Copay vs Coinsurance | How to Save Money on Healthcare Costs
Dec 5, 2024
80%! According to industry experts, that's how often medical bills are wrong. 80%! Imagine if
you got things wrong 80% of the time. Would you get paid? Most likely not. Well, your medical
provider shouldn't either. Between a not-so-mini ski accident, a major and kind of gross eye
infection while running through August heat in Disney World and Universal Studios, that's me
with my eye patch, and that's my four kids on the latest Velocicoaster ride at 70 miles an hour
before they're about to flip upside down. Oh, and the fact that we sell life and health insurance
for a living. I'm going to tell you all about co-pays, co-insurance, in-network versus out-of-
network medical providers, and my top five tips for lowering your health care costs,
as well as what to do about those pesky medical bills filled with errors. If you already know
everything you've always wanted to know about co-pays and co-insurance, timestamps are below
this video. Go ahead and jump straight to the part on understanding and lowering your health
care costs and medical bills. For loyal subscribers and viewers, welcome back. We love you guys. And
for those of you new to Diamond Estate, welcome to the number one place to learn about money,
insurance, and retirement. I'm Jennifer, first generation American, and I've spent most of my
life in finance. Started working at banks like J.P. Morgan and Goldman Sachs at the age of 17,
and graduated top of my class from NYU and Harvard Business School. And now I work on
all things personal finance with business owners, as well as young professionals at places like
Bloomberg, WeWork, and Marshall McLennan. So co-pay versus co-insurance. Those of you that know me,
that know us, know all about our beloved charts and tables. So here's one that clearly explains
the difference between co-pay versus co-insurance. So first, what is it? What's the difference
between a co-pay versus co-insurance in actual dollar terms? A co-pay refers to a fixed fee,
say $20, that you have to pay out of your own pocket each time you visit your doctor or fill
a prescription. And co-insurance refers to a fixed percentage that you have to pay. The actual dollar
amount will change depending on the services, and the higher your co-insurance percentage,
the higher your share of the cost is. This is one of the reasons some people prefer co-pays
to co-insurance, because they know exactly what they should pay, what they should budget for each
medical visit and prescription. The second difference between a co-pay versus co-insurance
is when do you pay it? With a co-pay, you pay each time you visit your medical provider,
or fill a prescription, right there on the spot. With co-insurance, you're billed by the
health care provider directly after the visit is over. This is another reason why some people
prefer co-pays to co-insurance, because again, not only do they know exactly what they have to pay,
they also paid immediately when they see their health care provider.
There's no waiting for the bill, and no surprises on the bill afterwards. All things being equal,
if you're someone who's working within a budget, or someone who really doesn't like uncertainty,
a health plan with a co-pay might be better suited for you than one with co-insurance.
And if you need help finding a health plan that's right for you, drop us a note at
to see if we can make the process a bit easier for you.
Now, the third difference between a co-pay versus co-insurance is does it apply towards
your deductible? With co-pays, the answer is it depends on your health plan. Sometimes,
the co-pay counts towards the deductible, and sometimes you pay it only after you've met your
deductible. So, you'll need to check with your health insurance carrier on this one.
Co-insurance, on the other hand, is only paid after you meet your deductible. So,
what's one easy way to lower your co-pay or co-insurance and your overall health care costs
for this year? Here's money saving tip number one, and this you can do immediately. Always stay
in-network. In-network providers are doctors, specialists, and other health care facilities,
including pharmacies, who have negotiated and contracted with your health insurance carrier
to provide medical care, services, and products at a discounted rate.
Want to see the difference in rates between an in-network versus out-of-network provider?
I'll show you a real-life example from my own physical therapy visits this year because of
my torn ACL. See how the list price here for each of these five visits is $340? The list price is
the price you would pay if you simply walked into the physical therapy practice with no insurance.
So, the list price of $340 is the same for all five visits because it was the exact same service
each time. The exact same therapist as well. Three of these were charged correctly as in-network.
So, all I owed for each of these visits, after all discounts and insurance contributions,
was $32. For the other two visits, though, someone somewhere along the line marked them
wrongly as out-of-network. And the balance I owe for each of these visits is $160 versus
$32 in-network. That's five times more for out-of-network versus in-network.
Need more reasons to stay in-network? Well, staying in-network will typically result in
lower co-pays or co-insurance, lower deductibles, and lower out-of-pocket maximums. If I stay
in-network, my co-insurance after I've met my deductible is 20%, as you can see here. So,
if the doctor bills me $500 for his services, I'm responsible for $100 of that bill. And my
insurance company is responsible for the other $400. If I go out-of-network, my co-insurance
skyrockets to 50%, meaning I'd have to pay $250 of that same $500 bill, not just $100.
