Trump, Xi, Putin To Meet as Jensen Huang Reportedly Eyes Nvidia Comeback

Financial news
286 followers
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedThis episode of \"The Pulse\" examines the intersection of AI volatility, global economic shifts, and geopolitical tensions. It covers NVIDIA's leadership uncertainty, Anthropic's IPO, and the U.S. economy's AI-driven strength. Additionally, it analyzes President Trump's diplomatic mission to Asia, energy security risks in Europe, and Flagship Pioneering's AI-biotech expansion in the UK.
Market makers and market movers,
this is The Pulse with Francine Lacqua.
Well, good morning, everyone. Happy Monday.
Welcome to The Pulse. I'm Francine Lacroix here in London.
Now, the AI trade faces a crucial test this week as investors prepare
for Anthropic's blockbuster IPO and NVIDIA's earnings tomorrow.
Meanwhile, in the latest twist, an NVIDIA succession drama,
The Financial Times is reporting that Jensen Huang
is considering a comeback as chief executive.
In a moment, we'll discuss what all of this means for the markets
with Jean Boivin, head of the BlackRock Investment Institute.
But let's begin with Parmi Olson, technology columnist.
At Bloomberg Opinion, I have many questions,
as is usually the case when I speak to you, Parmi.
So could we actually see Jensen Huang make a comeback at NVIDIA?
At this point, I'd be very surprised to see something like that happen,
certainly not anytime soon.
What we're hearing is that he is talking
to industry leaders about some sort of campaign to come back.
There is this groundswell of enthusiasm for him from the majority
of staff at NVIDIA have said they want him to come back.
A number of tech leaders like Elon Musk
and Tim Sweeney of Epic Games, who, of course,
knows NVIDIA from back when they were dealing with games.
...designers and game companies,
they're also calling for him to come back.
And investors like Bill Gensler have
also signed an open letter calling for him to come back.
Well, of course, they want him to come back
because it's in their financial interest for NVIDIA
for the status quo to continue and the music not to stop.
But I think there's so much legal uncertainty around all of this.
President Trump has said that the FBI is now investigating Huang.
He's got to go to a congressional hearing,
Huang himself, on the 3rd of December.
So I can't, just with all that liability,
I just can't see anything happening, certainly
before then.
And probably not even afterwards.
This isn't like when Sam Altman was fired
and clawed his way back into the driving seat.
This is, like, much more serious, I think.
Pardon me, there's, again, there's a lot of names that were then
dropped, you know, rumors about who could take his place.
What do we know so far?
And actually, I was surprised to also see
the Treasury Secretary really kind of weigh in on this.
Yeah, it's interesting to see.
I mean, and that's another reason why I think.
Huang's return seems so unlikely. The fact that Bassant
is already himself saying there needs to be a shakeup.
René Haas is one, the former CEO of Arm. Seems like an obvious pick.
He maybe doesn't have the charisma of Huang,
but he certainly understands the chip industry.
He's got the network, the relationships, similar to what Huang has.
But for now, Collette, the CFO, is just trying
to keep things running smoothly, particularly as they have their...
There are results coming out tomorrow,
and people are going to be really looking to those for what
the potential outlook is for this company.
And then this is a week, Anthropic IPOs, huge.
Yeah, this whole thing could just overshadow this incredible moment
for the first frontier AI company to go public.
Thank you.
You know, this is a really big moment for both these companies,
and I think maybe we're kind of moving into a phase where
AI leaders are being held to account.
You know, it's very different
to three years ago when Sam Altman came back.
We've got another big AI company going more transparent.
They're going to have to be reporting to the SEC on a regular basis.
You know, if Huang doesn't manage to come back,
which I personally think should be as
he shouldn't come back,
then maybe this is a sign that the industry is maturing.
You know, that these leaders and kind of hype men,
who have created so much kind of investment in this whole business
are being held to account, and they have to follow the rules.
Parmi, thanks so much.
Parmi Olson, the technology columnist at Bloomberg Opinion.
Now, for a deeper dive, of course, into markets,
we're joined by Jean Boivin, head
of the BlackRock Investment Institute.
Jean, as always, thank you so much for joining us.
I want to talk to you about inflation, about the U.S. economy.
But first, how resilient is the U.S. economy?
I mean, how strong is the U.S. economy?
Thanks to AI and actually the build-out of data centers.
And do you have question marks of what happens going forward?
Yeah, I think the U.S. economy is not resilient.
It's actually strong.
I mean, when you look compared to where we
were at the beginning of the year,
there were concerns maybe about the consumers slowing down.
There were concerns about K-shaped economy.
We're sitting at the end of the year right now,
and it's been surprising on the upside.
It's broad-based.
And what's K-shaped is actually you need to tilt the K
because everything is going up.
Yeah, I mean...
Wealthier people go up more, but everybody's going up.
How do you explain, I mean, the resilience of the U.S. consumer is,
I mean, there'll be Hollywood movies on this,
because no matter what you throw at them, they keep on consuming.
Yeah, there's a saying, right? Never bet against the U.S. consumer.
I'm not sure if that's going to always
be true, but it has been true so far.
