I am finally checking out the K1 3D printer by Creality. This machine clearly is taking inspiration from Bambu Labs, so let's see if I think if Creality can still compete with modern printers.
Time Stamps: Intro - 00:00 Unbox and Specs - 1:06 Setup and First Tests - 3:01 Creality Slicer - 5:44 More Tests and Build Plate Complaints - 7:58 Testing Enclosure and ABS - 10:39 Comparisons to Bambu - 13:50 Final Thoughts - 17:58
My go-to PLA is Polymaker PLA Pro. Not only is it easy to print, it is extremely strong: https://bit.ly/3rNdd3f My favorite is of course my 3D Print General FDE - it sells out quick - so make sure you sign up for notifications if it is currently out of stock: https://bit.ly/3SB1JuW Both links are affiliate.
Follow now for more free giveaways and 3D printing tutorials! Visit http://3dprintgeneral.com/ for products I have used in the past and approve. You can also rep 3D printing and support the channel via my Merch Store: http://bit.ly/2GidwfQ
Alright everyone, I might be a little bit behind the curve on this one, but here is
my review of the Creality K1.
I was really excited to check out this printer when it was announced like 6 months ago, but
unfortunately a bunch of delays and shipping issues ends up that I only got this printer
a couple of weeks ago.
Creality isn't really known for coming out with unique printers.
They normally like to see how the market is going and then copy whatever is selling really
well and I think most of us can kind of tell where they got their inspiration on this one.
Keep in mind that Creality also has their K1 Max which is larger and has additional
features but I don't have that printer so we won't be reviewing it, we're only checking
out the regular K1.
All of that said, this is not a perfect 1 to 1 clone of BambooLab printers, it does
have some unique features.
So why don't I go over the specs while you watch me unbox it.
First of all, the packaging on this thing is no joke.
Someone let me know that only reviewers are getting packages that come in these crates.
I'm not sure if that's true or not but Creality really wanted to make sure that this printer
wasn't damaged in shipping.
This printer is CoreXY and has a lot of the features we want in printers today such as
automatic input shaping for fast printing without ringing, hands free auto bed leveling,
a good extruder and hotend combo, a good touchscreen, an auxiliary cooling fan for rapid cooling
for great print angles and it does all of this with the same build volume as the Ender
3 with it being 220mm by 220mm by 250mm.
This is normally the minimum size I suggest for someone new to 3D printing and Creality
did a great job of keeping the footprint very small, meaning this printer should fit on
just about any desk or rack setup without any issues.
The printer has Wi-Fi for remote viewing and controlling and it does look like Creality
changed up their slicer and control options with this printer.
You have the option to add an AI camera, something that Creality was kind enough to send to me
but it looks like it's an extra $32 retail for that.
I actually think the camera is worth it for that just because Creality did a great job
on the quality and frame rate on this camera.
Compared to Bamboo Labs like 1 frame every 2 seconds, this camera by Creality is pretty
much smooth to watch.
Creality also says you can add LiDAR to this printer, though I don't see it as an optional
add-on.
Regardless, I wasn't sent any LiDAR so that won't be reviewed here.
And then Creality is doing all of this, minus any add-ons, for a very reasonable retail
price of $599, though it does look like it's actually $60 off right now, bringing it to
only $539.
With prices like this, I have no idea why anyone would buy their other line of printers
like their Ender 5 S1 or the random ones like the Ender 7, but before we make proclamations
like that, let's get into my tests.
My initial look at this printer makes me really like it, except for one annoying complaint.
This door does not want to stay open.
Now so you'll see me a few times in this video kind of Mickey Mouse prop it open.
Oh look at that, it's actually kind of staying open a little bit now.
But it doesn't want to stay all the way open for when I'm filming, and so when you're printing
in PLA, you want to make sure that you have this top door off, or top ceiling or whatever
it's called off, so that it doesn't get too hot in there, because that door will probably
inevitably close on you.
But that's just such a minor complaint.
Everything else on setup on this was perfect and exactly what you want on a printer in
2023.
It just takes you through it, you don't need to screw any bed knobs or anything like that.
They did a really good job on the initial setup on this.
Creality also sent me some of their Hyper PLA series, which is supposed to be meant
for fast 3D printing.
I'm not sure what makes it different from regular PLA, so I'll compare it to that in
a little bit.
But yeah, just so you know, I'm using at these first couple of test prints, their Hyper PLA.
Regardless of any of that, I go ahead and print their three included G-code files that
came on this machine, with the first of course being a Speed Benchy.
And I'm already starting to be impressed with this machine.
I know under 20 minute Benchys are becoming kind of standard, but it will never feel like
it's not magic to me watching printers fly like this and then make a near perfect model.
I do also want to note right now that while the motor movements aren't very loud, or at
least nearly as loud as the BambooLab P1 or X1, the fans are very loud.
