Charlemagne’S Grandsons Lost Everything - Birth Of France

The Origins
17 followers
Jul 1, 2026
AI Generated·May contain errors
It is the 3rd of July, 987. In the Cathedral of Rheims, Archbishop Adalbero anoints the head of
the King of the Franks with the holy oil once used to crown Clovis, the first Catholic King
of Francia. Kneeling before the Archbishop is Hugo Capet. With this ceremony, the reign of
the Carolingians in the western part of Charlemagne's empire finally comes to an end.
The descendants of the Capetian dynasty, founded by Hugo Capet, would go on to rule what would
become the Kingdom of France, with some interruptions, until the 19th century,
while other branches of the family would ascend to the thrones of many kingdoms throughout Europe,
such as Sicily, Naples, Hungary, Poland, Spain and Portugal. Yet, every great success story
has humble beginnings. In this video, we will trace the modest rise of the House of Capet,
or the Robertians, and explain how this family secured one of the most prestigious thrones of
the former Frankish Empire. To do so, we must examine the political developments in West
Francia during the 9th and 10th centuries, and follow the gradual ascent of the Capetians,
who rose to power as loyal servants and eventual rivals of the last Carolingian kings.
Before we begin, it is important to note that both modern research and
national historiographical traditions make this topic highly complex.
Naturally, what now follows can only scratch the surface of the fascinating and turbulent
late Carolingian world. Like his father Charlemagne before him, Emperor Louis the Pious
attempted to preserve the unity of the Carolingian Empire, defying older Frankish
traditions of partable inheritance, in which a realm was divided between the ruler's sons.
According to Louis' wishes, his eldest son, Lothar, was to serve as co-emperor and principal
heir, while his younger brothers would rule autonomous sub-kingdoms that owed fealty to
Lothar. Thus, formally, the Empire would remain united under the Carolingians. In practice,
none of Louis' sons were satisfied with this arrangement. Beginning in 830, Emperor Louis
faced repeated rebellions by his sons and discontented nobles. When he died in 840,
the Carolingian Empire descended into open civil war, as each heir sought to secure and expand
his share of the inheritance. The conflict shook the foundations of imperial authority,
and exposed deep structural weaknesses within the Frankish state. In 843, the Treaty of Verdun
formally divided the Empire between the three surviving sons. Louis the German received the
Eastern Lands, Lothar the Middle Kingdom, and Charles the Bold the Western portion.
A second treaty in 870 reinforced the East-West divide, while the Kingdom of Italy emerged as a
separate entity. Over time, repeated partitions created as many as six Carolingian kingdoms,
each ruled by a different branch of the dynasty. Historians point to a variety of causes for the
Empire's long decline. In simplified terms, the division of the Empire meant the division of land,
wealth, and authority. Kings increasingly depended on the loyalty of powerful magnates,
which they secured by granting permanent lands, offices, and rights. At the same time,
all Carolingian realms faced relentless external pressure. Viking, Slavic, Muslim,
and later Magyar raids devastated the kingdoms and drained royal resources. These pressures
transformed how the Empire was governed. Under Charlemagne and Louis the Pious,
royal authority strove for a centralized system that closely supervised key regions
and appointed officials, who ensured the enforcement of royal rule and decrees.
But this system did not survive the civil wars and external pressures that bore down upon the
Empire after Louis' death. The mechanisms for raising troops and administering justice
gradually collapsed, and control over distant regions was delegated to local elites.
Late Carolingian kings found it increasingly difficult to intervene in local affairs.
In response, nobles demanded high rewards for their support. Counties, abbeys, and churches
passed from royal control into the hands of powerful families. Even royal officials,
such as the Counts and Misi Dominici, began prioritizing their own local interests.
Cultural, linguistic, and legal differences between the emerging kingdoms and sub-kingdoms
further encouraged fragmentation and fostered strong regional identities.
