David Ricardo's "The Principles of Political Economy and Taxation" (Part 1⧸3)
Hey hey everyone, back again.
Today we're going to continue on the political economy train with David Ricardo's The Principles
of Political Economy and Taxation.
Now before jumping into it, if you want to follow me anywhere other than here, you can
find me on Instagram at theory underscore and underscore philosophy or on Twitter at
David Guineo.
If you're new here, welcome welcome welcome, I'm David, I try to explain philosophical
texts and ideas in a way that makes them accessible to you.
So if you haven't already, like, share, subscribe, tell your friends, comment, I'd love to hear
from you.
If you've found this on YouTube, you're going to be able to find it pretty much anywhere
where you get podcasts, where there shouldn't be any ads.
Or if you've found this in podcast form, you'll be able to find the channel on YouTube where
I sometimes release videos if you're into that at all.
And if you want to help me out, obviously, liking, sharing, subscribing, you can also
help me out monetarily via Patreon or PayPal, but no pressure.
And yeah, don't waste any more of your time with that stuff.
Let's continue on the political economy train.
Now to fill in anyone who's just jumping into this at this point, my goal, my intention
was to cover is to cover Adam Smith, David Ricardo, and then move into Karl Marx.
So I've already done Adam Smith's The Wealth of Nations.
So if you haven't listened to that, you can go listen to it.
It's four parts.
I know it's long, but you can go listen to that if you want.
It would be helpful if you did, because some of what Ricardo does here is in direct response
to Adam Smith.
Now, it would be helpful, but not necessary.
So at any point that Ricardo mentions Smith, criticizes Smith, and it's kind of funny because
this book is a lot of Ricardo throwing shade at other political economists like Smith,
Malthus, I think that's how you pronounce it, Buchanan, Say, all these thinkers David
Ricardo is totally dissatisfied with.
So if you want to go listen to that, you can.
It won't be necessary, though, because any point that I bring up Smith, I'm going to
fill in the blanks so that it's clear what Ricardo is saying in relation to Smith.
And then, of course, following Ricardo here, I'm going to be moving into Marx at some point.
So stay tuned for that.
Long intro.
Let's jump into David Ricardo's The Principles of Political Economy and Taxation.
So like any book, this begins with a preface in which he describes how there are three
broad classes of society.
This is important to know because these classes are always going to come up and they kind
of serve as a benchmark to understand the economic population within any nation.
So these broad classes are the owners of land, who earn rent, so those are the landlords.
You have the owners of stock, who are the capitalists, who own machinery, who pay laborers,
who own equipment, anything like that.
And then you have workers, who earn wages.
So for Ricardo, political economy is a science, specifically it is the science of these three
classes of landlords, of capitalists, and workers, and the various dynamics that make
them function together.
Now this isn't something that he mentions in the preface, but it's important to bring
up in order to have a good understanding of this idea going forward.
And that is capital.
That is, what is capital?
Now, if you think capital is money, you'd only be partly correct.
In fact, capital is much broader than money.
In fact, capital can even not be money at times.
Or there are forms of money, or there is money that isn't capital.
So for something to be capital, it must, in Ricardo's words, it must be part of the wealth
of a country which is employed in production and consists of food, clothing, tools, raw
materials, machinery, etc., necessary to give effect to labor.
Now that's just an important thing to put on the back burner, because it's a term that
I'm going to throw around, and it's just important not to immediately associate it with dollar
bills, with money.
Now another big term that comes up throughout the course of this book is value.
Now he spends the first chapter describing value, so we're going to just move into that
I want to say that value is a very tenuous term within the domain of political economy,
and you'll see this in Marx as well, where value is exceptionally difficult to define,
because what it ultimately comes down to is people's individual preference.
But as we will see throughout this whole process here, or throughout this book, value is inextricably
related to labor.
So the value of a thing will be determined by how much labor was put into it.
Now that is the very short definition, but it's one that will serve as a kind of, I guess,
a point of departure for what we're going to get onto here.
