more efficient
than England both in the production of wine
and in the production of textiles.
Suppose that,
on a given period,
Portugal needs 80 hours of work
to produce a unit of wine
and 90 hours to produce a unit of textiles
and that England needs 120 hours
to produce the same unit of wine
and 100 hours to produce the same unit of textiles.
We therefore see that it takes less hours
to produce wine and textiles
in Portugal than in England.
However, Portugal has an interest
in specializing in the production of wine
and to export the excess
against the textiles produced in England.
England, on the other hand,
has an interest in specializing
in the production of textiles
and to export the excess
against the wine produced in Portugal.
In both cases,
the specialization of the country
in the production which offers
a comparative advantage
in the example mentioned
is the wine for Portugal
and the textiles for England
and the exchange of the excess
in relation to the needs of the country
against the other goods produced abroad
results in a total production
of wine plus textiles
superior to the production
which would be realized in autarcy.
However, Ricardo does not say
how this excess of production
will be shared between Portugal and England.
It is John Stuart Mill
who, in 1848,
will answer this question.
Of course,
Ricardo's model is theoretical
and is based on hypotheses
not always united in reality
or not completely.
For example,
Ricardo specifies that
his analysis is only valid
in the case of a low mobility
of production factors
between countries,
which was the case at the time.
In the case of capital mobility,
however,
companies would be interested
in relocating
rather than producing
on their own territory
and exchanging with foreigners.
Despite certain limits or reserves
that have been underlined over time
– we think of the objections
of the German economist Friedrich List –
the theory of comparative advantages
is still not fundamentally
questioned nowadays.
Ricardo also addresses
the issue of revenue distribution,
more precisely,
the distribution between
income and profit,
and draws conclusions
about the long-term evolution
of the economy.
Income is the remuneration
of the landowner,
profit is that of capital
and wage is that of labor.
A landowner's income
is constituted each time
there is a gap in productivity
between two lands.
If the landowner of the first land
produces more cereals
than the landowner of the second land
with the same amount of capital
and labor,
he enjoys an income
equal to the difference in quantity
produced with the same means.
This difference comes from
the fact that the first land
is more fertile than the second,
the second will be more fertile
than the third, and so on.
When the population grows,
we need either more capital
and labor on the lands
already exploited,
or more cultivable land
to produce more cereals.
And with the law on the yields
of the crops that we have just mentioned,
income can only grow.
The increase in the price of wheat
due to the use of a greater amount
of labor and capital in agriculture
to meet the needs of a population
that is growing, also explains
the rise in income.
The Corn Laws, which restrict
the importation of cereals,
thus force the English to exploit
less and less fertile lands
and thus push income and prices up.
Ricardo then examines
the formation of the wage.
He distinguishes the subsistence wage,
which is in a way the minimum wage
necessary to ensure its subsistence,
and the current wage,
which results from the law
of supply and demand,
which can be higher or lower
than the subsistence wage.
If it is lower, conditions
for employees are difficult.
If it is higher due to,
for example, economic growth,
it provokes a population growth.
He joins his friend Malthus on this point,
because employees have enough income
to start a family
and feed more mouths.
However, the population growth
de facto leads to an increase
in the number of workers on the market
and, consequently, a decrease
in the wage rate, which gradually
brings it back to the subsistence wage.
The current wage
can therefore not move away
from the subsistence wage.
Ricardo considers that
the purchasing power of employees
cannot improve significantly.
For Ricardo, profits depend
on wages.
If wages are high,
profits will be low, and vice versa.
Moreover, he estimates that
due to the mobility of capital,
there cannot be several
profit rates in the economy.
The profit rates between industries
tend to equalize.
As the wage level
follows the price of cereals,
if the price of cereals increases,
the subsistence wage increases
and therefore the profit rate decreases.
If a man produces
a quantity of cereals
worth 150 euros
and his subsistence wage
is 120 euros,
the profit is therefore 30 euros,
which corresponds to a profit rate of 20%,
i.e. 30 divided by 150.
If the price of this quantity
of cereals increases by 10 euros,
the wage of the worker
must go from 120 to 130 euros
so that he can ensure his subsistence.
The price of the quantity of cereals
will therefore be 160 euros,
which corresponds to 130 euros
of wage plus 30 euros of profit.
The profit rate will then be
18.75%,
i.e. 30 divided by 160.
We see that following
a price increase,
the profit rate decreases,
going from 20%
to 18.75%.
One could wonder
why the capitalist does not increase
the price more to maintain
his profit rate.
