The Brewers are letting Dustin May walk...
Nov 18, 2026
The Brewers are letting Dustin May walk.
It's not too surprising of a decision,
as May was acquired from the St. Louis Cardinals at the trade deadline.
But still, it's a name that is lost to a team in the Chicago White Sox.
It's not the Chicago Cubs, but it is the White Sox in the AL Central.
We're going to be talking about all
that on today's episode of Brewers Digest.
We know with the World Series comes a lot of players
that were impactful in your World Series run.
And their time with the team in Milwaukee coming to an end.
That has been the case for a couple of guys.
Jake Bowers will have a video out on that with a lot
of more details reviewed about that.
And also now with Dustin May.
But the big news is how May signed
a contract with the Chicago White Sox.
And you honestly have to be really happy for May.
It's been a career, you know,
really defined by tons and tons of injuries.
He was able to find his footing this year
in split time with St. Louis and Milwaukee.
And May signed a really big contract right here
with the Chicago White Sox,
a three-year, $52.5 million deal.
But that does mean that he will
no longer be with the Milwaukee Brewers.
But I was really happy with May's time in Milwaukee.
Started off strong, definitely fizzled out a little bit,
But was still impactful really being able to just be.
Be that arm, you know, be that for starter for that bullpen game.
I know he had his lows giving up the homer to Otani,
but even after that, he was able
to pitch scoreless innings of baseball.
And even in the game that the Brewers
are unfortunately not able to get the job done,
may still pitch pretty well in that one as well against the Rays.
So he was impactful in the playoffs for the Brewers,
and it will be a name in the that
started in the starting rotation,
moved a little bit to the bullpen that will no longer
be wearing a Brewers uniform.
We're going to look at the full, you know, release right here.
Here it was announced it was 52
and a half million dollars, but initially.
Initially, by Robert Murray on X, it says free agent pitcher Dustin May
and the Chicago White Sox are in agreement
on a three-year contract worth just north of $50 million.
That's how you got to the $52.5 million,
according to sources familiar with the deal.
So $52.5 million, I think, is a sizable amount of money for Dustin May.
Nothing to him.
Rather, I should say, it'd be a sizable amount
of money for the Brewers to bring back Dustin May.
And that's the question that I have for you guys.
Would you have wanted the Brewers
to sign May for three years, $52.5 million?
I personally say no.
because the Brewers are really good with their young pitchers.
paying them on these cheap, you know, rookie type contracts.
Misurrowski making south of a million dollars.
Logan Henderson, south of a million dollars.
They usually do not have veterans in their rotation.
And when they do, it's a guy like Dustin May,
who is just a half of season and you don't have to pay him much.
So I say no, but you guys can let me know yes or no in the comments,
kind of with your reasoning and your thoughts on it.
But you do have to, again, be very happy for Dustin May.
It's a guy who loved everything he brought to Milwaukee.
I know he definitely had those rough stints,
but he was able to be consistent.
He was able to be healthy.
He was able to be in there for the Milwaukee Brewers
when guys like Kyle Harrison started to really fade
in what their season was looking like.
He was able to step in and really make an impact.
We have to, you know, be very excited for May.
He won a World Series with the Brewers.
Obviously, he is no longer here.
Put that a little bit in black and white.
But he has won four World Series in his MLB career.
So the Chicago White Sox are getting
a guy that might be a good luck charm.
If he's just on your roster,
your chances of making the World Series might just go up based on that.
But no, all jokes aside, he's had three with Los Angeles,
got this one with Milwaukee.
He is now what you can call a veteran.
And we can take a look at what he did
with the Milwaukee Brewers this season.
And his numbers, I know they do not pop off the page too much.
Now here's kind of a comparison, regular season to playoffs,
when we talk about his impact in the playoffs.
He did not have as many strikeouts per nine,
definitely more balls being hit in play for outs.
When you look at the ERA, it was definitely north of a 4.7 and a 5.73,
but you still see some of the other numbers, like his WHIP.
It was less than his regular season WHIP.
Because when he'd give up a hit, it would kind of be a big one,
like we talked about with that Ohtani home run in NLCS Game 4,
which the Brewers ended up winning nonetheless.
That's kind of what we've seen from Dustin May.
But maybe you're a White Sox fan watching this video,
wanting to know what you're getting from May.
Well, here are some key insights on Dustin May to know.
Kind of some positives.
He throws about as hard as anybody in the league.
He averages a 92.6 miles per hour
on his pitches across his entire arsenal.
That puts him at the 88th percentage in all of Major League Baseball.
And also, the movement on his baseballs,
they're more than the hitters expected to.
His stuff spins at 2,504 RPM,
which is also the 88th percentile in the league.
He fills the strike zone and makes hitters beat him.
That is where the ERA definitely influxes because,
you know, he really pumps it in the zone.
And that is what his kind of game is.
You see the positivities.
His pitch is moving a lot.
His speed of his pitch is being very high.
When the ERA is north of four, it's just
because hitters have been able to connect.
But we know the Chicago White Sox,
this was a team that had a huge bounce back here this year.
They might be able to turn May into an even better
version than we saw with the Milwaukee Brewers.
And those are just some key insights.
We take a look at May right here, which
I'll actually throw this on the big screen.
This is his pitch breakdown on what he threw this year with the...
St. Louis Cardinals and Milwaukee Brewers,
he mostly threw a four-seam fastball, which
came in just shy of 97 miles per hour on average.
Then he has that cutter that was 93 and a half,
a sinker that is just shy of 97 in its
own, a sweeper, a curve, and a changeup.
So that's why when you see his average arsenal, you know.
