Amendment 3 property tax cut: legal questions, local fees and unfinished rules to watch

Fox - 13 News
14 followers
Nov 22, 2026
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedAmendment 3 aims to cut property taxes by expanding homestead exemptions, but it may result in a \"tax swap\" rather than actual savings. Local governments may offset losses with new dedicated fees or tax rate hikes, while legal challenges regarding residency requirements and funding gaps for rural counties create further uncertainty for homeowners and public services.
Well, the Amendment 3 property tax cut may
not play out the way many voters think.
First, your mortgage company may not lower your escrow payment
until after your first reduced tax bill arrives in late 2027.
And by then, local governments could offset
the cut with new taxes and fees,
leaving you paying the same, or in some cases, more.
What are people going to feel?
If we shift this tax to another place,
did it solve any of our problems?
No, and we'll explain how that can play out in just a moment.
But first, there's a legal issue that could get
at least part of the amendment thrown out in court.
As written, those who are not permanent Florida residents
by December 31st, 2026,
will have to wait five years before getting the expanded exemption.
Attorneys say the five-year wait could
violate equal protection under the law
by penalizing newcomers.
And for perspective, the state Supreme Court struck down
a similar five year residency requirement
for an expanded homestead exemption back in 1982.
So here now, those who miss out could sue to strike down
this amendment three or at least nix the waiting period.
And removing the waiting period would deepen the hit
to local governments and sheriffs are already facing tough choices.
All vacant positions are frozen. There's no new hire.
And to make up for the coming cut,
the Flagler Sheriff just proposed a dedicated property tax.
That's a tax increase to help offset the tax cut.
And other local governments also weighing new dedicated fees for waste,
for stormwater, for fire protection, and more.
That money does not go into the general fund.
It goes to a specific fund.
Dedicated fund to pay for what it's being taxed for.
Well, if or when those fees are added, they'll just show up
in a different part of your same property tax bill.
And those dedicated fees don't depend on the value of your home,
so they're not reduced by your homestead exemption.
That's how a tax cut can become a tax swap.
And since dedicated fees are also the same across the board,
owners of small homes can wind up paying
the same as owners of beachfront mansions,
which takes a bigger bite out of those, of course, with less.
And on top of that, local governments
that haven't reached their rate caps
can also raise tax rates across the board.
As someone who supports Amendment 3 and who is publicly in favor of it,
worked hard to get it passed,
we also have to acknowledge there's no such thing as a free lunch.
That phrase originated in 19th century American
saloons where bartenders advertised a free lunch.
And the catch was that patrons had to buy
at least one drink to get that food.
And the food was deliberately loaded with salt
to make customers thirsty enough to buy
several more rounds of drinks,
which wound up paying for what would have been the price
of the meal or more.
The laws of economics remain undefeated,
and there is still no such thing as a free lunch.
Well, before he leaves office,
Governor DeSantis wants lawmakers to act.
Limiting local governments from just doing an end run around
the amendment and taxing them in other ways.
But the new Senate president isn't in such a rush.
So we do have time in the regular session to talk about it
and to vet the ideas and the issues.
Under Amendment 3, the homestead exemption
for non-school taxes expands from around $50,000 to $150,000 in 2027.
And then it expands again to $250,000 in 2028.
And that raises particular concerns
for so-called fiscally constrained counties.
That is, small, rural counties
that rely heavily on property tax revenue.
Look at those 14 counties.
Once the exemption expands to $250,000...
Around 90 to 97% of the homesteads there would owe
no property tax except for schools.
So how do you handle that?
For the fiscally constrained counties, we're not going to forget them.
We have their back. We're going to figure that out and make that work.
Well to that end the state could create a fund for those counties
but that money comes from
state taxpayers. One taxpayer pot refilled from another
and lawmakers would have to decide
which counties qualify for that help.
Now let's go back to that list of those 14 counties that
would take a disproportionate hit from Amendment 3.
See none of them are in the Tampa Bay area.
Tampa Bay area homeowners could end up helping to fund those counties,
paying new dedicated fees on top
of that while seeing local services cut all at once.
So the legislature has a lot to work out on this.
The core tax cuts take effect automatically,
but the Florida legislature still has some other work to do.
For example, it has to set a procedure for cities
and counties that want to raise homestead exemptions even more all
the way up to exempting homesteads entirely.
Lawmakers are also expected
to write more detailed rules for property appraisers to
follow on this. And that leads to another concern.
You can't always trust the Florida
legislature to even know what it's doing.
For perspective, voters passed a property tax cut
10 years ago, also called Amendment 3.
And as written, that one gave a property tax
exemption to totally
and permanently disabled first responders living in Florida.
But, the legislature had to pass a bill to implement the amendment,
and the fine print
in that bill excluded most totally
and permanently disabled first responders living in Florida.
Myself and my 66 other colleagues that would have
to administer this exemption were shocked.
We found lawmakers who voted for it were also surprised.
It wasn't clear, I think.
They said they excluded most of those first responders by mistake.
One representative added a line stating the injuries had to occur
while serving in Florida or an operation authorized by the state.
And other lawmakers missed it.
And that's our problem. We have a bad, bad communication problem.
Meanwhile, there is something else local governments could do.
The only way to recover some
of that money without tax increases or fee increases
is to increase the tax base of commercial and non-homesteaded property.
Hillsborough Commissioner Harry Cohen
is specifically referring to the city and county deal
to build a new baseball stadium for the Rays.
The passage of Amendment 3 actually makes it more important
for us to have opportunities like this.
And that suggests that Amendment 3 could
also push more local governments
to chase big commercial projects like stadiums to grow their tax bases.
One way or the other, Amendment 3 is going
to drive some interesting discussions of money, power and politics.
