Contextualizing Elagabalus | A partial response to Metatron

Cycle Nomad
1 follower
#elagabalus #metatron #rome
Bassianus, better know as Elagabalus, was one of the most infamous Roman emperors. In the modern day, Elagabalus is often held up as an ancient example of an lgbtq individual, and some sources do paint the emperor in that light. But, those sources are often hostile and limited in nature. So what can actually be said about Elagabalus?
Here is Metatron’s video on the subject:
https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=lI3Ek8bO8uk
sexus varus avitus basanis otherwise
known as Marcus aurelus
anthoninos or perhaps more infamously
known as elagabalus was emperor of Rome
for approximately 4 years between 218
and
222 he was probably one of the most
hated people to have ever had the job
and his condemnation in ancient sources
has certainly been echoed down through
the modern day a balanced view of his
Reign though is actually failed
difficult to do and it's not for lack of
trying because the sources which survive
are not exactly concerned with things
that would make such an assessment
possible such as tax policy for instance
instead they're often outright hostile
and by Roman standards some of them are
actually fairly slanderous he is also
known in the modern day for being held
up as an historical figure who was
possibly gender fluid or perhaps
bisexual it depends on who you ask and
recently a museum in the UK has actually
placed a coin depicting elagabalus in
its lgbtq section and this has stirred
up some controversy so with that being
said what I would like to do in this
video is try to contextualize the
emperor in his own time period how did
alabas come to power what is the sun
cult how should we understand these
sources which describe him as eminate
and what do these things mean in a
broader Roman cultural context because
elagabalus and his sexuality is a
subject which comes up fairly often in
the modern day I want to take a moment
and just make it very clear that I am
not intending to make any sort of pmic
about any of this and if on the off
chance that portions of the video are
interpreted that way I would like to be
very clear that this is not my intention
I am really just interested in the Roman
context and the secondary literature
that is the stuff produced by Roman
historians to do that then I want to be
very clear about the sources I'm using
for this video we have three ancient
sources ources for this subject the
writings of cassus Dio The writings of
herodian and an anonymous work known as
the Historia Augusta and we'll be
talking about all three throughout the
video I'm also drawing on four secondary
sources the crimes of elagabalus by
Martin I which is the most upto-date
academic treatment of the
emperor sex and sexuality in Greek and
Roman culture written by Marilyn Skinner
Mary boat writes peoples of the Roman
world and Simon swains
helenismo notice that there is a
subtitle for this video it is a partial
response to a video on the same subject
that was done a few months ago over on
metatron's channel it is one of the more
viewed videos on the subject and
actually a fairly well done video and I
would recommend it so this is not a
response in the sense of a correction to
mistakes so much as it is a Cory to that
video because I want to go a bit deeper
with the information and how to actually
interpret our sources hostility in
ancient text is perfectly fine but how
much of it is genuine and how much of it
is genre
convention so the first thing we should
do then is discuss the nature of the
source material from the classical
world history broadly speaking is based
upon the employment of two types of
sources documents otherwise known as
primary sources and material evidence
which tends to be more in the domain of
archaeology
in the best of circumstances historians
and archaeologists are brothers and arms
but in other situations the two can be
opposed diametrically a document might
say something sure but if the material
evidence appears to contradict it well
then so what how should that be
interpreted of course you also have the
danger of attempting to shoehorn
archaeological evidence to fit textual
evidence which has its own problems
ordinarily we find these primary sources
things written by Witnesses either
during the event in question or sometime
after in archives for the Roman period
though that description is not entirely
accurate although we do have examples of
things that would fit this definition of
primary sources from the classical world
what we typically think of as primary
sources from the period the writings of
Livy Plutarch and casassus Dio just to
name three of them would probably be
better understood to be a form of
secondary sources and when you were
investigating somebody like elig gabalis
this distinction really really matters
because the way history was done in the
classical world was not by quaring it
off as its own discipline instead it was
considered something like a branch of
literature and like all literature the
historical genre was expected to have
tropes and motifs and forms of stock
characters it's very easy to dismiss
something like the swords of Roman
soldiers igniting before joining a
