0:00 - Chinese Tech Stocks Plunge 40% 1:37 - Why Investors Are Turning To Chinese AI Stocks 5:49 - U.S. Midterms And The China Trade War 10:39 - Trump, Xi And Putin: A Historic Summit? 17:04 - China's Role In The Iran And Ukraine Wars 21:53 - How Close Are China And Russia? 24:02 - China's Economic Slowdown And Tax Revenue Crisis 33:00 - China's Real Estate Collapse And Wealth Destruction 39:13 - China's Bond Market And Deflation Problem 45:10 - Can Chinese AI Chips Compete With Nvidia And Samsung?
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI Generated
Sean Ryan of the China Market Research Group analyzes the potential for a rebound in Chinese equities, the strategic importance of a proposed trilateral summit in Shenzhen, and the diverging economic pressures of inflation in the U.S. and deflation in China. He argues that Chinese tech is undervalued and that geopolitical shifts could lead to a trade de-escalation.
Trade and economic relations with China will get better
in the coming months because Trump
sorely needs a win. I mean, he got destroyed.
And the best pop, I think, is going to be in
the Chinese stocks. If you believe in the AI story
in the United States, investors are going
to allocate away from the United States right now,
especially after the midterm elections,
where they're scared that the Democrats
are going to crack down on Silicon Valley
and they're going to be looking for where you can get a great pop.
The U.S. tech sector has suffered enormous losses over the last two
weeks, with the Nasdaq falling 5.5 percent just on last Thursday alone.
Overall, it's down more than 12 to 15 percent on the month, with major
stocks like Google now having come down 30 percent from its highest.
But the Chinese tech sector already led the decline.
The Star 50 index, which
measures the biggest 50 technology and science stocks
in China already fell more than 40% from its highs earlier this summer.
Sean Ryan, founder and managing director
of China Market Research Group, brings us the latest from China
for not only the Chinese tech stock sector,
but also the market overall and what's next for the Chinese economy
and how that impacts the rest of the world.
Welcome back to the show, Sean. Good to see you.
Good to see you, David.
Last time we spoke, which is about a month and a half ago,
you argued that Chinese tech stocks
We're significantly undervalued
and that investors should be buying Chinese semiconductor companies.
Since then, the Star 50 index plunged about 40% from its recent highs.
Wiping out an estimated $480 billion in market value.
What went wrong?
So over the major drop of 40% hasn't just been in the last few weeks.
It's been over the last few months.
So I think what I'm arguing is I've been to Australia.
I've been to the United States in the last month
or so to meet with the world's largest
mutual fund and hedge fund investors, David.
And what they're telling me,
even starting in August and September, is they were worried
Prices in AI had gotten too frothy in the United States.
And so at that point, they were starting
to look for new places to allocate their money.
And there are really two areas.
The first is they've been looking at more defensive stocks.
Maybe the consumer plays like a Ralph Lauren, like an Adidas.
Where the stocks are down,
but the numbers are actually pretty good for those companies,
especially in a market like China,
where Ralph Lauren sales have gone up 50% in the last
quarter.
Adidas has gone up 16% to 20% every quarter for the last three.
Now, my argument is that Chinese AI stocks
are a place where you might be able, with
a lot of caution, get a lot of returns
because the prices have dropped 40%.
And I think if you believe in the AI story
in the United States, which I think still
stands, even though the frothiness,
I think a lot of those American and Australian and
European investors are going to start looking at the Jupus,
the Minimaxes, the Cambercoms,
the CXMTs of the world, and they're going
to allocate away from the United States right
now, especially after the midterm elections,
where they're scared that the Democrats are
going to crack down on Silicon Valley, and they're going to be looking.
For where you can get a great pop.
And the best pop, I think, is going to be in the Chinese stocks.
Again, you need to be really cautious.
There's going to be a lot of volatility.
Prices might, you know, soar for two or three days.
And they collapse for two or three days.
But if you're smart money, you can get in,
sell at the high, buy on the dips.
That's the argument.
AI still is a good story.
I'm not convinced of the American AI story in the short term,
but we've already hit, I think, rock bottom in Chinese equities.
It's now time to start looking here
because the foreign investors are going to gain exposure
to China and Hong Kong in the coming months.
And that's the big sell-off in tech in the U.S. sector,
in the U.S. side, the NASDAQ specifically.
Would you be looking at the differentials and valuations between
Chinese stocks and U.S. stocks and make the same argument today
that Chinese stocks are still undervalued relative to the Nasdaq,
even after the big drop in the Nasdaq?
Yeah, absolutely. I'd still make that argument because I think,
you know, the Chinese AI stocks have gone down
because people are scared of China overall.
They're scared about the geopolitical situation.
There's a question of are the profits sustainable in the China market?
And then fourth, will other countries use Chinese AI stocks
and semiconductors?
And I think the answer is yes, they will. You see that Google
Announced a $15 billion investment into Malaysia, which is interesting
because Malaysia is one of the few countries that is still using
NVIDIA chips, but they're also using Huawei and other Chinese chips.
