Chinese Face Desperation Amid Prices Skyrocket; Li Keqiang Once Admitted China's Fake GDP Figures

China Focal Point
678 followers
Bus Fare Hike in China? Analysis: Government Running Out of Money
Vanke States Entry into the ‘Hitting the Wall’ Period: China's Property Bubble Bursts
Xi Jinping's Strict Real Estate Oversight May Reignite Banking Industry Panic
China CDC's Chief Epidemiologist Wu Zunyou Dies of Cancer
Li Keqiang Confessed to US Ambassador About China's Fake GDP Figures
#china #chinatruths #chinanews
Bus fare hike in China? Analysis. Government running out of money.
Bank state's entry into the hitting-the-wall period. China's property bubble bursts.
Xi Jinping's strict real estate oversight may reignite banking industry panic.
China CDC's chief epidemiologist Wu Zunyo dies of cancer.
Li Keqiang confessed to U.S. ambassador about China's fake GDP figures.
It's all covered in today's China Truths.
Bus fare hike in China? Analysis. Government running out of money.
In recent times, bus drivers in several Chinese cities have taken to the streets
in collective protests, demanding that the government pay their overdue salaries.
In response, on October 26, the Chinese Communist Party's Ministry of Transport
announced an adjustment to increase bus fares to cover operational costs.
In response, prominent Chinese media personality Huang Jinqiu commented,
this indicates that the Chinese government is running out of money.
He further explained the reasons. One reason is that our foreign relations haven't been well
managed, leading foreign orders to shift to Southeast Asia, resulting in a decline in our
earnings from abroad. Secondly, through this questionable foreign policy, the CCP has been
lavishing money overseas, depleting China's reserves. Consequently, the Chinese government
now finds itself shore of funds. This includes salary cuts and layoffs for public servants in
Guangdong, as well as nationwide layoffs, leading to a reduction in the number of buses.
It's all part of the broader situation. Mr. Huang analyzed that the CCP government is currently
facing a financial crisis and is shifting the burden onto the Chinese people through comprehensive
price hikes on daily necessities. Mr. Huang stated that essentially anything people can
afford is going to see a price hike, such as bus fares, water, electricity, and daily necessities.
According to him, the third wave may include fare hikes for public transportation,
subways, and more. One motive behind raising bus fares is to encourage people to buy cars.
Commenting on this issue, a retired engineer from Shanghai, Mr. Huang,
believes that the CCP's financial sustenance relies on land sales. However, with the bursting
of the Chinese real estate bubble, China's economy is faltering, causing various regions to run
budget deficits. The government can no longer operate as it is devoid of funds and faces a
financial crisis. They are left with no choice but to shift the financial burden onto the people.
This has resulted in inflation and a tenfold increase in prices,
ultimately causing ticket prices to rise.
Bank State's Entry into the Hitting the Wall Period – China's Property Bubble Bursts
On October 20, Bank's Chairman of the Board, Liang Yu, admitted that China's real estate
industry has entered the most painful phase of the marathon, known as the wall-hitting period,
marked by prolonged and intense struggles beyond expectations.
As a representative of mixed-ownership real estate and surviving private enterprises in
today's China, Liang Yu's words suggest that the already burst real estate bubble is irreparable.
In a marathon, the wall-hitting period is a challenging segment that athletes must endure.
Typically occurring around the 30-kilometer mark, it's when the body has nearly exhausted
its sugar reserves used for energy and begins burning fat for energy. During this phase,
athletes experience severe physical fatigue, muscle soreness, and push their bodies to the
limit, much like hitting the wall. However, Liang Yu said that once you pass this stage,
you can continue. He used the concept of the marathon's wall-hitting period as a metaphor to
illustrate the current real estate industry's struggle and pain, akin to hitting a wall this
year. According to data from the China Real Estate Report, in the first half of this year,
the profit situation for the top 50 listed real estate companies continued to worsen.
Collectively, they incurred a net loss of approximately $13.2 billion
and had to cover financial expenses of approximately $11.1 billion.
Notably, the companies experiencing significant losses are not limited to private enterprises.
Many state-owned and government-owned companies are also affected.
Among those with losses exceeding 10 billion yuan, companies such as Country Garden, Evergrande,
Sunac, Oceanwide, and Shimao Group are included. Country Garden experienced the most substantial
operating losses, causing its sales performance to drop from the first position to the sixth
among the top 100 real estate companies. Since the arrest of Evergrande's Su Jiayin,
a new wave of decline has swept through the real estate market.
