In this episode, I discuss the Maya collapse of the Terminal Classic period and explore two cities that survived it. Why did they make it when others did not?
🔔 Subscribe for more in-person exploration 📍 Location: Chinkultic and Tenam Puente 🗺️ Series: Antiquities Explorer – Central Mexico ►Grab my FREE SCREENSAVER PACK of ancient sites — they’ll inspire your next adventure https://86fb90c275cd11ef91efc1594cccd986.eo.page/8wfph
FTC Disclaimer Notice: Some of the links here may be affiliate links, meaning that if you click on them and purchase something on another website, I get a small commission. It doesn't cost you any extra, but I thought you should know! It does help support the channel. ► SOUNDTRACK Gabriel Lewis, "Ancient Discoveries" Mike Franklyn, "Optical Delusion" Alcones Negros, "Cada Primavera (Instrumental Version)" Phoenix Tail, "Listen Closely" Fantoms, "Like a Zip" Follow Professor Miano on social media: ►FACEBOOK: https://www.facebook.com/DrDavidMiano ►INSTAGRAM: https://www.instagram.com/drmiano/ ►BLUESKY: https://bsky.app/profile/davidmiano.bsky.social
AI Generated·May contain errors
During the late classic period, between the years 600 and 900, Maya society was at the zenith of its
cultural and architectural splendor. Its rulers were more powerful than they had ever been before
and despite the constant warfare there was little indication that within a short time
the whole system would fold in on itself. It is generally known that in the 9th and 10th centuries
the Maya world as it was then collapsed, never to revive. The cities were abandoned and the Maya
returned to a more modest rural lifestyle which many still practice today. But what is not generally
known is that although this collapse was widespread, it was not universal. There were some Maya cities
that survived and survived for a long time and today I'm going to show you two of them. We'll
talk about what happened during the period of the collapse, why some urban centers lived on
and for how long. The site of ancient Chincoltec lies in the eastern Chiapas highlands on the Comitán
plateau near the modern town of Comitán, not far from the Mexico-Guatemala border. Chincoltec is
small but it occupied a strategic frontier location at the southwestern boundary of Maya civilization
which made it crucial for territorial control and its interaction with neighboring peoples from the
highlands of Guatemala helped bring foreign goods into the Maya world. Positioned between Lake
Tepancoapan and Lake Chanuhabap, the city never lacked for water. There's a river now known as the
Yubnaranjo which flows between the two lakes and it divided the city into a northern and southern
half, possibly representing some kind of division between social groups or cosmological zones. The
site lies within the beautiful Lagunas de Montebello National Park. Locals come here to take in the
scenery but foreigners are rarely seen this far out. The earliest evidence for human occupation
at Chincoltec dates to the late pre-classic period around the 3rd century BCE but it was during the
classic period beginning around 250 CE that Chincoltec transformed from a modest settlement
into a significant regional center. Like most Maya sites of this area, Chincoltec experienced its
greatest development during the late classic period, particularly between the years 700 and 900.
This was a time when a branch of the Chan-Ahau royal lineage arrived and established control here.
They ruled for about three centuries. The core of Chincoltec contains approximately 200 mounds
representing structures ranging from small domestic platforms to massive pyramidal temples.
We're entering Group C in the southwestern part of the site which contains a large concentration
of carved monuments. Note the finely cut limestone blocks. Oh you can see something here.
This ball court has a narrow playing alley that would require exceptional skill and precision
by the athletes. It's interesting that the end zones are asymmetrical. For what reason I don't
know. The most famous artifact found at this site comes from the ball court. It is known as the
Chincoltec ball player marker and it's now at the National Museum of Anthropology in Mexico City.
