Daisy Delogu, The Afterlives of Joan of Arc

BookverseNow
7 followers
16 Video Views·Nov 22, 2023
There is no doubt that Joan of Arc—15th-century heroine or heretic, depending on your point of view—led an extraordinary life. No less compelling are her seemingly countless, often contradictory, cultural afterlives. How can one person mean so much? This session examined some of the ways in which the figure of Joan has been invoked and deployed over the centuries since her execution to serve a dizzying array of religious, political, cultural, and artistic ends, from symbol of France, to figure of resistance, to model of personal integrity and courage.
- So thank you everyone for coming.
I hope you're having a good Humanities Day,
and welcome or re-welcome to the Smart Museum.
Before I start, I want to issue my raft of thank yous.
So really first and foremost,
thanks to the staff at the Smart Museum
for all of their assistance,
and especially Berit Ness who's not here right now,
but she's a wonderful collaborator,
for incorporating collections into curricula
and she's been very helpful with my past
Joan of Arc courses.
I'd also like to thank the humanities division staff,
and especially all the tech people who are here right now,
and the ones who are not here right now,
but were here earlier to make all of our equipment work
for the people in the room and also for the people on Zoom.
And last, and really most important,
I'd like to give a big shout out to all of my past students
and my past graduate student teaching assistants
in my Joan of Arc classes,
because I've taught two different times,
a course on Joan of Arc, history and legend.
The first time I taught it,
one of my students on the first day asked me
if Joan of Arc was a real person.
And I think that it's an entirely legitimate question,
because there's so much mythology that has accreted
around the figure of Joan of Arc that,
it's a legitimate question one might ask oneself.
So when I teach the class,
we spend the first half of the quarter, more or less,
just going through the documents
about what we know about her life, her history.
And then in the second half of the quarter,
we move into what I've called today, the afterlives.
And so that's a little bit
how we're gonna organize the class today.
Just to set up a little bit,
what is the state of play when Joan of Arc
comes on the scene?
In the 15th century,
is when she comes on the scene.
And so basically what we're dealing with is warfare.
So there is an ongoing war between France and England.
This is the Hundred Years' War that you might've heard of,
or you might've read about it in Shakespeare.
This is already in about year 90, more or less.
But then in addition, there's a civil war that's going on,
and the civil war is taking place
between the King of France, Charles VII,
whose legitimacy has been contested,
the King of England, Henry the VI.
Henry the VI is actually a baby, but that's okay,
'cause the war is being prosecuted for him by other people.
And then the third party is Philip the Good,
the Duke of Burgundy.
And all of these people are related to one another.
They're all second cousins,
or first cousins once removed or some such thing.
And so we have layers of war on top of layers of war,
and imagine in your brain, the kingdom of France,
and in the lower maybe third is territory that is controlled
by Charles VII by the King of France.
And then we have here some areas up in the north,
where Normandy is and also some areas down here,
in the Pyrenees and over by Bordeaux.
These are regions that are controlled by,
or under the direct occupation of the King of England.
And then over here in what is today the low countries,
Belgium, Eastern France, you get the picture.
We have a big zone that is controlled by,
or under the occupation of the Duke of Burgundy.
And so the king of France at this time,
does not control Paris.
That's a really important point.
He's well south of Paris and the Loire,
and so he's in control then about of a third of his kingdom.
So 1429 is Joan of Arc's big year.
And so I've ordered it both geographically,
and chronologically.
Domremy is where she's born.
Vaucouleurs is where she has her first success,
and I'm defining success here,
as her first success in convincing a total stranger
that he should trust her and help her.
Next Chinon, she undergoes multiple tests of her person.
Orleans is the very famous,
maybe what most people have heard about Joan of Arc,
raising the siege at Orleans.
And then Reims is the city in France,
where all of the kings of France are anointed,
from time immemorial.
And so this is where Joan of Arc succeeds
in having Charles VII crowned and anointed.
And we're gonna go through each
of these spots a little bit more slowly.
So we see that Domremy is up here, just a tiny smidget,
south of Vosges and it's also in a border zone.
So Alsace and Lorraine,
you might know from more recent history,
has been a region that has been disputed between
what is today, France and Germany,
but what was then not France and Germany,
but it is nevertheless a border zone.