In fact, Ricardo tells us,
under the effect of the tendency
of population growth,
the wage increases,
i.e. less fertile lands
are exploited,
which pushes the prices
of cereals up
and therefore necessarily
the wages go up,
because if wages did not increase
with the price of cereals,
workers would no longer be able
to ensure their subsistence
and would refuse to work.
Consequently, with the increase
in the cost of labor,
capitalists see their
remuneration rate,
the profit rate,
decreasing gradually.
This decrease in the profit rate
inevitably leads to a
stationary state of the economy,
according to Ricardo.
The technical progress and
foreign trade, he tells us,
can delay the decline,
but not stop or reverse
this movement.
The accumulation of capital
cannot therefore continue
without end.
This question has been the subject
of many debates since
Ricardo and continues
to animate the community of economists.
To develop his own theory
of the evolution of the capitalist system,
Karl Marx will rely
largely on Ricardo's economic analysis.
Ricardo deals with taxes
in several chapters of the Principles.
In substance,
taxes have a negative effect
on the economy.
If taxes hit wages,
they de facto increase the subsistence wage
and consequently reduce the profit rate.
If they hit products,
they increase their price
and therefore the salary,
which also reduces the profit rate.
If they hit profit directly,
they reduce the accumulation of capital.
Ricardo also denounces
the use of public deficit,
which, in order to be financed,
leads to a collection of private savings
that cannot therefore
invest elsewhere.
This is what is called today
the eviction effect,
which leads Ricardo to prefer
direct tax to public debt.
In conclusion,
the State must therefore limit
the amount of taxes
and intervene as little as possible
in the economy to avoid limiting
growth.
Ricardo's doctrine of taxation
has dominated the economic world
until Keynes.
Since then, the economic role
of taxes and the State
has been re-evaluated
in a more positive way
by many economists.
And Ricardo's doctrine of taxation
has been neglected for a while.
With the question of plans
to restart the budgetary deficit
from the 1970s,
Ricardo's name has
however reappeared
thanks to the work of the American economist
Robert Barrow,
who gave rise to the Ricardian equivalence theorem,
also called the Barrow-Ricardo theorem.
This theorem stipulates
that the increase in income
induced by a budgetary deficit
will essentially be spared
by economic agents
to face a rise in taxes in the future
or an erosion of the value of the currency.
As a result,
the budgetary deficit would have no impact
on growth.
In chapter 17 of the Principles,
we can find a similar analysis,
which explains why the name of Ricardo
is associated with this theorem.
In conclusion,
we can say that
the different economic mechanisms
described by Ricardo in his book
form a coherent whole.
The value of goods depends
essentially on the amount of work
incorporated directly or indirectly
in their production.
The income from this production
is divided between income,
salary and profit.
The salary, which revolves around
the amount necessary for subsistence,
determines the profit rate
that allows the accumulation of capital.
The income,
remuneration of the landowner
and the price of cereals
can only increase
with the growth of the population.
As the income increases
and the salary can not go below
the level of subsistence,
the profit rate can only decrease.
Technical progress
and international trade
can delay the outcome
of a profit reduced to nothing,
of a zero growth,
of a stationary state of the economy.
On the other hand,
a too high tax will only
precipitate this delay.
The State must be content
with a minimum service
and must not be too indebted
in order not to be forced
to increase the tax in the future.
Let us add to this that
Ricardo considers that
the law of debauchery
is perfectly valid.
There can be no crisis
of overproduction
or insufficiency
of the general demand.
The global supply
is always equal
to the global demand.
Ricardo recognizes
the existence of partial imbalance,
but this is compensated
at the global level.
He also believes
that the currency is only a veil,
that is,
that the amount of money
in circulation does not affect
the production,
only the price level.
Therefore, the monetary mass
must not increase too much
in order to avoid inflation.
Ricardo was very successful
until the end of the 19th century,
to the point that Keynes wrote
in 1936,
Ricardo conquered England
as completely as the Holy Inquisition
conquered Spain.
But the marginalist revolution
that took place at the neoclassical school
swept away his theory of labor value
to replace it
with the theory of marginal utility.
The introduction of differential reasoning
to the theory of the borderline income
is one of Ricardo's major contributions
to economic analysis.
But nowadays,
Ricardo is mostly widely recognized
for his theory of comparative advantages.
Almost two centuries after his death,
some of his analyses
still retain a certain degree of validity
and many economists
belonging to different currents of thought
continue to refer to them,
to expose them or to comment on them.
By his abstraction,
deduction and out-of-the-ordinary
David Ricardo, a successful economist
and courtier, has produced
many original concepts
that have made him enter the pantheon
of great economists.