battle is something very clearly not
real but what do you do about elagabalus
apparently stating that he wanted to be
addressed as a woman is that actually
factual or since he came from the
Eastern provinces and in Roman culture
Eastern regions had stereotypes about
the people hailing from them as being
AFF feminite and weak is that just the
utilization of a stereotype to denigrate
elagabalus because the source is hostile
with these ideas in mind then let's turn
to the sources we have for the Emperor
who were these historians and why did
they write in the manner that they did
Marcus Aurelius was the last of a group
of men known as the five good Emperors
and it's with him that two of our
historians come into play unlike the
other four preceding Emperors Marcus
Aurelius did not adopt an heir instead
he chose his biological son
comus he is perhaps one of the most
infamous Roman emperors attempting to
establish something like an ancient cult
of
personality and he appears to have been
more interested in fighting in the arena
than actually governing so when a series
of disasters struck including a plague
and a devastating fire that gutted Rome
people began to have enough and he was
assassinated in
192 the important thing here is that the
assassination does not appear to have
been a large conspiracy by the
government the army or any large scale
group of Elites instead assuming that we
can actually believe that this is the
reason Commodus was going to execute his
mistress along with several others
including a few senators so three
members of that group including his
mistress attempted to poison him and
when that failed they sent a wrest into
the baths with the man strangled the
emperor despite this assassination
Commodus successor pertinax did not do
anything to signify a break with Marcus
and Commodus in terms of policy he very
much attempted to emphasize continuity
when he was killed in 193 civil war
broke out and that war brought the
Severn Dynasty to power consisting of
septimia 7 seus and his two sons seus
began a propaganda effort to have his
dynasty be seen as a continuation of
that of Marcus Aurelius claiming to be a
member of the anonine family himself as
well as overseeing a renewal of the
Roman
Empire that by itself is nothing new nor
is it really all that striking the theme
of renewal After Decline is something
that crops up throughout the history of
the Roman Empire all the time the
problem with seus though was that this
could not be presented as a genuine
renewal because he did not identify the
antonines with any sort of decline or
decadence that he was attempting to
reverse and by claiming to be an Anthony
himself he was essentially constrained
in terms of
rhetoric so when seus died into 11 the
next decade saw four Emperors including
his son kacala rise and fall and Rome
entered a period of political
instability which would culminate in the
outbreak of the 3dr century crisis in
235 because despite ruling for 13 years
between 222 and 235 Emperor seus
Alexander was never able to solve all of
the political issues facing Rome that
stemmed from this period of instability
elagabalus came to power in that first
span of time in 218 and he was killed 4
years later in 222 so these problems had
to be explained what exactly had gone
wrong with the supposed golden age of
the five good Emperors especially Marcus
aelius how could Rome have declined in a
mere 43 years between the assassination
of Commodus and the assassination of
Alexander seus the idea of a lost Golden
Age could very well have been perceived
as being the reality but it was also an
AC of construction on the part of two of
our Roman historians cassus Dio and
herodian both of whom were alive when
Marcus Aurelius died and who lived
through the severan Dynasty and died
just as the 3dr century crisis was
unfolding casassus Dio was an aristocrat
of senator rank who wrote several
histories of Rome the one that concerns
us here is his history of Rome the
longest work he produced and which
unfortunately comes down to us in chunks
because this one deals with
elagabalus this work is a very clear
departure from an earlier history he had
composed singing the Praises of the
severan dynasty because casassus Dio
very clearly marks out the death of
Marcus Aurelius as the beginning of a
decline whereas his earlier Works don't
give that impression in fact one of
those earlier writings actually received
an endorsement by Septimus seus because
Casas Dia was making an effort to show a
connection between the antonians and the
seign herodian writing is titled the
history of the Empire from the death of
Marcus and unfortunately we know
extremely little about the man himself
all the details of his life being
derived essentially from this one text
that history though appears to be
modeled on that of thides is the history
of the pelian war and this goes back to
the earlier Point raised about the
nature of History writing in Antiquity
it was expected to follow the formulas
set down in classic works and it was
expected to adhere to certain
conventions whether or not events
outlandish or otherwise were considered
true or not needs to be considered but
it also needs to be remembered that
Romans just expected certain motifs and