To be fair it was found at the nearby site of La Esperanza. How it got there we don't know but this
is its original location. It's a beautifully carved stone disc showing a ball player in typical
game attire in mid-action. A band of 12 glyphs surround the figure. They give us a mile-long
count date corresponding to May 19, 591. That happens to be two days before this ball court
was officially dedicated. We know that from another inscription. The inscription refers
to a lord associated with the Chan-Ahau dynasty. This dynasty is identified by its emblem glyph
and the name means either sky lord or serpent lord. Chincoltec was possibly the paramount center
of the Chan-Ahau dynasty who probably had subordinate polities in the area or a network
of allied branches of the same royal family. With approximately 40 carved stelae, Chincoltec
has one of the most substantial collections of classic period hieroglyphic inscriptions
from the eastern highlands. These monuments date from 591 to 897 documenting almost three
centuries of political stability. Yeah more red huh? It did but maybe they didn't use blue on here
I don't know. One of the distinctive elements of the portrayals of the rulers of Chincoltec
is they love to dress up in the warrior garb. Even more so than some of the other cities.
So you'll see a good example of that here. I don't know if we can make out his name
but the the regalia that he's wearing is very much associated with warfare, the military.
Okay look at this huh? Immediately south of the river Yub Naranjo is group B which contains the
sunken plaza. Hear me all my countrymen. The vast seating area around the plaza suggests this was a
for public spectacles and ceremonies. Note the viewing platform in the upper middle section,
probably for the ruler and high-ranking nobles. We found a cave entrance nearby. The limestone bedrock
was honeycombed with caverns many of which contain pools and underground rivers. The Maya viewed
these caves as entrances to the underworld and places where communication with the supernatural
world was possible. I guess that's the older bridge underneath the newer bridge.
As we headed over the river and into the northern section of the city center,
we made our way up a steep hill towards the Acropolis. That is the Agua Azul Cenote,
a natural sinkhole approximately 164 feet deep. Cenotes were believed to be portals to the
underworld. Natural terraces led down into it which gives the impression of a stairway going down.
The city name Chincoltec means stepped cenote. Yes it was named after the Agua Azul. At least
two temples were constructed on the cenote rim and archaeologists found offerings within the waters.
Here we are at the top of the Acropolis and the view up here is amazing. This is the major
religious site of the city and it's built right next to the cenote down there, the Agua Azul
Cenote. It's about 50 meters deep that cenote but they believed it was sacred the cenotes because
they were perhaps an entrance to the underworld and there were a thousand steps that they had to
climb to get all the way up here. Can you imagine that? We think that stairway probably represented
the passage of the sun from beneath the earth up into the sky and this area was very sacred. It's
got your main step pyramid here, some subsidiary structures. They did find some tombs, elite tombs
beneath a couple of the altars here but they were from the early post-classic period maybe 1200s or
so and it shows that when the site stopped being used for ceremonial purposes at least the elites
wanted to be buried here because they thought the site was sacred. Joyce, our 89 year old woman,
she made it all the way up here. She was determined even when we kind of discouraged it.
On our way out we caught sight of an overgrown mound called the Pyramid of the Slab Stones.
It doesn't look like much now but this building contains Mesoamerica's largest cut stone building
blocks. Unlike most major Maya centers in the southern lowlands that were abandoned around 900
during the classic Maya collapse, Chincoteague continued to be occupied until the 13th century
making it one of the few Maya sites in the region to survive into the post-classic period. The
suggests a change in political organization at that time. In a bit I will explain why it survived
when the others did not but first I need to show you another city that lived on past the Maya
collapse. On the drive between the two Maya sites we found a great little restaurant called Los
Camelos. I recommend stopping if you ever come by this way. Not far from Chincoteague and actually
closer to the city of Comitán lies the site of Tenenpuente which sits on a high elevation
and commands a panoramic view across the Comitán plain. The name Tenenpuente is a mixture of Nahuatl
and Spanish and means something like fortified bridge. Nobody knows its original Maya name.
