399 VS 649 What s The Difference Budget Kayak Comparison

Headwaters Kayak
7 followers
2 Video Views·Oct 29, 2022
What's up everybody? Welcome back to the channel. I'm hanging out in Redding, California today at
Headwaters Adventure Company and behind me I have two different boats. One is a Lifetime Tamarack
Pro. You guys seen me review this a few months back. This one goes for $399, so really good value
and you can find it at box stores like Dick's Sporting Goods, Walmart, etc. And then to my right
I have the Feel Free Moken 10 V2 which goes for around $649 and you can find these at more
independent kayak shops like Headwaters Adventure. So what I wanted to do is talk to you about the
two different boats, compare and contrast, show you what you get when you spend $400, show you what
you get when you spend a couple hundred more for the Feel Free, and kind of let you guys make the
decision yourselves of what might work best for your needs. I'd love to know your thoughts on the
two boats and kind of, you know, tell me why you'd pick one or the other. If you have time leave that
in the comments below. So I'd like to start off just by talking about stats. To my left we've got
the Lifetime Tamarack Pro. It's 10 foot 3 inches long, 31 inches wide, and has a 300 pound total
capacity. Hauling this thing around off the water you're looking at about 57 pounds, so pretty
lightweight. And I definitely noticed that when I was putting them on the racks here today. To the
right you have the Feel Free Moken 10 V2, which means this is the newest, the latest, and
greatest from Feel Free. It features the high-low chair, standing platform, wheel, and the keel. This
one's 10 foot long, 33 inches wide, has a whopping 440 pound capacity, 65 pounds with the chair out,
that's what they say on their website. Realistically that chair probably adds, I don't know, 4 or 5
pounds, so we'll call it a rough 70. Both boats are a similar size, similar paddler fit. I'm actually
kind of surprised at the 140 pound additional capacity on this one. But when I look at it,
it definitely has more volume on the side. The cockpit sits a little deeper. It's definitely
a stout little boat. I think this one is 13 inches tall and the Lifetime Tamarack is 12 inches tall,
but it does seem to have substantially more volume. Now that's not to say a 300 pound person
can paddle either of these boats, really that's not the intended thing. It's how much weight will
this kayak hold before the water starts coming up into the cockpit. Realistically I've seen 250,
270 pound guys in this boat and in this boat, and that's really at the max. Any bigger than that and
you're really going to start getting top heavy, chances are you're going to get wet. So if you're
a bigger guy and you're looking for a kayak, you know there's a kayak like the Lifetime Yukon,
which is a little bit higher volume, a little bit longer, a little bit better suited for larger
paddlers. Or actually this kayak right here if you're looking at the Feel Free Moken, but
maybe it's a little bit too small for you. This one actually has a little bit higher capacity.
This is a Big Fish 105. One of the biggest differences between these two kayaks is how
they're made. The Lifetime to the left is blow molded, which means there's a tube of plastic
that comes down out of the ceiling. They inject air into it and it pops into a mold and out pops
a kayak. So this is all about an efficient process to build a kayak. Now it's not to say it's a bad
way to do it. It makes a pretty durable, affordable kayak in a timely fashion. But when you do roto
molding, you can get a lot more details and a lot more, you know, curves and contours and features,
but it is a more time consuming process and with time comes additional costs.
So although the kayaks are molded differently, they're actually made out of the same stuff,
polyethylene plastic. The additional weight on the Moken mostly comes from the additional features.
So let's just get into that. Let's jump straight into it. We'll compare apples to apples on
what you get for $399 versus what you get for $649. So we'll start in the front. You see the
carry handles. On the Lifetime here, it's just a simple carry handle. You see it's a molded end.
They drill a hole. They add a handle. If this ever were to break loose, you know, that's
you're going to have a hole in your boat, something you'd have to weld and attach a new handle.
Whereas over here, you've got a big molded end piece. Really nothing can go wrong with this.