Even the insurance carrier tells me that going out-of-network is the highest cost option,
and to avoid out-of-network providers if possible. And if you look at my deductibles
and out-of-pocket maximums, in-network, my deductible is $2,800, and my out-of-pocket
maximum is $6,850. Out-of-network, my deductible is $5,600, and my out-of-pocket maximum is $14,000.
That's more than DotWall! Guys, if you're enjoying this video, don't forget that thumbs-up
and subscribe button. This tells me that we're putting out the money-saving, wealth-building
videos that you want and need for your financial journey. Which leads us to tip number two for
lowering your health care costs, another one that you can do immediately if you have medical
bills outstanding. And that's check them! Check those bills! As I mentioned at the beginning of
this video, industry experts estimate that about 80% of medical bills are wrong. In our own personal
experience, that number is closer to 33%, but our sample size is also much smaller. But even if we
believe it's just 33%, that's still quite often that we're all billed incorrectly for our health
care. I already showed you the physical therapy bill errors before. That one was just for a few
hundred dollars. Bad enough. This one was for over $2,000. How much did I owe in the end? Nothing,
it turned out! And here's another one that was wrong. This one's a few hundred. And I also ended
up owing nothing. Thank goodness! According to Emscribe Medical Billing, billing errors result
in us paying 26% more than we should on average. So how did I find all these mistakes? Here's tip
number three for lowering your health care costs, and it's also something you can do immediately.
Call the billing department of the doctor, hospital, or specialist that sent you the bill,
and ask them to walk you through each visit, each charge. You can try to call your health insurance
company, but in our experience, the mistakes typically are from coding errors from the doctor,
hospital, or specialist side. One wrong digit in the billing code, it's all that's needed for you,
or for me, to be billed incorrectly. Some of the responses I got on my walkthroughs on the phone
with the billing department, oh wow, that's wrong. That doesn't make any sense. I think that was a
All of which had clearly also gone through my head as well, so I was glad they confirmed the errors
for me. Had I not called, we would have ended up paying thousands more for medical care than we
should have. Listen, not every bill was wrong, but the number of errors was shocking. If I made that
many mistakes in my business, I'd be out of business. And if you made that many mistakes at
work, you'd be out of a job. The good news is you know better now. And the great news is that when
the billing department does find those errors, it will correct them. But it does take some time to
get through all the paperwork and resubmit to your insurance carrier. So be patient. Tip number four
for lowering your health care costs. Negotiate if you really can't afford to pay off the bill in full
right away. When we've gone through this process with our clients, the average reduction has been
Most health care providers also have the option for you to pay in installments. So this is another
avenue that you could consider. Whatever you do though, don't ignore those medical bills. Because
if you do it too often, those bills will be sent to a collection agency. They'll hit your credit
report, they'll lower your credit score, and they'll reduce your chances of approval for new
Tip number five for lowering your health care costs. Consider getting a high deductible health
plan, an HGHP, especially if you're relatively young, healthy, have little to no dependents,
and some savings. Yes, the deductible is higher, but the monthly premiums are lower, sometimes
significantly. Check out our HGHP versus PPO video here to learn more about the six questions you
should ask yourself to see if an HGHP is right for you. Or this other HSA millionaire video here.
We've had an HGHP since we moved back to the US from Germany about five years ago,
and one of the big advantages of an HGHP is the ability to set up a triple tax advantage HSA,
or health savings account, that you can use for medical expenses both now and in the future.
And if you need help either sorting out the right HGHP because not all HGHPs are HSA eligible,
or if you need help figuring out the best way to become an HSA millionaire, email me at
jenniferatdiamonestic.com to see how we can give your financial journey the big boost it deserves.
Moving on to tip number six for lowering your health care costs. See if they're tax deductible.
Medical expenses such as co-pays, coinsurance, and premiums may be tax deductible if they exceed
seven and a half percent of your adjusted gross income. If your health care expenses
are higher than that threshold, the amount that exceeds seven and a half percent can be deducted.
And if you're self-employed, in some instances you might be able to deduct your health insurance
premiums even if your total health care costs don't exceed the seven and a half percent threshold.
Guys, thanks for watching. I hope you enjoyed all these top tips for lowering your health care costs.
And if you have any questions about life, health, or disability insurance,
shoot us an email at jenniferatdiamonestic.com,
and join us next week for another money-saving, wealth-building video that's just for you.

