5 Fishing Kayaks Under 500 Part 2 of 2 ON WATER REVIEW

Headwaters Kayak
7 followers
31 Video Views·Oct 29, 2022
What's up guys, it's Dan from the Headwaters Kayak Shop,
and I'm coming to you from the banks of the McCallum River
here in Lodi, California,
and I'm finally getting around to doing my top five kayaks
under $500 video.
Again, these were five kayaks that I picked up
at my local department stores,
boats that I thought were a good value,
or boats that some of you guys have recommended
in the YouTube comments.
So I bought five kayaks,
and I'm gonna get them on the water today
and let you guys know my feedback.
If you haven't done so already,
check out the video where I walk you through in the shop.
I'll have that linked up at the end of this video.
But for now, let's get into it.
So the five contenders that we're gonna be reviewing today
is the Pelican Kicker 120X Angler.
I got this kayak at Costco for $399.
Next in line is I've got the Eagle Run by Field & Stream.
I bought this one at Dick's Sporting Goods
because I've heard really good things about it.
I also know a few people around our area that paddle it,
and have been very satisfied with it.
So I decided to pick this one up.
Next up, here's a Perception that I bought over
at Sportsman's Warehouse in Stockton.
This one was a little bit over our budget at $550.
It didn't come with a paddle,
but I felt like it was such a huge upgrade
in quality and features that I had to add it to the list.
Just in case somebody was at that $500 threshold,
but willing to spend a little more,
you're getting a lot more bang for your buck
on this one here.
The next one in our lineup is a Perception Swifty 9.5.
I really like the quality of the Perception.
They use a high-density, rotor-molded construction.
It has plenty of room in the cockpit.
It looks like it's gonna paddle really nice,
so $350, I felt like it was a good value,
definitely one I wanted to have in the lineup.
And the last one in my lineup,
and probably the most loved kayak from beginner kayakers,
the most recommended by you guys,
as well as when I hear people coming through the shop
that have started out in this boat,
they're very satisfied with it.
That is the Lifetime Tamarack Angler.
It's the cheapest kayak in the bunch.
I got it for about $279 with the paddle and a rod holder
from Walmart, our local Walmart here in town.
So I'm gonna go ahead and hop in them
and kind of talk to you about what do you get for $279
all the way up to $550, what's worth spending money on,
what maybe isn't worth spending money on.
So at the end of this,
hopefully you'll be able to make a informed,
educated decision on what kayak's gonna work best
for your budget.
Another quick thing I wanted to touch in,
in all fairness, was paddles.
Some of these kayaks came with paddles.
Some of them did not come with paddles.
So what I have here is I've got a couple of boats
that came with paddles.
The Pelican came with this aluminum two-piece paddle,
very heavy, but at least it's the correct size for the boat.
The Lifetime, the cheapest kayak in the bunch,
came with this paddle right here,
which literally feels like I could bend it with my hands.
I could totally just snap the blade.
There's gonna be no grip, no power in this paddle.
It's not even suitable for kayaking in any condition
because chances are it's gonna break
and leave you stranded.
So let's just dispose of that one.
Another paddle I got here,
this is the Field & Streams Chute.
I got this one at Dick's Sporting Goods
just because they didn't have a whole lot of options,
but I did wanna just kinda show what's available.
This paddle's okay, it's two-piece.
What I didn't love about it is the blade shape
and the amount of flex it had.
And it was still 59 bucks,
so it wasn't really that inexpensive.
So not a terrible paddle, but I tell you what,
for five more dollars, $64,
the Bindi Branch's Whisper is a huge upgrade.
A lot stiffer, it's got a composite ferrule,
so it's not gonna be clunking around
or coming loose on you.
And I'd say maybe a third less weight.
So significant upgrade for five bucks more.
So if you're buying your kayak at a big box store,
do yourself a favor and just order
one of these guys offline.
Austin Canoe & Kayaks would have them,
anywhere would have this.
Bindi Branch's Whisper, this paddle can be bought
online all day for about 65 bucks.
Lastly, I bought a paddle from my shop.
We do sell the Whisper,
but we also sell the Feel Free Day Tour paddles.