themes to be in these works just as an
example to illustrate this point point
the battle of the catalonian Plains took
place in 451 when Atilla and his Huns
faced off against a coalition of Romans
and their allies somewhere in Gaul the
manner in which that battle has come
down to us and the description of how it
was fought very closely mirrors the
Battle of Marathon in part because it
was a familiar scene to Romans and they
would have expected to have seen
something like it in their
histories the overall point here is that
both casus Dio and herodian are not
entirely objective works and herodian
likeus Dio very much emphasizes the idea
of a decline selecting as his starting
point the death of Marcus
Aurelius now in doing so herodian
essentially whitewashed the antonines
holding them up as a glorious bygone era
and he doesn't really mention all the
problems that that dynasty had such as
the plague and various Wars not all of
which went well so then what needs to be
kept in mind here is that because these
two historians lived through the period
and wrote their histories with a theme
of pessimism and decline in mind what
they say about a figure that stirred up
controversy in Rome like elagabalus
needs to be taken with a very heavy
grain of salt it's not that they can't
be used they are but the limitations of
the sources need to be
remembered which then brings us to the
third major source the Historia
Augusta this is frankly a difficult
document to work with it's unreliable in
parts and in some other places it's
simply makes things up but given the
relative poity of primary sources for
the 3rd
Century sometimes this is all we have
and in describing its usefulness and its
limitations Patricia Southern in her
textbook on the 3rd Century the Roman
Empire from sist to Constantine sums up
the issues with employing the document
pretty well when she writes the
following a considerable Corpus of
modern literature has grown up
concerning the Historia Augusta it has
been dissected for its Clues as to which
authors ship its date and its purpose
the Historia Augusta is such a fertile
ground for debate that it now has a
series of colloquia devoted to it in the
full bibliography in no less than three
volumes was published in the 1980s
Fergus Miller epitomizes the
difficulties of assessing this work
quote the problem of the Historia
Augusta is one into which sane men must
refrain from
entering Ronald Sim labeled it as a
curonian bog Anthony Burley produced a
very useful synopsis of the Historia
Augusta its various surviving additions
and translations and its many inv varied
exasperating problems the work as extant
purports to be an assemblage of Imperial
biographies continuing the tradition of
suetonius by a collection of different
writers but from the 19th century
onwards beginning with Herman daau it
has been argued that there was in fact
only one author whose scrupulousness and
honesty are questionable the consensus
of opinion is that the work is fourth
Century but which end of the 4th Century
has been hotly debated certain
references to events of the reign of
Diocesan and Constantine and dedications
to these Emperors have been used as
evidence that the writer was a
contemporary and that the work therefore
belongs to the early 4th Century to a
period just after Constantine
perhaps since there is never likely to
be any proof of the date it must remain
speculative but it is an important point
to try and established because the date
of the work puts it into context and
reveals its likely bias and political
subtext the sources of information used
by the author are also important but not
yet proven Beyond doubt it has been
shown that the Lost work of Marius
Maximus the author of biographies from
nerva to elagabalus had a great
influence on the biographer of the
Historia Augusta Who quotes Maximus as
one of his
sources this of course means very little
since the author quotes many sources
some of them imaginary some of them real
and seemingly has no scries about
inventing information from any of his
supposed sources it was postulated that
there was once some other common source
the so-called Kaiser gista or history of
the Emperors utilized by the author of
the histor Augusta and by other writers
such as zarus and
zazus this Theory meets with less
acceptance now than formerly the ground
has been dug over many times and it is
not the purpose here to repeat or refute
the conclusions reached by various
Scholars the major problems must be
underlined of course it is the
authenticity of the information in the
historic Augusta that is in doubt which
parts of it are to be accepted and which
not it is equally full hearty to reject
everything ignoring the work altogether
as it is to give Credence to everything
without
question an evaluation is mandatory but
welln impossible in the absence of other
corroboratory evidence it is easy to
fall into the habit of accepting all the
facts that seem to support one's own
ideas and to reject those which seem
contradictory end quote
the overall point that southern is
Raising is that the Historia Augusto
often just makes things up but
unfortunately when it comes to
elagabalus that Source plus the relevant
passages in casassus dio and herodian