It's just a solid place, a good place to tie to, a place to lock up to. On the front, you have a
tank well area. This is actually a well with scuppers that you can put a dry bag. You can put
a dog. Think of it like the trunk of your car. It's just space to bring extra stuff. Over here,
you kind of have a concave deck. Would do the same thing if you were just trying to transport a dry
bag, but no actually like well to hold the stuff in place besides just the bungee. So if you're
bringing a dry bag, no problem. Or if you wanted to throw a bath mat down and bring a dog, really
either one would work. But the well definitely is going to keep stuff in the boat. As we move back
to the cockpit here, you see adjustable foot braces on the Lifetime. Remember when I reviewed that,
I actually really like the contour of these foot braces. And they do feel a little bit chintzy
with the plastic, but they work pretty well in my demo review. You see tracks up here with
five screws holding them in place. Those are just drilled straight into the boat.
And again, cheaper plastics, but it works for, you know, light trolling. It comes with this
little rod holder. And if you're trolling for trout and things like that, you know, it'll hold
up for that. But light use. It features this measuring tape on the floor, which I thought was
kind of a cool idea. Might as well if you're going to mold it anyway. That's an easy way to measure
your fish. In the cockpit, you also have this little hatch, which you can open up, access the
interior of the boat. And it's got a little bucket. Under the bucket, you open this up and
you actually see directly into the kayak. So there you go. The little bucket pops out. That just goes
into the inside of the kayak. And they're hollow because they're sit-on-tops. This has a little
spot that says, pop that out if you want a place to store your pliers. So as we look at the Feel
Free cockpit, similar but different. You know, you have your adjustable foot pedals. These are a
twist lock feature. So you flip the lever, move them to where you want to go, lock them in place.
The plastic's a little bit stouter, a little bit burlier on this foot pedal system.
The tracks they feature are metal, although they are proprietary to Feel Free. So if you want to
use a traditional, you know, Scotty, Yakitac, Railblazer, Ram mount, you will need an adapter,
which is about a $4 part. I don't know why Feel Free does that. They do sell unique track adapters
for around $20, but it is proprietary to their boat. So kind of a unique thing they do. Other
features in the cockpit, instead of having that round hatch, they actually have this flip-up
console where you can keep your stuff in between your legs. Now there's no seal on this console,
so I don't think it's going to be super watertight, but it is between your legs and
it does close. So you have plenty of room for things you want easy access to throughout the day.
Other things you're really going to notice in the floor, this one here on the measuring tape,
this one here has a reinforced standing platform. So what that means is there's a
plexiglass, I don't know if you can kind of see it down there, a small piece of plexiglass
that's attached to the boat. Very secure standing platform that reinforces the whole deck area.
So when you're getting in and out, or if you are wanting to stand up and fish,
you do have that feature. This little guy right here works as your stand assist leash.
I'll cut that open and show you guys how it works. There you go. So stand assist
leash. If you need to pull yourself up in the cockpit, you can use that little leash there.
Another thing we'll touch on later is these little guys. These are tubes that run all the
way to the back. If you wanted to add a rudder system to this boat, it's pre-plumbed ready to
go for that. So one thing the Moken doesn't come with is a rod holder. This one comes with the rod
holder. Like I said before, it's just a little basic, but it does come with it. The Feelfree
does not. That's an accessory that you'd have to add on. Moving back, we're going to talk about
the seat. We'll talk about the handles, paddle storage. This one has a frame chair, a mesh seat,
you can watch my whole overview video and I'll tell you what I think about that. All in all,
I found the seat very comfortable. The attachment points to the boat was something I touched on
that were a little bit chintzy. Like that's pretty cheesy plastic. I think over time,
that's something that you may see fail. Got this little bungee underneath, which I think
could be for a tackle, but I don't know how you would get a tackle box underneath there.
I kind of feel like that's just for added features, but I'm not sure how
functionally practical it is because that's a very small, tight clearance to get something
underneath there. There's no high seat option. You strictly have this one seating position.
Carry handles on the side here are just your typical kayak carry handles that are screwed
directly into the plastic. That's where you'd pick your boat up from. Paddle clip on the side.
This is one thing, Lifetime, if you watch the videos, this is something we got to address.
That's where your paddle goes. It would just bungee along the side here,
but that goes straight into the in the hole of the boat. It's like they put the bungee in and
it's got like a little flip that keeps it from popping out, but it also allows water to just
come right in the side of your kayak. It'll be a slow leak all day, but at the end of the day,
you can kind of expect that you're going to have some water inside this kayak.