With Country Garden's formal default, the real estate industry's sales have plummeted into a
bleak and frozen landscape, giving rise to widespread pessimism and desolation within the
industry. Both the real estate and stock markets are bearing the brunt of this turmoil.
Data from China's National Bureau of Statistics indicates that the total output value of the real
estate industry contracted by 2.7% in the third quarter of this year, marking the most significant
quarterly decline in 2023. The real estate sector accounts for as much as a quarter of China's GDP.
The ongoing string of defaults by real estate companies has triggered a powerful shockwave,
affecting businesses up and down the supply chain and financial institutions,
including banks, across the entire nation. This has weighed down China's economic recovery.
S&P Global Ratings projects that, in a bearish scenario, China's real estate sales in 2024 could
drop by as much as 25% compared to 2022. This would lead to China's actual GDP growth rate for
that year falling to 2.9%. The antidote for the real estate crisis has failed.
Beginning in November 2022, when the Chinese Communist Party introduced the 16 financial
measures and the three financial arrows for real estate financing, financial policies started to
loosen. Real estate policies also became more lenient, including recognizing homes instead
of loans, reducing interest rates on existing home loans, lowering the down payment ratio for
home loans, and easing property purchase restrictions, among other measures.
Since September, various regions have introduced policies promoting buying new homes with old ones,
resulting in multiple incentives that somewhat boosted home purchases.
However, over 70% of private real estate companies have already defaulted on their
debts, and obtaining further financing support from banks has become challenging.
Currently, the real estate market sales situation remains unchanged,
and the risk of defaults has spread to state-owned and government-owned developers.
Companies throughout the real estate industry's supply chain are affected by the ongoing real
estate crisis. Investors have lost confidence in the real estate market.
In October of this year, amidst continuously declining property prices, homeowners are
uncertain about the future of property prices. They are capitalizing on the new real estate
policies by aggressively lowering prices to sell their homes. This has led to waves of home sales
across China. This move leads to an intense price wars and promotional battles have ensued.
Right now, all the policies rolled out by the Chinese Communist authorities to stimulate
housing consumption haven't managed to give the housing market economy the boost it needs.
The real estate industry has lost faith in these policy rescue efforts.
The bursting of the real estate bubble, no remedy.
Going back as far as two years ago, Ren Zeping, a Chinese economist and the chief economist of
Zhongyuan Bank, emphasized that the real estate sector serves as the nucleus of economic cycles,
being at the core of nine out of ten crises. Many global economic crises have had a strong
association with the collapse of real estate bubbles. Political analyst Tang Jingyuan pointed
out on October 26th that the real estate bubble in China has already burst, and there's no solution
in sight. He explained, prominent real estate giants such as Evergrande, Country Garden,
Sunac, and others have all succumbed to defaults, and it appears that no matter what policies are
enacted, they are proving to be ineffective. Despite the Chinese Communist Party's efforts
to stimulate home purchases, people remain hesitant to buy due to their lack of confidence
in the economy. With such a high unemployment rate, it's becoming increasingly challenging to
earn a living. New homes are sitting unsold, and a growing number of developers are struggling to
sustain their profits and keep their businesses running. Mr. Tang also foresees that the Chinese
real estate industry will experience a sharp decline in the future. China's economy currently
finds itself in a precarious situation, with the Chinese Communist Party using excessive
currency printing as a mere postponement strategy for the inevitable crisis eruption.
However, this approach is unsustainable in the long term.
Xi Jinping's strict real estate oversight may reignite banking industry panic.
In the midst of turmoil in China's real estate sector, especially following the arrest of Su
Jiayin, the founder of Evergrande Group, which has sent shockwaves both domestically and
internationally, insiders have revealed that the Chinese government is expanding its investigations
to encompass banks and financial institutions that unlawfully facilitated property developers.
On October 26, The Wall Street Journal in the United States, citing insiders, reported that
during a meeting in September, Chinese President Xi Jinping explicitly emphasized that no details
should be overlooked in the rectification of the real estate industry. He stressed that while they
could tolerate a slowdown in the real estate market leading to a deceleration of economic growth,
the anti-corruption campaign must continue without interruption. Individuals under investigation
include the former head of the Bank of China, Liu Longge. On October 16, Liu Longge was arrested on
charges including bribery and illegal loan disbursement. Insiders indicated that some
of the allegations against Liu Longge are related to the bank's provision of loans to Evergrande.