So what you're starting to see is global south countries like Malaysia
are starting to play America and China off each other by using
the stock or by using the chips from both of those countries.
So, yeah, I do think that China has a way to come up.
The reality, David, is there's so much polarization, there's
so much anger in the United States right now and the political system
that the Democrats are saying, get ready, lawyer up,
we're going to go after Trump, we're going to go after Mark Zuckerberg,
we're going to go after Jensen Huang, we're going
to go after Elon Musk, we're going to go after all of the tech tycoons
who, you know, cozied up to Trump in the last two years,
and they're going to try to set an example.
So if the Democrats do do that.
And you're starting to see, you know,
Jeffries and some of the Schumer and some of the leading
Democrat leaders are saying they're going to go after Trump
and after the tech oligarchs
that could hit the American equity markets
quite hard like they did two days after the
midterm election results.
And that's why I think China is a good place.
Again, high risk.
I wouldn't put more than five to five
to 10 percent of your money there.
But if you're looking for a real pop,
there is a potential in the Chinese equity markets.
OK, let me come back to the Chinese stock market in just a bit.
But since you brought up the midterm elections,
which, by the way, saw the Democrats sweep
both chambers of Congress,
what can you expect in terms of relationships between China and
the U.S. for the remainder of Trump's two years?
Can we see tariffs in the trade war de-escalate now
that the Democrats could potentially pass
legislation to counter what Trump's been doing?
Well, I think the first side,
I was actually in Texas on the day of the election and the day of
the results. And it's amazing that even Texas and Kansas went blue.
You know, these are historically
red states. And I think, David, the issue is that a lot of Americans,
it's just unaffordable to live,
right? You know, the average car is about 48,000 US dollars.
Food prices in restaurants have gone
Gone up 50%.
Over the last five years in the United States.
So America's facing massive inflationary issues.
Gas is up at $6.
And you're even seeing companies like Walmart
and McDonald's are reporting bad numbers
because they say the American consumer can't buy things.
And that really is due to two things, David.
The first is the Iran war.
Obviously, gas.
Prices have soared over the last six,
seven months since Trump launched this war.
That's really upset the American consumer.
But we have to look at the bigger picture, and that's tariffs, right?
China has been facing a deflationary cycle for the last 10 years.
America has been facing an inflationary cycle for the last 10 years.
And it all stems from first Trump
and then Biden's trade war against China.
And so I think the Democrats have said we need
to stop some of the tariffs.
And I think they're going to try to rein it
in probably more on the tariffs against Canada,
because obviously Canada is an ally of the United States,
you know, might rein in some
of the tariffs against India and Vietnam.
But I'm hoping that at the end of the day,
the Democrats and the Republicans are going
to say clearly the American consumer or the American voter.
Voted for a more affordable America.
So they have to do something about the tariffs.
Now, in the United States, you know,
people talk about the president being very powerful.
But there are actually a lot of checks
and balances when it comes to domestic issues.
Trump can't just push through ICE and immigration laws
because you might have governors like
Governor Newsom in California might push back.
The one area that American presidents really have absolute power
is in international affairs.
And that's why since the end of World War II, American presidents,
to distract from weakness in the domestic policy,
to distract from weakness in support from the electorate,
has gone after Korea, has gone into Vietnam, has gone into Iraq,
gone into Afghanistan, gone after Iran, gone after Ukraine.
So I think the idea is that Trump might try to nurse his wounds.
Um, by doing something internationally,
the fear I have is he might do it by supporting Israel to
bomb Iran, which they've been bombing
the last couple of days on that oil Island. I can't
pronounce the name Korg Island.
Um, it also might be, he might try to provoke something in Taiwan,
but I think at the end of the day,
Trump is going to look for a win by trying to come to a better
trade agreement with China.
And so I think when Trump visits China later this month in Shenzhen
for the APEC Summit.
He might meet with President Xi.
He might meet with President Putin.
This is where he might want to nurse his wounds
and show the American people he's still in
charge by coming up with sort of a grand bargain,
a grand deal when it comes to geopolitical
relations.
So I'm actually hopeful that economic trade
and economic relations with China will get
better in the coming months because Trump sorely needs a win.
I mean, he got destroyed.
Before we continue with the video,
let's talk about one of your most important assets that
may be at risk right now.
Most people will assume that personal information
is private unless they choose to share it.
That's not how that works.
Data brokers collect your name, home address,
phone number, even details about your family
and sell that to anyone willing to pay for it.
Today's sponsor, Delete Me, is what I use to cut that down.
Their team finds where your information
is listed on data broker sites, submits removal
requests to the ones that have it,
and keeps checking because these listings tend to come
back.
My latest report showed 253 records reviewed.
And Delete.me has saved me 23 hours of searching
for my own information since I joined.
Scan the QR code on the screen here
or go to join delete.me.com slash David Lin linked
down below in the description
and use my promo code David Lin for 20% off.
Take control of your privacy before the holidays.
Now back to the video.
Let's zero in on this.
This was no longer a rumor.