And I think it's really important
to just keep this in mind if we're thinking
about Joan of Arc's childhood,
because some people are growing up in a part of France
where the political allegiances are pretty coherent,
they're pretty consistent.
You're in French territory,
you're in English territory.
Here? No.
The people in the village over are Burgundian.
And the people in her village are French.
And so the experience of civil war,
is one that's being lived out by people in the fabric
of their daily lives.
So at around the age of 13, she begins to hear voices,
and the voices tell her that she needs to go to France,
which also shows she's not in France,
if she has to go to France, right?
And that she needs to find the king,
and she needs to save the kingdom.
And so she doesn't act on this voice right away.
You can imagine that it takes several years actually,
before she takes action.
And just as an aside,
all of the information that we have about Joan of Arc's life
and things that happened to her,
the vast, vast, vast majority of it,
comes from the trial documentation.
But it's really important to bear in mind,
that the trial documentation undergoes multiple revisions
and transformations both linguistic from oral to written,
from different manuscript copies.
And so it's mediated
through these multiple voices and hands.
And we need to always just remember that,
what is said at the trial,
we need to take a little bit with a grain of salt,
or just remember that it's a heavily mediated
set of documents.
And she calls herself from the time
that she begins to act on this broader stage and forward,
Jeanne la Pucelle, Jeanne the maiden, daughter of God.
She says that she's been sent by God,
to save the king, to save the kingdom.
So here's Google Maps.
If you wanted to go from Domremy to Vaucouleurs,
it would take you four hours,
it would take you four hours
if you were walking on that road.
If you are not walking on that road,
'cause it's the 15th century,
it'd probably take you a little bit longer.
And so this just gives you a sense of the scale
of the journey that she's undertaken.
So she goes to Vaucouleurs three times.
Here's what remains of Vaucouleurs.
So Robert de Baudricourt is the captain of the village,
and the fortress at Vaucouleurs,
which is one of the only remaining strongholds
loyal to France north of the Loire River.
And she goes multiple times.
And to me, three always sounds a little too much
like a fairytale for me to a hundred percent believe it,
but at the same time I don't have other data.
So anyway, it is said that she goes three times,
and on the third time, Robert de Baudricourt,
finally is like "Fine."
And he gives her a sword, an escort and men's clothing.
And so with her escort in her men's clothing,
she goes from Vaucouleurs to Chinon.
Now if you were walking, it would take you 97 hours.
She's on horseback riding at night,
through Burgundian and English controlled territory.
It takes many days to get to Chinon.
And when she arrives at Chinon,
they do not know what to do with her.
They do not know what to make of her.
So imagine a 16,
17-year-old peasant girl showing up at your door,
and announcing that she is there
to save you and your kingdom.
So no one, I mean, no one wants to really condemn her
out of hand because if on the outside chance she is legit,
and God has sent her,
you don't want to say "No," to the gift of God,
but at the same time she could be demonic.
And so they're just very, very cautious.
And so what they do is for about six weeks she's examined,
and I mean examined.
They verify her virginity,
because this is an important point both to prove the honesty
of what she has said to them.
She has said that she's a maiden,
and also to prove her chastity,
which means that she's pure of soul, pure of heart.
And they also try to evaluate her religious orthodoxy.
Does she know her prayers? Has she been baptized?
Who are her godparents? Does she go to church?
And at the end of all this she seems okay,
but they're really still not sure.
So they decide that they're gonna wait for a sign,
and what they decide is going to be this sign,
it is Orleans.
And so they agree with her that she can go
with her contingent of people to Orleans,
and that she can attempt to raise the siege at Orleans.
So a couple things about Orleans.
Orleans is the last big city
that's holding out in the northern part
of Charles VII's territories.
If Orleans falls,
the English are just gonna keep going south,
and it's gonna be pretty much a clean sweep.
And so strategically and militarily,
it's very important that they hang on to Orleans.
But in addition, the Lord of Orleans,
is currently in prison in England,
because in 1415 at the Battle of Agincourt,
he'd been taken prisoner and had not yet been released.
So just so that you understand from a chivalric
point of view, a code of honor point of view,
it is not okay to attack the town or the fortress,
the property, the castle,
of someone you are holding prisoner,
because by definition that person cannot defend themselves.
So you're engaged in something dishonorable,
slightly sketchy and everyone knows this.