Regarding this matter, Taiwanese financial expert Huang Shicheng shared his thought that
Xi Jinping may be seizing this opportunity to eliminate political rivals and, at the same time,
expose the relationships between politics and business that he perceives as problematic in
the past. At the same time, when it comes to pushing the future of China's real estate
market downwards or when addressing issues affecting China's economy, he can say,
This is not my problem. It's due to the past relationships between politics and business.
I am simply upholding the banner of anti-corruption, and even if it means sacrificing
the economy, I believe I can gain the support of some of the people. Currently, the Chinese
authorities have been investigating whether Su Jiayin transferred assets overseas. Insiders have
also revealed that another focus of the investigation into Su Jiayin involves potential
illegal fundraising by Evergrande, such as bribing bank officials in exchange for loans.
The report also mentioned that the authorities are paying special attention to the 20 largest
creditors of Evergrande, including state-owned banks and banks controlled by local governments.
At this moment, one of Evergrande's largest creditors, China Mincheng Bank, which is owed
hundreds of billions, is currently under scrutiny. In July of this year, the Shanghai Stock Exchange
requested China Mincheng Bank to list all real estate borrowers, but the bank refused to provide
the requested information. According to Mr. Huang, continuing to suppress the real estate sector will
undoubtedly have a considerable negative impact on the financial industry, including many financial
products now facing defaults. This may lead to a domino effect, causing even banks with less
direct connections to face defaults. So, he stated that in the current situation, the adverse effects
on the real estate sector will certainly have a significantly detrimental impact on the financial
industry. American economist Davy Jay, Huang claimed that in addition to bank loans, what's
even more concerning in China is the extensive fraud and deception carried out by securities
companies, various manipulative practices related to going public, and deceiving ordinary citizens
into investments. This is the real core issue in China's financial industry.
This problem might be even more severe than that in the banking sector, so it appears that
financial issues cannot be entirely eradicated at the moment. In recent months, numerous setbacks
have occurred with China's real estate giants, causing investors to be cautious, while prospective
homebuyers can only hope for the best. Although there has been hope from external sources that
the CCP would provide comprehensive assistance to the real estate sector to prevent the crisis
from spreading to the financial industry, so far, Beijing has only taken some scattered measures to
support developers and stimulate home buying. However, they have yet to introduce an
all-encompassing plan to assist developers in debt restructuring, thereby reducing losses for
banks and other stakeholders. Expert Huang Shicheng suggests that, ultimately, the financial sector may
suffer the most from the collapse of the real estate market. In the coming years, the financial
industry in China may face even more severe repercussions due to its entanglement with the
real estate sector. China CDC's Chief Epidemiologist Wu Zunyo Dies of Cancer
On October 27, Wu Zunyo, a renowned public health expert and the chief epidemiologist of the Chinese
Center for Disease Control and Prevention, CDC, passed away at the age of 60 due to pancreatic
cancer. Wu Zunyo was a prominent advocate of the zero-COVID strategy during China's relentless
battle against the COVID-19 pandemic. Upon hearing the sorrowful news of his passing,
a wave of appreciation from many mainland Chinese netizens emerged, expressing gratitude for Wu
Zunyo's unwavering dedication during the relentless pandemic battle. However, some couldn't
help but recall the harrowing memories of the Shanghai lockdown during the pandemic and raised
a haunting question, could it be that the spirits of those who perished during the Shanghai lockdown
have called him to their side? During the pandemic, Wu defended the
zero-COVID policy in various media interviews and through his personal Weibo account.
In March 2022, he suggested that achieving societal zero could be attainable with timely
rounds of mass nucleic acid testing in outbreak areas. However, despite Shanghai and Beijing
implementing strict measures and frequent mass nucleic acid testing,
they were unable to achieve the zero-COVID objective. On September 16, 2022, Chongqing
identified China's first monkeypox case among individuals undergoing quarantine.
In response, Wu Zunyo posted on Weibo, advising people not to have skin contact with individuals
returning from abroad within the past three weeks and to avoid skin contact with strangers.
This statement was criticized by many netizens, who considered it racially biased.
Li Keqiang Confessed to U.S. Ambassador About China's Fake GDP Figures
The unexpected passing of former Chinese Premier Li Keqiang at the age of 68, along with his
mysterious demise, has left both national and international public opinion in a state of
astonishment. In this context, the media has reexamined the statements he made during his
time in office, with particular attention paid to his confession about China's fake GDP figures.