A couple of weeks ago,
Putin floated the idea of meeting in a trilateral summit between
Xi himself and Trump.
Now it's confirmed they are probably going to meet.
What do you think is going to be on the table for the discussion here?
Well, I think for...
Trump, he needs a win in Ukraine.
And so hopefully he's going to be able
to broker peace between the Ukrainians and the Russians.
And I think, you know, I'm not a Trump supporter,
but I'm not against Trump.
I think one of the things that's good about him
is that he's willing to hold negotiations.
He's willing to hold face-to-face discussions.
If you don't meet with Putin face-to-face,
how are you going to come with a solution?
One of the major reasons that I've
been very critical of the Biden regime
And Western European powers like Ursula
von der Leyen is they forbid the Ukrainians to meet
Zelensky to meet face to face with Putin.
If you don't meet, then you can't come up with a solution.
It was very clear the Lindsey Graham's,
the Joe Biden's, the Mitch McConnell's of the world
wanted to use Ukraine as cannon fodder to bog down Russia,
which they've done,
hurt them economically
and send a warning shot to mainland China not to invade Taiwan or not
Not to have armed aggression against Taiwan now.
You have to give credit to Trump
that he might be willing to meet with Putin,
just like he met with Kim Jong-un,
the head of North Korea, in his first administration.
And surprise, surprise, North Korea has actually been fairly peaceful
over the last six, seven years since Trump met with Kim.
That's what I'm hoping on the side with the Russians and the Ukrainians
in a potential meeting with Putin.
When it comes to China,
I think, you know, Trump is going to push a lot more for trade deals.
Right now, the Chinese are only buying about seven
and a half billion U.S. dollars a year
of agricultural products like soybeans.
That's down from 30 billion during the Biden regime.
And that's actually way, way down.
From 10, 15 years ago under Obama and Bush,
when the Chinese were buying tens and tens and tens of billions
of dollars of agricultural projects, products from the Americans.
So I think they're going to push for more sales there.
And I think the Chinese are going to have
to give up a little bit on rare earths.
You already saw Scotty Besant yesterday said
that the Chinese have to adhere to the Busan.
agreement and give us more access to rare earths.
But I think at the end of the day, David, China has
the upper hand in any negotiations.
And so they're going to push hard to get access or power.
Over the United States and maybe get access to more chips and some
of the Blackwell NVIDIA chips and maybe reduce some of the tariffs,
which I think Trump might be willing to do right now,
because, again, affordability was the biggest reason why
the Republicans lost the midterms.
Americans are struggling, struggling financially.
Yes, and on this summit, so first of all,
it will be held in China near Shenzhen.
And the optics of this are huge.
China hosting a potential trilateral meeting between.
Trump, Putin, and Xi.
Again, historic, says the press, which is correct.
Experts, however, say the three leaders
are unlikely to discuss anything substantive
because their interests are at odds,
but they would gather for photo
with China carefully choreographing the meeting.
Ultimately, what does China want from Putin
and Trump together in the same meeting here?
I mean, what is China's end goal with bringing together...
Either, uh...
Arguably three of the most powerful leaders in the world.
People are looking at this and saying to me privately and asking to me,
Hey, does it look like China, Russia,
and the U.S. are forming a new three-way superpower alliance here?
Well, I think that would be great.
I mean, I think for China, it's the optics of looking like
they're kingmakers, like they're rainmakers, like they're peacemakers.
And having, you know, Trump and Putin
both go to China, hopefully it's an era where the three markets
and the three countries are
going to get closer together,
more intertwined politically as well as economically, because the
world, you know, people aren't doing well.
If you look at it, what country in the world is doing well right now
No country is doing well,
and it's really because of all the tension with Russia and China
and the Western world. You know, it's a K-shaped economy.
Only the top 1% or maybe even only the top 0.1%
are doing really well right now. Everybody else is suffering.
Europe is a complete mess because
they're spending four times what they
were doing before buying LNG from America rather than Russia.
The Chinese are unable to export at high numbers
with good margins to the west of the world
because of tariffs.
So everybody's really hurting.
So you have these three countries' leaders come together
in Shenzhen as the backdrop.
Now, for your audience,
what they might not realize is Shenzhen is probably the leading
hub of innovation in the world.
You know, they've probably in many ways surpassed Silicon Valley.
Silicon Valley is great when it comes to software,
but Shenzhen has software as well as hardware.
I mean, that's where Tencent is headquartered.
That's where Huawei is headquartered.
That is where DJI is headquartered.
You know, 40 years ago, Shenzhen was a rice paddy.
25 years ago, Shenzhen was a base for mistresses
of Hong Kong girlfriends, and there was a
lot of prostitution.
15 years ago, it was low-end manufacturing.
Shenzhen has reinvented itself again
to be the place for deep tech as well as software,
hardware.
It's an absolutely incredible ecosystem
that's unparalleled anywhere in the world.
And I think the APEC meeting
was importantly held there because China...
China wanted to show America and Russia
and other nations this, we are the lead.