Even though I think at the time there was a lot of conflict
between ideals of warfare and codes of honor,
and realities of warfare and wanting to win.
So this is again from the trial documentation,
so to be taken with a grain of salt, a citation from Joan,
to one of the illegitimate sons of the Duke of Burgundy,
who is defending the town,
and the fortress.
"God at the request of saints,
Louis and Charlemagne, took pity on the city of Orleans,
and does not want to allow
that his enemies possess both the person
of the Lord of Orleans and his city."
And so for whatever reason,
that really is not fully explicable honestly,
she is successful.
I mean, she and all of the other soldiers,
are successful collectively.
Yes, collectively the siege is broken,
it is a victory for the French,
it is a turning point in the entire really,
Hundred Years' War,
and in also the French civil war, sub war, in between.
People who maybe believed her to begin with are vindicated.
People who weren't sure think,
"Well, maybe she is to be believed."
Even the people who did not believe her cannot deny
that something unexpected,
interpreted then as miraculous,
has happened in military terms.
And so after this victory,
what Jeanne d'Arc wants to do is take the king to Reims.
And so here we are in Orleans,
and we can see it's well south of Paris,
just a little smidge west.
And then Reims is up here north and east again,
far, far in English controlled,
and Burgundian controlled territory.
And so there are many advisors who think
that it is a bad idea to try to go to Reims,
that it's too risky,
and that the payoff is not really that great.
And Jeanne d'Arc's argument is that the symbolic importance
of being anointed and crowned at Reims is essential
for Charles VII.
That for him to reign as king,
and for him to really assume his role as king,
he has to do this.
He has no option. So off they go.
And because the news of Orleans has spread quickly,
in as much as news spreads quickly in the 15th century,
towns and strongholds lay down their arms.
They just are like,
"Come on in, come on through, no problem."
And so this becomes in some places,
an almost triumphant just procession,
from Orleans to Reims,
where there's very, very little armed resistance,
to the king.
And all of this then becomes mutually reinforcing
the further they get and the less they have trouble,
the more it seems to be an indication of God's favor
or return of God's favor, something.
In any case, it all re-downs to the glory then,
of Joan of Arc.
So this is a manuscript illumination of the anointing,
and I just want to observe that Joan of Arc is not here.
And so there's a lot of tension,
even, I mean in scholarship, people do not agree now,
and I think people did not agree then,
over what to make of, what to do with, how to incorporate,
Joan of Arc into a political program.
And so there is a lot of notable silence
on the part of the king,
at least public silence around Joan of Arc.
So then things start to go badly after Reims.
Around about a year later,
she's captured in Compiegne by the Burgundians,
and she's sold to the English who want to put her on trial,
not for any secular or political crime,
but trial for heresy,
because for them it is important not just to kill her,
they actually don't wanna just kill her.
They want to discredit her.
They want to show that this is not a divine
set of happenings and that she is not
a divinely sent person.
So around about a year after she's captured, she's executed,
she's burned at the stake in Rouen.
And then a handful of years later,
there's the Peace of Arras between Charles VII,
and Philip the Good, which puts an end to the civil war.
And then 20-ish years later,
an end to the Hundred Years' War.
And then just a couple of years later,
there's what's sometimes called the trial in rehabilitation,
or the nullification trial.
They really just say that,
what happened in the original trial,
it's like it didn't exist,
like it didn't happen, didn't unfold.
And this is important for Charles VII,
because no one wants to owe their legitimacy
to a convicted heretic, right?
And then she's canonized, but a lot later actually in 1920.
And you notice the timing with World War I, right?
And the conclusion to World War I. Okie doke.
So here is the only extant visual representation
of Joan from her lifetime.
And actually it's really great,
that we have it in the background.
You can start to look at the the sculpture on the right,
because we have certain features that are shared.
And I would point out the skirt plus armor,
a look that many of us sport,
and the well, hair of varying length in both cases,
holding a sword,
but not in a position that it can actually be used,
and in the drawing holding a battle standard.
All right? So you can just keep looking at those sculptures.
So reading the trial documentation,
it's a little bit like a war of attrition.
She's asked the same questions over and over and over,
and over again,
and you can almost as you're reading,
feel her wearing down and wearing out.