And I think there's a part of the story that comes down to AI.
playing a big role, not only in terms of the boost
to the activity that AI has been providing,
which might be coming to a turning point,
because I don't think we're going to keep
increasing these CapEx expenditure at the same pace,
but also through the wealth effect that
this has created for consumers.
So the stock market has been, apart from wobbles recently,
has been a pretty strong tailwind.
And I think that explains a lot of the strength.
Where do you see the main strength coming from?
And actually, what does it mean for Fed policy?
Yeah. So actually, so that's backward looking.
I think going forward, there's more questions around AI coming.
And I think, you know, just to zero in on AI a little bit,
the whole build out and the whole adoption of AI, the actual like
promise, have always been like generally massively uncertain.
And for some time, that uncertainty, I think, has been put aside
because we were convinced we just need to build this thing.
And there's nothing to debate about that.
And there's such an infinite demand for compute.
So that has been the story.
And as we start to build, that starts to be reflected in the price.
And I think now we're going to enter a phase
that's going to be a lot more nuanced.
And now, you know, the genuine uncertainty
that the whole AI story was representing is now becoming real.
I think, you know, you can point to...
You know, just key man or key person risk that we are seeing at play,
that's a source of risk, but there's a lot of form of concentration
in the way the build-out is playing, and key person risk is one.
The political landscape around AI is also a big source of uncertainty,
but I would say the deeper source of uncertainty,
and I think where we don't really have visibility, is on actual...
Final demand for AI, you know,
we haven't seen much evidence of a bottom line,
financial bottom line being impacted by AI other than in the AI sector.
So would this impact the economy or would actually just impact markets?
And are they due a correction given where they are?
So I think there's a there's a well.
A correction is somewhat happening as we speak, right?
The last few weeks I've seen some significant resetting.
Thank
I think, and I think this is markets
and the economy go quite closely together.
better.
And I think, you know, if we are to see some slowdown in the build-out,
you
that's going to have some real economy
very
impact, that's going to be material.
I mean, a big part of the growth in the U.S.,
the actual physical growth comes from...
From AI, if that's slowed down,
much.
that's going to be a significant story in 2027 of slowdown.
And then you get the wealth effect that could impact
the consumer or slow down the consumer.
So I think from here, it's more uncertain on the trajectory.
And I think you should expect some weakness to appear.
What do you think Fed policy looks like,
given at the moment there seems to be a realization
that actually rates at this level aren't that restrictive?
Yeah, it is a sea change of assessment, right?
When you think about, we started the year
with two cuts being what was needed to get closer to a neutral.
And now we have one hike behind us, expectations
of a few more coming from the market, maybe 50 basis points.
And we're questioning whether financial conditions
or monetary conditions are easy or not.
So I think it speaks to, we've
been talking about a polyfricated environment.
So there is a...
The macro uncertainty, uncertainty doesn't mean much,
because we overuse that word,
but the direction in which we could go on the macro is so vast, right?
And we thought we might
be at the lower neutral rate, it might be higher.
These are big macro calls.
Thank
I happen to think that maybe right now we're
probably shifting too far on the other side
of the hawkish interpretation of the environment,
and I think a lot of the inflation story with the last print.
you,
is reflected in market pricing, and I think the market now has assumed
Charles.
that the Fed would be pretty hawkish, and I think now a lot
of that is priced in, so I don't expect the Fed to be as hawkish
as the market interprets it right now, and I think the inflation story
is likely to start to ease with maybe the Middle East situation.
Leading to some oil price relief and as well as a slowdown
in the economy that I've just mentioned could play a part.
Jean, I mean, overall, when you look
at what you've just explained very, very well in the U.S.,
what kind of read-across is there for the rest of the world?
Well, the rest of the world, sorry, the inflation story is real.
It's a global phenomenon.
You know, you look at Europe,
this is even more of a growth impact story.
And then.
And then, you know, Canada has seen like upside surprise on inflation.
And this is really a tension between growth and inflation.
So we have this supply shock feature everywhere in the world.
But again, I think this is a global story.
And if we can get some relief on the Middle East and oil during
Going into 2027, that might allow Central Bank to adopt, I mean,
they're going to get more hawkish before they get more dovish,
but I don't think this is a straight line hawkish going into 2027.
Does Europe have a growth problem?
And actually, if you look at a lot of the elections in France
and elsewhere, how does Europe do in 2027 compared to the U.S.?
That seems to be all powering out.
Yeah, no, I think, you know,
Look, the revision in the forecast for Europe,
it's a full percentage point that we've shaved for a year ahead.
We're close to, you know, half a point of growth for Europe
or maybe less going into 2027.
So, yes, there's a growth problem.
There are opportunities in Europe we see, I mean, that are localized.
You know, the AI adoption in Europe is a phenomenon.
And you see that in the financial sector as being a big driver
and that has worked well for investors.
So there are pockets like this, but in terms of a broad story,
I think there are significant headwinds
and the higher rate environment we're seeing globally has
clearly manifested itself in a big headwind in Europe.
I think that's an important point. The rise in rates we've seen,
I think, is coming from a positive story in the U.S.