are really all we
have and it makes evaluating elagabalus
and his Reign extraordinarily difficult
we have more and better sources on Nero
for example and he is only just starting
to be fully re-evaluated the same goes
with domian the problem is much harder
for someone like elig gabalis who is
reviled and For Whom the extremely
limited evidence is often extremely
hostile all right so with that out of
the way now let's talk about
elagabalus our Story begins with a
murder although not the murder of elig
gabis but rather Marcus aelius
anthoninos otherwise known as kacala who
was killed in a conspiracy directed
against him on the 8th of April 217
kakala had initiated the war against
Parthia the previous year in 2116 and
when a soldier was passed up for
promotion that individual stabbed kacala
while the emperor had stopped to pee
after that happened mcus the petorian
prefect seized power and with the
backing of the army was essentially in
control he later was recognized by the
Senate but he had two very serious
problems immediately confronting him the
first is that he is an equestrian that
is to say he comes from the wrong social
class
prior to him Emperors were from the
senatorial class and this rubbed the
senate in Rome the wrong way they
largely appeared to have backed him
because he already had the support of
the military and he had declared himself
Emperor along with the requisite titles
rather than having them conferred upon
him by the Senate so right away protocol
is essentially being broken and the
Senators took umbrage with this the
other major problem is that mcus was
still embroiled in a war with Persia and
on top of that and on top of that carala
had essentially spent a great deal of
the Imperial
Treasury and although he did broker a
pieace with Persia he had to pay them a
lot of money which he basically didn't
have and the Roman Empire was under
threat from other theaters as well other
Emperors had had one of these two
problems but not both at the same
time so when you boil it all down to the
basics the severe lack of money and the
circumstances through which mcus had
come to power meant that he was unable
to effectively deal with the third
Channel required to be perceived as a
legitimate
Emperor from a rather cynical Viewpoint
yes the military was required to get
somebody into power but once somebody
had power in the Roman world the
situation became extremely complex
extremely quickly because the Roman
state was held together through a policy
called consensus essentially the
permission of the Roman population was
required to hold office not in the sense
of government of by and for the people
in the sense of a modern democracy but
rather in the sense of the emperor being
seen as fulfilling a role that Roman
Imperial ideology expected the emperor
to be able to
fulfill protecting the borders engaging
in public works projects engaging in
propaganda designed to link set Emperor
with the past or to demonize previous
Emperors and thus to correct past wrongs
and also being seen as a protector of
the Roman people the Citi body had the
right to send the emperor a petition for
something say a lower tax burden and to
expect a
response cities could do this
collectively as well in a rather famous
incident an old woman attempted to ask
the emperor Hadrian a question and he
responded that he didn't have time for
her so she shot back at him sto being
Emperor then at which point hadrien
stopped his horse and listen to what the
old woman had to say this right here is
the system which enabled the Roman
Empire to mend itself back together each
time after Civil Wars the population as
a whole largely bought into the idea of
Rome because they felt they got
something out of it on the one hand this
was all a fiction that people bought
into because swords mattered more than
pens but on the other hand this was a
very real issue Emperors had to deal
with because Swords by themselves are
not necessarily going to get you
long-term tax revenue but cronus's
problems meant that he didn't have the
ability to get the system under control
in a timely manner so as all of this is
going down mcus had sent the relatives
of the now dead severan Dynasty to
amessa in
Syria there are multiple people there
but for the purposes of a video on
elagabalus the six that matter in a
messa long term are Julia DNA the mother
of
kacala Julia Misa her sister and thus
kacal's aunt and the daughters of Julia
mea Julia mamea and Julia somas
thus carella's cousins each of whom had
a son Alexander seus and sexus various
avitas basanis respectively so these two
would be kaka's second
cousins right away we have some problems
in dealing with this family especially
bassianus who would later be known as
elagabalus first and foremost would be
that they were dominated by women
especially Julia
DNA it probably is not an understatement
to say that Roman culture was was often
misogynistic so the fact that this
branch of the Severin were dominated by
women especially Julia domna would have
caused Romans to have viewed them in a
less than favorable
light and this does make it into
casassus Dio and herodian the men of the
family were also from Syria specifically
they were from Essa and in that City