And that is chapter one on value.
So for him, a commodity's value will be determined by the relative quantity of labor which is
necessary for its production, not on the amount paid for that labor.
Now the reason that that is, is because the amount paid for labor, wages, the value of
it is going to change across time.
There are going to be periods in which wages are higher than others.
But what stays the same is the amount of labor required to produce a specific thing, or a
specific set of things.
Or what I should say, is that all things are going to be produced with the effect, or through
the effect of labor.
Now roughly, there can be two broad forms of value.
So there is either use value, or exchange value.
Now because we measure value in relation to labor, use value refers to the amount of labor
saved through something's being used.
So for instance, a hammer is able to save some labor, or to make labor easier.
And so its value then will be tied to the amount of labor it is able to save.
Now for something's exchange value, that is, how many dollars it'll take to buy a thing.
If I make a hat, and it's $15, then I'm earning $15 worth of value.
Value is not the $15.
Value is actually how much labor I am able to get for that hat.
So if I sell the hat and get $15, I have $15 worth of possible labor that can be spent
put back into capital, which can then help the process keep going, to be able to make
more hats, or whatever.
Because when you sell something, what that person is giving you in the form of money,
is giving you the, I guess the bounty, or what they earned for their labor.
So you are taking part of their labor in the form of the money they give you, so that you
can give them the thing that you've made through labor.
Now he adds to this, that is, he adds to the idea of use value and exchange value, the
idea that as something goes up in use value, it will go down in exchange value, and vice
versa.
So for example, air has a lot of use.
We all need air.
Likewise with water.
But the value of those things are pretty low.
In fact, they cost nothing.
And where, by contrast, something that is made purely for superfluous ends, like vanity
or reputability, like a diamond necklace, has very little use value, but it has a great
deal of exchange value.
Now a commodity's exchange value is going to be determined by not only production, that
is, not only labor put into it, but it's also going to be determined by scarcity.
So if something is hard to find, if there's high demand for it, but the supply is limited,
its monetary value, its nominal price, that is the dollar figure of what it'll cost, is
going to go up.
Now having set all of this out, this idea about labor being a determining, or I guess
a constituent part of value, Ricardo then says, wait a second.
We must turn our critical gaze upon this idea of labor as though it's just something that
is unchanging, that the same amount of labor is going to be used and is going to be worth
the same amount today as it will in a hundred years.
Ricardo says that ultimately there's no real way to determine labor or to have a perfect
standard to determine value.
And that is because it's ultimately subjective, and any of these measurements we use to determine
value, whether it's labor or if it's, I don't know, necessities like corn, because corn
can be argued to be a good indicator of value because we all need corn, and if we measure
things in relation to their value in relation to corn, then we can get a good idea of its
value in relation to an absolute necessity, or if we determine something's value in relation
to gold, we are still going to run into issues because their prices, that is the number value
that we use to understand value, even though it's not a perfect measurement, those values
are always going to be changing.
Labor is always changing.
Price of corn is always changing.
What it can buy in relation to other things, how much labor it takes to make, all of these
things are always changing.
And so Ricardo says while we'll never have a perfect standard measure of value, we use
labor, we use gold as pretty decent indicators because we just don't have anything else that's
so neat, that is so consistent, even though it's not perfectly consistent.
So what Adam Smith says in The Wealth of Nations is that with something like corn, that is,
he takes to be a kind of baseline of all possible value because it's something we all need,
something we all consume.
He says that if there is a change in the price of corn, or the value of corn, then, but let
me just asterisk, price and value are not congruent, they are not the same thing, I'm
just using it to give us the most easy way to understand an issue with Smith here.
So Smith says that if there is a change in the price of corn, then that means something
else has happened, nothing has happened to corn, but maybe money has gotten less valuable,
or maybe money has gotten more valuable, which would determine or change how much money is
needed to buy corn that is always going to have the same measurement of value.