It's a competition for capital,
but the knock-on effect is a negative one for Europe.
And
Challenges the fiscal outlook.
Yeah, and we don't know what happens to energy prices.
that
I mean, given the number, it's also, you know,
the U.K. seems to be taking the brunt of a lot of this.
you
Do you worry about bond yields specifically in the U.K.?
very
I mean, globally, but also kind of leading
to some kind of fiscal event in the U.K.?
I think we're seeing right now.
much.
This competition of capital that was driven mostly by AI
and led to this global repricing
of yield globally,
I think we're seeing a more nuanced story in AI, as I said.
So I think the pressure on yield is going
to ease somewhat globally, and I think as
a result, we're in a high rate environment
and rates are not going to come down.
But I think the pressure on the UK,
on the fiscal side and so on, is not going to get
worse than it is right now.
But it is something that's requiring management, yeah.
John, going back to the U.S., I forgot to ask you about the midterms,
because I don't know whether it's the rest of the world that should
be worried about some of the policies coming out from the Trump
administration, given he's much more constricted at home.
Yeah, so I think there's a lot to digest
from the midterm election and, you know,
we'll learn a lot over the course of the next few weeks and months.
I think on AI, there's a whole questions about what kind
of policy restrictions we're going to see.
This is more of a state level story, but like it's a big thing to track
and whether it slows down the build out.
We tend to think, you know, this is going to be a two way story between
the economic impact of a slowdown versus the politics.
And things will evolve.
I don't think we're going to see a pause on AI at large,
but it's going to be a more nuanced story.
The fiscal side is going to be another thing to watch.
I mean, I don't think in this environment
we're going to see fiscal restrictions of any meaning
or addressing fiscal objective in any meaningful way,
but it might be more constraints in terms of spending.
And so one thing to watch.
Thank you very much.
And I think...
As I mentioned,
the story about why oil prices might be getting some relief
and coming from the Middle East,
I think is a knock-on effect of the midterm election
that might lead to, you know, an incentive to get some solution there.
Okay, thank you so much.
As always, Jean Boivin there,
head of the BlackRock Investment Institute.
Now, coming up, oil traders weigh Middle East tensions against
a well-supplied physical market.
We'll get plenty more on that with Nadia Martin-Leguin.
That's coming up next, and this is Bloomberg.
So U.S. airlines are working to return
to normal operations after the longest nationwide
shutdown in more than two decades.
The Federal Aviation Administration predicted airlines would
be back to normal after Friday's tech outage
and a weekend of recovery efforts to reposition planes
and reposition crews.
But the world's busiest aviation market still has a long way to go.
So let's get the latest with Danny Lee,
our Asia Aviation and Transport reporter. Danny,
I mean, it was just absolutely incredible what happened on Friday.
What has been the fallout
chaos in U.S. air travel.
Well, US Transportation Secretary Sean Duffy has had
to walk a very fine line
presiding over yet another meltdown
of the air traffic system. As you said,
it's the world's biggest aviation market.
And immediately after the meltdown on Friday afternoon,
Duffy was calling for an upsized $50 billion of emergency funding.
And the fine line he has to
walk is to not just appeal to Republicans,
but also to Democrats who will control
Both chambers of Congress from next year
and the blame game has always...
So Danny,
what's
the state
of play today?
Well, we are looking
at a more normalised schedule after days of disruption,
particularly the number of cancellations has been reduced.
We're now looking at around 100 for now,
although we're very early into Monday morning for the US.
But there has still been a lot of delays
and delays could still mount up as travel larger gets back to normal.
But we've heard from airlines such
as American Airlines, Alaska and Delta,
who are all signalling a much more normalised service.
this and the
Severe reduction or the amount of reduction
of cancellations looks much more likely to have more stability
and visibility into what's going to happen into the week ahead.
So pretty good news, but still cautious
given what has happened recently.
Danny, thanks so much.
Danny Lee, our Asia Aviation and Transport reporter.
Now, oil is reversing earlier declines
as traders weigh tensions in the Middle East
against a well-supplied physical market.
Well, joining us now is Nadia Martin-Wiggin,
Director of Svaland Capital.
Nadia, always great to have you.
So, thank you so much for coming in.
There's just a lot going on in the price of oil.
Last week, there was a lot more calmness.
What are you expecting or how are you expecting
that to actually behave in the next couple of weeks?
Well, it's, of course, very difficult to say.
It's impossible.
We, you know, this morning we have reports of,
you know, a tanker going down.
The attacks in the Middle East have continued.
The Houthis claim they attacked the East-West pipeline.
But we have to admit that there is more oil coming out through
the Strait of Hormuz and the Middle East in total.
And we even see LNG ships.
Thank you.
Going through at a third of a regular pace,
but there is that improvement.
I think the market, though,
has largely faded the war in the Middle East,
and there are constantly renewed hopes
of peace between Russia and Ukraine,
which in our view are not well-founded.
And as a result, when we look at open interest,
in particular in the Brent market,
it's really come off in the last week.
So our view is that...
Investors are just stepping out.
They don't see a real opportunity to make money right now.