If you want to talk about technology standards going forward,
if you want to talk about innovation
going forward, it's going to be in Shenzhen.
And that's the backdrop to this meeting.
I think the Americans are going to be awed
at just how far ahead Shenzhen is.
I was just there two weeks ago,
and it's incredible what's happening there right now, David, in
terms of innovation.
Trump desperately needs to get out of Iran
in an orderly fashion that would save face.
Now, is there any scenario in which he would meet
with Xi Jinping and Putin to discuss
this so-called strategic retreat in a way
that I guess benefits all three parties?
In other words, could they come to the help of Trump in some way?
Yeah, I think they could.
And, you know, even Scott Bessent, who's a massive China hawk,
has said that China has actually been a pretty good player
when it comes to Iran,
and they haven't been supplying too much money, too much arms.
And you have to remember,
China only does about 35 billion
U.S. dollars a year of trade with Iran.
They do 105 and 110 billion of trade with the UAE and Saudi Arabia.
So China wants an end to the conflict in the Middle East
because it's hurting their trade
partnerships with not just Iran, but also the UAE and Saudi Arabia.
China is starting to run out of oil.
I mean, I think they've held off better than
the rest of the world because they've reduced
the amount of oil they've used by 5.5
million barrels a day, which is what India uses daily.
But China's their their resources, you know,
their savings are starting to be depleted.
And so they want an end.
So I think there could be some sort of a deal
that the Chinese might put some pressure on the Iranian leadership.
Maybe that Trump would play ball by reducing some of the tariffs
and reducing some of the rhetoric over Taiwan and allow China to.
Be able to plan over the next two
to three years what it can do economically and militarily
vis-a-vis Taiwan and the South China Sea
and not have to deal with the Americans looming
large.
So I think a deal is possible to be made
and it would benefit Trump more than anyone, but
it would also benefit the Chinese.
It's also speculated that Xi Jinping, sorry, not Xi Jinping,
but Putin wants to speak to Trump about Ukraine,
possibly with China president.
What would China's role be in this particular discussion?
And broadly speaking,
what does China want in regards to the Ukraine war?
Now, on the one hand, some analysts have argued that the Ukraine war
being prolonged is beneficial for China because it keeps the Europeans
and the Americans focused on Russia instead of China.
Or does it become more of a liability now for China
if the war keeps dragging on? What do you
think? I think there's been some truth
that China's benefited from the tension there. I think
Russia, Russia and China historically are not as close
as a lot of Western observers like to think.
You know, there's the two countries really have come together
in the last five to 10 years,
more out of survival.
Rather than actual common interests and common love for each other,
both countries feel that Western Europe under NATO, as well
as the United States, have been trying to not just contain them,
but destabilize them and push for regime overthrow.
So the two countries have come closer together.
And I think the Chinese are scared.
That the Russians are going to get too close to the United States.
And so for them, strategically, it's been really good.
And they've opened their arms up
to welcome the Russians closer to them.
You see that Russia now is really
because of the sanctions don't have Western cars anymore.
So almost all of their cars right now
are NEVs from China, like a BYD.
So the Chinese are really benefiting by exporting to Russia
and having a stronger partnership
with them.
Um, but.
That said, I do think that China has been turned
into a boogeyman by Western Europe out of this.
Because, you know,
You know, the Western Europeans are saying
that the Chinese are supporting
Russia too much. And so they don't want
to do business with the Chinese right now. And so I
think we're starting to reach the point, David,
where the Chinese have been able to squeeze out
all of the benefits from this war.
And it's now time for them to want to end it.
Because they want to be able to have good trade relations
with the Germans, they want to have good trade relations
with the French, because the European bloc still,
even though they're still very strong, when they combine together,
they're almost 20 trillion US dollars a year.
And China needs to have those markets to export their semiconductors,
export their technology, export their everyday items,
you know, like shoes and clothes.
Because the reality is...
They've increased their exports to Southeast Asia
and to Middle East and to Africa, but at the end of the day,
they still need the export markets into Western Europe.
Otherwise, China's economy will stagnate in one
or two years if they can't open up new markets.
Broadly speaking, how would you describe
the relationship now between Russia and China?
What are they partners?
Is China trying to leverage control over Russia in some sense?
Because China's economy in nominal terms right now
is about $21 trillion, and Russia's is $2.8 trillion.
That's 7.5 times larger, and the Cold War is over, Sean.
So what do they want from each other?
I think it's just having two major powers,
one economic that doesn't like to use its
military, one that's a lot weaker economically,
but is willing to use their military, having
the two of them together.
They're clearly not vassals of the Western world.
They're willing to stand on their own politically.
Having these two powerful nations combine their economic
and military strength provides
a bulwark of defense against Western imperialism.
I would categorize them as really good relations right now.
Um, there,
Again, it historically didn't have to be this way.
There wasn't a lot of trust between
the two countries even 10 years ago.
But clearly, after the last three, four years,
there's a lot of love between the two countries.
You always see Wang Yi, the foreign minister of China, and Lavrov,
the foreign minister of Russia, come together as old friends.