Whereas Ricardo says this is just totally unrealistic, it's almost like Smith is just
bracketing off corn from a broader economy, from the exchange in free market, as though
it just transcends everything and floats above everything, when in fact, it itself is always
going to be subject to various changes.
But even so, to reiterate, Ricardo thinks that these are the best measurements we have.
So he will talk about value in terms of labor, in terms of corn, in terms of gold, but his
real focus here, that is Ricardo's, is on labor, value being determined by labor, how
much labor is required to buy a thing, how much labor you are then saving when you buy
a thing, or whatever.
But when we talk about value, it's not as though wages paid to laborers is going to
be one of the, I guess, one of the expenses to bring something to the market, to produce
an object and then bring it to the market.
There's also going to be the cost that goes into machinery, that goes into maintaining
buildings, that goes into raw materials.
Now all of these things as well, because they play a part in producing some commodity, will
determine and will affect its value.
So it's not just human labor per se that gives something value, it's all of these other things.
Now if you're, I guess if you're clever, you'd say, well, none of those other things exist
on their own.
They were only made possible through labor, which is true.
So if there's a machine that is introduced into a manufacturer or into a factory or whatever,
that might bring more things to market, it might make it easier for things to be produced,
and so we will see a decline in labor, but we're going to problematize that as we go
forward, but we will say, for example, that labor has gone down because the machine takes
over the work of four or five people, let's say, but it may have taken however many years,
however many people to actually build that machine.
So it itself is the product of labor.
So when we include that price into the price of a commodity, we are still only attaching
labor price, I guess the value of labor to that commodity, because the only way that
that machine was able to enter the factory was through labor.
And this isn't just true under industrialization, industrialized capitalism.
He provides the example of hunter-gatherers hunting beavers, for example, where he says
that what they might trade that for to another party, another group of people, is not just
the amount of time or labor that went into acquiring the beaver, it was also how much
labor they had put into making the tools in order to hunt the beaver.
Let's say they use a sling or a bow and arrow, whatever, all of that is going to be factored
into it as well.
So labor, so value, I should say, is not only going to be determined by the actual presence
of laborers, but all the history of labor that has gone into the production of a thing,
which includes, like I said, the labor put into making machines, labor of transportation,
labor of overseers, supervisors, whatever.
Now if you have two different commodities, two different products that are made with
the exact same amount of labor, then technically they should be worth the same amount in the
market.
That is, their value should be the exact same.
Now there are so many problems with this, not because Ricardo is necessarily wrong,
but because we live in a different world now, and it feels very strange to think about value
in this way.
So for example, when one of the Kardashians is paid millions of dollars to make a Twitter
post, are they doing labor?
And if not, where is that capital, that money, those dollars, coming from?
What is it being paid for?
And so here we enter into a kind of new realm where capital isn't nearly as attached to
labor as perhaps it once was.
Or if it is, it is much more hidden, which is kind of Marx's nightmare, but we'll get
into that with Marx as we go on.
This is just something to keep on the back burner.
Now if everything was equal between two manufacturers that were producing two different commodities,
that is the amount of labor and all that put into these two different commodities, then
their values should be the same.
But the world doesn't work that way, and one manufacturer might have better machinery than
another, or another manufacturer might have better workers than another, you know, whatever.
Any of these things are going to change the value, or the price even, of a thing when
it comes to market, when it is prepared to be sold.
But these are two different things.
So let's say one enterprise had better machinery, and one enterprise had better workers.
These draw from two different kinds of capital.
So if we remember capital is everything, it can include, you know, money put into a company
in order to pay wages, or to pay for machinery, or the machinery itself, all of this falls
under the domain of capital.
But capital can be further differentiated into either fixed capital, or circulating
capital.
So fixed capital is the capital that is able to be procured or put into machines, things
that you're going to have for a long time, that you know, you might buy once, and you
have to pay a little bit to maintain, but it's going to be there, and it's going to
keep earning you the same amount of money, hopefully.
Now, circulating capital is capital spent on labor, which is want to change, it might
change quite a lot, actually.