And nevertheless,
there are these phrases that are recurrent,
that as I read it, demonstrate her efforts to push back,
and to resist the lines of questioning.
And so keep going.
"Does this have anything to do with your trial?"
"I'm not saying anything else right now.
I'm not permitted to tell you that."
And this refers to the fact that according to Joan,
God told her not to reveal any of her secrets,
or anything that the voices said to anyone but the king.
And then finally, "I've already told you that."
And that's true because they ask her
the same things all the time.
All righty.
So they drop 70 articles of accusation against Joan of Arc.
These are eventually narrowed down into 12 main accusations.
And here I've given you just some of the ones that I find
to be particularly relevant,
especially in terms of her later reception.
"So you assert Joan, that you've had revelations,
and apparitions of angels and saints.
This is very presumptuous to think that God has spoken
to you as though you were Moses."
And "You assert that by God's command you have worn,
and continue to wear men's clothing,
and have cut your hair short without leaving upon you
a single trace that shows you are a woman."
The whole clothing hair thing is such a big deal
to people at the time, and people later.
You can hardly imagine how important it seems to be.
And also this second part of it,
it's not just that you've cut your hair,
and that you're wearing men's clothes,
it's that you're not broadcasting in any way
what your sex is.
And this is problematic.
And then I also really love this one,
"You assert that the saints speak French and not English."
I think the French today,
think all the saints speak French, not English.
"Because you are not of the latter's party."
And so here we can see,
we can imagine a current going into a nationalism,
patriotism, alliance of nationalism with religion,
that in some later contexts has taken on
very nefarious qualities,
and that in other cases has been inspirational.
"And then finally you assert that if holy church..."
And holy church, what her accusers mean,
is the church as an institution,
comprised of a clerical administrative apparatus.
"If holy church wished you to do the contrary
of what you say God has commanded you to do,
you wouldn't do it."
And so this idea that she obeys God,
but she doesn't obey the clerics,
who are carrying out her trial,
this distinction that she makes is very threatening,
and very problematic for them.
She's found guilty of heresy, blasphemy,
idolatry, and also schism.
And she is, like I said, burned at the stake.
All right, so I actually think now,
just because I think it's gonna take us a little minute,
I'm gonna invite you if you wish, starting here,
to stand up and maybe make one loop.
If you wanna be able to look more closely at the artworks
that are with us,
that you can go around the back of the table,
and then down this side of the room
and go back in your seats.
The afterlives stymied me.
I had this point where I was like,
"Which afterlives am I gonna talk about?"
Because there's a zillion of them,
and they're constantly more and more and more.
And I am sure that I have underestimated,
and underrepresented the amount of cultural production.
And some of the afterlives are so diametrically opposed,
that you can hardly understand
how the same person could have been invoked as explanatory,
or exemplary in these contexts.
So just to give you one example, during World War II,
Joan of Arc is held up as a model,
an inspiration for the French resistance,
but she's also made into the poster child of Vichy France,
the Collaborationist government.
And here, shout out Phoebe Holtz,
whose final presentation in my class in the spring
was on Vichy France,
because that was actually not on my radar.
It's one of the many uses
to which Joan of Arc has subsequently been put.
But it's a very interesting one to my mind.
And then I have just my tiny quote from Mark Twain.
"Joan of Arc is easily and by far,
the most extraordinary person the human race
has ever produced."
Definitely I would say you could make that argument.
So here we are at the Smart Museum with Joan of Arc.
Both of these statues are from the 19th century.
And I wanna say just a couple words
about the 19th century, why it's important.
For about a decade, maybe a little more than a decade,
Jules Quicherat, a scholar,
edits all of the trial documentation.
And so what this means is locating manuscripts,
transcribing them, printing them into printed editions,
and then creating this published set of works
that provides all, at the time what was known,
what was available about what happened at the trial,
both trials.
And then in addition, Jules Michelet, a historian,
writes a multi-volume history of France with a big chunk
on Joan of Arc that also actually is published independently
as a freestanding biography of Joan of Arc,
and is very popular.
And for him, Joan of Arc is this extremely important figure,
really transformational in the history of France.
She somehow both gives birth to France,
and modernity, which is pretty amazing.
And she's also very feminized by Michelet.
And so the two sculptures that we have with us,
actually, the one further from me is made earlier.
The one closer to me is the one from 1872.