Beginning in the late 9th and fully in the 10th centuries, West Francia increasingly
resembled a realm dominated by powerful princes rather than the centralized kingdom that Charlemagne
might have hoped to establish. Yet the consecrated Carolingian king remained a crucial, symbolic
figure. Authority still flowed, at least nominally, from the crown, and magnates derived legitimacy
from royal appointment. At the same time, the late Carolingian period saw a renewed mobility
among the aristocracy. Noble families moved between the emerging kingdoms in search of opportunity,
refuge, or advantage. One such family would later become known as the Robertians,
the ancestors of the Capetians. The Robertians likely originated in East Francia, with early
influence around the city of Worms. It is possible that they even had family ties to the Carolingian
main branch, but nothing hard can be said in that regard. After falling out of favor with East
Francian king Louis the German, the family appears to have moved westward into the West Frankish
Empire. Their first prominent figure of that family to make his renown was Robert the Strong,
who emerged in the sources in 852, when King Charles the Bold granted him several abbeys
and royal offices. Despite rebelling against the king in 858, Robert regained royal trust,
and in 861 was appointed military commander of the March of Neustria.
He received the counties of Anjou, Torain, and Blois. Over the next decade, Robert proved
himself a capable defender against Viking raids and became a pillar of West Frankish defense.
Before his death fighting the Vikings at the Battle of Brissac in 866, he had expanded his
influence into Burgundy and acquired lands in Maine, Anjou, and Tours. However, these holdings
were not yet hereditary. After Robert's death, many of his offices and lands were redistributed
by the crown. Still, he had established his family as a major force in West Francia.
Robert's son, Odo, continued this rise. He assumed control of the county of Paris in 882,
and soon gained fame during the Great Viking Siege of the city in 885. Odo successfully held Paris
until Emperor Charles the Fat arrived in 886 and negotiated the Vikings' departure through tribute,
a well-established Carolingian strategy. In recognition of his valiant defense of Paris,
Odo was rewarded with offices and counties his father had once held.
Control over key territories near Orleans and the Abbey of Saint-Martin-of-Tours
made him one of the most powerful magnates in the kingdom. As with his father before him,
his rise was driven not by rebellion but by loyal service to the crown.
But a turning point came in 888, when Charles the Fat died childless after being deposed of his crown
under pressure from Arnulf of Carinthia, who was crowned ruler of East Francia by its nobles.
With Arnulf focused on his own eastern realm, Odo was elected King of West Francia,
the first non-Carolingian to hold the throne. Despite his coronation, Odo faced the same
structural limits as his Carolingian predecessors. His real power was confined largely to his own
lands, and he depended on the cooperation of other princes. To secure his position,
he acknowledged Arnulf of Carinthia as his superior. Odo did achieve further military
successes against the Vikings, further legitimizing his rule, though often at great personal risk.
His brother Robert became one of his chief supporters, receiving the March of Neustria,
multiple counties and numerous abbeys as lay abbot. This concentration of ecclesiastical
wealth became a defining feature of Robertian power and alarmed other magnates.
Yet the Carolingian line was not extinguished. Charles the Simple, the posthumous son of Louis
the Stammerer, had been passed over due to his youth. Educated under Archbishop Fulk of Rhymes,
Charles became the figurehead of an opposition movement when Odo clashed with the Counts of
Flanders in the early 890s. After years of conflict, a compromise was reached in 895.
Charles received the city of Lyon and recognition as heir to the kingdom of West Francia.
When Odo died childless in 898, his brother Robert honored the agreement and supported
Charles' accession to the West Frankish crown. In return, Charles confirmed Robert's offices
and, crucially, allowed him to pass them on to his son, making a first step in making them
fully hereditary and separating them from royal approval. As with the other late Carolingian
rulers, Charles the Simple also struggled to control the realm, lacking royal possessions
and other assets. Meanwhile, Robert remained loyal and successfully fought the Vikings,
remaining an important asset of Carolingian rule. Most prominently, Robert defeated the
Viking leader Rollo in 911, who was then granted the county of Rouen, laying the foundation for
the famous Duchy of Normandy, whose Ducal line would conquer Anglo-Saxon England some 150 years
later. Despite Robert's loyal service to the West Frankish crown, tensions between the mighty
magnate and the king eventually emerged. The relationship between them finally collapsed in
921, when Charles favored a courtier named Hagano, whom the West Frankish nobility viewed as an
upstart outsider. At an assembly, Charles publicly, symbolically elevated Hagano to Robert's level,
by placing him on his left, provoking outrage. Robert joined the opposition and was crowned
Anti-King in 923. War erupted, and although Robert's forces prevailed, he himself was killed
in battle. Charles was captured by Heribert II of Vermondois, sidelined and used as political
leverage, while a third party compromise candidate, Rudolf of Burgundy, was elected king.