This is an aluminum shaft, two-piece take-apart.
Very nice quality.
This is what we use in our rental facility.
I really like the blade shape of these,
the lack of flex you get in the blade, and the index.
So this one's about 69 bucks.
So again, don't just buy whatever the shop's selling.
Look around, get a Day Tour, get a Bindi Branch's Whisper.
You'll be a lot happier with your investment.
And as I always say in all my videos,
the paddle makes as much of a difference,
if not more of a difference in your paddling
than the kayak will.
So splurge, get the right paddle.
You're gonna sit inside, look for around a 220 to 230.
If you're sitting on top, 230, 240.
Those are kind of rough and dirty numbers.
There's a link to a paddle video I did
with Out West with Chris, where I go into way more detail.
If you want more details about paddling,
check that video out in the description.
Okay, without further ado, guys, let's paddle some boats.
This little paddle's really smooth, I gotta say.
My only gripe is the comfort.
It's absolutely horrendous how uncomfortable it is.
There's just no support.
Like if you lean back, you just keep going.
There's no support, so you really gotta stay
kind of flexed and upright the whole time.
I do like the open space it gives me in front.
I also like the access to the rear.
You know, you can put a nice tackle bag up here.
You can definitely have some space to work,
land a fish, even measure a fish.
I like a lot of things about this boat,
but I just can't get over the quality of the build,
the quality of the pieces and parts on the boat,
and how uncomfortable the seat is.
If I was just strictly going off paddling performance,
this is my favorite one of the bunch, I think.
So as much as I've been enjoying the Pelican
for its speed, its tracking, its glide,
its overall performance on the water is really good,
but I just can't get over the fact
that the flex of the deck and the hull,
the feel of the pieces and parts and the handles,
it all just feels very chintzy to me.
And it's something that I can maybe get over
if it had like a really good seat or something,
but the cockpit, the feel of this boat,
it feels like if you lean back, you just,
you keep going back, there's really no support.
So if you're a bigger guy, absolutely not.
If you're a little older, stiff, I'd say no way.
And if you're a young guy
and you wanna get to your spot fast,
and you know, then yeah, I'd say go ahead.
This is actually a pretty sweet paddling boat.
I really, out of all the boats,
I would say it's probably my favorite one to paddle,
but I just can't get over some of those other things,
the build quality and the comfort of the seat.
The other thing is you notice
I'm not using the paddle that came with it.
The paddle that came with it is really heavy,
really, really hard to use.
So I'm using the Whisper,
and that would definitely affect my review of it
if I had to use that paddle that came stock with it.
That one is pretty bad.
Now, one thing I'll say in regards to the seat
is there is actually pad eyes all around.
So if you wanted to upgrade to a nicer clip-in seat,
or if you have already got the Pelican,
you can get a better seat for, you know, around 59, 69 bucks.
Yak Gear has some decent seats.
Feel free to make some decent clip-in seats.
So look around a little bit online,
and if you have this boat,
you'll love it way more with a better seat.
I'll tell you that right now.
All right, let's jump in the next one here.
So I got this thing in a rod holder.
Just the weight of this camera
is completely flexing the whole of this thing.
And maybe this is a hot day here in Lodi,
but look at the flex of this deck.
It's just absolutely crazy how much flex this thing has.
Even on the floor, it's like a drum.
It's just pushing up and down.
So the overall quality of this Eagle Rod is,
it is roto-molded,
but it must be some pretty inexpensive plastic
that they're using, because it is flexy.
I got to give it to the outfitting department, though.
So the outfitting of this boat feels really comfortable.
The thigh pads, the backrest, the foot pedals,
it all feels spot on.
Oh man, this thing just glides on the water so easy.
You notice I stop paddling, the kayak just keeps gliding.
It keeps going straight.
Out of all the kayaks in the bunch,
this is the most efficient.
I still like the Pelican a little bit more
for an all-around fishing vessel,
but this one flies on the water.
The other thing I'll say after swapping back and forth
on a bunch of different paddles,
the Daytour is my favorite.
It's still cheap.
It's like 69 bucks, I think.