Actually they're so nicely...this wasn't planned,
'cause I didn't know how they'd be set up,
but they're in front of their respective little tickets.
And so the "Princess Marie Christine d'Orleans,"
we all notice that she's d'Orleans.
And so she is a descendant of the Dukes of Orleans,
but she's writing, or sorry,
she's sculpting before Quicherat, before Michelet.
So she's really at the forefront of a rediscovery
of Joan of Arc that's taking place in the 19th century.
And Louis Philippe is her father, the king,
but not an uncontested king.
And he at the time is renovating Versailles.
And so he has asked his daughter
to create this sculpture for display at Versailles.
And so clearly it is playing a role in the legitimation
of his own rule.
Then the second statue, 1870 to 72,
a very different representation, and called,
"Joan of Arc at Domremy,"
and so explicitly invoking the early part of her career
before really Vaucouleurs and all the subsequent history.
And so in terms of her clothing, her posture,
she is very different in appearance
from what she is in the later statue.
And again, the date is worth noting.
1870 is the Franco-Prussian war, which France loses.
But by creating yet another visual representation
of Joan of Arc and connecting Joan of Arc to France
and reminding everyone of the role
that she played in French history,
it's almost a way of pushing back against the reality
of a military defeat that was very humiliating for France.
So we can go back to the statues,
I mean, we will go back to the statues.
But I'm also sensitive to time,
and I wanna make sure we have time for our Q&A.
So the next afterlife that I'd like to talk about,
is a musical one and it's Julius Eastman.
So a couple of years ago I was reading
in "The New Yorker," and I read this phrase,
"It culminated in another startling acapella moment,
a rendition to,
'Prelude to the Holy Presence of Joan of Arc,'
by the avant-garde Black composer Julius Eastman,
who died in obscurity in 1990."
At the time, I've never heard of Julius Eastman,
and I cannot understand why an avant-garde Black composer
would have any interest in Joan of Arc,
but I do not investigate this at the time,
because I'm doing other stuff.
And so I back burner it, I keep the note,
but the next time I teach my class, I go back to it,
because I wanna investigate,
"Well, what's up with this Julius Eastman?"
So, and I hope that you're all gonna go home on YouTube,
and find Julius Eastman,
'cause you wanna hear this whole piece of music.
So the piece of music,
"The Prelude of the Holy Presence of Joan of Arc."
We're gonna listen in just a second, not quite yet,
to just the opening about 45 seconds
and try and hear what the singer is saying.
All right. Which I hope it works.
♪ Saint Michael said ♪
♪ Saint Margaret said ♪
♪ Saint Catherine said ♪
♪ They said ♪
♪ Saint Michael said ♪
♪ Saint Catherine said ♪
♪ Saint Margaret said ♪
♪ She said ♪
- All right, there we go.
So I'm gonna tell you just a little
bit about this piece of music.
It's about 24, 25 minutes long,
and it's divided into two parts.
And so the first part is vocal.
You heard just the beginning of it.
The second part is for 10 cellos,
totally worth listening to,
but we're not gonna listen to it today.
And so for the whole first part of the musical prelude,
what we get is variance on St. Michael said,
St. Catherine said, St. Margaret said,
he said, she said, they said.
And so there's this repetition and this insistence on names
and speaking and speech.
And then we're gonna listen to it in just a minute.
But around minute 3:20, depends on your recording,
There is an introduction of the name Joan,
an apostrophe Joan,
and a melisma,
which we can talk about melisma after we listen to it.
It'll make a lot more sense.
But you'll hear that the name Joan is extended in time,
and that the notes vary.
Then at 6:08, a new word, "Speak."
Then about a minute later, another new word "Boldly."
And then finally we get at about 7:39,
more or less "When they question you, speak boldly."
And I think it's worth remembering that Joan is questioned,
not just at her trial, but really throughout her whole life.
I mean, as soon as she leaves her village,
and starts to try to say who she is,
and what she's trying to accomplish,
people are constantly questioning her.
And then at around minute nine,
there's a real change in the quality of the music.
It becomes much slower. It becomes much softer.
So we're gonna listen to...
Let's see, Davone Tines.
So just as a rappel,
Davone Tines is who "The New Yorker," article was about.
Actually he's a performer.