they were Priests of elabel a solo deity
which was associated with a sacred Black
Stone known as a bital which probably
was a meteorite we'll talk about why the
rans and specifically of the senate had
an issue with this cult later in the
video but initially the worship of this
God does not appear to have been really
all that much of a problem it appears to
have been popular with soldiers and
there is evidence of the cult as far
away as what is today of the Netherlands
but perhaps most importantly different
regions of the Roman Empire had
different ethnic stereotypes and for the
Romans people from the Eastern
Mediterranean generally but Syria and
the surrounding region specifically were
often seen as manly effeminate weak and
generally just weird so because Roman
history is often conform to literary
conventions stereotypes like that make
appearances in the writings of casassus
Doo and herodian doo specifically refers
to basanis as sardinops an Assyrian King
that in Greek writing had all sorts of
ethnic stereotypes from the region
attached to him including that he was a
crossdresser and was dedicated to
physical pleasure and to the Greeks this
made him very much a moral
degenerate because elagabalus was from
the same region the same stereotypes
applied so the overall point is that
genre conventions and motifs are
attached to the emperor which may or may
not be true and if they are true they
may certainly be
exaggerated anyway Julia Misa wants to
get back in power she's not particularly
happy with the murder of her nephew in
the rise of mcus so using the fact that
apparently both of her daughters had
slept with kacala she gets one of the
nearby Legions to recognize basanis as
the actual son of kakala so this would
be a product of incest basically and
they raised a revolt on the 16th of May
218 with basias taking the name Marcus
aurelus antoninus that is the actual
name of kacala himself thus attempting
to really establish some sort of
legitimate
connection this was extremely dangerous
for mcus for two reasons reason number
one is that the Army had loved kacala
so someone claiming not only to be his
son but also using his name could make
her a very messy situation reason number
two is that when mcus had made peace
with the Persians he had paid the
Persians a great deal of money and he
had not paid the soldiers any sort of a
bonus for time on the campaign so many
troops were extremely already angry with
the sitting Emperor and they began to
murmur about getting rid of him so mcus
getting wind of these developments and
obviously being fairly scared of what
was happening
sends his sporan prefect julianas to try
and calm things down and to bring the
defected Army back on his side but they
kill julianus so then in response mcus
goes to another Legion declares his own
biological son as Caesar that is Junior
Emperor gives them a bonus but in the
process of doing so a messenger shows up
with a basket containing julius's head
things are now becoming extremely
dangerous to mcus leaves fleeing towards
Antioch while more and more troops are
defecting debasis and his family and the
two then clashed near Antioch on the 8th
of June 218 basanis and his forces win
and mcus is executed as is Marcus's
10-year-old son later on after he's
captured after that basanis enters
Antioch and he sends word to the senate
in Rome who promptly accept that he has
declared himself Emperor and he gives
the soldiers a bonus of 2,000 cestuses
each we do not know why he and his
Entourage do what they do next all we
know is that for some reason rather than
taking a ship right across the
Mediterranean from Antioch to Rome they
instead elect to travel Overland to the
city and it takes about 14 months to do
so it's once he's in Rome though that
all of these stories of his excess and
his degeneracy really start to show up
in the sources and because of that it's
at this point that I'll start calling
him alabas rather than
basanis while on the way to Rome
elagabalus continued to practice the Rel
religious rights associated with The
Cult of elabel during the winter of 218
and 219 and assuming that this did
indeed happen and there probably is not
a reason to think that this didn't this
apparently deeply worried Julia mea
because of how this could potentially be
received by the government in Rome elig
gabis had already done something sort of
odd as it is since they were taking the
long way to Rome he had sent on ahead a
gigantic portrait of himself so that the
Romans knew that this is what their
Emperor looked looked like coins were
already being minted and that was
perfectly normal for a new emperor but
the painting just stands out as a weird
thing to have done and you really get
the impression from both Casas Dio and
herodian that the government and people
in Rome were sort of apprehensive they
don't exactly know what sort of person
is coming to them the most important
thing to keep in mind here is that he's
about 15 by this point and he doesn't
appear to be behaving like a mature
Emperor should but that in of itself
doesn't really mean all too much in
Roman law the age of majority was 25 so
at 15 he was still seen as something
like a child and not taking the job that
seriously fits in with another literary