Or at least the auxiliary cooling fan sounds like a jet engine when it's turned on.
And that fan will often turn off and on throughout the print, so the noises can be a bit weird
while you're printing.
Along with that Benchy that seems to have come out pretty good, I also went ahead and
printed their CAT model.
Again, looks like it came out great, though white doesn't show great on camera.
But what's really impressive is the file that Creality included to show off their maximum
printing speeds of 600mm per second.
Now that's a speed I would never suggest slicing at, but for specific models like you see on
the screen, I guess Creality can handle it.
Now if there are a lot of starts and stops on your model unlike this, don't go at these
speeds, but the fact the hotend and extruder can actually handle 600mm per second is really
impressive.
In order to test out if it's just the Hyper PLA that's able to do this, I go ahead and
load up some Orange PLA Pro by Polymaker, just their normal PLA Pro, and print all three
G-code files again.
And well, all three came out perfect.
So I don't think the Hyper PLA is needed, I'm not sure what's really going on there.
That said, Polymaker also recently announced their Polysonic for high speed printing, so
something is going on with these new PLA blends, I just haven't found them necessary yet from
my testing.
After printing those included G-code files two different times with two different types
of PLA, I go ahead and test out their slicer.
In the past, Creality would just reskin Cura with no real changes, something I always complained
about since I never really understood why companies would do that.
This time though, I can't quite figure out what the slicer is based on.
I don't see any credit given to other slicers, so either Creality created this from scratch,
or they just aren't giving credit to whatever slicer this is based on.
Either way though, they're at least trying something unique rather than just using normal
Cura and slapping their logo on it, so I'm not too upset with it.
What's best about this slicer is that you can click on device, and then you get complete
control of the printer with what looks to be exactly like standard Clipper controls.
Now this printer runs on some form of Clipper.
I know a lot of people were complaining to Creality to release their source files, and
on September 11th, they did that by saying they are going open source.
Now they have to go open source in order to comply with the licenses of Clipper, but they're
making an announcement like they're doing something special.
Regardless though, let's just be happy it is open source and not complain too much.
At least we have a consumer grade printer that is open source, because that doesn't
seem to be the trend that all the other manufacturers are going right now.
So after this, I go ahead and slice my two favorite test prints, of course a Benchy,
and then a Torture Toaster.
Both of these tests, I don't do much tweaking from the stock settings at all.
The Benchy takes 42 minutes, so I'm not quite sure what tweaks they had to do to get the
test file under 20 minutes, but 42 isn't half bad.
Then the Toaster takes 5 hours to print, which I consider really good.
Anything under 7 hours is impressive to me, especially when we think a stock Ender 3 probably
takes 14 or 15 hours to print a Torture Toaster.
Unfortunately on my first Toaster, I forgot to remove the brim when slicing, so that wasn't
really usable, but I go ahead and reprint it, and the reprint is perfect.
Well almost perfect.
There's a little bit of ugliness on the 0.4mm and 0.5mm tab, but overall the rest is just
about flawless.
That's great, because a lot of printers I've tested over the last year just are unable
to print this Torture Toaster, so kudos to Creality, they got it done in 5 hours and
it looks good.
So far, zero complaints about this printer.
Rather than bore you with my next few test prints, I'll just summarize it by saying I
loaded up some of Creality's black Hyper PLA and kept printing random files.
These include a couple of tool holders like this guy, and a drawer for the front, which
just slides right under, but overall those came out great.
I also went ahead and printed 3D Bunny's artistic piece, but it looks like that auxiliary cooling
fan is just too powerful for stringy prints like this.
You can actually see exactly where the auxiliary cooling fan was blowing from based on how
the strings are angled.
This is the only print in this entire video that I wasn't stoked on, and I'm positive
it could look great with a little bit slower printing speeds and just turning that auxiliary
cooling fan off.
During these tests though, I do end up swapping the build plate to a textured PEI plate, something
that I want to go over because their build plate is a complaint that I have.
You see, BambooLab X1 gave you a really crummy, sticky sheet build plate that required a glue
stick, but they had a reason for this because that printer used LiDAR, and the LiDAR didn't
work with textured PEI plates.
BambooLab knew this build plate wasn't ideal, so on their printers that don't have LiDAR,
they include a textured PEI plate instead of that sticky sheet that requires glue and
constant changing.
Creality on the other hand, this K1 doesn't have micro LiDAR, but they still give you
that sticky sheet, glue stick, crappy build plate, so I'm not really sure why.
I know the K1 Max has LiDAR, so that would make sense to come with that printer, but
this regular K1 should come with a textured PEI plate because that build plate is my biggest
complaint about the X1 Carbon by BambooLab.
I'm not positive that it's the exact same thing as the sticky sheet one on the BambooLab
X1 Carbon, but it does seem really similar, it requires a glue stick, and it prints at
a lower temperature.
