Brooklyn Building Collapse: First civil lawsuit filed, criminal charges possible

Fox - 5 NY
45 followers
Nov 16, 2026
This morning, families are mourning
the eight people killed in last week's building collapse
in Brooklyn, the community, of course,
rallying around those who've been left behind, a funeral
for 26-year-old construction worker Jose Luis Cahuana.
He is being laid to rest today at St. Barbara Roman Catholic Church.
I think we have some images from just a little while ago,
some of the mourners arriving,
showing his picture there.
Clearly a fan of soccer. His Barcelona jersey is what he
was wearing in that photo that they had right there.
And this is them carrying his casket inside.
Of course, Cahuana was working at the site when the building collapsed,
collapsed at 1321 Flatbush Avenue and brought down part of...
Brought down part of an adjacent building.
I mean, we talked about this story so much last week,
and there's more to talk about this morning.
Eight people were killed, 18 others injured.
He was one of them, Cahuana residents and members of the faith community
held prayers near the site.
Bethesda Church of God across the street from the collapse,
collecting a lot of donations.
The church across the street there has become
a real hub for relief efforts,
and you can see this morning friends and family.
Coming to say goodbye to this 26-year-old construction worker,
one of the eight victims who...
Who is being laid to rest this morning.
We did just get some entertainment news
that we're going to tell you about in just a second.
Somebody just handed me a piece of paper,
so I want to let you know about that.
We're going to let you know about that.
But before we go on to that story,
I do want to bring in Francis Wang, if we can.
Because, Francis, I want to keep talking, if we can,
about the building collapse out in Brooklyn.
Thank you.
Because you have an exclusive story this morning.
What's going on with what's happening there?
So I actually just obtained the court filings.
The steps to pursue legal action in a civil case have begun.
At least one of the construction workers
who claims he was injured on this job site after
that building collapsed last Wednesday has now lawyered up.
And this morning I actually spoke
with his attorney about what they believe happened there.
Thank you.
So it's a bit complicated at this point
because we're still talking about the criminal case.
You actually had an attorney this morning
on Good Day speaking about that.
Yes, Arthur.
So that's going to delay the civil litigation.
But this lawyer actually said the contractor in question,
who we talked about extensively in a report that was put out on Friday,
is no stranger to him.
In fact, he's actually represented several clients
and sued this contractor before.
He actually provided a photo that he received
from some of the construction workers
who voiced to him that they were concerned about the safety of it all.
In this complaint, multiple defendants are named,
including the contractor as well as the owner
of the building that actually collapsed.
So is this one of the first, if not the first,
of the civil attorneys that we're hearing from?
Thank you.
Could potentially file this side of it.
I mean, I know we're looking still at the possibility
of the criminal charges that could evolve here.
But is this one of the first civil cases
that we're seeing being filed and moving forward?
Yes. In fact, the lawyer you spoke with, Arthur,
this morning said lawyers are all over this right now.
As you would imagine.
When I went through a search of court records Friday
and then again this morning,
this is the only one I found thus far.
All right, so we do have two pieces of sound.
Are they both together on the same clip here?
For Idella, yes.
No, no, not for Idella, for the, yeah.
This one's wrong.
All right, so they're both on the same clip.
This is the guy I interviewed.
So in his first soundbite,
you're going to hear him talk about
what the workers allege to him happened
when it comes to the construction site
and the excavation activity,
the underpinning and the shoring of it.
He actually said the building owner did not...
I do not want them to shore it up
because he was concerned that that would cause cracks
and damage to his property.
That's the allegation in this lawsuit?
That's the allegation.
Okay.
And so you're going to hear the lawyer
describe what you'll also see in the photo,
which we'll show.
Okay.
And then in the second sound bite, I'll explain that after.
It's a bit complicated, but this is someone
who's been in this field for 40 years and
he said he's never seen anything like this.
This actually has to do with the permitting process
and another document that we were able to obtain.
So let's play the interview, and then
I'll explain a little bit more after.
Okay.
Several of the workers that were there at the time of the accident
is that the adjacent building owner didn't want shoring attached
to his building because he thought it would be damaged.
So then what happened is that the contractors,
I believe it was a lead contractor who's the employer,
then created kind of this third world solution of banking dirt
up against the building six feet high along the unshored.
Part of the building and then covering it with two inches of concrete.
We found no permits and instead what we found
was a hold harmless indemnity statement issued by the owner
of the property to the Department of Buildings agreeing to indemnify
and hold the Department of Buildings harmless.
If there was any litigation arising
from this job site prior to the issuance of permits,
which to me is just incredible.
I mean, I've been doing this for 40 years
and I've never seen something like that where
an owner had agreed in writing to hold
the Department of Buildings harmless and then
proceeded to perform work prior to the issuance of permits.
So given that, I have real doubts and real questions as to what exactly
is going on in the Department of Buildings prior to this accident.
That's an interview that you just did with the civil attorney
who has just filed the lawsuit.
Just to put it in context here, what we're looking
at is the casket of one of the construction workers who died.
Who who was who was just taken out of the funeral home.
Tyler, I think that there is there may be an interview or something
that's happening now. Maybe it's a scene. I just want to take a listen.
I just want to bring people into this moment.
Some of the raw emotions that are still very much still very much
a part of this case. Let's take a listen.
Thank you very much.
It's hard to listen to. That's happening right now.
This is the funeral for a 26-year-old.
His name is Jose Luis Cajuana.
I'm not sure if I'm pronouncing his last name correctly.
Exactly.
That funeral is this morning
at St. Barbara Roman Catholic Church, happening now.
Thank you.
Thank you very much.
