3 Ancient Questions About Jesus That You've Never Considered

Jesus Christ
33 followers
4 Video Views·Apr 29, 2023
If you're a little bit like me, you've spent some time exploring some interesting questions about Jesus.
What did he really look like? Because judging by many of his popular depictions,
you wouldn't think he was a carpenter from ancient Palestine.
More like a carpenter from a 1970s Ikea.
Was he concerned about moderation and drinking alcohol?
I mean, turning all the water at a wedding into wine sounds like a good time,
but it could also be interpreted as a bit of a cry for help.
Either way, let's just be glad that Jesus did not, in fact, take the wheel that night.
How rowdy did he get turning over the merchant tables in the temple?
Did he just turn one over and give everyone a sermon?
Or did he really charge in there and yeet those things like a real son of a-
God.
Now, if you're a lot like me, you grew up considering and discussing larger theological questions pertaining to Jesus.
Does his turn-the-other-cheek bit imply that he was a total pacifist?
Did his soul suffer in hell for three days for our sins while his body remained in the tomb?
And exactly how does the Trinity work?
These questions are not uncommon in the least.
However, there are certain questions about Jesus, some that have been the subject of furious debate,
which most of us have never heard of, much less considered.
Based on what theological narratives are popular in our time and place,
most of us assume the answers to these questions one way or another within our theological positions,
treating them as a given, a non-issue.
Ancient people closer to Jesus' time, though, probably wouldn't have seen these things the same way.
In fact, the questions we'll explore here were likely quite common among Christians in the first few centuries CE.
Before we finally get to these questions, let me clarify to those of you new to my channel
that I am not religious and did not intend to argue for any theological position in this video.
I just really enjoy studying the development of religious systems
and thought it would be fun to just share some things that I've read about with you guys.
So, if you'd like to join me for that, let's get to it.
Did Jesus have a physical body?
Yes, this was a very real, serious question which early Christians hotly debated.
It existed within the larger debate over whether Jesus was human, a god, a mix of the two, or something else entirely.
If he was God, they wondered, how could he truly be human?
Humans have needs and limitations that God doesn't have,
and if a human doesn't have those needs and limitations because they're divine, are they really human at all?
Likewise, God presumably has knowledge and abilities which humans don't have,
so if one is truly human, wouldn't they lack the knowledge and abilities of God?
To better illustrate why there was disagreement over this question,
allow me to contrast two early Christian sects who held two polar opposite views on the issue.
We'll begin with a sect called the Ebionites.
This sect believed, as many early Christians did,
that Jesus was a man who, because of his strict and righteous observance of the Law of Moses,
pleased God so much that God adopted him as his own son on the day of Jesus' baptism.
They did not believe that he was inherently divine or born of a virgin.
Naturally, they thought that Jesus had a physical body, just the same as any other human.
A sect called the Marcionites would have disagreed entirely,
or at least that's what available sources seem to tell us.
Unfortunately, the writings of Marcion, the founder of this sect, are lost.
Our sources on Marcionite theology are limited to the writings of its direct opposition,
such as early Christian writer Tertullian's work against Marcion.
That said, it's important that we take what's been said about the Marcionites with more than a grain of salt.
The Marcionites believed that the material world, including our physical bodies, was imperfect, even corrupt.
To them, divinity was incompatible with the material world, in this case the flesh.
So the Jesus they believed in was in some ways the exact opposite from the Jesus of the Ebionites.
He didn't have a physical body made of flesh and blood.
In fact, he was never even born.
Jesus was so truly divine that his appearance must have simply been a projection of some kind,
one that had the appearance of flesh and blood, but was somehow just an illusion.
The view that Jesus was fully human only in appearance is called docetism.
To be clear, one doesn't have to think that Jesus' body has no substance or that Jesus was purely an apparition to be a docetist.
This term simply refers to the idea that Jesus appeared to be fully human when he wasn't.
I think it could be argued that there are a lot of docetists still around.
I'd imagine that plenty of Christians, if asked if Jesus had the ability to understand speech as an infant,
or read the thoughts of others, or perform physical feats that humans can't typically do,
would say, yes, of course.
If he wasn't able to do those things, he wouldn't be an omnipotent God.
So, in this way, I'd guess that plenty of people would indicate their belief
that Jesus didn't have the physical or cognitive limitations of humans in being omnipotent,
but appeared thoroughly human.
Even so, neither Ebionite or Marcionite theology ultimately came to dominate the Christian world.
Marcion was actually an incredibly successful evangelist,
seeing his message become the original and majority Christian view in some areas of Asia Minor.
However, in the ancient Roman world, there existed suspicion toward new or novel religious movements.
To appeal to Roman sensibilities on a grand scale, a religion needed to be grounded in the ancient.
As we'll see in the next part of this video, Marcionism was fully divorced from Judaism
or any other previous philosophy, so it makes sense that it didn't ultimately win out.