Luckily, though, 220 by 220 millimeters is a very common build plate size, like I said,
the same as the Ender 3, so I went ahead and slapped on a textured PEI and then smooth
PEI on the other side build plate by Elegoo that came on one of their Neptune printers.
So it is pretty easy to swap the build plate, and something that I think is worth doing
because those consumable sticky sheets that require glue sticks get really annoying, and
then your prints have kind of a sticky underside as well, something I really don't like doing.
The only tip that you will need after swapping a build plate, if you choose to do so, is
in the slicer, you need to up the build plate temperature to 60 degrees Celsius, because
I believe it prints at 40 or 45 when using the build plate that comes with the printer.
So just make sure if you're printing PLA that you have this top off because 60 degrees Celsius
will get that ambient air a bit too hot if you completely enclose it in your printing PLA.
My final tests on this printer are to check how sealed and good this enclosure is.
This top is held on by kind of pressure and magnets, so it's actually pretty good.
It's just a little annoying to line up sometimes.
It just kind of...
Let's see if I can get it on camera here.
You just got to pop it in.
Boom. There we go.
It's on, and it does trap heat pretty well.
There is a chamber temperature reader on this, but, you know, I'm not going to look at that.
I'm going to look at my own reader so that it's apples and apples comparisons to the
other times I've tested chamber temperatures.
I go ahead and have the build plate about two thirds of the way down, the reader in
the middle between the hot end and the build plate, and then set the build plate to 100
degrees Celsius.
And that build plate heats up pretty quick, taking just about four minutes, which is not
bad at all.
I then let the chamber heat up over the course of about 15 minutes, and then we hit a peak
ambient air temperature from my reader of 55.3 degrees Celsius.
That's plenty hot enough for printing in ABS.
I always suggest a chamber temperature of over 50 degrees when printing in ABS.
Over 55 is great.
Just as a comparison, when I did this exact same test with the X1 Carbon, my ambient air
temperature got to 60 degrees, so pretty close.
And 55 is plenty hot enough.
Not hot enough for polycarbonate, but hot enough for ABS.
So I go ahead and load up some ABS and start printing some torture tests.
First up is a hollow box without any tops, because this is my favorite test print for
ABS.
It's really hard for printers to complete it without a very high ambient air temperature,
because the corners like to warp, the walls like to delaminate, and then even in some
chambers, the walls will concave.
You really need a high ambient air temperature for this print to come out clean.
Well, even with printing at pretty fast speeds, this box came out great.
No warping, no delamination, and most impressive, the thin walls weren't concaving at all.
And this was on that textured PEI plate that I mentioned I added to the printer.
I then continue the same process, but with a very large and dense part, with it being
this vise by 3D Master Race.
And while this print came out near perfect, it does look like the one large part slightly
warped.
This vise was still usable and looks great overall, just worth noting that I did have
one slight warp.
Again though, this is with the textured PEI.
Maybe the glue stick in their original build plate, there would be no warping.
But like I said, I really don't like those types of build plates.
My next test is to print another torture toaster, this time using ABS.
And I'll be honest with you, I've actually never done a torture toaster in ABS.
I always figured it wouldn't come out great, because without a lot of cooling, these angles
won't look good, and then tolerances will be messed up.
But that's not the case here.
Tolerances move all the way down to 0.2 millimeters, and the angles are not perfect, but way better
than I thought they would be.
Some printers I test can't print a PLA torture toaster.
The fact this K1 printed an ABS one is great.
And finally, I just go ahead and load up a bunch of Legos onto a build plate, and print
them in ABS, just to see how the tolerances are.
And they snap together.
You know, there might be a little bit of quality issues on the side, but that's only because
you're printing in gray, and gray really shows off defects.
But overall, came out great.
All right, let's get into some of my final notes, and my comparisons of this to Bamboo
Lab, because there's really no way to get around it.
The, you know, Creality's really trying to copy or imitate Bamboo Lab with this printer.
You know, it's a little frustrating that Creality's got to be forced to innovate,
because they clearly have some great engineers working for them, if they were able to come
out with this product.
I honestly don't think anything was holding Creality back from coming out with this printer
two years ago.
They just needed Bamboo Lab to kick them in the butt, to let them know it's possible.
If you went back to my videos two years ago, or maybe even less than that, I would continually
say there is no reason there isn't a great all-in-one $600 printer.
That was the exact price point I would say.
$600.
There's no reason there isn't a good $600 printer.
And my requirements for that $600 printer were way less than Creality is giving you
with this printer.
This K1 is far better than that printer I wanted for $600 two years ago.
And guess what?
They actually have this discounted for only $540, so it's $60 less than that $600 price
point I was saying.
So overall, great job by Creality.
Just hopefully it's not two years too late.
