A 9–0 Win for Religious Freedom—What It Means

NTD+
2.8K followers
In a unanimous decision, the US Supreme Court has just ruled 9-0 in favor of a Catholic charity over in the state of Wisconsin. By doing so, they have effectively expanded the rights of religious nonprofits across the whole country.
---
🧶More NTD Programs:
https://www.ntd.com/programs?utm_source=YouTube&utm_medium=Social
A 9–0 Win for Religious Freedom—What It Means
#religiousfreedom #supremecourt #nonprofits
---
© All Rights Reserved.
In a unanimous decision, the U.S. Supreme Court has just ruled 9-0 in favor of a Catholic charity
over in the state of Wisconsin. And by doing so, they have effectively expanded the rights of
religious nonprofits across the whole country. The organization at the center of this whole case
is called the Catholic Charities Bureau. It's a nonprofit that functions as an arm of the Roman
Catholic Diocese over in Superior, Wisconsin. And the Catholic Charities Bureau, as an
organization, it provides almost exclusively social services. They run several different
affiliated organizations that do different things. They help the elderly, they help the disabled,
they give food to those in need, they provide shelter to the homeless, things like that.
These services are available to the general public. They're basically available to everyone,
not just the Catholics. Also, the Catholic Charities Bureau doesn't really engage in
traditional religious activities like worship, Bible study, prayer, trying to convert the
participants in their programs to Catholicism or things like that. Their range of activities
are exclusively secular. Now, over in the state of Wisconsin, they have a state law
which exempts religious organizations from having to pay into the state's unemployment
insurance program. Or to be more technical, quote, Wisconsin law excuses religious organizations that
are operated, supervised, controlled, or principally supported by a church or convention
or association of churches from paying state unemployment tax. Now, naturally, the Catholic
Charities Bureau wanted to take advantage of that exemption. They applied for it,
but they were rejected. You see, the state of Wisconsin determined that this particular
organization was not religious enough to claim this tax exemption. Now, the Catholic Charities
Bureau, they pushed back and they filed a lawsuit against the state, arguing that for one,
their work was driven by their Catholic values and that serving others was a part of their
religious mission. But then secondly, and more fundamentally, is that the Catholic Charities
Bureau were arguing that this whole situation was a violation of their First Amendment rights,
that the state government doesn't have the authority to determine how religious something
is based on whether it, quote, unquote, looks religious to them. Eventually, the case made it
all the way up to the state Supreme Court of Wisconsin, who actually wound up ruling against
the charity. The Catholic Charities Bureau, they appealed this decision all the way up to the U.S.
Supreme Court, who, after well over a year, finally ruled on the matter just last week.
In that unanimous nine to zero decision, the U.S. Supreme Court, they ruled that the state of
Writing for the majority of the court, you had Justice Sonia Sotomayor write the following,
quote,
is physically expressed, not just through worship, but also through service to others. People might
want to express their religious convictions by setting up an organization to help others,
even if that help is purely secular. And the U.S. Supreme Court has now just ruled that when the
state government tries to define what real religious work actually looks like, they're
crossing a line. So your secular work might fully qualify as religious work if you're doing it based
on your religious convictions.
