Youth unemployment is alarmingly high across major economies—and AI threatens to make getting that first job even harder.
With youth unemployment above 20% in Spain, France and Italy, and at 62.8% in South Africa, millions of young people are struggling to get onto the employment ladder. As businesses use artificial intelligence to automate routine tasks, could the junior positions that traditionally launch careers start disappearing?
In this video, I examine the Trading Economics youth unemployment figures, research on AI and entry-level hiring, and the potential consequences for earnings, housing, independence and the global economy.
If employers want experience but stop offering opportunities to gain it, how does the next generation get started?
AI Generated·May contain errors
Hi welcome back to the channel.
In today's episode I want to talk to you about youth
unemployment because some of the latest figures
are absolutely shocking. I think we need to ask
whether artificial intelligence is making it harder
for an entire generation to get its first
opportunity in the jobs market.
We keep hearing that AI is going to make businesses more productive.
It can prepare reports, answer questions,
write computer code and process information.
Companies can get more work done without employing as many people.
But those basic tasks are often the work taken on by somebody
when they join a business for
the first time.
They are how inexperienced employees learn,
develop their judgement and start building
a career.
So what happens if businesses decide that they
no longer need as many junior employees?
How do you get the experience required
for a better job if nobody gives you the opportunity
to get started?
And this technology is arriving
when youth unemployment is already above 20% in countries
including Spain.
France and Italy and in South Africa youth unemployment
is now above 60 percent. These are
people at the beginning of their working lives.
Decisions made about recruitment now could affect
their earnings, independence and prospects for decades.
So before we get into all of the details
could I ask everyone if you're enjoying my videos
so please give me a thumbs up for this video.
Please subscribe to the channel if you haven't done
so already. Hit the hype symbol if it's
available in your region and if you're interested have
a look at my membership scheme.
Where you'll get early access to my videos
and also help to support the channel.
So let's start with this youth unemployment table
from Trading Economics because it shows the scale
of the problem. Right at the top here
is South Africa where youth unemployment is currently
sitting at 62.8 percent
which is up from 60.9 percent in the previous reading. That is an
extraordinary figure. Almost two-thirds
of young people participating in the labor market in South
Africa are unemployed. These rates measure young people
who are working or actively seeking work
They don't include every student
or everybody else outside of the labour force.
If you're not looking for a job, then you're not included.
But amongst those trying to establish themselves in employment,
the South African figure shows an enormous shortage of opportunities.
If we then move on to Spain, which is sitting at 22.7%,
France, 20.6%, and Italy, 20.3%.
So four countries in this table have youth unemployment above 20%.
In three major European economies,
More than one in five young people in the labour force is unemployed.
And if we look down further on the list,
China is sitting at 18%, the Euro area as a whole, 15%,
the United Kingdom, 13.2%, Turkey and Canada,
both at 13%, Australia, 11.1%, and Saudi Arabia, 10.5%.
That gives us 10 countries in the G20
in double figures alongside the Euro area in aggregate.
And the United States is only just below that threshold at 9.9%.
Now compare those numbers with overall unemployment,
in Italy the headline rate in the accompanying
table is 6.2% against 20.3% for youth unemployment,
in China it's 5.2% overall unemployment against
18% for young people,
in the UK it's 4.7% compared with 13.2% for the youth.
The position facing somebody starting out
is considerably worse than the headline national
figures suggest.
Some latest readings have improved others have deteriorated
but the underlying problem remains
severe. A small reduction
in unemployment rate above 20% still leaves an enormous number of
young people looking for work
and that's before we understand the full consequences of businesses
changing their recruitment plans around what's happening
with artificial intelligence. Now young
people have always faced particular difficulties finding employment.
They have less experience,
fewer professional contacts.
And often compete with applicants who've already done similar work.
When businesses become cautious,
recruitment can be one of the first things that they reduce.
But AI introduces another reason
to question whether a vacancy needs to exist.
Imagine a company employing experienced accountants,
analysts or software developers.
Traditionally, those employees might work
with junior staff who prepare information,
handle routine tasks and learn as they go along.
If AI allows experienced employees to complete more
of that preliminary work themselves,
management may decide to recruit fewer assistants.
The business still needs expertise,
it still needs people to check the results and take responsibility,
but it may need fewer people
learning underneath them.
That's the danger for somebody trying to get started. The experienced
employees become more productive,
while the opportunities to become an experienced employee
are harder to find. We're already seeing research
that points towards this.
Stanford researchers analyzing American payroll data through
to June 26 found that employment
amongst 22 to 25 year olds in highly AI exposed occupations
was 19% below where it would have been
if it had kept pace with its peers in less exposed work.
Now that's a relative employment gap rather
than the youth unemployment rate
but the finding that particularly caught my attention was that
reduced hiring appeared to be a major mechanism. The researchers
Can't establish precisely how much of the gap AI caused.
However, the pattern raises an important concern.
The disruption may arrive through
employers taking on fewer young people
rather than simply dismissing existing employees.
For the applicants, that distinction offers very little comfort.
The vacancy they hope to apply for is no longer available.
And this can create a particularly difficult experience trap.
You apply for a job and you're told you need experience.
But to acquire that experience,
somebody needs to employ you to give you a job.
An entry-level position is supposed
to provide a route through that problem.
You start with limited knowledge,
contribute what you can and become more capable through practice.
If employers reduce these opportunities,
more applicants compete for the remaining places.
Businesses can then become more demanding
about qualifications and previous experience.
The first step becomes harder to reach precisely
because fewer people are being allowed to take it.
And this is not exclusively a graduate problem.
People leaving school, completing vocational courses
or changing direction early in their working lives
also need employers willing to invest in their development.
Different forms of automation affect different occupations.
