►LEAVE A COMMENT We would love to hear your thoughts about the video. Please be civil to the other commenters. If your comment does not appear, try again with different words. YouTube sometimes glitches and comments don't go through. Or they might flag your comment as potentially inappropriate.
► SUPPORT THIS CHANNEL Supporters get access to behind-the-scenes videos, early-release videos, course discounts and more! http://www.patreon.com/worldofantiquity
For regular videos on ancient cultures and forgotten civilizations, please subscribe.
A more recent pseudoscience is Precisionism, an idea popularized by a machinist named Christopher
Dunn. The basic concept is that certain ancient artifacts (almost always stone artifacts) have
been made so precisely that it would have been impossible for known ancient peoples to have
made them. The intent here is to attribute the manufacture of these items to an unknown
civilization with more advanced tools. This idea is based on the premise that accuracy
in manufacture is determined by the tool, not by the person or persons operating the tool.
This is a claim that has never been accepted by the scientific community, nor has anyone
ever attempted to demonstrate it to be true in a study published in a scientific journal. It
is merely an assumption. The only support for it you will ever hear is an argument from authority,
such as someone saying, “Well, I am an engineer, or I am a stonemason, or I am a fill-in-the-blank,
and I know this is true.” They want you to accept it because of who is saying it,
rather than on the argument itself. That should raise a red flag right there.
Not only has this principle never been supported by any scientific research,
but it is demonstrably irrational for several reasons. First of all, a tool,
no matter how advanced, is only as effective as the person operating it. This is well
known simply from experience. Give the most sophisticated tool to an inexperienced child,
and what are you going to get? Similarly, you can give a skilled artisan a random rock and a piece
of stone, and they can create a masterpiece. Tools don’t make artifacts. People do. Second,
it ignores all the evidence from periods when we are absolutely certain what the tools were,
such as the medieval period, when amazingly precise stone was crafted, but there wasn’t any
super advanced machinery. Third, it ignores the evidence of techniques that were developed over
the centuries, and which people still use today, to achieve highly accurate work, such as methods
for achieving highly accurate flatness and highly accurate circles or arcs. For thousands of years,
artisans have known that if you spin an object on a mount that is fixed to an arbor,
and the abrading tool is anchored so it doesn’t move while working the surface,
you are going to get a perfectly round object. The less pressure from the tool,
and the faster the spin, the more accurate it will be. Fourth, the emphasis on stone manufacture and
not on other material suggests that the argument is primarily based on the difficulty of cutting
stone rather than on the precision itself. Fifth, it reasons backwards from the finished product,
assuming that the object as they see it was exactly what the artisan intended. Even
imperfection they attribute to intent. Then they say, it was impossible to achieve this result by
ordinary means. This is circular reasoning. Sixth, it suggests that someone went through the trouble
of using highly advanced machines to create everyday household items for no apparent reason.