Being in the 88th percentile, that is very impressive
when you're throwing a curveball
and a changeup and a sweeper for it to still
be some of the top stuff when you take all
of your pitches in your arsenal.
Again, I'll flash that up once more for you guys,
some of the keys to know about Dustin
May.
Even though this is a name that will no longer
be with the Milwaukee Brewers, this is what
we saw with him this season.
And these are going to be the things that
will be interesting to see when he leaves
the Brewers if he gets better.
This is nothing towards the Brewers organization.
We know if there's an organization that turns a pitcher better,
it's really hard to be better
than the Milwaukee Brewers, maybe Tampa Bay Rays.
Cleveland Guardians are good examples,
but May has the stuff. He really has, you know,
the analytical numbers that you love to see in some arms,
and it just, you know, it worked in
Milwaukee. I don't think it really exploded,
if that kind of makes sense, when you really
think of what he did. But we're going
to take a look at Dustin May's stats.
Over his career as well, and look at this career for him.
We talk about it.
It's a career plagued by injuries,
but his last two seasons, he's really been able to
put it together.
You see at the top is his 2026 season,
where he started the most games in his MLB career.
At 31, he was able to acquire seven wins to a ratio of nine losses.
His 4.7 ERA, that was over 145 and two-thirds innings pitch.
If you look earlier in his career, you know,
definitely some lower ERAs, but it's just
a lower sample size in the games.
I mean, you could say, hey, you know what?
I think 2023 was his best season.
But yeah, that's over nine starts.
It's not over 23.
It's not over 31.
So the White Sox have been able to watch May get
a little bit more understanding of what
his full season can bring if they bring him
in to be that starter on a three-year, $52.5
million contract, and what he can bring at a bigger sample size.
Now, I don't know if Dustin May will really be a starting pitching one.
I don't think that's what they're bringing him in to be.
They're bringing him in to leave Milwaukee
and bring him into Chicago to maybe be a four
or five.
So White Sox team that made the playoffs this year, they had a
at 2-0 lead in the DS that they unfortunately lost three straight.
So May could be that veteran piece that knows how to win.
Pat Murphy also gave him a lot of praise in the playoffs
when May was on the roster and
he was getting those opportunities,
which a lot of people obviously were 50-50 on.
Really saying that, you know, May has the experience.
You know, pitching in the playoffs
is so different than pitching in the regular season.
May has the experience.
And again, I know it didn't turn out like a perfect upgrade in that,
but he still sustained some pretty good numbers,
and he obviously deserved that ring.
It was a little unfortunate to see him go just
because he was connecting with the Milwaukee community really well.
He was at the awards.
He was, you know, courtside at a Bucks game
and things like that that we've seen.
But he no longer will be there.
He'll be taking his talents to Chicago.
Luckily, it's the White Sox, not the Cubs.
It's not yet another brewer that tries to go to Chicago
and do something with their career.
But no, he will be joining a Chicago White Sox team.
That is very good.
But that's all the news that we got on Dustin May.
It's definitely a sizable loss.
I'm going to be talking about, you know,
a little bit more down the road.
With May now being on the Chicago White Sox,
kind of what can the Brewers do?
How are they going to be able to replace him?
And will it just be someone in the system?
Could they go after a free agent?
There's going to be lots of talks about this because
the reality with the Milwaukee Brewers,
when you win a World Series,
kind of with any team that isn't a top, top big market,
You're going to lose some players.
They've lost Jake Bowers.
They've now lost May.
They probably will not bring back a guy like JoJo Romero,
who was also in that package with May.
This is going to be the reality of the team.
But the Brewers have the top farm system,
and that's also kind of the other reality.
They want to keep their younger talent.
They're cheaper.
They could be, you know, healthier
because they are these younger stars.
Obviously less experience, so it's a little bit of a risk.
This is what the Brewers are going to be dealing with.
So we're going to make sure to track all
of that and more on what the Milwaukee Brewers
will do with their young talent,
or if they'll bring in a veteran in a position like May.
But acquiring May at the trade deadline, no,
it wasn't Schubel, but it still resulted
in a World Series ring, actually defeating Schubel's team
in the Dodgers to get to that
World Series.
May and Romero.
Two big additions that both made the playoff roster
and had a huge impact in Milwaukee.
So obviously hoping to, you know, or wishing rather, I should say,
Dustin May to have a successful career in Chicago.
No hard feelings there.
It's going to be really exciting to see what he's able to put together.
But again, once more for you guys, you let me know,
would you have one of the Brewers to sign May
for this three-year 52 and a half?
I just say no.
That is more just to how the Brewers really work with their team
rather than Dustin May as a player.
There's a reason why the Brewers don't bring many of these back.
Obviously, this was losing May.
To just another team signing him,
but we've seen the Brewers trade a lot of guys
with just a year left on their contract.
This being a different example,
it's not too surprising that they're not bringing him back.
But again, that's all I got for this episode of Brewers Digest.
I appreciate you guys tuning in as always.
We're going to have lots to talk about about the crew.
Really break down this Jake Bowers news as it is officially official.
As of today, the Brewers put out a post just about
an hour ago thanking Jake Bowers for
everything, and then also a pitcher
that the Brewers did acquire that will be sitting
hopefully in the back end of their bullpen
by the time that the end of the 2027 season
is around.
So make sure to stay tuned in for all of that news on Brewers Digest.
You can follow the channel right here.
It's one click of a button.
It's easy.
Also, you can find multiple clips
of this on the Facebook page if you maybe don't have
time to watch every episode, which I totally understand.
But always signing off,
talking about your 2026 World Series champion Brewers.
Which I'll never get tired of saying that sentence.
But I'll be back in a couple of hours talking about another pitcher
that is in Milwaukee despite the departure of Dustin May.