Like Chincoteague, Tenenpuente survived the Maya collapse and it continued to be occupied
into the post-classic period. For some weird reason no video cameras are allowed on site
so everything you see here was shot on my phone. Although ceramic evidence suggests possible late
pre-classic occupation, the sacropolis began to be constructed during the early classic between 250
and 600. But major modifications and expansions took place in the late classic between 600 and
900. Recent excavations have revealed that the main plaza served as a marketplace beginning in
the late classic period. The city was a major commercial center controlling trade routes
between the highlands of Chiapas and Guatemala and the central depression. They brought in exotic
materials from the Gulf Coast, the Soconusco region, and distant Maya cities. It's interesting
that the market is directly below the acropolis. This suggests elite surveillance of marketplace
activities and possibly tax collection. The east side of the plaza is where public ceremonies took
place and there are the remains of a ball court. The ruins of an attendant house, which probably
stored equipment and sheltered ball players, sits adjacent. A deer bone fragment found inside
was carbon dated to the late classic period. Remember that as we go up we enter into progressively
more restricted areas reflecting both the social hierarchy and defensive considerations. The most
sacred and exclusive spaces are at the top. The main facade of building 29 apparently was once
covered with mottled stucco depicting Venus and symbols associated with death and sun gods, but it
is much deteriorated now. A stela was found in front of the stairway with traces of reddish paint on it.
The city acropolis is built on several terraces, so exploration requires steep climbs up more than
a hundred steps. The ancient builders transformed a natural hill through massive earth moving
projects and leveled these terraces at different heights with monumental retaining walls. The
architectural style here, as in Chincoteague, is in the Chiapas highland tradition. They didn't build
with elaborate decorative elements like corbel vaults, roof combs, and intricate facade sculptures,
which is characteristic of lowland Maya architecture. It may simply be a different
tradition or maybe it had to do with resources. These buildings use dry stone masonry featuring
precisely cut limestone blocks with no mortar between them and they were once all faced with
lime stucco. This place is even more amazing than I thought it was going to be. We are here at
edifice number seven, structure seven here. This is one of the best stepped pyramids here on site
and look at that. We're going to go up in a second, but there was a stela that was right here as you
can see at the bottom, but the stela now is at the Tuxla Gutierrez Museum. We think the stela
belonged here and that stela has a date on it of 790 CE, so this is when we think that this
pyramid was probably inaugurated. But let's go up to the top and see how it looks. Who needs a drone shot?
This pyramid rises about 75 feet, 23 meters, above the third terrace platform. Everyone down below
would probably have had a good view of the ceremonies performed up here and have seen the
smoke from incense burners for miles. The building here, structure 20, contained the tomb of one of
the site's rulers, but it's closed off to us. On the same level as ball court number two, considerably
smaller than the one down below, it retains unequal playing alley sections characteristic of
Highland Chiapas ball courts like we saw at Chincoteague. Up we go to the next terrace. Here is the city
center's third ball court. This place has more ball courts than any other site in the Comitán Valley
or neighboring regions. Being higher up, this one would be the most restricted of the three. You
could only get to it from restricted staircases from the lower terraces. It's also the smallest.
This is Plaza B. Structure 17 is the main temple of Plaza B. Being the eastern terminus of the east-west
axis, it probably was a place for important ceremonies. From the top, you can see all the
way down to the marketplace. The plaza itself served as an administrative center of some kind.
Finally, up to the highest section, the fifth terrace. Here in Plaza C sits Structure 14, just a
partially preserved platform. Locals, you see, make an annual pilgrimage here in May when the rainy
season is about to begin to pray for sufficient rain and a successful harvest. Here on the same
level is Plaza D. The building there with three stairways is Structure 42. It may have supported
multiple buildings on top. This also is believed to have been an administrative center of some kind.
Located around the edges of the monumental core were elite residences alongside crop fields and
probably workshops. Tenom Puente, Chincoteague, and the nearby sites of Tenom Rosario, Santa Elena,
and Poco Huinic all survived the critical period when most Maya lowland sites were abandoned.