convention that shows up in Roman
histories portraying young Emperors like
Nero as well kids that being said this
is not all just convention because elig
gabalis takes things to new heights on
account of his religion because when he
shows up in Rome he brings the sacred
stone of elabel with him and it one
point he apparently puts it in a chariot
and he parades it around the city now
while he's in Rome elagabalus begins
constructing a temple to the God and
this does not necessarily seem to have
been all that controversial Roman
religion was fairly syncretic and
different Cults made their way to Rome
itself and to various points in the
Roman world all the time the issue
appears to have been that elagabalus was
attempting to elevate elabel to a
position higher than that of Jupiter and
he takes the title most distinguished
PRI of the unconquered son elabel which
again does not necessarily appear to
have been an issue except for the fact
that he was the emperor and he placed
that title before ponteix Maximus which
upended all sorts of long-standing
customs and precedents in Rome it is
with that in mind that we can talk
albeit to an extremely limited degree
about whether or not elaba should be
seen as somebody who was perhaps gender
fluid as you will often see in the
modern day when he's
referenced and I say that we can talk
about this to an extremely limited
degree for the following reasons he
marries several women he first marries a
woman named Paula in 219 and he then
divorces her and marries a Vestal Virgin
this was a huge scandal in Rome because
the Vestal Virgin was supposed to be
dedicated to Rome and to the goddess
Vesta if relations were had with men
according to Roman law the Vestal
virgins who had broken their vows of
Chastity was supposed to be immured so
the marriage between el abis and the
Vestal Virgin was a huge affront to the
Roman State and to the Roman culture
essentially at the most foundational
level you can possibly
imagine now why does he do this well it
apparently was religious because as the
representative of his God elagabalus
hoped to produce something like a Divine
Offspring or at the very least to
strengthen religious bonds he then
divorces the woman marries a descendant
of Marcus Aurelius divorces them marries
somebody else divorces them again and
then remarries the Vestal
Virgin cassus dial tells us that
apparently elagabalus was looking for a
surgeon to perform genital surgery on
him and essentially to give him gender
reassignment surgery and a lot has been
made of this over the years if this is
indeed genuine then perhaps it would
help explain the marital problems and
his lack of a biological air perhaps he
simply was not interested we're only
able to discuss this in a very limited
capacity however because this may or may
not actually come from
Dio instead it comes from zarus a
Byzantine or medieval Roman if you want
to use that term Theologian and Scholar
from the 12th century who wrote a work
of history which relied heavily on
cassus Dio and because cassus Di's whole
text has not come down to us today the
line of text which states this about
elig gabis does not come from the oldest
extant manuscript but rather from a work
that quoted it this has led to
disagreement as to whether or not the
line was actually in dio originally or
if it's a corruption or a mistranslation
or otherwise some addition which made it
into a later text about 8 centuries
after the man himself was writing there
are two other Byzantine instances in
which the line shows up but the problem
is that it's a line without context a
literal translation of dial from Latin
or Greek would have an extent body of
text and then that line sort of is left
hanging in that translation so it could
mean everything or it could mean
absolutely nothing depending on how you
look at it and where you want to place
it because the original context of that
line is not clear what we do know is
that elab is planned or at least seems
to have planned on having children so it
would be really difficult to try to
square a procedure of this nature with a
desire to have children so how should we
interpret this
well it's very possible that this was
something which was just misunderstood
by Roman writers because Eastern
religions often featured castration as a
ritual that male priests would undergo
and it may be the case that Priests of
elabel or at least some of them would
have been castrated and because he
appears to have taken his role as Chief
priest very seriously apparently putting
it above the office of Emperor it's
possible that this is what elagabalus
really
meant unfortunately however at the end
of the day we simply do not know the
evidence is not fully there to the
extent that we would like he did
apparently go into brothel and act as a
prostitute meaning that he was on the
receiving end which in Roman culture was
What mattered more than who you slept
with it was a mark of masculinity to be
on the dominant side of things whereas
it was seen as a feminite if you were
the submissive so on the one hand could
eleg gabis at the very least have been
considered what we today would
understand as
bisexual sure possibly but but you also
need to bear in mind that similar
