Brad Pitt DENIED!? Angelina Jolie’s Lawyer Accuses Him of HARASSMENT!? Lawyer Reacts

Angelina Jolie
5 followers
2 Video Views·Oct 11, 2026
AI Generated·May contain errors
Brad Pitt denied. Is Angelina Jolie actually winning? No. Turns out she's not.
We got Christopher Melcher to break down what's actually happening.
Welcome to Popcorn Planet. I am Andy Signor.
So glad to have my friend Christopher Melcher back. How you doing, sir?
Oh, I'm doing great. On a little bit of a road trip here for work,
but very happy to join. Always appreciate you making time,
and I love our continuing chapters of the Angelina Jolie Brad Pitt saga.
For longtime fans, Chris and I have been covering this now for years.
It feels like it's been going on, but there's been this latest update,
which is in the media, is spinning this as a win for Angelina
with Brad getting denied this sort of harassing a request for documents
and how dare he sort of request her financial records during a certain period over
this battle for Chateau Miraval, the wine company that we've discussed at length.
So, Chris, you describe it better. What's actually happening here? Can you?
We have the documents. We what's going on? Can you break it down for the viewers?
Sure. So, yeah, you have up on the screen.
This is called a minute order from the Los Angeles Superior Court.
This is the ruling on this request for information
that Brad Pitt made against Angelina Angelina Jolie.
Sorry, and ultimately, the court found that Brad was justified
in seeking this information, but that the information wasn't relevant
because Angelina Jolie made concessions during this process.
So, during this dispute over the documents, Angelina said, "You know what?
I'm not going to make these other claims that I was making before, and therefore
my income records aren't relevant." So, I can unpack this really quickly.
So, for everyone who's not totally familiar, the these couple owned a winery
and chateau in France, makes this wine called Miraval. And when they broke up,
Brad Pitt offered to purchase Angelina Jolie's interest in the winery and chateau.
She rejected it. Did not make a counteroffer.
And I think that's significant. She just said she didn't even.
I don't think responded, and instead, which sold,
which is so key because if you didn't want to continue fighting with him,
that was the opportunity to just end it there. But she chose to what, Chris?
She chose to sell her interest to this Russian oligarch who has an interest
in Stollie. I think he's you know this company based in Luxembourg,
but sold it to somebody who's a complete stranger to Brad Pitt.
Basically, then putting this other.
Person.
As an involuntary partner with Brad Pitt into this chateau,
which and winery business, which was for sure going to lead to a fight.
Again, rather than just negotiating for a higher price,
if she says that the price that she was offered by Brad was too low,
or they could have done a dispute resolution process to submit
this to a neutral decision maker to make a binding determination of value.
So there were many decent pathways open to her that could have resolved
this much easier than what she did, which was a guaranteed fight,
because no one is going to want to have somebody co-own their home
and business with somebody they don't know.
It's guaranteed to be a fight. So this was a poison move by her.
Now, so now what's going on with this document dispute?
So during this whole dispute,
Angelina Jolie gave several justifications for why she did this.
She said, "Look, I put my career on hold."
You know, and was not making that much money.
You know, the implication is I had to sell this.
She also said that Brad used this Miraval business and the profits
from it as leverage over her by withholding this money from her.
Again, implication is I had to sell and.
So she she was making all of these allegations that made it appear that she
was going to argue at trial that she was being forced or coerced into selling this.
What choice did I have? Because I was basically financially desperate.
So Brad Pitt said, "Okay, well,
I want to see your financial records for during this period of time."
And she said, "No, it's private," and and so his argument is, "Look,
you can't have it both ways. You can't say that you were destitute or forced
into selling this because your financial circumstances are not telling me what
your income is." So that went to court. During that court dispute,
Angelina Jolie's lawyer said, "We will not make those arguments."
We are instead explaining that her pull away
from work was to focus on family.
And that although she is upset
and does claim that he withheld distributions from her from the business,
she's not claiming that she had to sell for financial reasons.
So she withdrew that claim.
And because she withdrew that claim, he doesn't need her income records.
That's what the court ruled. But the court said if she tries
to revive that claim in any way, he gets those records.
And the court made an express finding that Brad was reasonable or justified
in seeking this information based on the claims that she had previously made.
So okay, great. So they both kind of won something.
She got to keep her income records private, but he also eliminated this argument
that she was going to make at trial about her having to sell for financial reasons.