This is an aluminum one.
They also come in fiberglass.
But the overall feel of this paddle in the water is awesome.
The way it maneuvers from power phase to back phase,
it just feels really good.
So I think if you could overlook the flex and the hole
and the flexibility of the plastic of this kayak,
it actually paddles really good.
I've actually taken it out twice now
because I wanted to make sure
I was giving my best information.
And it's significantly faster
than any of the other kayaks out there.
It glides across the water.
So if you're like a recreational paddler
that likes the idea of fishing once in a while,
but you wanna actually cruise and get somewhere,
this is not a bad kayak to do it in.
You know, the price is a little higher
than some of the others,
but I don't know of any inexpensive wreck kayaks
that paddle quite as good as this Eagle Talon.
So it definitely gets my vote of approval
from a paddler's perspective.
It's got a high secondary stability, a high capacity,
but it cuts through the water.
So kudos to Field & Stream on that one.
As far as fishing out of it,
you know, I've got a little bit of room
down here in the cockpit, not a ton.
I got pole holders here.
It does have a little dashboard up in the front,
but you know, it's not very big.
It's not even enough for like, you know,
maybe a car keys or something, but yeah, there you go.
You can kind of see it there.
Nice big open cockpit, bungee in the front.
So not a lot of bells and whistles,
but where it counts is the outfitting,
the thigh pads, the foot pedals, the backrest,
all feel really good in this kayak.
So if you're a paddler, you'll definitely like this boat.
You know, it's got this little dry box in the rear,
which I guess I could get to it.
I don't know how crazy I am about that.
It's, I guess it's added features,
but you could easily just throw it in a dry bag
and probably have a lot safer ride.
Your stuff have a much safer, drier ride.
So it comes with it.
What the hell?
I would say if you care about your stuff being dry,
still put it in a dry bag,
even if you're putting it in that rear hat.
You guys got to laugh at my camera setup.
I'm always doing something super ghetto.
This is like a painter's pole
with a X-grip cell phone mount on the end.
Some high dollar YouTube entertainment going down right here
at the headwater.
So right now I'm in the Perception Pescador 10.
This was the kayak I was kind of most excited about
just because I felt like it was a really good quality,
a lot of nice features that I'd expect on a higher end kayak
but in that $500 price point, actually about 550.
A few of you said in the comments of the last video
that these can be had for cheaper
if you shop around a little bit online.
So heads up there, you know, maybe be patient.
But I would say if your local kayak shop
sells a Perception, buy it from them
because you're going to get the support from them
long after the fact, long after you buy your kayak.
The overall fit and finish of this Perception's phenomenal.
It just feels really high quality,
really stiff, no flex, nice high back on it.
The seat pan's pretty flat.
I might add a little bit of padding there,
but it's not too bad.
Not as fast as the other boats I just got out of.
Both the Eagle Run and the Pelican both had better speed,
but this one is a little bit shorter.
It's only 10 foot.
They make this in a 12 foot,
and if you're wanting that extra speed, shoot for the 12.
As you guys know, longer boats are just faster,
so that's why those other two
have a little bit better speed.
But this one doesn't feel bad.
And if I were to be floating a river or something like that,
I would actually prefer the little shorter boat.
The overall fit and finish, hatches, everything,
definitely a step up from everything else
we're testing in the buck.
So you spend a little bit more, you get a little bit more,
which is to be expected.
Very stable.
This is a boat that if you're a little bit bigger guy,
you can feel confident that this is gonna feel stable for you
and you're not gonna feel near as tippy
as you would in that Pelican, that's for sure.
So if you're sacrificing speed,
you definitely make up for instability.
Next, I wanna jump in that Perception Swifty 9.5.
Same manufacturer as this one, but a lot less money.
It's only 350 bucks.
It's their little sit inside.
I kinda wanted to test and see how the quality stacks up.
All right, here we go.
So now I'm hanging out in the Perception Swifty 9.5.
And although it's only supposedly six inches shorter
than the Pescador I was in, it feels a lot smaller.
I feel like my feet are at the end of this kayak.
Still decently stable.