In fact, Tenom Puente flourished in the post-classic period, lasting as late as 1200,
after which it too was abandoned. Before I tell you about the Maya collapse, let's go take a look
at some of the artifacts found at both Chincoteague and Tenom Puente just to give you a fuller picture.
Buildings are one thing, but the smaller objects are fascinating in their own right.
Got some character, huh? The Comitán Archaeological Museum is downtown.
It's a very nice area with shops and restaurants. This is really cool.
The museum contains several recovered stelae and sculpted monuments from Chincoteague.
These are fragments of captive sculptures found in the ball courts. That's an effigy urn. Effigy
urns are fascinating and I'll tell you more about them in our next episode. Here are some ceramics
that were found at Tenom Puente. The captive sculptures look a lot like the ones we saw at
Toninan. So here are these two cities that survived well beyond the general collapse
of Maya urban society in the terminal classic period. But why? Well, I suppose I first have
to tell you about the Maya collapse and what it was all about. And while I tell you, I will show
you some of this gorgeous country called Mexico. The next day we made our way westward to see
Sumidero Canyon. It's probably the most amazing and beautiful place we saw on this trip. And we
didn't see it looking down from the top, but from the bottom on the Grijalva River itself.
We booked a one-hour boat tour and it took our collective breath away.
The Sumidero Canyon is the symbol and the coat of arms of the state of Chiapas. Ah, okay.
Martin, all right. We're on a boat cruising up the Grijalva River. It's an amazing experience.
Crocodile on the beach. Is there a crocodile? Oh yeah, look it. Okay, so the Maya collapse.
The first thing you should know is that the Maya collapse was not caused by any one factor,
but multiple stresses interacting in such a way that it created a cascading series of failures.
The initial trigger was severe drought episodes beginning around the year 820. Paleoclimate
research has shown that the Maya world experienced a series of multi-year droughts
interspersed with wetter periods. Now, the Maya had developed sophisticated water management
systems to cope with seasonal variation and rainfall, but these droughts were too much for
the systems. I mean, they tried innovating. Catchment systems were created. Reservoirs
were built. But these depended on seasonal rainfall and it just wasn't coming. Now,
keep in mind here that Maya rulers had monopolized the water sources during the
usual annual droughts. It was a way for them to exact tribute from subjects. But when rulers
couldn't ensure water supply or agricultural success, their claims to divine sanction
were called into question. This in turn would have led to political instability. We expect
there were revolts by the common people. Factionalism appeared among the elites.
Polities began warring over water. States fractured. This would have disrupted trade networks,
so the economies would have suffered. If a city was no longer able to sustain the populace,
people would have been emigrating to places where it was easier to survive.
This likely explains the abandonment of cities. Due to the length of the period of droughts,
the collapse wasn't followed by the development of new political orders,
as may have happened in the past. But we have to keep in mind that the southern lowlands
had it the worst. Major cities like Tikal, Calakmul, and Karakol completely collapsed
and never recovered. In the northern lowlands, up Yucatan Way, the droughts were less severe,
so some places lived on into the post-classic period. Chichen Itza, for example. But why were
things better in the highlands? Highland zones often had richer, thicker volcanic or alluvial
soils that supported more reliable agriculture. They were less vulnerable to the severe droughts.
Sites in the highlands also were frequently located in naturally defensible positions,
making them harder to overrun amid warfare or instability. Proximity to trade routes
connecting to other areas allowed access to commodities they needed. But to be clear,
there was, even here, a breakdown of the Cahul Ahau divine lord system of rulership with its
emphasis on monuments and water control. The highland sites reorganized around different
power structures without total societal failure. Some Maya cities even lasted until the time of
European contact. Our next episode is going to be all about another Mesoamerican civilization,
that of the Zapotecs. We will be venturing into the state of Oaxaca to visit the great sites of
Monte Alban, Atzompa, and Mitla. If you don't know much about the Zapotecs but would like to,
this will be the video for you.