Again, on the Feel Free over here, they do the molded inside handles. A big, solid place to grab
onto the boat. Again, that's going to add a little bit of weight. That's something you can only do
in roto-molding, but it adds a lot of durability and longevity to the boat.
They upgraded to this seat system, I think it was 2020, and it's been very, very popular. You see
it on a lot of the Feel Free brand, Seastream, Johnny Boats, all are featuring the same chair.
It's a steel frame chair, definitely a burly setup. You see how it's woven underneath there
to keep everything nice and tight. If it loosens up, it's all adjustable. It also has a high-low
position, so you see it low here, and then you can just pick it up, lift it, and then set it down
there in the high position. So this is a strap that attaches it into the boat, and you can see
it's a nice metal cam buckle. So that is a very solid and secure way to attach your boat. The
other thing is, if you ever need to replace this, this is a standard thing in the kayak industry.
Every strap is made from one of these buckles, so an easy part to replace versus a little plastic
clips over there. I mean, Lifetime may have that this year, but in five years, it's probably going
to be a completely different kayak. So, you know, a little bit more longevity over here with the way
the seat attaches. You've got tackle storage on either side of the seat, so on both sides you
could fit like a little Plano box there. And overall, it's just a much bigger, better chair
on this one. It's more breathable, wider, more support. Over here is a little bit smaller. Again,
I found the contour of the seat to be very comfortable, but just a little bit smaller,
more simplified. You see the strap adjustments underneath here. It's got three strap adjustments.
This way it's three straps of adjustments, and that keeps the tension on the seat. So
not a bad seat, and for $400, I would say it's a really, really good seat. And compared to what
we've seen on other lower-end models, the seat is a huge improvement. So I'm not trying to knock
this seat, but definitely just saying like $400, you're going to get a basic seat. For $649,
you're going to get something that's a lot more refined. Let's move to the back of the boats.
Kind of the business end of the boat here. This is like the pickup truck end of the boat for kayak
fishermen. This is where you're going to store your tackle. This is where you're going to
transport your rods, your nets. Maybe your fish is going to go back there. Maybe you're going to
use a catch bag. When we're comparing these two boats, a lot of ways are similar. You've got two
flush mount rod holders behind the seat. These have built-in rod leashes that come with the boat.
You also see a gasket that they have on there to keep the water out of the boat.
Over here, a little bit smaller rod holders. And again, three screws drilled directly into the
boat. I don't know what kind of sealant that they're using, but I don't see a whole lot of
sealant on there. On the Lifetime, you have the paddle holder along the side. And on the
Feelfree, you see how they moved it back here, right behind your hip. The tank well itself is
fairly similar in size. This one's a little bit deeper. You see how they have little square notches.
So if you're using a milk crate, a milk crate would fit right in there. This one's a pretty
good sized tank well. Not quite as deep. You know, the whole boat isn't quite as deep. But it still
has plenty of room. A milk crate would fit back there as well. The Lifetime attaches in four
places. The bungees kind of come off here. So if you wanted to attach something, you know, it's
doable. The Feelfree over here has a little bit more adjustment because it unclips in the center.
So if you wanted to hook up a black pack or, you know, maybe a little nicer crate,
you can definitely do that. Just have a little bit more adjustment in your bungee here.
Or if you just wanted to get the bungee out of the way, you can just unhook it from the center
and have room for your dog or kid to ride back there. This one also features tracks on the back,
same uni tracks, but additional tracks. So if you wanted to add flags, if you wanted to
add more rod holders, if you wanted to add an over-the-shoulder camera mount,
it has that ability. This does not, but it does have flat spots. So you could add
additional accessories to the boat. And then the last couple of things,
rear handles, again, simple toggle, drain plug. This thing is attached to the boat. So you
definitely can't lose it as easy, but you also can't use it as easy either. I'll pop that thing
out. But yeah, so drain plug, if you needed to drain water out of the inside of the boat,
this is the plug you'd use it with. And I think they do that so you don't lose it. I mean,
one of the things that happens a lot of time with these is you unscrew it to drain the water out,
and then you leave this on the side of the beach. So definitely not a bad idea to order an extra
one of these because that does happen. Now I will say you're a lot less likely to get water in this
boat, but still, it is something to consider. These are replaceable and feel free to sell them
on their website, you know, if you wanted to get an extra drain plug. Same thing with Lifetime.