What do you look at?
I mean, again, it's really interesting to hear you explain the dynamics
because a lot of the oil is coming out.
Also, it's run through routes. Is it just much more expensive?
And how much of that forward guidance already priced in?
Well, the freight market is extremely expensive.
We hit a high mid-October,
where it's $1.67 million a day to take a ship.
Before this war, it was around $200,000.
Historically, at $400,000 a day plus,
it was always a sell, which is a very dangerous trade.
Then the insurance costs around $12 million.
And if you make it through,
and that's for an oil tanker, you get half of that back.
So that's very expensive.
But at least the freight part has come down.
But the logistics take so long.
It takes about two weeks longer to get through the Strait of Hormuz
because of all the ship-to-ship transfers.
And when you look at substitute crudes coming
from a much further distance,
this is where all of that comes into the cost.
So you have the IEA saying that, well,
we see a build coming in the fourth quarter.
It's already started.
But when you have that oil selling on the water,
it's not in refineries resolving the diesel crisis right now.
And so the market has taken, in our view,
You know, quite a negative stance on these builds,
but we've yet to see the proof in the pudding in the inventories.
Has Europe been able to diversify supplies like they said they would?
On the oil side?
On the oil side.
Yes, we are more diversified,
and we were always less dependent on the Middle East.
And this is where Guyana, the U.S.,
the U.S. Gulf Coast crude price is into the Brent contract.
So that is something that has been in the works since shale, Canada.
So, yes, we take from many more places,
but Asia is where we have the biggest glut of refinery spare capacity.
China is running 3 million barrels per day less.
than they could when we were short diesel
and you know the latest data from last week the
teapots the independent refiners are only running
at 56.4 percent of possible abilities whereas the
U.S. has been running at a hundred percent non-stop
to try to get this diesel into the market.
When does it change in Asia?
Well, so this is what is so strange.
We saw that Chinese imports of crude jumped
in October to 9.88 million barrels per day.
That's about a million barrels per day higher than they have been.
November looks like they could import even more,
but they banned exports of diesel.
As in, these were ships that were set to load
and they've been cancelled.
And this is where it's a very confusing message.
And if you look at this idea that we're oversupplied in oil,
Why aren't they exporting the products that we need?
In addition, we've lost 1.5 million barrels
per day of Russian refinery capacity
and 2.5 million barrels per day of Middle Eastern capacity.
We're not seeing the products flow through.
It's primarily the crude that is flowing through from the Middle East.
And that's where I find it very difficult
to pair up that policy in the U.S.
with what the supply-demand numbers suggest.
I mean, when you look at the predictions for the winter,
I mean, it's expected to be really cold and bitter in Europe.
Do you worry about what that means for gas prices?
Yes. I think the narrative going in was it's super El Nino year,
so we're not going to have a winter.
But when you look at the summer, it's a very dry summer, and usually
in an El Nino year, you have a wetter summer, and this is where…
I live in Norway. We have hydro levels extremely low.
The battery of Europe is out.
And this is where last week we had German power
prices first hit 450 euros per megawatt hour.
That's when you want to switch to diesel.
All that diesel capacity that was built up in 2022.
But the product where they were the shortest is actually diesel
We hit up to 600 euros per megawatt hour
and we've drawn down at three times the pace
that we typically would in the last two weeks.
In addition, come January 1st, we're not taking Russian LNG cargos.
Russia has supplied 15% of our LNG at the start of this year.
Having said that, we see demand destruction coming.
That's come in China, in the ceramics industry and so forth.
It's come in Egypt that they've cut down
the amount of fertilizer they're going to make.
By 33% versus last year as a narrative.
So they're trying to take a lid.
But then you have the part of Asia
that doesn't have that demand flexibility
because they need gas for power generation.
And that's Japan and South Korea, most importantly.
And South Korea has super low inventories the way we do.
And their inventories only cover normally 10% of demand.
For us, full inventories cover 25% of demand in a normal winter.
So, any kind of...
Real cold weather there will really have them scrambling
to buy LNG from everywhere.
And what are our reserves looking like in Europe?
Well, they're very low. I mean, but depleted or kind of. Yeah.
Well, we didn't build them up. Historically, since 2022,
we thought, OK, 80 percent, give or take 70 percent.
You know what I mean? We ended September at 61 percent.
Yeah. And that is, you know, you're kind of filling season.
So we're much lower. And that's where we're very much subject. But on.
On the other side, we have way more LNG regasification capacity.
So in that desperate moment, we can get some more,
but we're going to have to pay for it, especially if it's cold in Asia.
Nadia, it's so good to speak to you.
Thank you so much.
There's so much actually going on, and you just tell it beautifully.
Nadia, Martin Wiggin, director at Zeland Capital.
Coming up, President Trump heads to Asia.
With trade and technology in focus,
we'll be live in Manila and Shenzhen.
We'll also bring you analysis
with the Chatham House chief executive, Bronwyn Maddox.
So that's coming up next.
A couple of other things we're watching out for.
Look, there's, of course, a lot going on with AI.