As for the Ebionites, by the end of the 2nd century, non-Ebionite Christian writers
didn't seem to treat Ebionite theology as much of a threat to their orthodoxy,
suggesting that the group wasn't bringing in many converts.
This makes sense, as the Ebionites held to Jewish law,
meaning non-Jewish converts had to begin a kosher diet and get circumcised.
With those requirements, it isn't a shock that the view went out of style in just a couple of centuries.
Was Jesus in league with Yahweh, the God of the Old Testament?
Remember how I said Marcionite theology was fully divorced from Judaism?
Yeah, that might even be an understatement.
Marcionites believed that the loving, merciful Jesus stood in stark contrast
to the jealous, wrathful God of the Jewish scriptures, a.k.a. the Old Testament.
They also thought that there was too much suffering and misery inherent to our world
to have been created by an entity as merciful as Jesus.
Their solution?
The Old Testament God and Jesus were not only not in cahoots,
but stood in direct opposition of each other.
The God of the Jews, in the eyes of the Marcionites, was a wrathful, sadistic fool
who not only ordered needless bloodshed in the Old Testament,
but created this material world broken, full of flaws which cause hardship for his creation.
Jesus, on the other hand, was a loving savior who was sent by a supreme, benevolent God,
a completely different, never-before-seen deity.
Seeing the torments to which the wicked creator of this world subjected humanity,
the supreme God sent Jesus to Earth to create a way for humans to escape their tormentor
and live with him in the afterlife.
Now you can see why Marcionites believe that the material world, including the flesh,
was corrupt and incompatible with Jesus' divinity.
The material realm was a creation of the wicked creator God,
so if Jesus really was divine, he couldn't have had a physical body.
Now, this may all sound very unusual given how far removed it is from popular Christian theology today,
but in the ancient world, this was a view many Christians seriously considered.
Our sources indicate that Marcion, as previously mentioned,
was a very successful evangelist in his time, especially in Asia Minor.
And if we stop to consider why, it isn't hard to see Marcionism's appeal.
First of all, Marcion established what was probably the first closed biblical canon ever.
In other words, the first version of a New Testament was created by Marcion
and served as the official text of his church.
It consisted of ten of the letters of Paul, which Marcion edited to remove Jewish-sounding passages,
which he considered later corruptions of the originals,
as well as Marcion's own version of the Gospel of Luke,
and a book written by Marcion himself called Antitheses,
which directly compared certain Jewish scriptures with the teachings of Jesus
in order to show their contradiction.
Marcionism was also probably appealing to many because it offered clear solutions
to the questions of why suffering exists and how we can escape it
without all the guilt involved with the idea that suffering is a result of sin.
The god of the Marcionites had no checkered past and was not responsible for all the ills of this world.
His words and actions offered only love, mercy, and salvation.
Also, Marcionism was in no way tied to Judaism or the extensive Jewish law,
which made the religion more appealing to Gentiles,
especially those who, you know, didn't want to turn their hoodie into a turtleneck.
It was also probably appealing to those who didn't really care for the Jews.
Because remember, kids, no matter what part of history you're studying,
you can always expect to find one thing.
Bigotry.
While Marcionism was ultimately unable to spread across the entire Roman Empire,
some concepts within Marcionism continued to exist in other Christian sects.
Christian Gnosticism, for example, is an umbrella term
which contemporary scholars use to identify various Christian sects
which occupied a certain school of thought.
One feature of that school of thought was a dualistic theology much like Marcion's.
The Monad, a superior, perfect god working to thwart the will of the Demiurge,
an inferior god who created the material world.
By the way, if you want to listen to a story from a Gnostic text
about secret agent Jesus coming to undermine the Demiurge,
check out my video where I covered the Gospel of Judas.
So, this question of whether Jesus and Yahweh were aligned or in opposition
is one which Christians disagreed on for centuries.
One may even wonder if past Christians of a more Gnostic or Marcionist persuasion
took their answers to this question for granted with the same confidence
as those Christians who'd answer it completely differently.
Did Jesus believe in heaven and hell?
It may surprise you to learn that most critical scholars,
those who employ historical and scientific methodologies in examining the biblical text
and whose work is accountable to the scrutiny of other critical scholars of various specialties,
agree that Jesus subscribed to the view of Jewish apocalypticism.
Within this view were specific beliefs about the body-soul divide,
the cause of human suffering, the afterlife, and, of course, the end times.
In this Jewish tradition at the time, there was no delineation between the body and soul.
The life force of humans was just called the breath
and wasn't thought to live on after the death of the body.
For the apocalypticists, like many other Jews, bodily death was death.
The apocalyptic view also posited that demonic forces in the world were the source of suffering
and that God was coming soon to overthrow these forces and create a utopian kingdom on Earth.