So you're paying an employee, and if the employee is dissatisfied with how much they're making,
they might go work somewhere else.
And so that labor is not going to be, or that capital is not going to be fixed.
You don't own laborers when you pay them wages, which is kind of a, this is what Ricardo thinks,
so we'll accept that for now.
But of course, Marx is going to problematize all of this.
Now between fixed capital and circulating capital, they form a spectrum, I should say.
So it's not just as though fixed capital exists, you know, totally separate from circulating
capital, they in fact, mirror one another in a lot of ways.
So in order to maintain machines, it is required to hire maybe certain laborers that are going
to watch over it, which are then apt to change, they might change, you know, they might want
to earn more money, they might work somewhere else.
And so does that then change the way that fixed capital is associated with the machine
or circulating capital is associated with the machine, because now, it is determined
not only by it as being a stationary thing, but it is now dependent upon circulating capital.
So this is, he doesn't really elaborate on this, but it's kind of an important distinction,
or it's good to know that fixed capital and circulating capital form a spectrum.
Now here's the kicker when it comes to fixed capital and circulating capital.
If you had a business that focused more on fixed capital, so let's say a factory, it
had lots of machines that it relied on to keep earning it the same kind of money.
Now if we contrast that with something, a business that relies more on circulating capital,
let's say, for example, I don't know, you have a business of painters, and these painters
go around and paint people's houses.
That is all circulating capital because you don't own like a building, you might not even
own a building, you might not even own equipment, you might not own anything.
It's just you're paying people to do a job and they might leave, they might go, whatever.
Now if we compare these two kinds of businesses, one reliant on fixed capital versus one reliant
on circulating capital, a rise in wages in each of them, or in either of them, is going
to have different effects on the price of the thing being produced, or the service being
provided.
So he believes that with a company that relies more on fixed capital, as wages go up, so
as the employees are paid more, the value of the product produced will go down, whereas
with circulating capital, or a company or business that relies more on circulating capital,
as wages go up, the price of goods, the things being produced, will also go up.
So what he's essentially saying here is that less durable machines, or less durable equipment,
things that are going to need a lot of circulating capital going through them in order to maintain
them is going to have more of an effect on the cost of the thing being produced than
in the case of fixed capital, or it will have a different effect, I should say.
So if there's a business that relies on circulating capital, a lot of money is going to be put
to keep, I guess, people happy, to keep, if there are like little pieces of equipment
being used, they probably aren't very durable, because, you know, there's not a reliance
on big, heavy, steady, fixed machines, then what's going to happen is that as wages go
up, and all of those pieces of equipment are going to need to have their little bit of
maintenance they're going to need, more of them is going to need to be bought, etc, etc.
As wages go up, because more labor is still going to be needed, then so too will the price
of commodities go up, or the price of the things being produced go up.
Now if there's a company or business that relies more on fixed capital, as wages go
up, the owner of the company will say, well, I'm just going to lean more heavily on all
my machines, because, you know, I don't want to have to pay these people more.
And so they will find ways to get around having to pay the people more by probably firing
them, laying them off, relying more on the machines, which is going to allow them to
actually bring their prices of things down, or to keep them the same.
Now all businesses rely on some kind of relationship or proportion between fixed and circulating
capital.
No one business relies purely on one, and another business purely on the other.
And so part of the ways that value is ascertained, or it demands an engagement with all of these
dynamics between fixed and circulating capital, which is all very abstract and all very difficult
to do, because it's actually quite difficult to ascertain the difference between circulating
and fixed capital, because it's a spectrum.
And so the best we can kind of do is to just, well, I guess, try, you know, to attach somewhat
arbitrary significance to certain things like labor, like gold, corn, in order to have some
kind of benchmark, or to be able to say that that machine there represents fixed capital,
whereas, you know, the paper person, the paper boy going throwing papers around is an example
of circulating capital.
Not mentioning, of course, the fact that the bike is fixed capital for the kid who's relying
upon it potentially forever to do their job.
But anyways.
But with all this being said, a raise in wages does not necessarily mean that the value of
labor has gone up.