Not only do we have earnings from NVIDIA tomorrow,
but a lot with Anthropic this week.
Well, good morning, everyone, and welcome to The Pulse.
I'm Francine Lacroix here in London, and these are your top stories.
Pressure mounts on NVIDIA as the Treasury Secretary calls
for a dramatic leadership
shakeup while the FT reports Jensen Wang is considering a comeback.
Anthropic makes its megastock market debut
this week as investors gear up for the world's
biggest ever IPO.
Plus, President Trump heads to Asia.
The U.S. president will meet with leaders of China
and Russia in a diplomacy blitz from
the Philippines to China.
So more on that story now.
President Trump is set for a high-stakes trip to Asia this week.
A key focus is a meeting scheduled
with the Chinese President Xi later this week
and a trilateral that would include Russia's President Putin.
While Ava Hong is at the ASEAN Summit in Manila, Trump's first stop.
Let's begin with Armin Menlo, who's in Shenzhen.
So thank you both for joining us.
Min Min, what is President Trump hoping
to achieve from this meeting with Xi and Putin?
Well, that meeting with Xi and Putin certainly is a first, right?
Certainly, it will make a good photo opportunity.
It really brings to mind the Yalta Conference post-World War II
in terms of the significance you have
the big three leaders of the world right now.
But in terms of practical outcomes, perhaps paling in comparison,
because President Trump has said he wants
to raise the issue of denuclearization.
This is where we're unlikely to see any breakthroughs,
given that China is reluctant to discuss
its nuclear arsenal, which for now...
China still is much smaller than the U.S. is on Russia's.
The U.S. officials have
also indicated their desire to talk about the Iran war, but not
so much the Ukraine war.
When it comes to Iran,
we know that the U.S. has been wanting China to use its levers over
Iran to put an end to that war.
And of course, higher inflation,
a slowdown in the global economy, that's not a positive
for China as well.
So perhaps there is some level of alignment
of interest there, but China is unlikely to
I don't need to want to...
Expand too much resources into a conflict that it doesn't see
as relevant to, that it's sort of beyond its...
Political backyard, if you will.
And then when it comes to Ukraine,
U.S. officials have told Bloomberg that they're unlikely to raise
that at any conversation around Ukraine without Zelensky being present
is going to be raising alarm bells across European capitals
and with Asian allies of the U.S. as well.
Taiwan will certainly be watching very closely as a sign
of whether its own fate could be decided in a similar fashion.
So there's a lot to watch for.
But in terms of room for actual practical outcomes.
That is pretty limited for now.
Min Min, how much could the NVIDIA fallout
also complicate Trump's talks with President Xi?
Well, when it comes to his meeting with President Xi,
there is a lot on the agenda, right?
You have the trade truce, you have, of course,
the Nvidia fallout really bringing to question
whether or not US tech curbs will start to tighten even further
because without the voice
of Jensen Huang, who has been this outspoken advocate
for looser restrictions, we're seeing
an opening for Democrats to push for an acceleration
of the closing of these tech loopholes that
allows Chinese companies to access overseas data centers.
Any tightening of tech curbs could potentially derail
the ongoing tech truce, which for now
rests heavily on the U.S. putting on pause any impending tech curbs.
So this is potentially something
that could escalate tension even further.
It might encourage China to use
its leverage over rare earths even further.
Of course, RIA has said that even the flow
of rare earths have not been coming through
in the volume and the pace that the U.S. is expecting.
Agricultural goods trade as well.
The U.S. has been wanting China
to buy more non-soybean agricultural goods,
$17 billion worth of that.
And China has said that is only going to hinge on the implementation
of the trade agreement,
that so-called 30 for 30 tariff-free arrangement,
which has been heavily discussed.
But up until now, we haven't heard anything concrete
in terms of the timeline of implementation.
So certainly there is a lot to discuss.
And I think Chinese companies, for sure, are very keen
to find out what sort of changes we could see
when it comes to tech policy
because we already see that in the market reaction so far
with Chinese tech stocks heavily hit by the NVIDIA fallout.
Min Min, thank you. Avril, the NVIDIA fallout also, of course,
featuring heavily at the ASEAN meetings in Manila
where Southeast Asian countries are gathering.
Absolutely, Francine.
The worry here really is, given the NVIDIA fallout,
that we could see tighter U.S. restrictions on chip exports,
and that could constrain the AI boom that we're actually seeing in the
Southeast Asia region, particularly for data center growth that has.
Actually helped to offset some of the drag
that we've seen from the oil price shock in the region.
And as you may know, Trump administration officials fear
that some of these Southeast Asian countries are weak links
in terms of preventing China from getting
its hands on cutting-edge technology.
And it's very interesting, in the past week or so,
we've seen amid the NVIDIA fallout,
Singapore has charged a fifth person
in connection with an AI server fraud case.
Malaysia says it's investigating whether chips that were...
Avril, President Trump
gets to Manila tomorrow,
so what exactly
is expected on day one?
Yeah, I think here it's important to note
that the last time he was in the Southeast Asian region
was about a year ago, and back then it was Malaysia.
Back then we saw trade really dominating.
