Mastering the art of soft and fluffy potato dinner rolls!

Bigger Bolder Baking with Gemma Stafford
2 followers
Nov 19, 2026
Well Bakers, your day just got a whole lot better because you're about to learn how
to make insanely fluffy mashed potato rolls and I'm going to give you my five top tips
for making bread rolls at home.
They're so easy and once you know how to do them, you're going to make the best rolls
this holiday season.
The mashed potato is our secret ingredient which makes them really soft.
It's just a few basic bread ingredients and our first one, of course, is just leftover
mashed potato.
You have it from your dinner, you can even buy good quality in the store.
I have this because I love mashed potato, obviously.
But I will tell you, if you're going to buy it in the store, just make sure it's made
from potatoes and not potato flakes.
You want the real deal here.
So that's going to go into our stand mixer.
Now the reason I love this recipe is because it's leftover mashed potato.
It's not like just steamed potatoes or cooked potatoes like you see in other recipes.
This can just be mashed potatoes with butter, cream, milk, your salt and your pepper, everything
in there already which makes it so much easier.
So now my first tip for my bread rolls, I don't do 100% water, I do half and half milk
and water.
I'll tell you why.
It adds extra fat and it enriches the dough so it gives you that buttery kind of a bread
rather than like a kind of more savory white bread, you know?
The melted butter, same deal.
More moisture, more fat, more flavor.
So my next tip for making the best bread rolls at home is make sure your dough is enriched
with eggs.
You know, we use eggs a lot in brioches and challah doughs and things like that but we
don't use them often in bread rolls and it really does make a difference.
We have our beater on here, we're just going to mix these all together until it's blended.
I like to start this with my flat beater, what they call a K-beater, they used to call
it that, until it's combined.
Bread rolls are a big part of the holidays, I know we have turkey and all our sides and
everything like that, ham, but every year the most popular recipe on my website is actually
dinner rolls for this time of year.
People go crazy for them.
It's just a lovely, a compliment to add to the rest of your meal, especially when they're
homemade, fresh from the oven, still warm.
Okay, that's mixed.
Our next ingredient and my next tip is flour.
What kind of flour should you use for making bread rolls?
The answer is all-purpose, plain flour.
That is what you want for making bread rolls.
When you get that roll that just kind of disappears in your mouth, that's because of the all-purpose
flour.
If you use a strong flour, a bread flour that has around 13% protein, it'll make a roll
chewy and that's not what you want from a bread roll.
So that's our flour, then into this goes a little bit of sugar because that feeds our
yeast.
Saying that, next is our yeast, instant yeast.
If you're using active yeast, I'll put a note on the website about that, but I like to use
instant yeast because it just goes straight in with the other ingredients.
And then, of course, our salt.
I'm always generous with the salt in bread because it really does knead it.
Now let's just knead this until it comes together on around a medium speed.
Because this is a big dough, it's going to take around 8-10 minutes to knead.
You can try doing this dough by hand, it will just be a little bit harder, but it's not
impossible.
Okay, so that's been a few minutes.
My dough has kind of firmed up.
Just so you know, I want you to see this, this is a soft dough because of the mashed
potatoes.
So don't worry about the texture.
You know, often I say a dough has to come together to form a ball and that is the case
for most doughs, but not this one.
Oh my gosh.
Look how lovely it is.
I love enriched doughs because they have this color between the mashed potato and the
butter and the eggs.
It's a nice kind of golden color.
So that is our dough.
I'm just going to pop it into a bowl now that I have greased with a little bit of oil.
Okay, lovely.
So now we are going to do our first proof.
So we are going to cover it in cling wrap, like so.
Put a tea towel over it for extra snugness.
And then we're going to proof this dough for an hour and a half, roughly.
A dough like this that's a bit on the heavier side can be quite sluggish, so you're not
going to see it like double in size.
It will proof and it will rise, but it's not going to be huge, so just an FYI.
But just give it that time and it will be ready to go after that.
So it has been an hour and a half and our dough has risen.
Look at that.
I want you to see how beautiful that is.
Lovely.
This is such a lovely dough to work with because it's literally as light as air.