It might have meant as well that the value of money has gone down.
So it takes more money to be able to pay for people to do their job.
So if before $10 was what you paid someone an hour, if that raised to $11 because of
inflation, the people are still going to be, the workers, I should say, are still going
to be earning the same amount in real value, because $11 is going to buy you out in the
real world, everything that $10 used to, you're going to have a higher wage, but you're still
going to have the same buying power, or the real value will have stayed the same, whereas
the nominal value will have changed, or the nominal price will have changed, which is
just the number price.
So to determine something's real value will be to say, okay, how much of other things
in the world can I buy with this thing?
Now that is what is called its natural price.
So let's say a hat will get you two pieces of cloth.
Let's just say, for example, it gets you two pieces of cloth.
And then the next year, it can suddenly get you three pieces of cloth.
Now if we just look at that one example, we could say either that the value of the hat
has gone up, allowing you to buy more with it, you know, with the money you get for it,
it'll allow you to buy more cloth, or the value of cloth has gone down, in which case,
it takes less to buy more of it.
But if we found out as well, if we took many more examples, let's say, one year a hat,
you know, you get two pieces of cloth, you can get two cartons of milk, you can get half
a dozen eggs with it, all of that, you know, each one of those things potentially for the
hat.
And the next year, you're able to get more of all of those things, you can probably be
pretty certain that the value of the hat, its real value has gone up.
So it has become more expensive, it has gone above the natural price.
That is what it was the year before in relationship to all of these things.
And it has attained a kind of new value in that world.
Now, of course, with time, those things will come to balance out again, and they'll attain
what is kind of called the natural price of things.
That is however many things the hat can buy in relation to others.
But for a moment, it will have risen in real value, not just in the dollar value, because
now it buys a lot more of everything else.
So value is determined largely by relationships.
So the relationship between labor gone into producing something, but also it can be ascertained
by relationships between various people, between the three classes, broad classes of society
between landowners, capitalists, and workers, where if one of those groups, groups is buying
power from one year to the next, suddenly goes up, then we are seeing a disequilibrium,
we are seeing a departure from the natural rate of the natural price of a natural order
of things.
And one of those classes has attained more power than before, or more real value than
before.
And that, you know, that's essentially lays out the first chapter, it's the longest of
the bunch.
So don't worry, we're gonna the next ones are going to be much quicker.
And that sets out pretty much his view on value, which is an important one and one to
really have a strong grasp of going forward.
Now that brings us here into chapter two, on rent.
Now this is probably the most important part of this whole book, because here is where
he establishes or lays out his view of rent, that is diametrically opposed to many other
political economists of the time, specifically Adam Smith, Buchanan, and Malthus, who all
have an erroneous or incorrect view of how rent, the value of rent, or even the price
of rent, is determined.
So in the work of Adam Smith in The Wealth of Nations, he pretty much says that rent
is the product of profits.
So if, you know, if I owned a piece of land, and some capitalists were to come along and
say, hey, this is a great piece of land, let me put up this building here, I can start,
you know, manufacturing, and I will pay you a proportion of the profits being made.
Or if I have a plot of land, some farmer might come along, this capitalist might come along,
whatever, and say, hey, this is a great plot of land for me to earn some dollars off of
by growing some corn, let me grow some corn here, and I'll give you some money for profit,
in proportion to the profit that I make.
So that's how the landlord will make money through rent for Adam Smith.
Now, Ricardo sets out a completely different vision of rent here, and it is the crux of
this whole book.
For me, I don't know how it wouldn't be the crux of the whole book, because it comes up
over and over again.
So it's very important to know, but it's also a little bit tricky to illustrate, at least
through words.
So I'm going to try to be as clear as humanly possible in order to make this accessible
so that you know what's going on.
Now let's imagine a new territory is discovered with no one living on it, and it is just filled
with fertile land.
The people who find it, and there's no one else there, the people who find it obviously
are going to start working on the land, and they're going to start growing things on the
part of the land that is the easiest to grow on.