But the wider issue is whether businesses see inexperienced people
as future employees worth training
or an immediate cost that they can now avoid.
for an individual employer.
Reducing junior recruitment might improve its short-term finances.
It can concentrate resources on experienced staff
and use technology to support them.
But where do tomorrow's experienced employees come from?
An organisation can't assume indefinitely that somebody else will train
the people it eventually wants to recruit.
Across an economy, that approach would weaken
the development of practical skills,
professional judgment and the knowledge people acquire
by working alongside others.
There is a difference between receiving an answer from software
and understanding why that answer
is appropriate. People build
that understanding through experience. They make decisions,
receive feedback and deal with customers
and discover what happens when circumstances
do not match the textbook.
Those opportunities matter and the consequences of missing them
can last much longer than
the initial period without employment. If somebody spends a
a prolonged period struggling to find work. They miss earnings.
Training and the chance to build a record of achievement.
Meanwhile, other applicants are moving ahead of them.
When that person eventually secures a position,
they may enter at a lower salary than they expected
or accept work with fewer opportunities for progression.
Economists describe these lasting effects as scarring.
The initial setback can continue to influence somebody's career
even after they've found employment.
Now, it's not inevitable that an unemployed
young person will suffer permanently.
People recover, retrain and build successful careers.
But a difficult start can leave them with ground to make up.
Consider two people with similar qualifications.
One finds a suitable role quickly
and spends several years developing skills, contacts and confidence.
The other spends a year searching,
then moves between temporary positions with limited training.
By the time they apply for the same vacancy,
their CVs look very different,
even though the original difference may have
been the opportunity available when they started.
Then there's the effect on independence.
Without a reliable income,
moving out from your parents' home becomes much harder.
Saving a deposit is very difficult.
Renting somewhere suitable can become
impossible without family support.
People may delay relationships,
starting a family or moving to a location
where better opportunities exist.
And family circumstances can make a substantial difference.
A young person whose parents can provide
accommodation and financial support
has more time to search for the right opportunity.
Somebody who needs to contribute
to household bills immediately may have to accept whatever
work is available even if it offers little chance to develop.
That can widen inequality
between people with similar abilities
but very different financial support networks.
It also means unemployment spreads pressure across generations.
Parents may provide support for longer,
reduce their own spending or postpone retirement.
A labour market problem facing young people becomes
a financial problem for wider households.
And if enough young adults struggle to establish themselves,
the consequences reach the economy.
These people are future customers, taxpayers and homebuyers.
Their earnings support demand for goods and services.
If their incomes are weak, businesses face
a smaller market than they otherwise would.
Governments collect less tax than they might have done
while potentially spending more on support.
There's also a loss of productive potential.
People who could be developing useful skills
are spending their time searching for an opportunity.
That matters in countries concerned about productivity,
public finances and the cost
of supporting an ageing population.
We need younger generations to become productive,
adequately paid employees.
Blocking their route into work makes
those wider economic challenges harder.
Now, AI is not the explanation for every high number
on the table that we looked at.
South Africa's employment problems long predate AI.
Weak growth, investment, education,
infrastructure and the way national labour markets operate
All influence the opportunities available.
The OECD has found that relative position
of young graduates began deteriorating
before the latest generation of AI systems.
So the concern is that a serious
existing problem becomes harder to solve
as employers discover new ways to operate with fewer junior recruits.
There are opportunities out there as well.
AI can help inexperienced employees learn quickly,
prepare work and tackle tasks that would previously been beyond them.
A business could use that technology
to make a new recruit useful more quickly.
Smaller companies might expand
because tools make services more affordable.
But that requires an employer willing
to give somebody the opportunity in the first place.
Having access to powerful software does not guarantee
that there will be a salary attached to it.
And telling every young person to learn about AI cannot, by itself,
solve a shortage of entry-level positions.
If every applicant acquires the same skills,
employers still have to decide
How many people they actually need to employ.
That's why I think businesses and governments need
to pay much closer attention to the route into employment.
Apprenticeships, paid training and genuine junior positions provide
opportunities to acquire experience while earning a living.
Employers introducing AI should consider how it can support
those routes rather than assuming
that removing introductory work carries no long term cost.
We also need to examine recruitment figures.
The company can report stable employment
while taking on far fewer young people
because existing staff are staying longer.
The total workforce might look reassuring
while a door facing new entrants is gradually closing.
So the questions I'll be watching are straightforward.
Are businesses recruiting school leavers and graduates?
Are those recruits receiving useful training?
Can they progress into secure work and better pay?
Are young people finding employment that allows them to build a future
Rather than moving indefinitely between
insecure positions because these
unemployment figures represent people trying
to begin their adult lives.
They've been told to study,
acquire qualifications and prepare themselves for
work. Many have invested years into doing exactly that.
If they then discover that businesses no longer need as many beginners,
we need a much better response than
simply telling them to keep applying.
AI could help create a more productive economy,
but that economy still needs a way for people to participate.
So hopefully you found today's
video useful, informative
and most importantly
thought-provoking,
trying to get you thinking about how the impact
of AI could actually be long-term. It's not just
beneficial and helping introduce more productivity,
it could actually be negative in terms of
employment, training people
and bringing all of the youth into an established jobs market.
If you've enjoyed what I've said today,
then please give me a thumbs up. Please subscribe
to the channel if you haven't done so already.
Hit the hype symbol if it's available to you
and have a look at my membership scheme
if you're interested in becoming a member
and helping to support the channel and get early access to my videos.
Thank you so much to people who've already signed up.
If you're a member or a patron, thank you for that long term support.
Really keeps me focused on making more of these videos.
And if you've bought me a coffee or sent me a YouTube super thanks.
Thank you for that generosity.
Means a lot to me and I'll see you again next time.