They say really nice words to each other.
That's signaling the populations of both countries that Russia
and China really are as close as can be.
It's certainly the closest in my lifetime, and I'm almost 50 years old.
Again, it didn't have to happen this way.
I think there was a strategic mistake from Biden
to push the two countries close together.
And when you look at history
and you look at the warnings from Kissinger and a lot of
the great foreign policy stalwarts in America over the last 70 years,
they said having Russia
and China come close together
was not a good thing for American interests.
And that's what you're starting to see now,
because, again, they have the military power.
And willingness to use under Russia
and the economic power under the Chinese combined.
And that makes them chip away at American prestige and power.
Let's take a deep dive into China's economy itself.
So PMI in October came in at 49.3.
That's in contraction, Terry.
That's because it's under 50.
Now, we previously discussed a slowdown in Chinese growth.
The latest numbers, what are you looking
at to give you an indication of whether or not
growth is picking up or continuing to slow down?
You're starting to see CPI
is slightly turning positive. It's still under 1%.
It was kind of interesting.
This morning, I was walking on Nanjing Road,
which is one of the main streets in Shanghai,
and they had a giant electric billboard up
showing the CPI numbers, and they were showing that it was positive.
It's clear that the Chinese
government is trying to push that story to the Chinese consumer that
You know what? Inflation is slowly crawling back.
You better go out and spend because a lot of
Chinese think that prices are going to come down.
So they're not buying big ticket items like cars
and houses because they think that car prices
are going to continue to come down. So the government
is really trying to put a stop to what we call involution
or price cutting and is really trying
to push that story of inflation. Now, the economy is still weak.
Um, you're seeing that the middle class are cutting back.
They're really concerned, um, about income.
They're concerned about real estate.
They will buy things if they see value.
Again, I, I threw out a couple of names like on shoes,
Adidas, Asics, um, Ralph Lauren.
They're doing very well right now
on the multinational side, expanding in China.
Um, some of the Chinese companies
or Japanese companies that are doing well are like Muji,
Uniqlo.
Bosideng, Lao Pu is doing all right.
So these companies are doing well.
So there's still some good, maybe five,
10 companies that retail investors should think
about looking at on the consumer side.
But the bigger issue is in the last two, three weeks,
we've seen a slight cratering of confidence
from the wealthy 10%.
The government has put forward trusts.
where a lot of Chinese held their money overseas.
And basically, it was a gray area whether or not
they needed to pay taxes.
Well, the Chinese government in October said, there's a deadline,
you got to pay your taxes.
So we've been talking with wealthy billionaire type Chinese. And we've
been talking with private wealth managers to the tycoons.
And they're saying that huge checks
are pushing the wealthiest Chinese to pay
Taxes back to the Chinese government
because the Chinese government has run out of cash and tax
revenue. So they're going after the wealthy.
Now, I don't think that's actually going to impact
Spending that much, because if you're worth $5 billion
and you have to write a couple hundred
million dollar check, you still have billions of dollars to go out
and spend. And that's why
the Richemonts are doing well.
Cartier, Van Cleef and Arpels are selling very well. And the high end
watches because the Chinese are still spending at the high end.
But what is happening is one
of the reasons why the equity markets are down
is a lot of wealthy Chinese had to sell
shares in the companies that they control in order
to pay back their tax. And that's another
reason why I think you've seen in the last couple of weeks,
a stronger sell-off in the equity
markets. Now that tax has been paid,
I don't think you're going to see people selling off as quickly
as before. Interesting. Wait, but back up a minute,
Sean, did you just say that the Chinese
The Chinese government is running out of cash and tax revenue.
You have to think about it.
Over the last four years, there hasn't been that much profits in China.
It stems down from the 2022 lockdowns. I'm in my house right now.
I was locked here for almost three months. There was a time
when 400 million Chinese were locked down in their homes.
No business took place.
If no business takes place, there's no revenue tax.
There's certainly no profit tax.
And so you see a lot of local governments have run out of money.
So in Hunan province, a lot of the public or not a lot,
but some of the cities have
had to stop running their public buses
because they're unable to pay for their drivers.
You see that Guiyang in Guizhou province, you know, is overbuilt.
They went from one of the poorest provinces
To one of the most beautifully built up provinces by buildings,
but there isn't much tax revenue
taking place there, especially as Maotai,
the white alcohol maker, which is the biggest
tax, I think it's the biggest tax payer in that province.
They're not making profits right now.
Their sales are way, way down as people don't have
the money to buy Maotai alcohol.
So local governments are hurting right now.
And that's why the government...
is looking everywhere to squeeze out whatever they can
from a tax standpoint.
So two years ago, David,
the problem was local governments would go to wealthy tycoons
and say, 20 years ago, you did something illegal.
So if you pay us a fine of, say, $50 million, we'll let you out.
If not, we're going to hold you for six
to 12 months until you pay your fine.
That created a lot of fear amongst wealthy Chinese.
So they all just fled the country and went low profile
because they're worried about being seen
as rich and then be grabbed by local governments to pay this fine.