Any of the parts on the Lifetime, they're actually pretty good about replacing them if you were to
break it or had an issue with it. Other things on this boat is you got the built-in carry handle
in the back, and you've got all these little spots. Those are all pre-plumbed lines. This is
the up-haul, down-haul for your rudder. This is for your left control, for your right control.
So you can add a rudder to this boat and have a boat that you can do a lot of the steering with
your feet. So if you're fishing, you can get to your spot, you can paddle in and do a lot of the
control work with your feet. Just means more time with your hands on the rod. Feel free's patented
wheel-in-the-keel. They use a nice big wide wheel. Makes it really easy to pick up the front of the
boat and drag this thing down to the ramp. Now Lifetime does feature a wheel-in-the-keel on some
of their boats. However, their Tamarack Pro does not have that wheel-in-the-keel. And from experience,
the wheel-in-the-keel on the Lifetime is a little bit tenser. In fact, let me just show you one.
This is another boat that I'll be reviewing shortly here in the future. This is the Lifetime Yukon,
which is $599. But this one does have a wheel-in-the-keel. But when you're talking
wheel-in-the-keel, you know, this is an added part that's screwed onto the boat. And then just a
simple narrow wheel. So when you're dragging it around, you know, it's got to roll right on that
wheel. Otherwise, you're scratching up the boat. Whereas with the Feel Free, you have a lot more
surface area. And the other thing is, if anything were to break on this, it's just an Allen bolt
right there on the side. Pop it out, put a new wheel in, and most of the time that will fall
under Feel Free's warranty. And honestly, you know, we use these a ton in the rental fleet. We do not
have a lot of issues with our wheel-in-the-keel. It's one of the more robust things on the kayak.
And because I did this on another video, and you guys seemed to really enjoy it,
I'm going to flip them over and show you guys the whole of the boat.
Similar in the fact that you can see they sort of have this tri-hull design, right? You have a
center line. That's your keel. And then you have these big, buoyant edges. They kind of
w-out, if you will. And that provides a lot of secondary stability. In my review of this kayak,
I found it to be very stable for how small of a kayak it was. When you look at the Feel Free,
it's just got a little bit more. So the Feel Free, in a lot of ways, is everything this boat is,
but they just do a little bit more. A little bit more volume, a little bit more stability,
a little more features. So you can see it has a very defined keel, very defined edges.
Maybe not be as fast in the water as the Lifetime, but definitely going to feel a lot more stable.
But I'm actually surprised just how similar they are. I don't think I've ever had these two
side by side. Very cool. You can see you got two, four, six scuppers over here on the Lifetime.
Two, four, six, eight, ten, twelve, fourteen scuppers. So again, that's going to add some
weight, but it means that boat is going to drain out immediately if you get water over the deck.
It also is going to add a lot of support and structure to the hull.
Some ways it might be overkill. Like I said, I didn't have any problems with this, but
you know, you look at where the scuppers are placed in the standing platform.
You know, here's the seat. There's your standing platform. You flip it over.
Underneath that standing platform, you know what you have? Scuppers. So that's going to provide
even additional support to give you a nice, solid standing platform. Whereas this one,
not really meant for standing. It's got two scuppers in the cockpit, but if you were standing
up in here, definitely is going to have a little bit more squish to it. So there you have it,
I just wanted to compare these two boats, show you what you're getting for the price differences.
I know a lot of times when you're looking at boats online, you can kind of say like,
man, this one's got almost all the same features. But when you see them side by side,
you really go through the features. You understand why there's a little bit of a
price discrepancy. Hopefully that helps you guys make your buying decision.
I'm curious to hear your thoughts after you've watched this video. Which one would you pick?
Would you go for the less expensive, lighter weight, quicker option of the Lifetime Tamarack
Pro for $399? Or would you go for the Feelfree Mokin 10 for $649 and a lot more features?
Or maybe there's something else that I'm just completely missing the mark on. Maybe there's
some other boat that I should be reviewing. Leave those for me in the comment section below. I'd
love to hear your thoughts. So thank you guys so much for watching. We hope you found the video
entertaining. If you did, consider giving it a thumbs up, sharing it with your friends. And
until next time, this is Dan wishing you happy paddling. We'll see you on the next one.