And so we're gonna first hear him in voiceover,
talking about the work,
because he does this little introduction to a video.
So this, all right, here's Davone Tines.
- [Davone] This piece is actually about
standing in front of people,
and imploring them to be bold in their actions.
He was saying these saints were calling out to this woman
to go forth and do her work.
And everyone can be Joan,
everyone can hear their own saints.
Everybody can connect to an entire lineage of ancestry,
if not the entire flow of human history,
and have all of that force behind them as they walk forward,
to actually do something bold.
- Yeah, I like his introduction a lot.
All right, and so here then,
we're gonna hear the melisma on Joan.
All right? And here's Davone Tines.
♪ Joan ♪
♪ Joan ♪
♪ Joan speak Joan speak ♪
♪ Boldly speak ♪
♪ Speak boldly ♪
♪ Speak speak boldly ♪
♪ Speak boldly speak ♪
♪ Bold speak ♪
♪ Boldly ♪
So part of the reason that I wanted you
to listen first before watching,
was really just to focus on the auditory dimension
of the music.
But when you see Davone Tines performing,
you can tell how much energy and strength,
and effort is being required of singers,
and later in the cello part, same thing,
by Julius Eastman in this piece of music.
That this is a piece of music that requires
your whole body to concentrate on producing it.
Solo in the vocal part,
but collectively in the cello part.
You also heard the melisma on Joan.
And this practice of melisma, this technique,
is reminiscent of medieval monophonic chant.
And so Julius Eastman is also drawing on influences
and currents in medieval music with this medieval source
of inspiration and combining them,
with 20th century minimalism to create this piece of music.
And then the last thing I wanna say about
both Julius Eastman and Davone Tines,
in another part of the voiceover,
I'm pretty sure it's...
I'm confusing, if it's this voiceover,
if it's another interview, it's with Davone Tines.
He says, "As soon as I go on stage,
I am a Black performer.
I cannot get away from my body."
And on the one hand this is super obvious,
and at the same time I think it's worth really thinking
about the bodies that we all bring with us
to the things that we try to do.
Because some bodies, when they appear before us,
they already have credibility,
or they already have value.
And other bodies when they show up they don't.
And Joan of Arc's body when it showed up was young,
poor, uneducated, female, non-noble,
was not a body with credibility or value.
And I would say that for Julius Eastman,
for Davone Tines,
that this is also something that they have to deal with.
They don't get to walk around in an unmarked body.
So I wanna listen now just to the end part,
which I just also love.
All right, so we can go ahead Steve, thank you.
And play the last little bit.
This is maybe the last 30-ish seconds.
♪ Speak ♪
♪ Boldly ♪
♪ Joan ♪
♪ Speak boldly ♪
♪ Speak boldly ♪
♪ Speak ♪
♪ Boldly ♪
♪ Speak ♪
♪ Boldly ♪
So you almost are not quite sure when he stops singing.
And it's a very different quality of sound,
from what we heard in the earlier parts of the prelude.
And so sometimes when I think about the structure
of the prelude, the first part of it,
the very forceful part almost feels like
an apostrophe to me,
like an earlier stage of Joan of Arc's career,
where she is being exhorted by her voices,
to get a move on, get out of Domremy,
go do the things that you're supposed to do,
that we're telling you you need to do.
And to me, this final part,
it almost feels like a voice in your own head,
where it's not sound coming from without,
but it's sound coming from within.
And I think sometimes about what it could have been like
to be imprisoned,
and to be confronted with all these judges,
to have the contemplation of your own end,
whatever that was gonna look like.
And I think she didn't really know
what that was gonna look like,
till it was right in front of her.
I think that something she did imagine for herself
was life imprisonment at worst.
I don't think she imagined being burned at the stake.
And there is again, I mean who really knows,
but I think possibly we should imagine feelings of betrayal,
of abandon, of wondering where the voices were.
Had they fallen silent? Had she done the wrong thing?
And so this gradual hushing of the voice
at the end of the song,
I find to be both a testament to what she has done,
and her vulnerability,
but also something of a fragility,
to which she doesn't succumb,
to which she really never succumbs.
And so this, for me, this is one of the most moving,
and also for me, inspirational,
of the many afterlives I could have chosen,
both because of Joan of Arc,
but also because of Julius Eastman,
and also because the tradition of musicians then,
and creatives that he is inspiring in turn.