Once God had come to establish that kingdom,
those throughout time who had served God in life would be raised bodily from the dead
and, along with the righteous amongst the living, brought into the kingdom to live blissfully on Earth with God.
The living wicked who remained, however, would be punished.
Not in any afterlife, but by being cast into a real, earthly place called Gehenna to die
and then be made non-existent for the rest of eternity.
A little background on Gehenna.
This was a real place in Jerusalem.
According to 2 Kings 23.10 of the Hebrew Bible, King Josiah desecrated and burned the place
because it was thought to be where some of the kings of Judah
had once sacrificed their own children by fire to the god Molech.
Naturally, it was considered a pretty vile place.
If, whether alive or dead, your body was thrown into a blasphemous, fiery pit of rubble instead of buried,
that was understandably considered incredibly shameful.
This view, likely Jesus' own, did not include the concepts of a soul,
the soul or spirit leaving the body at death, a non-material afterlife, or eternal torment for sin.
So, on the question of whether or not Jesus taught about heaven and hell,
as well as the question of whether or not the earliest Christians believed in heaven and hell,
the likely answer, according to critical scholarship, is no.
As someone who's been told they're going to hell a lot,
like, a lot, like really, really a lot,
this comes as kind of an unwelcome surprise.
I mean, myself, most pagans, Darwin, Sagan, the creators of Pokemon,
all the people who've been told that they're going to burn in hell one day,
you know, we had a get-together planned, and I mean, now, that's, it's all ruined.
Something Jesus certainly did teach, though, was that God was coming to establish his kingdom soon,
within the lifetime of some of the apostles, even.
Since that time never came, it's no wonder this apocalyptic view of Jesus' teachings was discarded.
Those who still believed in Jesus' divinity had to come to a different interpretation of his teachings.
In the early years, most of those coming into the Christian church had a Greek background,
which would have included the idea that the soul was immortal,
separates from the body after death, and lives on somewhere else.
It may have been quite natural for Greek Christians to conclude that, since the end had still not come,
perhaps Jesus actually meant that the kingdom of God was in heaven,
and that the righteous would be rewarded by having their soul raised there after death.
Likewise, many Greeks had a concept of the souls of the unrighteous being punished after death.
For those who thought that the righteous would be taken somewhere good and be rewarded after death,
it may have been a natural conclusion that the unrighteous would be taken somewhere terrible to be punished after death.
With all of Jesus' talk of the unrighteous being cast into the shameful, fiery pit of Gehenna,
Christian Gentiles may well have taken this bit of Jewish lore about a physical place in Jerusalem
to actually describe the Greek idea of the afterlife for the unrighteous.
If taken as a Jewish apocalypticist who predicted the imminent coming of God's kingdom,
Jesus seems to have made predictions that weren't ever fulfilled.
Is it any wonder, then, that those who held onto the idea of Jesus being divine
came to a different interpretation of his words than Jesus' contemporaries who viewed him as a Jewish apocalypticist?
The question of whether or not Jesus taught anything about heaven and hell
may have really been a difficult quandary for the early Christians who survived the apostles.
As I hope this video has demonstrated, even our most basic assumptions about Jesus today
have been the subject of debate and disagreement since the beginning.
Even as someone with no theological dog in this fight,
I find the study of these questions and their many theological answers incredibly illuminating.
It's a way we can learn about the cultural sensibilities and psychology of ancient people.
For me, studying the Christian story teaches me about the human story, of which we're all a part.
But while anger and vitriol could certainly be facilitated by this discussion,
I find it more of an exercise in expanding my sense of empathy.
If I found myself in the sociocultural context of, say, an ancient Ebionite,
who's to say I wouldn't live and believe as they did?
The same goes for any other sect. If I were educated in their historical context,
I'd probably find myself in agreement with them.
This is an idea that I try to carry with me day to day.
Disagreements are to be expected, but if I do my best to empathize,
it's clear that most people, shaped by circumstance,
are doing their best to answer life's big questions just as I am.
Alright, I hope you enjoyed this video.
As per usual, I'd like to recommend one of my sources for further reading.
Heaven and Hell is New Testament scholar Bart Ehrman's latest book,
wherein he follows the fascinating evolution of the Judeo-Christian afterlife
from a time when heaven and hell were unheard of up to today.
Read the book either way, but if you'd like to listen to it as an audiobook as I did,
while supporting my channel in the process,
you can get a 30-day free trial from Audible by going to audibletrial.com slash gmskeptic.
The link is in the description as well as the pinned comment.
Thanks for watching. I've been Drew of Genetically Modified Skeptic.
A special thanks to my patrons for their constant love and support.
If you want to hear more from me, subscribe and follow me on social media at the handles below.
As always, if you're an apostate in need,
there are resources linked in the description to help you find community and mental health support.
Remember to be kind to others in the comments.
I'm not really looking forward to this comment section because people are going to be mad at me.
Please be nice to each other.
And until next time, stay skeptical.
