Easy, Medium, Expert: Which Old Fashioned Wins?

Fan Wine Cellar
Fan Wine Cellar
14 followers
Nov 22, 2026  #wine #winetasting #drink

#wine #winetasting #drink #cocktail

The Old Fashioned is over 200 years old and still one of the best drinks around. So can modern technique actually make it better? Here are three Old Fashioneds, each one stacking a technique on top of the last: a Black Forest Old Fashioned, a butter-washed Banana Bread Old Fashioned, and a PB&J Old Fashioned with peanut butter washed whiskey and a milk-clarified strawberry syrup. Two of them I'd serve tomorrow. One let me down.

All three recipes are in my free app, along with 1,200 more cocktails you can make, rate and add your own to: https://bartend.link/cocktails-by-steve

CHAPTERS
0:00 Can modern technique beat the classic?
0:27 Black Forest Old Fashioned
3:36 What makes a drink an Old Fashioned?
4:41 Banana Bread Old Fashioned (butter washing)
7:31 Leandro's version beat mine
8:20 Where fat washing came from
9:50 The honey syrup fix
10:30 PB&J Old Fashioned
13:52 Tasting the PB&J
15:37 Take two with a different strawberry syrup
18:13 Which ones would I actually serve?

THE RECIPES

BLACK FOREST OLD FASHIONED
30 ml (1 oz) bourbon (I used Buffalo Trace)
30 ml (1 oz) cognac (Hennessy VSOP)
7.5 ml (1/4 oz) crème de cacao (Tempus Fugit)
7.5 ml (1/4 oz) Cherry Heering
3 dashes chocolate bitters
Stir over ice. Garnish: a cherry

BANANA BREAD OLD FASHIONED
60 ml (2 oz) butter-washed bourbon (Buffalo Trace)
10 ml (1/3 oz) banana liqueur (Tempus Fugit Crème de Banane)
5 ml (1 tsp) demerara syrup
5 ml (1 tsp) honey syrup, 3:1 by volume
1 dash tiki bitters (Bittermens)
Stir over ice. Garnish: grated cinnamon

Make it better: add a touch of honey syrup. That's what made it pop. Leandro's version (Banana Bread Old Fashioned #2 in the app) also splits the base with Smith & Cross.

Butter-washed bourbon: melt some butter and add it to your bourbon. Leave it overnight, move it to the freezer until the butter sets into a solid cap, then lift the cap off and strain through a coffee filter. For more nutty, brown butter notes, take the butter a little further on the stove first.

PB&J OLD FASHIONED
60 ml (2 oz) peanut butter washed whiskey
7.5 ml (1/4 oz) strawberry syrup (Liber & Co was the better version)
2 dashes Angostura bitters
Stir over ice. Garnish: a strawberry

Peanut butter whiskey: add 100 g of peanut butter to a flat-bottomed container, pour a bottle of whiskey over it and leave it overnight. Move it to the freezer, then strain it through a coffee filter.

Strawberry whey syrup: blend strawberries with milk, add lemon juice so the curds split, then filter until it runs clear. Sweeten it 1:1 into a syrup. It's delicious on its own, but it gets lost in a spirit forward drink, so try it in something more delicate.