Which just makes sense, they're not going to go to the barren parts of the land to try
to make, to try to grow produce, that's just a bad idea.
So they're going to go to the most fertile part of the land that is the easiest to work
on, but because they're the first ones there, they aren't paying any rent.
So let's say, you know, they have a colony or there's a country that they are a part
of that they've just kind of departed from for a bit, they might say, okay, well, we
are making so much corn on this plot of land to feed ourselves, yet we have all of this
surplus corn.
We have corn that just goes way above what we need, why don't we just sell it back to
the country that we came from, sell it back to the nearest city, whatever.
So they are only going to be making like pure profit off of that after they pay the workers
that they've got there, or whatever, they're going to just pay them, and they aren't paying
rent to anybody.
So they're just having a great old time making as much corn as possible.
And you know, what that does is it makes the population happier.
Now let's say that suddenly the corn that was being made on that piece of land was no
longer enough.
So the population just started to grow for any number of reasons, the population started
to grow, there might be more demand coming from the city.
And so the people on this plot of land are like, okay, well, we have to expand, but expanding
demands that they expand into the less fertile land.
They're going to need to expand into those parts of the country that make it harder to
grow on, probably.
So let's call this next plot of land plot 2.
So we have plot 1 that was super easy to grow on, now we have plot 2, and it's a little
bit more difficult.
So by putting in the same amount of labor, you make less, because it demands more work
to actually get produce from it, to get more corn from it, or to get the same amount as
the first plot of land.
So you have two options.
Either you employ the same amount of labor and make less produce, you make less corn,
or you employ more labor and you make the same amount of corn.
In either case, it's going to be somewhat detrimental.
So it's going to either cost more to employ more labor to earn the same amount to make
the same amount of corn, or you're going to make less money off of it because you're going
to have made less corn by employing the same amount of labor.
But between these two plots of land, that is between the fertile one, plot 1, and the
less fertile one, plot 2, you can't charge different prices for the corn, otherwise the
plot on the second land won't be able to sell any of their corn and there would have been
no reason for it.
So they have to sell the corn at the same price, otherwise there is no point of doing
it in the first place.
So the value of the corn then, the price of the corn then, is going to be determined by
however expensive it is to make, to grow, on the less fertile plot of land.
So you're going to use that as your benchmark.
So let's say on the first plot of land it cost $100, you know this is absolutely a ridiculous
number, but let's say for example it cost you $100 to make all of the corn.
And you were able to sell that for $110, for example.
So you make $10 profit on the first plot of land.
Now the second plot of land, you have to put in $110 in order to make, I don't know, $115.
So you only make a profit of $5 on the second plot of land.
So the first plot of land makes a profit of $10, whereas the second plot of land makes
a profit of $5.
Now it wouldn't make much sense if one of those people was earning more than the other.
That is, with one person earning $10, another person earning $5, because then the person
earning $5 will say screw this, I'm out of here.
So they must actually create some kind of equilibrium between the two in order to balance
it out.
And this equilibrium comes in the form of rent, where now the person who owns the most
fertile plot of land is going to, I guess, transform into this thing called the landlord,
who is then going to take $5 off of the $10 profit in order to pay for themselves, to
pay, you know, to earn money for owning this fertile plot of land.
So rent is going to come out of the profits of the most fertile land.
Whereas the other plot of land, plot of land number two, pays no rent for Ricardo.
So the price of a thing is going to be determined by however difficult it is to make a less
fertile plot of land, because it has to be equal all across the board.
So we have to take the lowest possible measure as being the determining one.
Not lowest as in money value, but lowest as in least quality one that is sold for the
highest amount, or that is the most difficult to make that is therefore sold for the highest
amount.
Otherwise, no one would work that land, because if one, the first plot of land just made their
prices higher than the other, or lower than the other, sorry, then they would just run
them out of business and there will have been no point.
But the problem will remain, how do you make up for the demand?
How do you satisfy that demand?