Personally, I think this printer will be a great comparison to Bamboo Lab's P1S, which
is their enclosed, less expensive version of their printer, the X1 Carbon.
That P1S is $100 more at retail than this K1, $160 more after that coupon that's going
on right now.
I'm going to start by letting you guys know what I think this K1 can do better than the
P1S, and then I'll let you know what I think the P1S can do better than this K1.
First and foremost, the price.
This guy is obviously $100 less or $160 less.
That's clearly a positive that this has over the P1S.
The next major upgrade that this has over the P1S is the touchscreen.
That touchscreen is great.
It's very user-friendly as compared to the P1S screen, which is almost unusable.
It lets you do the basic stuff, but you're really going to want to control the printer
via your computer, while this K1 is really great to use the touchscreen.
It's a huge positive.
That doesn't affect print quality or capabilities at all, but it is a big deal when it comes
to user experience.
The camera on this K1 is a $32 upgrade, but it is well worth it, in my opinion, and much
better than the P1S's camera because the frame rate is great on this.
Then, this K1 is running on open-source firmware, something that BambooLab is not doing.
So, if you like open-source firmware, this is obviously going to be your better option.
Now, for what the P1S can do that this K1 cannot.
First of all, the P1S can use BambooLab's AMS system, which will allow you to print
in multiple colors.
That does cost a decent amount more.
We're talking about completely different prices then because that's about $1,000 to get the
upgrade, but you can at least have the option to add it at any time in the future if you
so choose.
There is no AMS for this K1.
Then, I like BambooLab's slicer pretty much way above any other slicer on the market.
Creality did do a lot better with their slicer, but it still doesn't compare to BambooLab's,
in my opinion.
BambooLab is allowing you to add third-party printers.
It's not on there.
This K1 is not on there yet, but I'm assuming it will come soon.
So, maybe that's not a huge positive that BambooLab's P1S has over this.
But then, another big difference is the build volume that P1S can print at 252 by 252 by
252 millimeters.
And like I said, this build plate is only 220 by 220.
It has roughly the same height of 250, but you're going to get an extra 30 millimeters
in each the X and the Y dimension when using that P1S, which means you will be able to
print projects that are impossible on this K1.
And then, some little things seem a little bit more polished with the BambooLab printers,
such as nozzle wipes and the fact that it uses tempered glass for the door and the
top rather than plastic on this K1.
And then, finally, that P1S comes with a textured build plate rather than this crappy one that
requires a glue stick on the K1.
And that's just about everything I can think of.
Both of these printers can print quality parts really fast and in just about any material
you're going to want to print in.
So, now I'm going to let you know which one I think you should buy.
First of all, this printer beats out all of the competition that isn't BambooLab.
Creality did a great job.
If your budget is $600 and you don't want BambooLab, this is the printer to go with.
But if you care about multicolor printing, skip this guy, go with the P1S.
You're going to be able to use the AMS system if you want to upgrade in the future.
If you don't care about multicolor printing and you don't care that this has 30 millimeters
less of build volume in the X and Y dimension, then honestly, I'm going to suggest this K1.
I don't see why you wouldn't want to save $100 or actually $160 right now and then get
the touchscreen and really all of the same capabilities.
I'm actually really surprised I'm saying this because I think the P1S is probably the best
all-around printer for the price point on the market today, but Creality really didn't
do a half bad job here.
Like I said, it's really frustrating that it took BambooLab in order for them to come
out with this because if they came out with this two years ago, Creality would still be
dominating the market.
And what's funny is, like I was saying earlier, this completely made all of Creality's other
models obsolete.
I mean, maybe not the Ender 3 because of how inexpensive it is, but the Ender 5S1.
Why would you buy the Ender 5S1 when this exists?
Why would you buy the Ender 7 or the Ender 6 or the Surmoon?
You know, all of these printers that I didn't understand why they existed, and they were
all like $500 each for those printers.
So why would you get those when this exists?
So maybe Creality is eating its own market share a little bit.
I don't know why anybody would buy one of those printers instead of this K1.
This K1 is the exact printer I was waiting for for like five or six years.
The only question is, was Creality too late to the market?
You'll have to let me know what you guys think.
Thank you all for watching.
I'll be back soon with more reviews, tutorials, fun prints, and news.
All right, guys, before I sign off, I just want to let you know, since I didn't have
a sponsor for this video, that I really like the company DIY Watch Club.
They're not sponsoring this video, but I am an affiliate for them, and I love building
their watches.
I've currently built two of them, and I want to order some more.
If you're into do-it-yourself and mechanical watches, which I certainly am, definitely
check out DIY Watch Club.
Links will be in the description down below.
If you use my affiliate link, I'd really appreciate it.
Other than that, make sure you check out my FDE PLA Pro with my face on it, the best
flat dark earth color you could possibly get.
It's fully back in stock.
Thank you all.
I will see you soon.