Robert's son, Hugh the Great, inherited his vast territories stretching from the Loire to the Seine,
along with numerous abbeys. Despite his power, Hugh declined the crown, recognizing that great
power in one's own vast possessions did not guarantee that one could prevail against the
other magnates and princes or count on their support once crowned king. Hugh retained his
holdings and gained even more influence, eventually controlling most of Noistria. Meanwhile, Rudolf of
Burgundy was a weak king, with his reign marked by external threats and internal instability.
He died childless in 935. Hugh then invited the young Louis IV of the Carolingian family
to take the throne in 936. This Louis was known as Doutremer, as he had, in his youth,
gone into exile in England with his mother. Hugh supported his coronation and was rewarded with the
title Duke of the Franks. Soon, however, rivalry emerged. Louis sought to curb Hugh's power,
while Hugh allied himself with Otto the Great of East Francia, marrying Otto's sister Hadwig.
In 938, Louis and his noble supporters found themselves in direct opposition to the
Robertians and their growing power. As his first and most important project, the king now sought
to win Lotharingen, to establish a new Carolingian power base there. However, this made Otto the
By 940, the attempt to conquer Lotharingen, alongside rebellious dukes, had achieved the
opposite of what had been hoped for. Instead of a new power base, Louis found his enemies
united against him, and Otto's troops invaded West Francia. It was only Louis' marriage to
Cabergeon, another sister of Otto, that saved the situation from utter disaster.
The conflict between Hugh and his king continued to drag on, with shifting alliances culminating in
the Great Magnate's excommunication in 947 and 948. Under pressure from the Church, Louis IV and
Otto the Great, who now intervened to support Louis, Hugh finally submitted to his king and
paid him homage in 953. After long struggles, Louis finally had his own center of power within
the fortress of Lyon and the city of Rheims, and had asserted his position against the magnates,
mostly by pitting them against each other, but by the late summer 954, the king died.
Louis' son, Lothar, came to power largely through the efforts of his mother, Cabergeon.
She enlisted the help of her brothers, Otto the Great and Bruno, the Archbishop of Cologne.
The latter was to serve as regent for Lothar until his own death in 965, and ruled the West
Frankish Empire in accordance with Otto I's wishes. So, once again, the greatest magnate of
West Frankia refrained from reaching for the crown himself. Once again, Hugh supported Lothar,
a young king, and was rewarded for it. Burgundy and Aquitaine were given to him before he died
of illness in Dordogne in 956, leaving behind three sons. After Hugh's death, the reversion's
suddenly became unclear. Hugh's eldest son, Hugo Capet, inherited his father's position
and retained power over the family's core possessions. However, the king extended his
status as a minor, thus not granting him control of key possessions and titles.
Some of Hugo Capet's subordinate nobles did not recognize the rule of their rightful overlord,
while others came into conflict with each other. It was not until 960 that King Lothar allowed
Hugo Capet to fully assume his father's inheritance. He was appointed Duke of the
Franks and Margrave of Neustria, but on condition that he recognize the independence of the local
counts. Furthermore, the king gave the parts of the Kingdom of Burgundy that the reversions had
acquired to Hugo's brother after Hugo Capet and King Lothar together fought against rebellious
nobles in that region. But King Lothar himself found himself increasingly under the control of
Otonians. It was not until the death of Otto the Great in 973 that Lothar had the opportunity to
break out and began to bring Lorraine back under the influence of Western Francia. This led to open
war between East and West in 978. Hugo Capet supported his king in the conflict because his
family had interests in the region that were threatened by Otonian initiatives. In a coup,
Lothar succeeded in occupying Aachen, the capital of the Eastern Empire, and plundering it for five
days. The King of the West Franks turned Charlemagne's eagle, housed in the palace,
to face East as a symbolic insult to Otto II. The East struck back fast and hard. Otto's troops
invaded West Francia without encountering much resistance, plundering the country and revealing
Lothar's weak position within his realm. Otto II then installed his cousin, Charles, Lothar's
brother, as anti-king in West Francia and began besieging Paris. The siege was eventually brought
to an end by illness, the approaching winter, and a relief army led by Hugo Capet. Otto II withdrew
and suffered most of the losses of this campaign when his rearguard faced a difficult river crossing
and was attacked by Hugo Capet's army. Following his great victory over Emperor Otto, Hugo was the
hero of the day and could use that victory to secure his position within the realm.
