'Major chilling effect': Former NYPD detective criticizes Mamdani for disbanding protest unit

Fox - 5 NY
45 followers
Nov 16, 2026
When there's a protest here in New York City,
it is often about some of those global issues.
It's often about things
that are resonating anywhere in the United States.
And you see those protests in one way
or another playing out across the streets of New York,
whether it's the Black Lives Movement
or some of those that you're seeing there,
people who are protesting the war in Gaza.
Well, now Mayor Mamdani and Police Commissioner Jessica Tisch say
the NYPD Strategic Response Group
will no longer handle protests.
The plan would move to the units...
counterterrorism work to an existing NYPD bureau,
while a civilian team and specialized
officers will respond to demonstrations.
So it's a big change.
We want to bring in former NYPD detective David Sarney,
also currently a professor at
John Jay.
David, I guess first,
just can you describe to us what it is that historically, for the
last several years, that the SRG has done?
Well, the Strategic Response Group, SRG, has worked.
They've been trained in active shooter
training. They've been trained in how to deal with protests.
And I always say this. There hasn't been
a time the SRG has suppressed free speech.
They're there to intervene in the possibility
of agitators and criminality. That's what it comes down to.
Criminal.
acts, not about speech, that has been a misnomer.
I think that's incorrect is what SRG has been doing.
They've done this job as well as they can,
given the amount of protests that take place
in New York City.
They have maintained a relatively secure environment
for both the peaceful protester and made arrests
when arrests were necessary to be done.
And, as I mentioned just a few minutes ago,
we do always ask our viewers to weigh in and scan that QR code there.
I did just want to get this up on the screen early
because it is pertinent to the discussion.
Brian out on Staten Island says disbanding NYPD SRG is a huge mistake.
He says get ready for major disruptions during public events.
And he goes on to talk about some other issues there.
Public safety become a major concern.
But the mayor, David,
says that these civilian teams will help de-escalate.
Things as they happen.
I mean, what's your take just from a former police police perspective?
It goes back to the same thing.
De-escalation has always been something that police do. It's
nothing new. There was verbal judo in the past.
We have always done that. Here's the issue that
we have to understand. You're creating a civilian group.
What is their training? What is their
capacity? What are they going to do when they
are on these protests? New York City has had
thousands of protests in the last several years, thousands.
How many people are going to be
assigned to this civilian group?
How much training are they going to get? What is going to happen?
Now, since you're removing SRG from that scene
and you're going to minimize the amount of
response when something happens similar
to what happened near Gracie Mansion when those
IEDs were almost exploded,
how long is it going to take for police to respond to something
like that?
Because this is what we're not understanding.
Everything sounds, looks great on paper.
We have not seen New York City handle protests in any...
Way, shape, or form in that manner.
We've done it well for decades.
There have been issues.
Of course there are.
When massive protests happen, there will be mistakes and hiccups.
But what you do is you have the best trained unit.
SRG to handle that. What you're doing
is when you dismantle this, you're dismantling
the opportunity for public safety,
not just to the protesters, the peaceful protesters,
but those around the community at large.
You're talking, you do protests in Times Square.
We have seen them branch off and create violent acts.
Destroying property.
What are we gonna do then?
How long is it gonna take for police to respond?
What is the protocol?
There is no protocol in place.
We're just hearing, this is what we're
doing, but there's nothing there.
You're taking tools away from police to protect themselves too
and protect the public at large.
But when it comes to the protesters
and the agitators that we have seen in the past, that
is nothing.
There's no barrier for them.
It seems to be okay.
And this is the problem that you have.
You were seeing a dismantling, a deep-
Population of the police department of the NYPD right now.
It certainly has been a campaign promise from the mayor,
has been an issue certainly among
some city council members.
And at first, it seemed like there
was this intense pushback from within the NYPD, and
certainly maybe there still is from some of the officers on the ground.
But the commissioner has come out in support of this.
Or at least has, she didn't appear in the video
that was put out earlier by the mayor,
but certainly has on paper been in support.
But we know the PBA says officers could then be forced to wait
until a demonstration turns violent before intervening.
Is that an operational risk?
I mean, how does that sort of change the approach?
Absolutely. We're doing this again.
We're creating a buffer of civilians that we have
no idea what their training experience is.
There's your problem automatically.
So what's the protocol?
All you've heard is we're doing this, we're getting rid of the unit.