So the value of an object, the price of an object is going to be determined by the least
fertile plot of land.
If we're talking about raw produce here, if we're talking about things being grown, whereas
rent is only going to come out of those ones that came before it, that are more fertile
than the other one.
And the rent is going to be the difference between the profits the first one makes versus
the profit the second one makes.
Now let's say, hypothetically, that second plot of land has been worked to as much as
it can be, and a third plot of land then needs to be explored, needs to be used up.
That plot of land will then determine the price of the objects.
That plot of land, the plot of land number three, will pay no rent.
And now, plot of land number two will start to pay rent, because it is earning more profit
than the other one, plot of land number three, and the difference between them will determine
how much rent is being paid, while still the difference between the first and the second,
but as well now between the first and the third, is going to determine how much rent
the first plot of land makes.
Now this might all be very difficult to imagine in your head.
So if you just imagine three plots of land, just to, I guess, get the most basic understanding
here, the most fertile one will pay the most rent, whereas the least fertile one is going
to be the one that determines the price of the objects, and it is the one that pays no
rent.
And rent is determined by the difference between the most recently, the most recently employed
land versus the last and any one before it, the employed land before it.
Now in Adam Smith's work, he said that rent will determine the price of objects.
If we take what, or the price of things being produced.
If we take Ricardo seriously here, then he's effectively shown that that is not the case.
Rent does not determine the value of objects.
In fact, it is the labor, the difficulty and toil of the least fertile land that is going
to determine the value of grown products in this case.
So high rent doesn't come from earning more, per se.
High rent is the product of a less abundant land being employed, being sought after, being
cultivated, not the sign of the most abundant land being cultivated.
So rent is not determined by high price of commodities or the other way around.
Rent does not determine that.
It is only determined, rent is determined by labor put onto the least fertile, least
workable land.
So if new machines were used on the land, or if new methods of agriculture were discovered,
what that would mean might be that we no longer need to work on the less cultivated, cultivatable
lands or the less fertile lands, or we're able to earn, to make more from it.
Now what that will do is it will shrink the gap between the first plot of land and the
last plot of land being cultivated.
And what that will mean is actually a reduction in rent.
So as a country grows more efficient, as it grows more productive, as it develops new
technology, rent will actually go down for Ricardo, not up.
Because for Smith, he says, as society progresses, rent will go up because people are earning
more and they'll be able to pay more.
Ricardo thinks that that's totally wrong for the reasons I've already just said.
So whereas the capitalist and the laborer are kind of on the same side here, they want
their lives to be easier when it comes to working the land, the landlord doesn't want
that.
The landlord wants it to be difficult because that means then that worse land is being cultivated,
which means that it is very difficult, which means that the price paid to them in rent
will go up because there will be a bigger gap between the most fertile land and the
least fertile land.
Now that's an important thing to know as we go forward here throughout the rest of the
book because it's going to come up again and again and again.
Now here we move on to chapter three on the rent of mines, where he says that essentially
like land, the rent of mines will be determined by the difficulty in, I guess, attaining things
from the mine.
And so the most difficult mine to actually mine in will be the one that is going to determine
the value of the objects circulating within the economy and not because of the easiest
mine to work in.
So the value of anything taken from the mines, like gold or silver or whatever, its value
is going to be determined by the total quantity of labor necessary to obtain it and to bring
it to market.
So it's not as though it's just going to determine value or increase value because these things
like gold and silver are innately valuable.
They're only going to go up in value as they have a relationship to the labor put into
them.
And that puts us here into chapter four, the difference between a natural price of something
and the market price.
So the natural price refers to the, I guess, the price that anything has in relation to
everything else in the market.
And so this natural price is a price at equilibrium between supply and demand, between other things
in the market and so on.
Of course, there might be like trends, for example, that make it so that linen is more
fashionable than whatever, cashmere is more fashionable than linen, whatever.
You might have trends like that and you might see then the money price of something go up,
but it will eventually gravitate back down to its equilibrium, to its natural price.