He is one of eight who was killed.
Your story now is that the civil side of things are moving forward
and you're familiar with his case, correct?
I mean, this is something that you talked to somebody about.
Yeah, we actually spoke with one of his mentors on Friday
who told us that he has a child but also has a pregnant wife,
Dan, who was actually due Sunday.
So the devastation is just unimaginable.
I spoke with the attorney about this, too.
One thing we've learned from both the mentor as well
as the attorney is many of the construction workers.
In this specific job site, we're not union.
Many of them were from countries such as Ecuador.
In the case of Jose Luis Cajuana, 26 years old.
It's just absolutely devastating.
The attorney kind of talked about how a lot
of these construction workers are exploited
and taken advantage of in these situations
because they are working for so much less.
They're not union.
And a lot of times the safety precautions
that maybe should be taken are not.
And he's alleging some of these contractors.
Cut corners, essentially.
Certainly would all be part
of the investigation that is moving forward.
Allegations at this point, proven in law, not yet.
What could happen on the criminal side of things,
definitely a real issue.
Will there be a manslaughter, a negligence,
a reckless endangerment of some kind charge?
We actually spoke with Arthur Idalla.
A criminal defense attorney, trial attorney, just a short time ago,
as we're still taking a look at this funeral that is underway
for one of the construction workers who was killed.
Okay, so let's take a listen to this piece of sound with Arthur Aydala.
We're also hearing about the guy who owned the site.
They're saying he's a notorious slumlord.
But the thing is this.
So now when you say slumlord,
you're thinking this guy is cutting corners.
Except I looked at the violations.
They're like for bedbugs and leaks
and things that don't bring a building down.
It really looks like the building wasn't shored up the right way.
They're digging next to it.
It's almost a 100-year-old building.
It's built on rubble.
It's built on a loose foundation to begin with.
So they're going to go back to the original drawings.
And they're going to look, okay, who made the drawings?
Now, that engineer is supposed to make sure it complies to all safety.
Then they give it to the Department of Buildings.
Ding, ding, ding.
Department of Buildings right now is 10% under capacity.
Did they not have enough hands on deck to approve it?
Well, because we knew, right?
We knew back in March that they wanted to do some extra work there.
Right, and it was stopped there, and they went back.
Do we know if the Department of Buildings went back
to that site and double-checked
or triple-checked to make sure that they
were adhering to what they were supposed to?
That's what they're looking at.
They're going to be looking at attendance records.
And in the past.
In the past, some engineers have faked attendance records.
Engineers who work for the city have gone to jail
because they signed that they went somewhere
and investigated when they did not.
The city has already announced, and they did this in my case too,
they're hiring an independent engineering company,
someone who has no skin in the game, to do an analysis.
And then they'll all go to Brooklyn DA Eric Gonzalez.
But won't he be doing his own investigation?
I mean, the city is doing it, or does he sort of...
Yeah, I mean, the truth is, Dan,
Brooklyn DA doesn't really have the resources.
Because you have to become like an engineer in itself.
Believe me, I'll tell you this real quick.
When I tried the crane case, after my guy was found not guilty,
All my friends were like,
Aydala, we thought you were
We thought you were committing malpractice.
Like, what the heck do you know about cranes?
But I learned, you know, in a year and a half.
I climbed cranes.
I read books on cranes.
It's the same thing.
You have to learn.
Now, Eric Gonzalez has great lawyers there.
So he will have some people figuring out the engineering stuff.
Is it like a negligence?
Negligence.
In terms of criminality.
Yes.
A negligence, a manslaughter.
Because people died.
I mean, what are we thinking?
In my case, we're charged with manslaughter.
It's a reckless.
It could be criminally negligent.
It can be a negligent homicide.
It can be a recklessness.
Obviously, there's no intent, right?
There's no, let's dig it out
so that we're going to bring the building down.
So it's criminally negligent or criminal recklessness.
That's what they look towards.
But there's going to, everyone's looking,
and then there's the inspector general of
the city of New York.
They're going to look at what the Department of Buildings did.
They're going to look at what the Department of Transportation did.
They're going to make sure everyone did the right thing.
So there's going to be literally,
maybe not hundreds, but dozens of investigators.
The feds will be involved.
I mean, it's a real tragedy
that we have to make sure
there's construction going on
everywhere around us.
Every block in Manhattan.
Yeah.
In the town in Upper East Side.
All right, so take a listen
to that interview that Roseanne
and I did on Good Day New York
this morning with Arthur Aydala
on the possibility
of criminal charges.
Somebody's handing me
something here.
Okay, so this is about
our entertainment story
that's coming up next.
It has to do with James Bond.
They finally made a casting for that.
We'll talk about that
after the break.
But do want to stay with this,
obviously very serious
story. Last word from you on this, Frances.
Yeah, one thing that Arthur mentioned too in
terms of the independent investigation,
someone who has no skin in the game, that's something I
actually asked this attorney about.
That is why he brought up this hold harmless agreement. What
he said in his 40 years he's never seen,
essentially the contractor, the company saying
to the DOB, if there's litigation involved,
we will cover the legal fees. That's how he
explained it to me. That's how I understood it.
So that was the answer to me asking him,
what do you think about the DOB investigating
this in an independent agency company?
Francis Wang, thank you very much.
Taking one last look at the funeral this morning,
the funeral for one of the construction workers
who was killed, 26-year-old Jose Luis Cahuana,
this morning, St. Barbara Roman Catholic Church.
He was one of eight who was killed at that site last week.
As Francis just reported, you heard it here first on Newsroom Live,
some of the civil lawsuits
We're going to take a break and we'll be right back after this.