And this idea articulated by Davone Tines,
that there is a genealogy or a futurity to the potential
that is opened up, the possibilities that are opened up,
by the figure of Joan of Arc.
So thank you very much.
(audience applauding)
- Hi, I recently read about Julius Eastman,
and I was just wondering,
did he feel like he was ostracized himself?
Why did he cling so into Joan of Arc
and wrote this piece?
'Cause he had a rough life,
and he ended up dying so tragically.
- Yeah, I mean I think that he is a person
who had difficulty finding acceptance in his lifetime,
and a lot of his music has been reconstructed post-facto
from recordings or performances including this one.
And I mean, I haven't found,
and anything I've read...
I've watched and read now a bunch of interviews,
but not all of them,
because someone just told me,
you just told me about another documentary.
So there's more to read and more to watch,
and know about Julius Eastman.
So I haven't encountered anything
that tells me when, how, why Joan of Arc in particular.
Yeah.
- I've never read Mark Twain's book on Joan of Arc,
which he considered his greatest work.
- Yeah.
- First of all, I'm shocked that it's so poorly known.
I mean I didn't even know who wrote this
until about five or six years ago.
So my question is, without it being spoiled,
the whole book, what was his perspective on it,
besides a historical tale?
I know it wasn't non-fiction, it was fiction,
but you just care about commenting on his
perspective on her.
Did he help the cause or?
- I mean it's really historical fiction.
He does a lot of research into the life of Joan of Arc,
and I think that many people then appreciate...
I mean actually when I was younger,
I read a lot of historical fiction too.
I feel like what I first learned about the French
wars of religion came from Alexander Dumas.
Anyway, not how you should learn about the French
wars of religion, but that's okay.
I mean, it's not the worst way to learn.
So I think a lot of people like that dimension.
And then it's interesting,
I read an article when I was getting ready for this,
an article on Mark Twain's "Joan of Arc,"
and the person had done all of this
investigation into contemporary readers,
non-specialist readers, looking at Amazon reviews,
looking at Goodreads.
And here too, to go back to Lena's question,
the difference in reception.
It's like you don't even know they read the same book.
So there was one comment,
the author of the article quotes a lot of comments.
There was one comment that said,
"Joan of Arc, she is such a wonderful feminine role model,
of self-sacrifice and devotion,"
and I'm like, "Yeah, kind of, sort of."
And then another reader is like,
"And there in the thick of the battle,
is Joan of Arc, badass."
And so these two readers are somehow reading
the same work by Mark Twain,
and pulling out of it...
yeah, the Joan of Arc, they need maybe?
Or features of what's in the work,
that respond to what interests them,
what's important to them.
Yeah, it's really interesting.
- [Speaker] So it's very subjective is what you're saying.
- Yeah. But that seems to be true with all the material.
Yeah.
- [Speaker] Very interesting.
- Yeah.
- So you mentioned that the trial of Joan of Arc
was the one of the best documented one,
up until that time.
So I found this very interesting.
Do you think it's because of some special reason?
Is there any specialties in the figure
of Joan of Arc,
which made this trial so important maybe?
Or is it just a coincidence?
- I think, no, I think there is.
And I think there's really two different things happening.
One has to do really more with religion,
and with something that is called,
the discernment of spirits.
And with a recent spate of visionaries,
some of whom are accepted as being legitimate visionaries,
others of whom are burned at the stake.
And so I think the church has a lot of concern about people
just asserting that they heard X, Y, or Z from God,
when the church hasn't verified it or agreed with it.
So there's a whole practice, discernment,
that is developed around figuring out
how to determine whether someone's visions
are orthodox, legitimate,
or whether that person is heretical.
So there's one side of it.
And then the other side of it,
is just the political side of it, that for the English,
this is supremely important.
I mean the English have to have this trial
go this certain way.
At a certain point, Joan of Arc gets sick,
and the English send in all these doctors
because they're like,
"We can't have her die a natural death,
she needs to be killed.
We need her to die the death we need her to die."
And so I think that as part of a political effort then
to de-legitimize the French and Joan of Arc,
she needs to be found guilty,
and she needs to be punished,
in this super exemplary way.
Yeah.
- [Speaker] We have a question from a remote participant.