Perhaps in the wake of that catastrophic campaign, Lothar installed his son, Louis V,
as co-king and successor to the throne of West Francia in 979. This move was supported by Hugo
Capet, most likely as he anticipated gaining control over the new king from his position of
power early on. But Lothar, on the other hand, could clearly see that Hugo was a threat to his rule
and tried to secure himself against the Capet's ambitions by setting aside his differences with
Otto II. In 980, the West Frankish king married his 15-year-old son Louis to Adelheid of Anjou
without consulting Hugo Capet, bringing her possessions under royal control and thus
pincering the possessions of the Robertians. However, as Adelheid was in her forties,
the marriage was not to last long. Just two years later, she separated from her teenage husband.
But another opportunity opened for Lothar when Otto II died young in 983 while in Italy. His
son, Otto III, was a minor of 7 years under the guidance of his mother Theophany and his
grandmother Adelheid. The Ottonian realm was plunged into further insecurity when other
parties kidnapped the young Otto. Lothar wanted to gain from this situation and tried to bring
parts of Lotharingia under West Frankish control. Hugo Capet also saw the situation as an opportunity
and began to improve his relations with the Ottonians by supporting both empresses against
claims from other candidates on the Ottonian throne. In 985, Lothar tried to capture Upper
Lotharingia by force with some success, but Hugo did not support his king, remaining steady on his
own pro-Ottonian cause. As Lothar could not begin an open conflict with Hugo, the struggle against
the Ottonians raged on, again showing the limits of the late Carolingian dynasty's power.
Lothar died suddenly the next year and his son Louis did not survive him all too long.
With his sudden death on the 22nd of May 987 in a hunting accident, the last Carolingian on the
West Frankish throne died. But within this short rule, Hugo laid bare the power structure in the
West Frankish kingdom, when he intervened in the trial against Archbishop Adalbero of Rhines,
who was accused of high treason in 986 for being a loyal supporter of Ottonian interests in West
Francia. The assembly at Compiègne, which was to decide on the archbishop, was dissolved when Hugo
appeared with a host of soldiers. Unsurprisingly, the archbishop proposed, with the support of a
cadre of other nobles, that Hugo Capet should succeed Louis as the king of West Francia.
The imperial Ottonians found him a viable option, because he was a relative and supporter of theirs.
A meeting was convened in Saint-Lys, where Hugo was elected. Only Charles of Lorraine emerged as
an opponent for the crown. However, Charles had few supporters among the West Frankish nobility,
the clergy, or the Ottonians. He had alienated them all in the past. When he invoked his right
of inheritance, Archbishop Adalbero publicly opposed this candidate in a speech. He called
Charles a troublemaker, without honour, faith, or character. Furthermore, he had married below
his station. If the West Franks wanted an era of prosperity, they should place the crown on Hugo,
the illustrious Duke of the Franks. Just a half year later, his son was crowned co-ruler,
laying the foundations of a new dynasty. As we have seen, the rise of the Capetians
was not the result of a sudden power grab, but a slow and careful accumulation of influence
and power, but in the end, still far from a position of hegemony. For decades, the crown
passed between Carolingians and Robertians as legitimacy, compromise, and pragmatism
shaped political decisions. In the end, Hugo Capet prevailed not because he was overwhelmingly
powerful, but because no major faction stood firmly against him. From these modest beginnings,
the Capetian dynasty would shape France's future for centuries to come.
More videos on the Frankish kings who shaped the destiny of medieval Europe are on the way.
If you don't want to miss that and many other historical videos, make sure you're subscribed
and have pressed the bell button to see them. Please consider liking, subscribing, commenting,
and sharing, it helps immensely. Recently, we've started releasing weekly Patreon and
YouTube member exclusive content. Consider joining their ranks via the link in the description
or button under the video. To watch these weekly videos, learn about our schedule,
get early access to our videos, access our private Discord, and much more.
This is the Kings and Generals channel, and we'll catch you on the next one.
