Across Africa: Changing constitutions

Aljazeera
59 followers
2 Video Views·Nov 22, 2026
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedThis report examines a growing trend across Africa where leaders are amending national constitutions to extend presidential term limits or alter election rules. While supporters claim these changes ensure political stability and continuity, critics argue they are strategic power grabs that undermine democratic institutions and the rule of law.
Hello and welcome to Across Africa.
I'm Ahmed Idrees from Nigeria's parliament here in Abuja.
This week we're going to take a look
at how leaders on the continent are changing their
country's constitutions in ways
that critics say will help keep them in power longer.
Hello, I'm Haru Mutasa in Harare, Zimbabwe,
where the constitution has been changed.
The president has been given two more years in office,
delaying elections planned for 2028 to 2030.
And I'm Chris Ochamringa in Kinshasa, DRC,
where a new law could pave the way for a constitutional change
that might extend presidential terms.
Twenty years ago there were heated exchanges in this building
when then President Olusegun
Obasanjo wanted to run for a third term,
a move considered unconstitutional. A constitution
is a country's supreme law.
It's a document setting out how a nation is governed.
Obasanjo's move did not succeed that time,
but today some African leaders are asking
their constituents to scrap age limits,
change how many terms they can have,
as well as the duration of each term,
and even how some presidents are elected.
That's what happened in Zimbabwe.
MPs there just voted to approve the overhaul
of the country's electoral process.
But it's how it happened that is raising concern.
Haru Mutasa is in Harare. She tells us more.
Thank you, Ahmed.
I am now at the National Assembly,
a huge building overlooking the capital.
This is where it all happened, with little opposition.
The lower house of parliament has 280 members.
226 MPs voted to change the constitution.
That's more than two-thirds of the house.
It was the same in the upper house where more than two-thirds
of the senate also voted to amend the constitution.
Here's my report and how people reacted.
Elections planned for 2028 have been delayed to 2030.
That means Zimbabwe's president, Emmerson Mnangagwa,
gets another two years in office.
He took power in 2017 after ousting long-time leader Robert Mugabe
with the backing of the military.
Mnangagwa went on to win disputed elections in 2018 and 2023.
Recent constitutional changes also give MPs,
not voters, the power to elect the president.
Through the recent constitutional amendments,
The party membership and people
of our beloved motherland have bestowed immense trust on ZANU-PF.
Supporters say extending the terms of office
from five years to seven for presidential,
parliamentary and local government
cycles will bring political stability.
We have noted that there is a sequence
which follows a five-year electoral cycle.
Within the first two years, there
is contestation of the previous election.
Within the following, in the third year,
there is mobilization for the next election.
Then in the...
ensuing two years, it becomes heightened political agitation.
So we've seen that this has given room
and allowance for a lot of toxicity to pervade our society.
Critics are challenging recent constitutional changes
in the Constitutional Court.
Anti-government protests don't happen often in Zimbabwe.
To hold a public gathering you need police permission,
and that is rarely, if ever, granted.
So civil society organisations
and opposition leaders tend to fight their battles in the courts.
Some Zimbabweans want a national referendum on the issue.
Is it for the benefit of the people,
because it should go back to the people, is the people
who have made this constitution.
The 2013 constitution was done by the people,
and when you want to amend it, it should go
back to the people, and the people should have a say.
Signs Mnangagwa would stay in power beyond
the end of his second term emerged about two
years ago, when supporters started chanting slogans at party rallies.
I'm starting to speak now.
Continue being in office until 2030.
Saying the president needed more time
to complete his development agenda.
Now some members of his governing ZANU-PF
are calling for Manangagwa to stay until 2037.
Harumata Saljizera, Harare.
Constitutional amendments may be different
from what obtains after a military coup but critics say
they undermine democracy from within and it's not only in Zimbabwe.
Ivory Coast, Togo, Chad,
Central African Republic have all new constitutions that
introduce extending presidential term limits
or changing voting rules. Uganda and Rwanda
have new constitutions that allow
their presidents to stay in power longer.
And Somalia is locked in a dispute over
who is in charge at the end of the term of the president there.
And in Democratic Republic of Congo, that country is inching towards
a process that could see to the extension of term limits.
My colleague in Kinshasa, Chris Ochamringa,
tells us what to expect in coming weeks and months.