- Oh, there's someone on Zoom, Rosalie. Sorry.
- Sorry.
"Was Joan of Arc considered a martyr by the people
of the kingdom of France at the time of her execution?
Or is that a perception that has accrued over time?"
- Yeah, that's a very good question.
And she's definitely,
by some people definitely considered a martyr right away.
I mean, in the trial for rehabilitation,
and again grains of salt,
but in the trial for rehabilitation,
someone says that it was said at the time,
"You've killed a saint."
And so not only is she a martyr,
she's already a saint in the 15th century,
even though she's not.
But one of the accusations actually,
that's made against her,
is that people do begin to venerate her during her lifetime.
People want to touch her, they want to touch her clothing.
And so among some people,
she has really already attained a divine status
during her life.
And I think that, I mean the English,
I feel like the English,
if they thought about this for a minute or I don't know.
Part of me is like, this went so wrong for you people.
All you did was create a huge martyr.
You did not succeed in killing a heretic.
So the PR move that they were hoping for,
went really like a complete 180 from their objectives.
Yeah. So that didn't work well.
- A little of a follow up question on that.
Is there any speculation as to why it took so long
to have her canonized?
Because it's ironic that when the trial was occurring,
the English were in a sense, they're accusing her of heresy,
the defenders of the church,
but then in the next century they become heretics themselves
in the eyes of the church by what Henry VII was doing.
So I just wonder,
what influences were put in place perhaps,
if there was this belief by a lot of people in France,
that no, she was a saint,
that it took so long for that official recognition
to be conferred on her.
- Yeah, I think that, I mean, to be honest,
she falls a little bit by the wayside.
I mean, here's her giant victory, but then she's died.
Things move on.
And I would say that there is relatively,
there is some textual production in the 16th century,
less in the 17th century around Joan of Arc.
But in the 18th century,
Voltaire writes this scathing send up of Joan of Arc,
basically saying that she's a whore of the army,
and making fun of her.
She's just a "credulous..."
because also he has a more secular position.
And so the power of the church is something
he's pushing back against.
And so then in the 19th century she undergoes,
I would say a massive artistic rehabilitation.
And why 1920?
I mean yes, World War I, but why not say earlier?
I honestly, I don't know.
That's not something I've done enough research into.
I don't actually even know who initially...
Someone has to spearhead these things. Right?
And I don't know who decided now was the moment,
and they had to get it done.
There were two people in the front.
- To piggyback what he just said,
this was obviously two countries,
France, and England,
basically at each other's throats,
within the construct of the church.
I was just curious,
how did the holy seat in Rome view Joan of Arc?
- Yeah, that's a great question.
How did the popes view Joan of Arc?
Over the course of her trial,
Joan asks multiple times for the intervention of the Pope.
She's like,
"Let's have the Pope come and I can talk to him."
And they're like,
"No, no, we're not inviting the Pope in here."
I mean, to be honest, the popes don't intervene.
And this is an ecclesiastical trial, right?
I mean this is the church militant
carrying out this trial.
Yeah.
- [Speaker] Is she officially a saint?
- Today? Now? Oh yeah, she is now today.
- [Speaker] So eventually the holy seat did, in the end...
- Yeah.
- [Speaker] Centuries later.
- Centuries later.
Yes. Yeah.
- If instead of Jeanne d'Arc, it was Robert d'Arc,
how do you think history would change?
And how do you think the afterlives would've occurred?
- Yeah. I'm not sure that Robert d'Arc,
would've been able to pull it off actually.
I think that part of what is miraculous precisely,
is her very improbability,
and there's a lot of insistence,
on the fact that she's female.
And so in fact,
her partisans and her detractors both will say,
"How could someone do these things?"
So for the partisans of Joan of Arc,
the fact that a feeble instrument like a woman,
could be the means through which France is saved,
it's just a way to reinforce that it's really God,
that it's really all about God.
It's not about Joan at all.
And so I think all of the factors that make her weak
are the factors that allow her to have done what she did.
So including her femininity, yeah.
But then the femaleness will be a giant obstacle again
during her trial because she does not submit
to hierarchical authorities either men,
or church or church men.
And so yeah, she's not doing what she should be doing,
as a woman.
All right, well thank you again very much for coming,
and enjoy the rest of your afternoon.
(audience applauding)