A number of countries were looking
to iron out trade deals with the U.S.
This time around, it's coming against
the backdrop of that midterm setback.
So it's going to be very interesting
to see how regional leaders engage with the U.S. president,
whether it's on the Iran war fallout, AI investments.
Given the NVIDIA saga, but also tariffs, and it's interesting
to see the extent in which Trump is going to perhaps use
this as an opportunity to reset the narrative in the Asia-Pacific,
given the midterm setback, but also project power.
And we know for the moment that he might be keen
to garner support among countries in this region.
For the IPEF initiative, that's seen as a way
to China-proof the supply chain for AI and for chips.
Aside from that, tomorrow we are expecting to see Trump meeting
with the leaders of India, Australia, Japan as well.
This is a grouping that is informal,
but seen often as a counterweight to China.
But it has faced criticism recently that it has seen
a loss of momentum under Trump 2.0.
So we're talking trade, we're talking security,
we're talking about AI investments as well.
Well, here in Manila,
thank you so much to both Bloomberg's Min Min Low in Shenzhen,
Avlor Hong in Manila.
Now, to discuss the wider geopolitical landscape after
the U.S. midterms, we're joined by
Bronwyn Maddox, chief executive of Chatham House.
Thank you so much for joining us.
There is a lot going on, and I feel all
of these uncertainties are really distilled as
we try and understand what President Trump wants
to achieve as he goes to Asia.
What do you think his number one, two and three priorities are?
He wants to look like a winner again in some way.
How I think his difficulties just have
this bruising setback in the midterm elections,
I would think part of it is as performative as they say,
wanting to stand beside these two leaders he has, for his own reasons,
seem to admire because of their strength
and control of their countries.
What he actually wants to get out of it, I think is much harder to say,
Okay, because...
He's done some of the big moves he was going to do in terms of tariffs.
They've been partly rebuffed by President Xi of China, saying they
have noticed how many of the world's critical minerals we own.
China is approaching this from a position of strength, I think.
And for Trump, I don't know that there
is much he can actually secure from this meeting.
Is there, you know, it seems that President Trump
and actually all of the U.S. has real difficulty in stopping China
in getting better with the AI and becoming more futuristic.
Is this going to be, I mean, how does the NVIDIA fallout play out
in the conversation between the two leaders?
That is bound to be there,
and presumably President Xi will be pushing for assurances
that controls on chips won't get any tighter,
or even wanting them possibly a bit looser.
But Trump almost certainly is going to want to push back on that.
But it's hard to know.
The people around Trump want him
to push back on that very much and say,
not too much of American security and too much
of the very slender American lead in AI has been put at risk.
But that's not where China wants to end up on this.
So it will be pushing quite hard on other things it can offer the US
to see if we can just keep those chips flowing.
I mean, is it going to be difficult conversations?
We also know that there was some kind of an agreement between the U.S.
and partners to safeguard key AI, you know, tech and infrastructure.
But given all this by allegations,
and we know there's going to be, I mean, I think we,
you know, there was talk about the FBI even being involved.
How does President Xi of China deal with this?
Does he push back against President Trump?
Yes, I think he will, but cheerfully.
He's got a lot of cards to play, to use the Trump
metaphor. He's selling very successfully to the world many,
many things and buying remarkably
little. So the thing he does want is those highest quality chips,
but there's an awful
lot that he could threaten
if the US looked like just shutting off the tap.
Partly. And, you know, China's been increasingly muscular in the way
that it has asserted these things in all kinds of countries,
including the US last year when he met President Trump.
But in all kinds of other countries like its neighbors,
Japan and so on, saying, well, we'd like this.
And if you don't do it,
we will turn off the critical minerals or whatever else.
So, you know, I think I think AI is going to be front and center,
but I'm not sure Trump can get very much.
He may want to talk as well about Ukraine or Iran,
but I think China sees these, particularly
Iran, as a mess that the US is making
and really wants no role at all in sorting it
out, though it could have one,
but it's just quietly continuing to buy its oil.
And in Ukraine, China is helping Russia more
in this conflict than I think Europe has wanted
to see so far.
In buying large quantities of its oil, so keeping revenues flowing in,
and in supplying engines for some
of the most powerful drones or missiles.
So it's keeping that stirring.
It's certainly not playing the role
of a mediator, bringing that to a close.
I mean, it's, you know, I don't know how you would describe
the current U.S. administration's relationship with Ukraine.
I mean, some commentators are saying, look,
they're persisting in its attempt to sell Ukraine to Russia.
It was quite bizarre seeing Jared Kushner next to,
you know, President Zelensky over the weekend.
How do you see this ending? And actually, can Europe push back?
I think Europe has to push back.
I mean, Ukraine is quite blunt in saying we're not really expecting,
despite the change in Congress,
we're not really expecting more money from the US.
We'd be delighted if we got that.
But this has been so bruising a couple of years where
our hopes are very low. We're looking to Europe for that.
And hoping very much to get more guarantees,
particularly the Russian frozen assets before
the big European elections next year, like France. Looking a lot.
to Britain and Germany in all that.