You know, we hit 200 pounds.
It doesn't feel unstable.
It does feel like I'm sitting real low in the water.
Like I'm kinda heavy for it.
I know the overall capacity's well over my weight of 220,
but those capacities are all sort of relative.
You know, they don't really mean a whole lot to me.
There's kind of an ideal weight range that kayaks have.
And I think I'm probably on the upper scale of this thing.
Here, look at the bow of my kayak.
And as I get going, there's what we call a bow weight
coming off the front of this thing.
You'll see it there in a little bit.
And I don't have to go very fast
for the water to start piling up on that bow.
And it feels like I'm pushing.
It also feels like the stern of the kayak
kind of breaks loose.
So, you know, I'm not that big of a guy,
but I would say that I would recommend this kayak
for somebody under 200 pounds.
Me at 200 pounds, I really feel this thing out
and it feels very small.
And it doesn't, it feels like it loses
a lot of its performance with my weight in it.
So do you like the little dashboard it has?
You know, I have lots of areas to store stuff.
I think if I was fishing out of this,
maybe I'd throw a little foam pad right here
that I could stick my hooks and stuff
that I wanted to have access to throughout the day.
Jam that right in there.
Oh, it's got a little paddle clip on here.
The overall fit and quality of the Perceptions
is really good.
So for 350 bucks, I feel like it's a good value.
But, you know, I would say that I would also
be looking at that Big Fish GT 10.5
that I reviewed a couple weeks ago.
I think for 399, you're getting a little bit better
bang for your buck.
You're getting that rear bulkhead
so the kayak doesn't sink.
All in all, a little bit better product for your money.
But if you're somewhere that doesn't have the GT
and you've got these locally, it's not a bad boat.
You definitely get a good quality yacht.
It's just a little small.
It's also a close to shore yacht
because if you flip this thing over
and you do get water in the cockpit,
you know, you got a boat full of water to deal with.
You're not flipping this back over and getting it back in.
You're definitely swimming it to shore.
All right, last but not least,
we have the Lifetime Tamarack Angler.
These guys are actually made right in Salt Lake City, Utah,
which is kind of interesting.
They started off as like a tables, chairs,
basketball hoops, toy manufacturer.
They got into the kayak business.
And to be honest, most of their kayaks
that I've ever seen are pretty terrible.
They don't really work that good.
They don't track like they're supposed to.
They're inexpensive, low quality.
But I've heard nothing but positive things
about this Tamarack Angler.
So I'm really keen to test it out, paddle it,
and give you guys my feedback.
Out of all the comments and Facebook and Instagram posts,
this was the most recommended boat for the video.
So I spent 279 bucks on it, I think, at Walmart.
And let's give it a shot.
Yeah, it feels real stable.
This one's 10 foot long, 31 inches wide,
weighs about 52 pounds.
It's not a fast boat, but it cuts through the water okay.
If I'm being honest, it doesn't feel too dissimilar
to that Perception Pescador 10 footer.
As far as the stability profile, the speed,
I think the bow pushes a little more water.
I can tell you this much.
I put this in every rod holder of every boat.
This camera mount I've got here,
I put it in all the rod holders of all the boats.
And the first two boats, the Eagle Run and the Pelican,
flexed the boat so bad,
I thought it was gonna rip the rod holder right out.
I put it in the rod holder of this boat,
and it was actually the stoutest of the whole bunch.
I tried to put it in the Perception,
but they just have those tubes
that aren't really rod holders and don't really work.
So out of the boats, this one had the stoutest feel.
And even though the plastic's blow molded,
which is a fairly cheap way to make a kayak,
it feels pretty darn stiff.
It doesn't have a terrible amount of flex to it.
Again, everything's relative.
We're talking a $279 boat here.
That is definitely Toyak prices,
but this is a kayak that you could definitely be capable
of floating rivers or catching bass at your local waters.
You're not gonna go far.
You're not gonna go fast, but it's stable.
It feels good.
It has really nice, logical deck layout.
You've got a little hatch access here.
So if you wanna have stuff underneath the hull,
you could have it there.
It's got the bungee up front there.