In 90 days, they'll be totally disbanded.
We'll have some people in Patrol Services Bureau,
they'll support patrol, but it comes down to it.
The movement and the ability to flow to an
incident rapidly by SRG has been there. We have seen that.
What you're doing now is you're allowing people that have
no experience, zero, in large, massive scale protests.
And who are you going to talk to?
Who is de-escalating?
Are you going to find the leadership?
I have not seen leadership within any of these protests,
especially when it comes to violent protests.
If you're destroying property,
you're going to have to de-escalate by words.
The only way to de-escalate the situation
is by arresting people who commit criminal acts.
And if you're going to create an extra delay in that
by creating this buffer unit of,
again, it comes back to who are they talking to?
That's the question. We don't have an answer,
and there is no answer. So there's your problem
there. This plan is failing on its own just by the concept,
because you're taking away
the opportunity to preempt violence at protests.
There has not been a time in my 27 years in the
police department that I've attended these protests,
that I've ever suppressed speech.
It's always about avoiding people
getting involved in criminal activity.
That's the job.
We let you protest, but once you veer from the scene and create damage,
then you're susceptible
to arrest.
When that's going to happen,
what are the civilians going to do at that point?
Yeah.
And just as we kind of come to an end here, I mean.
In some ways, if the same officers,
equipment and responsibilities kind of remain, is the
SRG really being disbanded
or is it just sort of being rebranded in some way?
But before I let you go, David, if I can,
a lot of people may remember there was a 2023
settlement that requires tiered response,
emphasizes de-escalation, does not allow for
the kettling, so-called, where you sort of round people up
and pen them in or whatever
it may be.
I mean, does this mean that some
of those practices they think weren't being followed
well enough, I mean, to kind of move forward with this,
or does that sort of further, I
don't know, make that official in some way?
Well, kettling has been gone.
The MOU has established there's no more kettling. To
understand what kettling was,
you would actually take out construction barriers and then surround
people if they refuse to move.
That has been removed, which is fine, understandably, because
unfortunately, there were some people
who were not involved in the protests who got kind of
fished in. That's the kettling aspect to it.
But here's the other issue comes to play.
We're not thinking about how these protests escalate.
Does anyone watch anything in Paris, France, or in Italy, or in London?
And you're creating a buffer.
It sounds wonderful.
It's great.
You can all sit there with one-on-one conversations.
But these protests, and I've been to several, are massive.
Who are they going to speak to?
That's the question.
What is the budget for this?
Are you a 24-365 operation?
What's the protocols and policies in effect?
The NYPD has them.
We had it in the MOU.
It doesn't change.
This is just.
Another addition to eliminate policing,
proper policing of these type of protests,
because you now are emboldening the criminal element
that come to these protests to do
nothing but wreak havoc.
And you're hurting the protesters who go there to actually
protest their cause. However heinous the statement is,
or whatever they believe in,
the NYPD allows that to happen. We do not intervene with...
Protesters who are protesting peacefully,
once there's a violent act or they move or they do
things that are improper, that are destroying the flow of traffic,
you are susceptible to arrest.
But now this is going to create a major chilling effect
when you talk about
the response by police, cuz it's gonna be minimal.
Cuz to fly to a command,
and we go flying, when you go from one command to another,
if you're going from Brooklyn and
it's a protest in, say, Manhattan, it's gonna take time.
But now you have those units together
all together in SRG1 in Manhattan, Brooklyn,
Bronx, and Queens, now you lost that.
And that's the problem. The policy is not thought out properly
because we have no answers. And you
could ask the mayor, I guarantee you there's
no true answer as to what the Committee of Public
Safety is going to do. We have no answers and we haven't seen it yet.
All right. Speaking with
former NYPD Detective David Sarney, currently a professor at John Jay.
David, if anybody wants
any more insight or your thoughts
and opinions on these things, anything you want to plug?
I'm on DS on the media and Instagram,
but that's not the problem or the issue. My thing is always
about I'm going to lay it straight.
You have to understand that. This is not about my police
perspective. I have 27 years on the job.
I teach college. I make kids think. This is what it is.
And if you think about this policy,
you can see it is not well thought out by the agents involved,
namely the city council and the mayor's office.
All right, David, we'll leave it there. Thank
you very much. We do appreciate the time
this morning here on Newsroom Live.