I'm trying to get through, again, one more winter,
but really I think increasingly the Ukrainians are thinking
this may not be solvable while President Trump
is still in the White House
because he is so much tilting the scales in Russia's direction.
And we did have these suggestions over the weekend
that could possibly some kind of...
The insubstantial promise that at some point Ukraine might join NATO
be enough for Ukraine to give up the Donbass to Russia.
But that's giving up something very solid for something that might
or might not come good.
And what a NATO guarantee of security means, we're not that clear.
Oh, yeah.
It was one of the better suggestions recently,
I think, of something that could be.
A very much a value to Ukraine, a security guarantee.
Thank you.
But I think Ukrainians increasingly
are thinking we've got to wait for President Trump out.
And I mean, what do we understand?
And again, maybe early days
because the midterms was a very short while ago.
But what's your read on what
the U.S. administration wants to do with Iran right now?
Wants to get out of it.
And there was a lot of voices saying,
do not escalate this further at this point with more strikes.
But the president may be impelled otherwise,
and it does depend who emerges on top of the Israeli government,
the process of forming a government that is going on at the moment,
because Netanyahu has been very much at the school of,
look, one more strike, one more big strike on Iran,
but don't let them get away with their nuclear program.
I think, if I had to take a guess, that...
The U.S. would seek to de-escalate this, try and do some kind of deal
that involves the nuclear material, call that a victory and go away.
And much of the oil is now flowing.
The thing that is keeping petrol
and diesel prices high is lack of refining capacity as opposed
to lack of tankers making it through the Strait of Hormuz.
Thank you very much.
So I think a quiet.
A quiet exit and leave it to the rest of the world to sort out.
But you cannot, with President Trump, rule out some last strike.
Yeah.
Bronwyn, thanks so much for joining us.
Bronwyn Maddox there, the chief executive of Chatham House.
Now, coming up, the biotech venture firm that brought
to the world Moderna is expanding its footprint.
We'll speak to Nubar Afeyan,
the founder of Flagship Pioneering and co-founder of Moderna.
That's coming up next.
And this is Bloomberg.
Well, flagship pioneering,
the biotech venture firm that brought the world Moderna, expanding
its footprint with its first full scale site outside the US. Now,
the life sciences investment firm will commit 100 million pounds over
the next few years to build out a London based lab that will conceive.
test, fund and build AI-focused biotech firms.
Well, joining us now is Nubar Afeyan,
the company's founder and chief executive.
Nubar is also the co-founder of Moderna,
which of course recently announced
that its therapeutic vaccine
for a deadly form of skin cancer
has succeeded in a final stage of trial.
Nubar, always great to catch up.
So thank you so much for dropping by.
So why are you expanding in the UK now?
Well, it's already been three years
that we've had a presence here
where we started connecting our Boston-based ecosystem
with some 45 companies.
to the geographic location cluster in London
and over time we began to make enough connections
that we got emboldened to try this next step
which is for the first time to set up our
own origination lab in the UK, which is a big deal,
it's just the beginning but with
the hundred million pounds
and bringing along partners we hope that will grow to about five
six hundred million pounds relatively soon.
We think that will be a very interesting investment
into building an ecosystem here in the UK.
Why the UK? Because there's many questions about actually,
does it have the right ecosystem?
I know the current government is getting slammed quite
a lot about not doing enough for entrepreneurship.
So interesting that you thought, you know.
You know, we have a different business model
in that we combine scientific creativity,
entrepreneurial leadership, and capital into one entity.
And so our dependence on what is needed
is really all about human talent and partnerships.
And I think the human talent here, especially with AI,
is exceptional, and I think the potential
for partnerships with folks that have clinical experience,
data, samples, a lot of world-class
Thank you very much.
All of that can be connected to what we do.
So I think if all we were doing is investing,
we would have a different calculus.
But since we're creating, we think this is a very interesting,
with great upside potential, starting point.
And you're putting AI really at the forefront,
right, of this venture in the UK.
What does it look like?
Well, I mean, it's fair to say
that it would be hard to imagine
starting companies in this day and age
that are not grounded on AI.
But in our case,
we've been at this for eight years.
And during those eight years,
we have learned a lot of the things
that can work and some things
that are not all that amenable
to just what AI can bring to bear
in terms of the human involvement, etc.
So I think we'll be able to jumpstart,
unlike what we did over the last 25 years
in Boston, where that additive capability
was not there.
I think we'll be able to jumpstart here
completely predicated
on AI
We have projects where we're automating
the whole scientific discovery process, for example.
We have others where we've already taken compounds
that are computer-designed
all the way into phase three trials.
So bringing that know-how and expertise
to create a new generation of companies,
that's something that we uniquely want to do here.
Are you expecting the next Moderna to be found here?
I would say hopefully many, just like we do in the U.S. as well.
I don't think this is a unique provenance of the U.S. or the U.K., etc.
I think that people
People, given the right tool, the right kind of support,
can in fact create extraordinary
outcomes.
The interesting ironic part is that I think they have
to always start with an unreasonable
premise.
The hardest thing to infuse into an ecosystem
is the notion that from unreasonable beginnings
can come extraordinary outcomes.