The central government has put
a stop to that, which is a good thing.
But they're now saying, well, actually, it's true.
You all didn't pay your taxes. So they're launching formal.
Proper investigations into wealthy people
and saying you need to pay your taxes.
It's much better than the quasi kidnappings of 2023 and 2024,
really by the northeastern
governments, Dongbei governments coming down
into places like Zhejiang and Shanghai and
Beijing and grabbing wealthy tycoons.
Now this is more central government led tax bureau investigations
because there's just
No profits here, right?
If investors are scared about investing in China
because there aren't enough profits,
you have to deduce that means there's
no profits to pay the government in tax.
And that's why the local authorities are cutting back on,
you know, banqueting.
So that's, they're saying that officials can't go out
and eat out in restaurants,
spend money on alcohol, which is hurting the high-end hotel
and catering businesses.
It's like a cyclical effect right now.
But third quarter GDP was 4.5%, right?
That was pretty strong.
How do you reconcile pretty strong headline GDP numbers
with exactly what you just described,
coupled with weaker retail demand that you just talked about?
Yeah. So I think what it is,
is the exporters especially are doing very well right now.
You're seeing a $1 trillion,
$1.2 trillion trade deficit with the rest of the world.
So when you talk to companies, even restaurants,
and they say business is terrible,
like we're really hurting. But you ask them, did you grow?
And they say, yeah, we grew.
But they're only growing, you know, 2%, 5%, 10%.
For them, that doesn't seem like a lot.
Why?
Because from 2000 until 2017,
they were growing 50%, 200% a year.
I remember I run a consulting firm
and our clients in the 2010s wanted to have 200% growth
every year.
If I told them that I think it was possible to get 50%,
my clients would get mad at me
Because I'd say 50%
It was way too low because they were getting pressure
from Western headquarters for China
to be the major growth driver for their organizations.
Now, if you're getting 5%, 10% growth,
then the China teams are really happy.
Most of my clients are getting above that,
but it still just seems very slow to just
10 years ago when people were expecting 200% growth.
Now, on the personal side, look, I've got...
20, 30 friends who are making $200,
$300 a month in the 1990s who are now billionaires.
People were getting 200%, 300%, 1,000%,
10,000% growth on their income earnings every year.
And then all of a sudden now they're only getting 2% or 5%.
It's still more.
I do believe 4% or 5% GDP is actually realistic.
I don't think it's a completely made-up number.
But it seems really, really slow from what it was five,
10 years ago when people could
triple or quadruple their net worth every year.
Okay, you know what, just since you brought that up,
based on not just research, but your personal experience witnessing
the rise of wealth in your circle and other people around them,
what are or what were some of the biggest contributors
of creating the most millionaires in the history of mankind
and billionaires in such a short period of time?
So I think there's two things that really created a lot of this wealth.
The first was real estate.
Um, you know, I, I've got a lot of friends
who built up great companies that went public
companies that you've heard of and they made good money out of it,
but they actually made
more money with their real estate investments.
So I'll give an example, a house that I lived in, I rented it.
I didn't buy it.
Unfortunately.
Um, you know, I, I lived in it.
You could have purchased it for about 400,000 US.
Five years later,
that very apartment was selling for 10 million U.S. dollars.
Wow.
So I've got friends who bought 100, 200 apartments,
you know, and they might have spent.
You know, $20 million buying them,
and then they ended up with a net worth of $500 million
when the real estate was at its highest.
Now these prices have dropped 30% to 50%,
so now they're still worth $100 million, $200 million.
So they're okay, but they don't feel happy.
And this was clearly a one-time-off wealth creation event.
So they're not going out and spending right now.
They're preserving.
It's not like in the United States where you see a Mark Zuckerberg
or an Elon Musk, their
numbers or their wealth continues to go up
because of their core investment in their
companies, which could continue to grow, right?
Tesla keeps reinvesting or reinventing itself.
Is it a car company?
Is it an autonomous driving company?
Is it a robot company?
Is it Starlink?
Whatever it is, you're making money off that.
In China, so much wealth was based off of real estate,
and that's a one-time affair.
You're never going to see
the real estate markets grow like they did 25 years ago in
China.
It's impossible, okay?
It's never in the history in the world did you go
from such a low base to such a high
base.
Corrected 30% to 50%, like you said.
Has that changed those wealthy investors' appetites
for investing in, I guess, real
estate?
abroad, outside of China.
In other words, okay, China's been in a terrible market.
Will they start looking elsewhere?
Or will they start preserving capital just as a mentality?
So they're trying to invest elsewhere.
The problem is big capital controls. It's hard
for them to get money out.
That's why, you know, Chinese were buying Bitcoin previously.
The government has really cracked down on capital outflows.
But like I yesterday,
Yesterday, I met with a mini tycoon.
Who basically, you're allowed to transfer 50,000 US dollars
per person per year to the overseas.
And so whenever he makes investments overseas,
he tries to get his whole village.