Okay, I'm going to stop mauling it now because people have to eat this.
I have a little bit of flour here for my counter, not too much.
And now what we want to do is divvy up our rolls into 12 even portions.
If you want to weigh them, your rolls want to be a little bit under 4 ounces each, which
gives you lovely big rolls.
Now here's my fourth tip about bread rolls.
The rolling.
Some people find this really hard and what happens, and I see this every year, is that
people can't get a smooth roll and when you don't get a smooth roll, you end up, the creases
don't bake out and it ends up being a little bit knobbly, which is such a shame because
everyone's always looking for that perfectly shaped roll.
So here's what we're going to do.
I'm going to show you how to get that perfect shape.
We're going to take a piece of dough, kind of fold the rough bits all to the bottom.
Now here's what we're going to do.
We're going to take our hand and we're going to push the roll into the countertop until
you can feel it forming underneath your hands to make the perfect bread roll.
As you can see, it is totally smooth, but also, flip it over, no seams.
And if you have no seams, then it is perfect.
When you have the seams, they don't bake out so you get these creases.
So into your pan, it has been oiled, it's 9 by 13, and we are going to do 4 lines of
3.
Let me show you again, really quickly.
Pull everything back.
There.
Flip them over.
Into the counter, push it in, swirl it around with this cup in your hand, just like this.
And this is, look at that, see the way it's shaping the roll for you?
You don't have to do hardly any work, a little bit of pressure on the roll and what you end
up with is a beautifully smooth roll all around and no seam.
You guys got this, I know you do.
That makes 12.
That's our last one.
And just so you know, because it's the holidays and there's a lot of people around, if you
want to double this recipe, it is very forgiving and you can do that easily.
Cling wrap over the top, a tea towel for extra snugness.
So now you want to set these aside to proof at room temperature for another 45 minutes
to an hour or so.
We want to see them rise up and then also proof into each other so they're kind of like
batch baking when we bake them later.
Okay, so it's been a little less than an hour actually, I gave them a little bit longer,
but check this out.
I want you to, come here to me Joey, I want you to show everybody what they're supposed
to look like.
Do you see the way they've proofed into each other?
You see the way they've risen quite a bit?
This is exactly what we're going for.
If they're not at this stage, let them proof for longer.
Now here's your tip number five when it comes to bread rolls, and this is an important one.
When is the right time to bake them off?
Are they proofed or are they not proofed?
What am I looking for?
I'm going to show you now.
Put your finger in one little roll.
If your indentation stays there and it doesn't jump back really fast, then it's proofed and
ready to go into the oven.
If you put your finger in and it pops back really fast, then they need more time to proof,
so cover them up and give them another few minutes.
But this is exactly what I'm going for.
Just when they look like this.
If you overproof a bread roll, I will tell you, once it goes into the oven, they can
collapse and you will see that on the bread roll, and it's a bit of a bummer.
But these right now are looking good to me, so the last thing I'm going to do is gently,
because it is a delicate bread roll, gently egg wash them before they go in.
And just make sure, take your time with the egg wash.
I always am really careful with bread rolls and egg washing because if you don't get them
all over, they can seem kind of dry, and you really want these to be a beautiful golden
brown, just like the way you'd see a challah or a brioche, because that's what they're
more akin to than anything else.
Done with the egg wash, now let's get them into our preheated oven.
Bake your rolls at 350 degrees Fahrenheit, 180 degrees Celsius for roughly 25 to 30 minutes
until they're lovely golden brown, it's really what you want on top.
Our rolls are baked and they look beautiful, look how shiny and golden brown they are,
and they smell so buttery.
You'll often hear me say, let a loaf of bread cool down before you cut into it, but that
does not apply with bread rolls.
I would say just dig in and enjoy while they're still hot and steamy, just like these ones.
These rolls will be very well received at any get-together this holiday season.
Look at that crumb, do you see how beautiful that dough is on the inside?
They look great, they smell great, and just look at how soft they are.
They're like airy little pillows.
Bold Bakers save this recipe, it's a must for your holiday table.
If you're in the mood for more holiday content, then don't go anywhere, I've got hours more
holiday videos for you to check out.
I'll see you back here again really soon.