But now she's making the argument and blaming him, saying, "Oh, you're coming after
my private records." Just literally what they're even saying in the article.
Angelina's attorney: This motion Brad should have never brought,
claiming he doesn't need to invade Angelina's privacy to defend himself in the case.
This is just a complete nonsense, correct?
Well, that's right. It's it's it's very easy to say that he had
no business asking for her financial records after she withdrew
her claim that she had some financial necessity of selling.
And and so of course it's not relevant, but she made it.
That way, by withdrawing the claims or at least the insinuation that she
was making earlier, so she could have done that from the very get go and said,
"Hey, you know what, Brad, you're misinterpreting what I'm arguing.
I promise not to argue that stuff." Then I don't believe this would have proceeded.
But again, it it it this in no way justifies a victory lap.
You know, basically what happened is is that arguments
that she apparently was intending to raise earlier have been withdrawn.
Yeah, I know it really as I as I read the quote from their lawyer Angelina's lawyer,
Mr. Pitts' unyielding demand for harassing information is the latest manifestation
in his attempts to control her and the narratives in this case.
What Angelina wants and has always wanted is to untangle her personal
and financial life from her ex husband.
Rather than do the right thing and buy her out at agreed price, Mr. Pitt at the last
minute tried to use her exit from Miraval as leverage to force her to sign an NDA.
That's why she did it to cover up his abuse, and that's what this case is about,
not her personal income and selling it to the Stollie Group. But as I read this,
just they they they why I don't understand that is I mean could that be a defense?
Is could did did did he force her to sign an NDA in order to make a deal with her,
and that's why she ultimately went to a rival?
Is that a fair defense that's going to win this case?
Well, that's one of the two things she's saying. The first thing is saying,
you know, he should have just bought her out at some agreed price.
Well, the problem is she didn't negotiate with him.
So you know he made an offer, and then she just went and sold to somebody else.
So you know it's so that that is a false narrative for for her to claim
that you know he just failed to negotiate. She was the one who failed to negotiate.
The second part about the NDA, you know, look, I I haven't seen the proposed NDA.
If it would be reasonable in a transaction to have an NDA about
the circumstances of the winery, so for example, if there's trade secrets
or you know financial information about the operations of the business,
that would be typical and normal and protective of the business. To say hey,
you know what, she's not going to talk about that once she's no longer an owner.
If if he was saying hey, you're not going to talk about me personally,
then that goes too far because there's no need for an NDA on personal issues
when you're just dealing with the winery.
Because I because I we like to cover all sides.
It's like if that's really the argument here, why didn't she push back and say no?
Here's the rate, no NDA, and have at least a paper trail that Brad said no to that.
In which case, then maybe we wouldn't have as much empathy for for Brad
and the selling to a competitor, the oligarch, when he proves like, look,
I you didn't you didn't even give me an offer to give you that deal,
while she and her lawyer are claiming he he did the wrong thing and last minute.
It it does read very aggressively nonsensical.
Yeah, and and and you know, look, and both of them when they decided to buy
this together, you know, they didn't have provisions in their entity documents
that kind of foresaw the possibility that they would get divorced
and have this nasty dispute, and you know, so they don't have all
these elaborate buyout provisions at least in a written agreement.
Brad says that that there was some promise or some legal obligation
to offer this up to him first. That'll be determined by the court.
But again, there there is a process called arbitration.
There's other forms of dispute resolution that they could have signed up for,
and and saying, hey, we can't agree on the value,
and have you know a neutral person after receiving appraisals
and valuation evidence determine the value of that thing, and require that he pay
her for that fair market value, or sell the thing and divide the proceeds.
So they could have signed up for a process like that.
It would have been totally you know legitimate you know way of determining
their rights. But instead, she just sold it to the oligarch.
And again, my my analysis and it's not perfect,
but it's similar to you know if a couple owns a home
and one spouse just says you know what hey I'm out I'm selling it to some dude.
And go, you know, go co-own the home with this stranger.
And then for her to say, well, what's what's the problem?
I'm just trying to leave the marriage, you know. I'm just trying to disentangle.
I'm trying to leave clean. Yeah. So I left with a stranger.
You absorbed that out. Yeah. Yeah. It doesn't feel very clean to me.
It doesn't feel like that's the that's the way to leave it all.
As she claims to do, and and and just because I want to echo that in the PR attempt,
you can see it like all over out there as fears for kids. Shock.