He'll get 20, 50,
100 friends every year to remit 50,000 US dollars overseas for him
so he can go out and make investments.
So that's something that they do.
But the second thing, David,
a lot of the wealth creation came from corruption.
You know, people had a brother or a father
or son who was in the Chinese government and they would just get deals.
You know, I remember one guy I talked to said to me,
I control all of the Australian wine.
being sold to police offices
because his wife's father was a fairly senior official in the police
force. And so he was able to get a deal
that all Australian wine had to go through him.
So they get rich, right?
You know, 25 years ago, every police station, if they wanted to
buy wine, and a lot of them did,
that would have to go through that family.
pure corruption. And that's why so many officials
and so many businessmen have rightly been arrested
during the Xi Jinping administration,
because there was it was just unfair. It was just pure,
pure corruption. You know, I'll give another example of a guy,
Desmond Shum. He wrote the
book Red Roulette. You know, he's been tweeting about me lately.
So I met him in 2003.
And he said, Sean, you know,
you've got better connections in China than I do.
I represent a big government family in China.
And I'll let you all, the audience, I don't want to use the name.
They can go do a search for what Desmond's wife got arrested for.
And he goes, you have better connections in China than I do.
Let's open nightclubs together and you can provide the protection.
And I bring in this political family as our backing and support.
You know,
So this family was ended up worth billions,
I think, you know, and Desmond's wife got arrested
or got into trouble. The New York Times wrote about it.
And Desmond fled the market and wrote
a whole book called Red Roulette.
And he's been tweeting about me lately. So I hope the audience
goes takes a look at what Desmond's talking about.
But it's pure corruption. Now, I don't
want to say he's corrupt because I don't want a libel lawsuit.
But there was it was all about
Connections in those days.
So you're not opening up a nightclub anytime soon.
Is that what you're saying?
Ha ha ha ha ha!
I'm a consultant.
Okay, that's too bad.
You know, I'm not a rich man, David,
because my wife and I, 25 years ago, said...
We think at some point the Chinese
government will crack down on corruption.
So we don't want to do anything corrupt
because we want to be able to sleep at night.
You know, I'm almost 50, but some people tell me I look younger than
that because I sleep about nine hours a night
because I don't have to worry.
And that's why I do consulting for American and European companies,
because it's like the least corrupt business that I can do here.
Yeah, you're doing quite well for yourself.
I think you're just being humble. But anyway,
let's talk about the bond market in China before we close off.
The bond market in China is extraordinary compared to the rest
of the world. And I'm going to pull up my screen here just
to show you what I'm talking about. As you're aware,
across Europe and the Americas, bond yields have been soaring.
The French bond, 10-year bond is now higher than Greece's.
And the 10-year yield in the U.S., although it's pulled back somewhat
in the last couple of weeks, is still very high relative to a year ago.
Take a look now at China's.
It's not only not gone that way, it's now slipped to a record low.
What is it about Chinese monetary policy
or perhaps even fiscal policy that made it a haven?
What happened here?
So I'm not an expert on bonds,
but I can talk about interest rates and time deposits.
I think the reality, David, is the banks are hungry to loan out money.
They're looking for clients to give money
to because they've got a lot of cash on hand,
right? Chinese are sitting on 20 trillion US dollars
of household savings. They're not going
to put it into real estate.
They're scared about the equity markets. And so they're putting it
into insurance products
and they're putting it into time deposits. And the reality is,
is if you are facing deflation of two, 3% over the last
five years every year, and you're getting 1%,
that's actually not bad. And then again,
for those rich people, you know,
they were just looking for wealth preservation. And so they would
just stick money into these time deposits for 1%.
The the state owned banks are trying to loan money
out. But the reality is, nobody's willing to borrow money.
And that's why like interest rates
And a loosening monetary policy is not the...
strategy for the Chinese government to jumpstart the economy.
You can lower interest rates. But
if people don't think that there's a way to allocate
and deploy the money, they're not going
to take out the loans. And that's why the yields
on bonds are so low in China right now, because
just nobody wants them.
That's the big issue that's going on in the markets right now.
Okay, good point. By the way,
people here in the West would love deflation. I see this in the
comments all the time. I am flooded with these comments.
We would love to see prices come down.
You've lived through deflation currently in China.
Tell us about that experience.
Is that something people should aspire to have?
Look, you don't want deflation, but you also don't want inflation.
You want to have 2%, 3% inflation,
because when you're in a deflationary environment,
nobody spends.
Everybody's waiting for the next discount.
So no money's happening.
I would say that China right now is not an electric place to live.
People aren't, they don't have the animal spirits,
they're not going out and spending
money starting new companies, but it's a very pleasant place to live.
So deflation is good if you have money,
because everything's cheap, you have a good quality
of life, you almost feel like you're retired.
And a lot of my friends, we all joke about it,
like China is the best place in the world
to retire to.
So the hope is you make money in the US.
Where there's inflationary forces,
so your money goes up, and then you spend it in China.
But I think you don't want to have a deflationary period.
There's stagnation, there's anxiety, there's depression.