And whereas its market price will just be what it goes for nominally, how many dollars
it will be, you know, it'll cost them to get it.
But you know, just to meditate on this for a second, it's exceptionally interesting to
me that this idea about value is so determined through money, because money is no real standard
of value.
Or that value is determined by its, a thing's relationship to other things, like how many
of those other things can you get for this thing?
So value is always being deferred, like it's never found in anything itself.
But it also, it only comes from relationships to other things in a certain economy of commodities.
Now what this does is essentially reveal just how subjective it is.
And it's all that much more mysterious to me how then we are able to have any agreement
at all.
Yet we can.
But anyways, that's just something that interests me.
Now that puts us into chapter five on wages.
And this book is like 30 some chapters long.
And the first two, that is the one on value and the one on rent are the longest.
But everything else is like, a few of them are only like a page long.
And it's kind of silly.
So it might come off like I'm just saying like a list like and then this and then this
and then this.
And sorry, that's not the best storytelling, but working with what I got here.
So yeah, chapter five on wages.
So the value of wages for Ricardo is going to be affected by the supply and demand of
laborers and the price of commodities.
So like any other mark, any other product in the marketplace, wages or labor has both
a natural and a market price.
So the natural price of labor is the price required in order to keep the laborers alive
and happy.
Because if you don't do that, then you won't have laborers.
So if $10 is the agreed price, let's say for per hour for a laborer, it is implied that
$10 is what is going to be required for them to have shelter, to have food, to have whatever
else they might need in order to survive.
Now the next year, that might have to go up to $11 because the price of everything else
has gone up for whatever reason, inflation, whatever.
So what that means then is its market price has gone up, it's a nominal price, it has
gone from $10 to $11, but its real price has stayed the same because it is still implied
that they are still going to be making the same amount to buy the same things that they
could before, the same necessities, the same food, shelter that they could before.
So if the cost of necessities goes up, if the cost of goods go up, so too must the cost
of wages because you still need your laborers to be able to make or buy those things I should
say that they need to survive.
But it works both ways.
So if the price of necessities or goods goes down, then so too will the price of labor.
Now that's all well and good in some kind of fairytale world where people will just
accept to have a decrease in wages, but that's really not how it happens in the real world
as it shouldn't.
But in any case, this is what he gives us, that as the price of commodities go up, then
wages will have to go up as well, and the reverse is also true.
Now the natural price of labor will always attain some degree of equilibrium, but the
problem here is that sometimes the effects are difficult to ascertain where capitalists
might say, okay, I think we can bring down the price of labor, I think we can pay them
less because the price of X, Y, and Z things has gone down, so they should be fine.
But then they do that, and suddenly thousands of people starve to death, and they're like,
oh, uh-oh, we have to bring it back up.
So what is the price of life at that point?
It seems totally wrong to just leave it totally up to the free market because there are these
potential negative effects.
There seems that there should be oversight to make sure that no single life is lost because
of someone's greed.
Carto doesn't consider that.
Instead, he says that almost any tax or any kind of law that limits this or that sets
like minimum wage standards is going to be harmful to the poorer classes, and he also
proposes regulating reproduction of poor people, which is just eugenics that is very clearly
problematic and not anything that should be espoused.
And it's quite ironic because he's against one form of regulation but for another.
He's okay with regulating bodies but not regulating the market.
And it's funny.
We see very much the same impulses that govern many conservative trends in North America.
It's all about policing people's bodies, but let the market that affects people on an immeasurable
scale do whatever it wants.
And that'll stop the first episode here at the end of the chapter 5 on wages, and from
here we'll move on from chapter 6 on profits.
And if you listened this far, thanks a lot.
If there's anything I got wrong here, I'd love to hear about it.
If there's anything you like, leave a comment.
If you're listening to this on Apple Podcasts and I think even Spotify now, if you can leave
comments wherever you listen to this in podcast form, do it.
I'd love to hear from you.
Leave 5 stars if you can, if you like what I did.
And yeah, catch you next time.
Take care.