Brad Pitt makes shock new demands, and as they sort of preface it,
the case with Brad is set to go to trial, but in the meantime,
he's pushing aggressively for all sorts of documents.
Who should be celebrating right now after selling her LA mansion?
The whole thing's causing her a pile of stress.
It's like, then why did you sell to the oligarch? I can't.
I can't get over that issue. She wants to play victim to this,
and it's oh, but even in the credit, they do say there is, you know,
there's a lot of issues because there's no doubt, ton of on the line here.
If she loses, it could really sink her.
This is, I mean, this could be really damaging for her eventually, correct?
If this all goes the way I suspect it's gonna eventually,
is that why she's being so aggressive on this to play the victim now,
so she can maybe use that if she loses this later?
Well, there's a lot at stake, and and certainly,
you know, Brad's got more money than her.
She's accused of of doing these things that are causing damage now,
financial damage to to the business. So the damages could be quite high.
She's also incurring a lot of attorney fees along with him. What what you know?
But as Brad is fighting in court, she's also fighting in the media.
So she's the one promoting a lot more stories than we ever really see any statements
from him. And using the kids, I should say too.
Like the kids are all involved. Oh, it's so hard now.
The kids feel bad for her, and now they're helping her as a mother.
It is creating a weird alienation too, doesn't it?
Well, that that's that's a whole feature that we saw during the divorce,
and so you know, and again, you know, I don't know this family,
I don't know the kids, I don't know the dynamics, but there were, you know,
certainly allegations that she was interfering with his relationship,
and I'm sure she would say she didn't do that and she had great reasons.
And now, you know, we see a couple of the children as adults,
you know, making their own apparent decisions.
That that's the most heartbreaking thing about it.
You know, kids shouldn't have to pick a side. They can love both parents.
You know that that can be true. They can love their mom.
They can love their dad, even though their dad and mom don't get along,
or even though maybe there's been issues. There's no perfect parent.
You know, so that that's that. Those are the real casualties.
You know, Brad Pitt's got plenty of money.
He could probably win or lose or Miraval and be just fine.
But you know, the the relationship with the children, you know,
is is is something that unfortunately was not protected through this process.
Yeah, I just I can't see I see through this narrative and the PR is sad
because if she really cared for the kids, I feel like what's wrong with the NDA?
What's wrong with signing and just giving an agreement? What? Why not negotiate?
All these things would have made more sense for the sake of the kids and for moving
on. But now that the kids are adults, that that debate seems to be finally over.
So now she's almost seems like she's found a new lawsuit to keep draining him
and straining him on, and it does feel very I don't know something.
Something feels off. Like if you,
I would I would want to be away from my ex and want nothing to do anymore with them.
But she seems to keep almost clinging on to this fight with him,
almost like she needs it. I mean, you're a celebrity divorcer.
Do you do you ever experience that a lot? Where there's a significant partner
who is just fighting because they don't want to let go? Is that common?
Yeah. So I mean, my sometimes we'll see cases go ten, twenty years,
and usually there's something more than you know, law or finance driving
that dispute, and um, and and that could be a mental health issue.
It it could be just anger. Um, is really unnatural.
Yeah, you know, so there's it's it's unnatural for for a dispute to take that long,
even in the legal system.
Now, here she'll say, "Hey, you know, he's he's suing me," which is true, you know,
but he's suing her because something she did, and so that that's you know, again,
that's what gives her the opportunity to create this narrative of being a victim
because she's being sued by him, and she's just saying, "Hey, I want to be alone.
I I don't want to be part of this." Well,
that's easy to say when you poisoned the well.
Right.
That's why I think most people don't really want to address in this issue.
I do think it's going to backfire on her. So we will see.
I'll keep you guys posted as we get more updates.
But fascinating breakdown as always.
Thank you for always opening our eyes to this case
because it's easy to want to support Angelina and think, oh, Brad must be a jerk.
But there's clearly a lot more dynamics behind the scenes in this,
as we see legally and from a PR perspective.
So always fascinating to go down this case. We'll keep you posted.
Make sure you hit that subscribe button if you haven't already.
Hit the bell for alerts so you get notified and smash that thumbs up
and let the comments down below know how much you love Mr. Melcher.
Ah, you can also follow him over on X at ca underscore divorce.
Thank you so much, sir. Thank you guys for watching. Stay tuned.
We got a lot more coming your way here on Popcorn Planet.