In a revelation by WikiLeaks, a U.S. State Department memorandum came to light.
In March 2007, when Li Keqiang served as the party secretary of Liaoning Province,
he candidly informed visiting U.S. Ambassador Clark T. Rant that China's GDP figures were
man-made and consequently, not to be trusted. As an economist well-acquainted with the
intricacies of the Chinese economy, Li Keqiang articulated his preference for evaluating the
economy through three alternative indicators—industrial electricity consumption,
railway freight volume, and the volume of bank loans issued. This stance taken by Li Keqiang
has attracted attention from the international community. Towards the end of 2010, the economist
constructed the Li Keqiang Index based on these very indicators. This index was found to provide
a more accurate reflection of China's real economic conditions compared to the official
GDP data put forth by the Chinese Communist Party. Li Keqiang tells the truth, admits China's
economy is in bad shape. On May 28, 2020, during a press conference following the annual sessions
of the National People's Congress and the Chinese People's Political Consultative Conference,
he revealed that 600 million Chinese citizens had a monthly income of just 1,000 yuan.
In an average city, this income wouldn't even cover rent, and the situation was compounded by
the ongoing pandemic. Li Keqiang's statement caused a significant stir and was seen as a
response to Xi Jinping's proclamation in 2020 that China would achieve comprehensive poverty
alleviation and build a moderately prosperous society within the year. At that time, China was
grappling with a severe pandemic, and both the economy and people's livelihoods were severely
affected. Businesses were facing substantial challenges. In response, Li Keqiang initiated
the promotion of street vendor economies, believing this would boost business vitality,
create more job opportunities, and even personally visited street vendors in Shandong.
However, shortly after the nationwide rollout of the street vendor economies,
Chinese state media collectively criticized it, citing impacts on urban aesthetics, hygiene issues,
and uncivilized behavior. Consequently, the street vendor economy was abruptly halted,
highlighting Li Keqiang's limited practical decision-making authority concerning China's
economic development. In May 2022, during an economic conference attended by over 100,000
officials from across the country, Li Keqiang publicly admitted China's unfavorable economic
conditions, emphasizing that in certain aspects, the difficulties are, to some extent, more severe
than those experienced during the pandemic in 2020. He urged local governments to revitalize
the economy. He also revealed that China's unfavorable economic conditions had significantly
impacted central fiscal revenues, with a 5.9% decline in national fiscal revenue in April
and local fiscal revenue declining even faster at 6.6%. Several provinces had requested approval
to issue emergency bonds to overcome these challenges, but the central government had
only one emergency fund remaining, forcing local governments to rely on themselves.
Li Keqiang's speech garnered international attention. However, on the same evening,
CCP media heavily censored it, aggressively removing the full text of Li Keqiang's speech
that was circulating on social media. It is evident that the former Premier Li Keqiang
and the current CCP leader, Xi Jinping, had completely opposing approaches. Regarding this
matter, legal expert and independent commentator Yu Ping shared his perspective, stating,
in fact, Li Keqiang initially displayed a people-oriented and genuinely concerned
attitude toward the public. In contrast, Xi Jinping focused more on grand personal goals.
So, in reality, what Li Keqiang discussed with ordinary people was very practical.
Mr. Yu pointed out that while Li Keqiang might not have been a central figure of attention during
his lifetime, news of his death has sparked a significant online reaction, reflecting the
public sentiment. Yu Ping acknowledged that the current Chinese society is facing numerous crises,
and the sudden death of Li Keqiang may or may not lead to social unrest, depending on future
developments. However, this event has sent shockwaves through many within the system.
Importantly, it also threatens Xi Jinping's authority. Therefore, how she handles Li Keqiang's
death and communicates with his high-level personnel is crucial. Mishandling it could
lead to more betrayals or distancing from him. Mr. Yu claimed that this is a highly significant
event. Furthermore, some are concerned that the sudden death of a CCP leader could trigger a
large-scale public movement, similar to the June 4 event after the death of Hu Yaobang in 1989.
Mr. Yu said that we need time to observe because the news has just broken and society needs time
to digest it. So, even those who share values with Li Keqiang and those who appreciate him
among the common people, including middle and high-ranking officials, may or may not take action.
He believes Beijing is very tense right now.
Don't forget to leave a comment in the section below to share your opinions on today's topic
with us. Make sure to like and subscribe to see more interesting topics from China Truths.