Things just don't get going.
But you also don't want to have the inflation
that's happening in the United States.
You know, as I mentioned, I was just there last week.
I spent a couple months in the U.S. actually this year
and last year, the longest in the
last 30 years.
And I talked to a lot of Americans.
I talked with a woman who is a school teacher.
She worked full-time as a school teacher.
And then afterwards,
she worked in a high-end residential building as a concierge for seven
hours.
And then after that, she would drive a Lyft or an Uber.
So she was doing three jobs a day.
I spoke with another person.
He worked for a major airline company, full-time job.
But before he went to the airline airport,
he would drive for three to five hours from
four to eight in the morning.
Go to his job.
And then he would drive for another three to four hours after he left.
So he's working from four to about nine every day driving
because he had to pay for his
daughter's education and his daughter's rent,
who is in university in Houston.
So one of the problems, David,
is the Americans are getting crushed by inflation.
And that's why they voted against Trump.
I mean, it's about affordability.
And the best way to solve this?
is to have an end of the trade war
and have the United States and China work together again.
That would put an immediate end to the inflation in the US
if Chinese were able to export BYD and Xiaomi and NIO cars.
And the Chinese would put an end to the deflation
if they felt that there's ways to make money in investing here.
It's clear that the world is all hurting
from the American Sinophobia and trade war against China.
It's not rocket science.
It's basic tariffs, which we should have learned from Smoot-Hawley.
But somehow American economists like Paul Krugman.
Government officials like Trump have forgotten Economics 101.
And, you know, Krugman should just shut up.
I have to call him out because he's been saying
that you need to have protectionism
and you need to have tariffs against the Chinese.
And he should be ashamed of himself
as a former New York Times columnist,
as a Nobel Prize winner.
He is hurting the American economy.
I think you're looking for more tweets to tag you, Sean.
All right, Krugman, if you're watching this,
please, you know, at Sean Wright.
I'm kidding.
All right, my final question,
I want to come full circle to the tech stocks in China.
Earlier in the summer and as well as in the fall,
the KOSPI index in Korea fell on the fears
that the Chinese chips were catching up and are cheaper.
My question is simply, where do Chinese chips stand or sit?
In terms of positioning, because you read headlines like this that says
Kospi down 6-5% as China's CXMT, which is a chip maker in China.
Advance hits Samsung and SK Hynix.
And then I see...
News from writers like this that says, oh,
actually, CXMT's performance is closer to
SK Hynix's previous generation chips.
They're generations behind.
And if you look at the yield, which
is the number of chips that are usable that come
off the line, they're about 20% to 30% compared
with yields of 70% at South Korea's SK Hynix.
So do you have any knowledge of this?
Where China is positioned.
Yeah, go ahead.
What I would say is China,
because Biden and Trump has weaponized technology over the last
10 years, China will never buy.
South Korean, Japanese, European, or American chips,
memory chips, semiconductors, they'll
never rely on foreign technology into their supply chain.
It doesn't matter if CXMT is one generation
or two generations behind SK Hynix or Samsung.
It doesn't matter if Cambricon or Hua Hong is behind NVIDIA.
It doesn't matter if they're behind ASML.
As soon as possible.
They're going to de-risk from the rest
of the world by focusing on indigenous innovation.
That's why, to me, the question of quality
and innovation doesn't matter.
The Chinese will only buy the Chinese.
The reality is that CXMT, they're full.
They're at capacity right now,
and that capacity is going into Chinese companies and some other
companies into the global majority.
So I am not worried about SK Hynix.
I'm not worried about Samsung
from Chinese overtaking them anytime soon.
Maybe five years from now,
when the Chinese build up their capacity, they're going to
be able to export into Malaysia or Indonesia or Saudi Arabia.
And be able to knock off Samsung or SK Hynix there.
That's possible, but not in the short term.
But here's the next thing, David,
is I don't foresee a situation where the Americans or
the Europeans are ever going to trust Chinese in the supply chain.
And so they're never going to buy CXMT in a major way.
They're going to keep buying from the South Koreans
because the South Koreans
are very close allies militarily with the Americans.
So what I would say to investors is if you believe in AI.
And you believe in that story.
You should be backing the Americans, the Koreans, and the Chinese.
It's not a either or.
All sides are going to rise up in the boat together
as water fills up and goes up.
SK Hynix will not be defeated by the Chinese,
and the Chinese will not be defeated by the Koreans.
They'll both do very well because of the geopolitical split.
Thank you, Sean. Great interview.
Where do we follow you? And tell us about your new book.
Thank you, David. I hope readers can read my book,
The Split, Finding the Opportunities in
China's Economy and the New World Order, published by Hachette.
That will give a good blueprint of
where you should be investing over the next three to five year period.
And you can also find me
sometimes on Twitter. Okay. He's quite active on Twitter.
So I'll put the link down below.
People should check out Sean's book as well as his social media.
Thank you, Sean.
We'll speak again soon.
Take care for now.
Thanks, David.
Thank you for watching.
Please do like, subscribe.