Welcome to Macaulay!
Political tensions are running high in the Democratic Republic
of Congo after a plan to change the constitution.
The governing party wants to change several articles,
including one that would lift
a rule limiting presidents to two terms in office.
When we want to change constitution,
it's not particularly one article or two.
It's about the orientation of our constitution.
It's about the vision of the constitution.
In May, President Felix Tshisekedi said he would run
for a third term in 2028 if the Congolese people asked him to.
That prompted opposition leaders to form what they called
the Coalition 64 platform to stop him.
It's named after Article 64 of the Constitution, which calls
on citizens to oppose anyone who seizes power unconstitutionally.
We have already made it clear that 2028 is the red line.
President Tshisekedi must step down.
He has had ample time to organize the country
and bring the war in the East to an end.
As the opposition, we have called for the launch of an inclusive
political dialogue as the only path to resolving the crisis.
The President responded to their call
and promised to hold a national dialogue.
The DRC constitution prohibits any amendments during a war
or a state of siege,
both of which are in place in the east after years of conflict.
However, the president's supporters want him to stay in office.
Let's go.
Let's allow President Felix Tshisekedi
to continue leading this country. He has great
ideas. He's worked hard and I believe he can take us much further.
Opposition members held protests in Kinshasa, which police broke up.
They called off another demonstration in July,
ahead of the national dialogue.
Many of these young opposition supporters
say they're determined to keep protesting
until the government withdraws its proposal.
But despite the vocal opposition from some parts of society,
the government appears committed to the idea of constitutional change.
Political rivals fear it will pave the way
for President Felix Tshisekedi to extend his time in office beyond 2028,
something they strongly oppose.
Chris Ochamringa, Al Jazeera, Kinshasa.
Critics argue democracy is already fragile in many African countries,
weakened by corruption, a lack of development and rising poverty.
With me now is Clement Nwankwo, Executive Director,
Policy and Legal Advocacy Center, Nigeria.
Clement, leaders call this constitutional amendment.
Is it a genuine effort or an attempt at power grab?
I think when you have constitutional amendments
sometimes it's driven by people wanting to
improve the constitutional framework of the country
as we see with Nigeria but in a lot of
cases we have seen constitutions being amended
because incumbents are intent in amending the
constitution to keep themselves in power
and when they do that they destroy the basis of
constitutionalism which is the basis of democracy in any country.
And how do these changes affect good governance
and democracy in Africa?
Because for an incumbent to seek to amend the constitution
to give themselves extended tenure it means that they have weakened all
of the institutions that protect democracy,
whether it's strong political parties,
strong parliaments or independent parliaments, a judiciary
and indeed using the appurtenances of power and the privileges
of power to influence and purchase more power for themselves.
And why are we seeing these changes now?
I think that when you have a situation where
the world is also getting to a stage where
the regional constraints or even
the international constraints against abuse of power and extension
of power is weakening, then there is a challenge.
You still have a situation where
the international community was quite active.
The peer review systems within the continent
It was also very effective in restraining what you call brother
or sister African presidents
from entrenching themselves in power.
All of that is collapsing,
especially given that from the West you also have a situation
where very little emphasis is being placed now on democracy,
and most of it now is about
bilateral relations, trade,
and profits from relationships with African countries.
So in a situation where relationship with countries
is not based on respect for human rights and the rule of law,
but much more on exploitation and trade and investment,
then you are bound to see that internationally,
the international organizations, foreign governments
are so much more interested in building investments
for their country in Africa
rather than in promoting democracy and human rights.
Is it all bad news or there is some good coming out of it?
Well, I think there are countries where you have seen resistance
to extend their tenure.
Nigeria is one of such countries where you did see
the Nigerian legislature stand back
against the previous president
who wanted to extend his tenure. The parliament was
strong enough to push back on this.
I'm not quite sure how independent the Nigerian
legislature has remained since then
because you have seen increasingly a more powerful
President in Nigeria in recent years
and I think for all of us it's a constant watch to see
that we can push back against extended tenure ambitions.
Clement Nwanko, thank you for your
time. As more governments rewrite the rules
the question is whether these changes strengthen
democracy. For millions across the continent
the debate could shape not only who governs them
but for how long. That's it on Across Africa this week.
Back to our studio in Doha.