Instead, what people do is look for the most reasonable idea
and then they hope for miracles
that somehow it's going to take over the world.
That we have not seen happen.
Okay, what's the most unreasonable idea
that you think you're working on?
You know, in therapeutics, we are doing some amazing things of using AI
to transfer what we could learn from how proteins interact all
the way into designer small molecules that can do the same thing,
purely computationally.
In the whole computing space, in AI,
we're doing some very interesting things,
learning from how human brains process information,
not just metaphorically by calling these neural networks, but actually
neuronal information and transferring it to new types of...
processing chips that are out there
these are all things that are beyond the cutting edge
and our teams are just boldly asking questions seeing
if they could reduce things to practice
and then we'll build some companies around those many
of them will be actually founded and rooted
here.
There are many questions on AI in general with agents
and the fact that they can hack some of the systems.
But do you only see good in the healthcare system
or do you still see pushback for people not trusting because they've
been AI generated or regulators being tougher on some of these models?
Well, we have a very exciting
and interesting relationship with the MHRA,
the regulator here, the Singapore-based regulator as well.
We formed just last year a partnership.
One of the things that encouraged us...
To physically also locate a lab here
was the partnership we've set up with the MHRA to
foresee things that are beyond what can be seen today
and start working on how to regulate
them.
So I think the regulator is an important component.
I think to your question,
the safety issue of agentic workflow is, in my view, among
the most vexing issues we have.
And ironically, Francine,
the only other space in which humans work on things we don't understand
is biology because we don't understand much about disease
and interestingly now with these agents
that are being created intelligent
agents
we also don't understand them
so you might say isn't that scary well the
reality is we have some tools by which we've
been dealing with human physiology
I think we're gonna bring that to bear
including how to think about putting
safeguards
how to think about regulating things that could be rather toxic
in the work environment I think there's gonna have
to be some real crosstalk
between these fields
Whose job is it to regulate it?
I think that it's inevitable that government,
in partnership with the private sector, has
to come up with lanes within which things can operate.
Look, at a simple level, coming from the pharmaceutical industry,
we know that part of the advantage
of regulation is that it's clear what you have
to do to have your products show safety
and efficacy.
A similar idea, I think,
should be thought of in this space before you have a calamity
of the sort that we saw in the pharmaceutical space spur
on the kind of regulations we have.
So I think it's not enough to just tell them,
the developers, you regulate yourself.
I think government alone can't do it,
but we have lots of examples and I think it's
time that we really think about intelligent agents.
I tell people it's not AI I'm worried about,
it's IA, intelligent agents, which we can't
quite figure out what they're doing.
to make sure we have some agreed-upon safeguards.
Nubar, we've talked about in the past
the fact that over the last five years
there's a lot more skepticism of pharma or big pharma,
and this is partly due to misinformation, disinformation, COVID.
Do you see that trust being rebuilt?
Especially in the U.S.?
I think the trust is being rebuilt one success at a time,
one scientific breakthrough at a time,
one life saved at a time, or a million.
I think these things come kind of a bit of a pendulum.
I think post-COVID there was a period of time
where people thought that government intervened with their lives
and indiscriminately applied that same disdain to science,
which makes no sense because they depend on science for their food,
for their climate, for everything.
So I do think that with healthy dialogue about these things,
And also scientists have to engage, you know,
we always, we have a group of scientists,
entrepreneurs within Flagship that we encourage to get out there
and talk about their ideas without fearing that people might doubt them
because as you talk about it, people realize, okay, we don't know,
we're going to try to find out and the beneficiary is humankind.
That's an okay role for a scientist to play.
When will AI make a meaningful impact on healthcare?
Like, you know, the one that will do headlines
that people actually realize makes a big difference to their lives.
Look, I think people fail to realize.
I realized that there's already AI
in Moderna's individualized therapy, there's already AI
in Generate Biomedicine's Phase 3 asthma
and COPD drug that's under development, there's
already AI in many, many different places.
People think about AI in the way they experience it
in their daily life, which is chatbots.
So they want...
You know, doctor bots and they want lawyer bots.
And I think that simplification is the part that's sensational
and also not the most short-term impact.
I think the biggest impact is going to be how do you take a massive
amount of clinical data and combine it to instruct what and how.
To offer a patient, to better help them
guide themselves towards a treatment.
These things are already beginning to happen without much fanfare,
and I'm very optimistic about that.
But is there going to be an AI vaccine that suddenly, actually,
thanks to AI, we're going to find a vaccine that, you know,
is there going to be a first?
I think, I honestly, Francine, think being in this field
for about 40 years now, I actually think this obsession about firsts
is a bit misguided because there's probably many already.
But in science, you go from first to first to first to first
and you don't think about a first as some major achievement.
So I would say just using AI as a way
to augment human intelligence to leap further, to leap broader.
These are all things that, at least within
the origination lab we're setting up here,
I think we're going to have dozens of examples of.
The first is probably more of a communication thing.
Nubar, I love that. Thank you so much.
Nubar Afayan, their founder and chief executive of Flagship Pioneering.
This is Bloomberg.