So you could add a dry bag or a tackle bag right there.
Plenty of room to access behind you.
I can see why you guys love this so much.
And I also know that there's some really good moths
for this kayak.
I watched the Mob and Outdoors YouTube page
and I've been following his stuff for a long time
and he's tricked one of these kayaks out.
So if you haven't already, go subscribe to his channel
and check out some of his Tamarack Angler builds.
One thing that's important to mention
is we don't ship kayaks.
A lot of you have been messaging me
and asking how much for a kayak,
how much to ship with you.
We don't ship.
We are just a local kayak shop here
located in Lodi, California,
and we just serve our local market.
We do these videos for you guys
just to be a community place,
kind of like a forum to talk about things
and to learn from one another.
Wow, I'm really surprised.
Like, I've paddled a lot of really cheap boats
over the years, you know,
trying to always get that entry-level price point
for our shop.
And I don't think I've ever paddled anything
anywhere close to this price that feels near as good.
It tracks straight.
It maneuvers easy.
Honestly, it paddled really similar to the Pescador.
You know, it's all right there.
You can do a lot of upgrades to this kayak,
even if you wanted to drill holes and add tracks.
For a beginner kayak,
the ones I checked out for an entry-level,
hey, I'm just getting started in the sport.
I want to see if I like it.
I've got 300 bucks to spend.
This is money well spent right here.
I really do feel like that.
And if you wanted to turn around
and sell it after a year or two
when you decide you love it,
man, you could sell it for 150 bucks
and be on 100 bucks.
That's a weekend rental.
I mean, think about that.
You could literally own this boat for two years
for the price of a weekend rental in most kayak shops.
It's a pretty tough argument to beat.
And I'm saying that to my own hurt.
I'm a kayak shop that rents kayaks.
I don't sell this kayak.
I'm saying that to my own hurt.
All right, guys.
So now that I've had a chance to sit in a mall,
paddle a mall,
I want to just kind of give you guys
my rough and dirty initial thoughts
and who I think these boats might work out good for.
The right boat's not the right boat for everyone.
So they each have different features
and there might be one that works good for your needs.
There might be one you just kind of want to avoid.
So I'll try to give some rough information.
And from there, hopefully you guys can deduce
which one's gonna work best for your needs.
Okay, so the first one in the lineup, the Kicker 120X.
My thoughts on this one was it actually
was really pleasant to paddle.
It cuts through the water nice, tracks well, it's smooth.
But the overall fit and finish of this boat
was so poor quality.
The flex of it, the handles, the latches,
it just all feels so incredibly cheap.
The fact that the rod holder broke
before I ever even got it to the water.
I just don't know that it's the best investment.
If you're looking for a fairly inexpensive option,
or if you're wanting to, you know,
if you could find this boat on a deal, you know,
for maybe a hundred bucks off or something like that,
it'd be worth buying because it does paddle really well.
It's just the longevity of the kayak
is fairly questionable to me.
The other thing that I really didn't enjoy
was the seat on this one.
Out of all the kayaks in the bunch,
this one has the worst seat.
The Pelican seat just hit me wrong.
It didn't have a lot of support
and it just kind of flexed with my body.
I would say if you are a recreational paddler
that's gonna be paddling with other people in fast kayaks,
this one cuts through the water pretty well.
I wouldn't say don't buy it,
but just know the features and the quality of it
is not on par with some of the other boats
that we tested today.
The next step up, the Field & Stream Eagle Run.
Oh, this boat was pleasant.
This boat cuts through the water really nice.
It has a large open cockpit, really generous stability.
It was actually more stable than the Pelican next to it.
The seat, getting out of this seat
and jumping into this was incredible.
The overall contact points, the thigh pads here,
the high back, the cup holder, the foot pedals inside,
all felt really well-made in quality.
The boat itself had quite a bit of flex to it.
There wasn't a whole lot of stiffness in the combing.
So you can see the density of the plastic
isn't as good as the Perception's next to it.
So my overall opinion on it is it paddles really nice,
but the quality of the plastic is a little thin.
You need to be aware of how you store it,
how you transport it.
But on the water, it cuts through the water really good.