stories were told about young Emperors
like Nero so in other words this could
just be seen as a literary theme which
takes exploits that alabas may certainly
have done and just blown them out of
proportion it also fits with Roman
stereotypes of easterners Simply Having
no
morals that being said although some of
the stories told about him sound extreme
there are a lot of them and while
casassus Dio herodian and the Historia
Augusta are our three major sources for
elagabalus
there are others which survive in an
extremely limited form it is not the
best analogy but more or less what we're
looking at with these other sources are
Standalone quotes or fragments from
other works basically we're attempting
to extrapolate information from like a
footnote it's not really the best thing
to work with but considering how old
these things are it's a miracle that we
know anything at all and this is what
we've got these are things like scraps
of poetry horoscope tables things like
that WR written after elagabalus died
but they still refer to him as well a
rather nasty piece of work he also
became involved with a man named
Heracles a slave and a charioteer who
elagabalus met during a race and this
would apparently prove to be his
downfall elagabalus once Heracles was
freed attempted to make him Caesar or
Junior Emperor and his family had a huge
problem with this as did the petorian
guard I suppose it's also worth
mentioning here that elagabalus
apparently had another lover zotus and
Heracles was apparently extremely
jealous so he gave zardus some sort of
an Elixir that how do I put this in a
way that keeps it YouTube
friendly he gave him some sort of a
concoction that kept zotus limp shall we
say and this so upset elagabalus that
the emperor banished zotus and then
Heracles apparently beat elagabalus up
for being unfaithful we have no idea
that actually happened it comes from Dio
and it strikes one as being extremely
hostile but it's still an interesting
anecdote nonetheless the disaffection of
the petorian Guard over these instances
seriously alarmed others in his court
and Julia Misa his grandmother convinces
elig gabis to promote seus Alexander to
Caesar in June of 221 instead of
Heracles and it's a good thing that he
does so because 9 months later in March
of 222 he goes to the camp of the
priorians in order to quell a rumor that
Alexander was
dying and while he's there the soldiers
praise Alexander and they kill alabas
and they throw his body into the Tyber
and many members of his court including
his lover Heracles were also killed his
mother met the same fate and her body
was dragged around Rome until it was
simply discarded somewhere we don't know
where the God and His sacred stone were
removed from the city and the massive
Temple which had held it was converted
into a temple of Jupiter thus ended the
Syrian Emperor so what are we to make of
elagabalus most of the source material
we have is concerned with his sexuality
and his well let's call them
exploits on the one hand yes there is
the bedroom stuff but those exploits
also include things like holding a party
in which he had rose pedals fall from
the ceiling and so many fell that his
guests apparently
suffocated and we have extremely little
on economic or foreign policy the sorts
of things we would actually like to know
certainly this was a period when some
emphasis on the word some women had an
increased status as the women of the
Imperial Family actually sat in on
Senate meetings and this was considered
an a front the most important thing I
think that we can say given the
limitations of our sources as we've gone
over earlier in this video is that
elagabalus was a young man under a great
deal of stress his family particularly
the women were connected to the sever
Dynasty and they had lost their power so
when a chance came to take it back They
seized it using elagabalus as a means
with which to do
so he himself really appears to have
been somebody who was brought up to
believe in his son cult and who clearly
took his role as Chief priest seriously
I would not be surprised if he himself
never wanted to be the emperor of Rome
perhaps he was unsure of his gender
identity but we don't have enough
evidence to really objectively judge
that either way we don't know and we
should be honest about that the single
biggest problem elagabalus appears to
have had though isn't really his
sexuality per se but rather his
insistent on remaining the chief priest
of his Eastern religion and trying to
bring it into the capital by itself this
was not a problem the problem was that
because that behavior combined with his
licentiousness to whatever degree that
actually happened was Unbecoming of an
emperor and he alienated the parties
that mattered in Roman
politics and it's this which led to what
seems to be a power struggle in the
Roman Empire and he lost and his cousin
Alexander cus won in the aftermath soon
after elagabalus was killed and thrown
into the Tyber Alexander began an active
campaign to demonize his cousin and to
damn his memory it is that Campaign
which is largely responsible for the
image we have of elagabalus today and it
is for that reason that the emperor
remains both an historical
Fascination and an enigma