And if you're a recreational paddler
that was looking for some efficiency
and the ability to fish, I would definitely recommend it.
The next one I demoed was the Perception Pescador 10.
And this one I got at Sportsman's Warehouse again.
It's got the molded-in handles.
The overall density of the plastic felt incredible.
There was no flex in the deck.
It felt really, really good.
All the hatches, the tracks, the foot pedals,
all the quality of the whole boat was on point,
which you would expect for a kayak around 550 bucks.
The seat, the back was good, but the pan was pretty flat.
Didn't have a whole lot of support, but it wasn't terrible.
I also really liked the fact
that you have those tracks on there.
So if you want to add accessories to it,
you know, this is a Yak Attack rod holder.
They're really easy to just add on some legitimate stuff
as opposed to the really cheap rod holders
that come with the Pelican or the Tamarack Angler.
So next kayak in the lineup was the Perception Swifty 9.5.
Now I bought this kayak
because I've had a Swifty in the past,
and I really enjoyed the Swifty,
and maybe it's because some of the other kayaks
paddled so much better, but this one pushed a ton of water.
I really, I got it going,
and maybe I'm a little heavy for it.
Maybe it would be better with a smaller person,
but at 220 pounds, it pushed a lot of water.
So who would I recommend this for?
Somebody that's looking for a fairly light,
well-built kayak, somebody that's under maybe 180 pounds,
but for a bigger person,
I would steer something a little different.
If you're looking to do more open water,
look for something with a bulkhead.
Again, since I bought all these kayaks,
Three Waters Kayaks came out with a kayak called the GT
that I reviewed, and I was really impressed
with that little kayak.
The price on it was only 50 bucks more than the Swifty,
and it had the rear bulkhead, the seat in it was better.
Just all in all, just a little bit better product,
better bang for your buck.
So as much as I wanted to like the Perception Swifty,
I wasn't a huge fan of it.
Next up was the Lifetime Tamarack.
This is the cheapest one in the bunch,
and the one I got from Walmart.
Again, this one came with a paddle,
but the paddle was absolute, absolute trash.
Like, it's an embarrassment that they even call it a paddle.
This boat was impressive to me.
It was stable, it paddled decent for its size.
The overall feel of the kayak, you know,
where I would put stuff,
where I would want to like have my tackle bag,
or maybe I would want to have something
under the bungee here.
It just felt good.
It's cheap, and it works, and it doesn't suck.
The stiffness of the plastic actually felt better
than both the Pelican and the Eagle Run.
I mean, it's blow-molded plastic,
so it's not the best manufacturing process,
but it does say on the tag
that they're using high-density plastic to mold it.
So it's a cheaper process,
but a better quality of material that they're using.
So I think if you're on a tight budget,
this would be a great way to go.
It'll get you in the sport.
It's something that you can literally use
for a year or two and sell it for 150 bucks,
and not lose that much money.
You know, you're gonna be coming out ahead
no matter how you slice it.
So if it was my 500 bucks, what would I spend it on?
Well, you gotta think.
It's not just the kayak you're buying.
You're gotta buy a whole bunch of other stuff,
especially if you're getting into kayak fishing.
So if it was my 500 bucks, what I would do,
I'd buy a Tamarack Angler.
I'd buy a decent paddle,
and I would trick it out with some really cool gear,
and that's just what I plan on doing.
I plan on doing a $500 build of the Tamarack Angler.
I'm gonna do some custom DIY outfitting on it.
I'm gonna do an anchor trolley system.
I'm gonna do a custom crate.
I'm gonna do a seat.
I'm gonna do rod holders,
and be expecting some videos on that real soon.
So if you like the Tamarack Angler,
or you have a Tamarack Angler,
you're gonna love these videos to come.
All right, guys, thank you so much for watching.
To all my new subscribers, welcome to the channel.
We hope to be your community kayak shop on the internet.
If you have any questions,
don't hesitate to leave them in the comment section,
and either myself or somebody else from the channel
will get back to you.
I think that's it.
Until next time, you guys, this is Dan,
wishing you happy paddling.
We'll see you on the next one.
