Have you been wondering why thrifting sucks now? As a former thrift shopping addict turned frugal person and minimalist, this question has left me scratching my head. Who is to blame? Did resellers ruin thrifting or was it corporate greed of CEOs behind thrift stores? If you're decluttering, don't donate to Goodwill until you watch THIS - the harsh truths that NO ONE talks about when it comes to thrifting and overconsumption!
This video examines the decline of thrifting, arguing that it is no longer a sustainable or affordable alternative to retail. It explores how corporate greed, the influx of low-quality fast fashion, and the psychological allure of the \"hunt\" have transformed secondhand shopping into a privilege and, in some cases, a deceptive form of overconsumption.
This is why stuff is ending up in landfills.
Look at these prices.
When you pay 25 cents at the Walmart,
but you have to pay $1.99 at the Goodwill.
Ain't gonna do it.
Not gonna happen.
Empty wine bottle, $7.
No!
Baby's first teeth!
Comes with the grilled cheese.
The amount of biohazards that I was exposed
to as an employee of a thrift store
should have been illegal. I was exposed to feces for $7.50 an hour.
I'm an addictions and mental health therapist and a thrifter and here's
why I think that thrifting should be studied by addiction medicine.
Buckle up because today we're going to do a deep dive
into some dark truths about thrifting
that I feel like no one is talking about
and why thrifting kind of low-key sucks right
now.
This topic has been on my mind lately
because I've been noticing some disturbing trends
at thrift stores and on social media lately
that have been rubbing me the wrong way, especially
as someone who loves thrifting
and has been an avid thrifter for almost 30 years.
It's pain.
Painful to see the direction that thrift stores seem to be headed in,
starting with the fact that
thrift stores seem to be getting more
and more overpriced and unaffordable. Thrift stores used
to be a place where you could find amazing deals
on things like secondhand clothes, vintage kitchen
and cookware, antique furniture.
But more and more, it's starting to feel like shopping at
secondhand stores, flea markets,
and even charity shops is a luxury that people can't afford.
Goodwill is getting ridiculous with their prices.
Gone are the days where a few dollars got you halfway decent items.
Instead, they're charging $18 for some Victoria's Secret slippers
and $8 for literal Walmart-branded candles.
$18 for a coffee maker that doesn't even have the carafe.
That's insane.
Oh, look, there's some obvious fake Jordans behind the glass here
and some knockoff controllers behind the glass as well for some reason.
And they still expect you to pay $11 for a brandless candle with a
Huge crack in it.
You'd think with all these copies of the same book,
they'd basically give these away.
But no, they're still charging full price.
When you pay 25 cents at the Walmart,
but you have to pay $1.99 at the Goodwill.
I ain't gonna do it.
Not gonna happen.
$2.98.
Guess how much they're selling it for.
$4.99.
$1.00.
Originally.
Now on sale for...
And I can't be the only one
who feels like it's totally crazy that people are finding
stuff at the thrift store priced double, triple,
or even more what their original retail price
was in the store.
This is why stuff has ended up in landfills.
Look at these prices.
They got Mega Bloks.
There's three bags here.
They're all $40.
$3.00
After I came across that video,
I decided to go see what similar blocks would sell for
brand new original retail price.
So I was looking up prices of Mega Bloks.
And as you can see,
it looks like these go for a big bag around $20 to $25 at stores
like Walmart and Target.
So who in their right mind is going to pay $40
for used Mega Bloks at the thrift store?
And that's why more and more I'm seeing people
talk about how they would rather buy the exact
same item brand new versus at the thrift store
because it just really leaves a bad taste
in your mouth when you see stuff
that these companies literally got for free being priced
with these outrageous price tags.
Five things we should never buy secondhand based off
of what I see at the thrift store.
Number five, anything that is not over 50% off of retail.
This is more the principle for me,
but if an item is priced at $6 at the thrift store
that I could buy for 10 brand new,
I'm going to buy it brand new. Consider it
my small act of defiance towards thrift store greed,
but it's gotten a little out of hand.
And I don't want this to turn into a commentary video where
I'm just sitting here complaining about the way things
are and acting like there's nothing that
that we can do about it.
So let me show you this next clip of someone
who was looking for a bread box and they found one in
the second-hand store and what I would do if I was in her shoes.
I have a bone to pick with Goodwill.
I've been on the hunt for a bread box.
This is beautiful and it is in great condition
but it is $35. You guys got it for free
and then you're gonna upsell it $35.
This is why I say that you should always take
your phone with you whenever you're going thrifting
so that you can comparison search
and see if the thing that you're looking at
is actually a good deal or whether it's totally overpriced.
And in this case, I...
I actually feel like $35 might not be too bad of a deal
and let me show you why.
So when I saw that video,
I went on my phone and I did kind of an image search with text
to try to figure out what similar roll top.
Bread boxes were selling for,
and I think I found the exact model that she was looking
at available at Target and at Target it's priced for almost $222.
And although the coloring seems a little bit different
when I was looking at it, as you
can see, when you open the bread box inside,
it has those two same strips kind of in the
back.
And that's what leads me to believe that this exact box
is the one that she saw at the thrift store.
So comment down below and let me know,
knowing that that bread box goes for $222 on Target,
would you pay $35 for it at the thrift store?
I mean, I personally think that almost $222 is a little bit outrageous.
For that box to be sold brand new, but I don't know,
I'm not like a bread box connoisseur or
anything like that. So I am definitely interested
to hear your opinions. The next thing I want to
talk about is how thrift stores
also have a huge problem with people donating stuff that's junk or
even literal trash just to avoid dealing with it themselves.
Unpopular opinion. I've never been more scared
to admit anything on the internet ever because
this one might get me canceled, I fear.
But thrifting sucks, okay? Someone had to say it.
Goodwill, you literally suck. These are Nike shorts.
You have price at $9.99 and they literally
have a hole on the side of them and you got these for free.
I've never seen Goodwill try to sell trash
before basically. Empty wine bottle.
I've had this exact same thing happen to me too many times to count,
especially as a frugal
minimalist. I used to like thrift shopping
as a way to kill two birds with one stone
because not only did it save me money,
but it also meant giving old items a second chance
for a new home and life.
But at least in my area, it's gotten to the point where 90 to 95%
of the stuff I'm finding in the thrift store is literal
Junk. And there's nothing more frustrating than finding something
that you like at the thrift
store and picking it up only to realize that it's stained.
It has holes in it. It's broken or it's
missing pieces. And things have gotten so bad.
I'm to the point where it can take me months of
on and off thrifting to find an item I'm looking for.
Like when I was shopping for a new glass
butter dish after the one I got previously
from the thrift store ended up getting chipped.
And all of the ones I found in the thrift store
were also either chipped or broken.
Unless you think I'm exaggerating, just watch this next clip.
Let's go to Goodwill and see what shenanigans they've been up to.
Alright, so starting here, $0.65 for some doll parts. Weird.
Okay, you can get this lounge chair,
but you have to get a tetanus shot first, and you can have it for $9.
Here's some corks that have been glued to a frame.
Kind of strange, but if you want, you can have it for $3.
Here's a lawn ornament, I think. I don't know.
It comes with a ton of leaves and spiderwebs and gross stuff.
But if you really want it, you can have it for $5.
And if you think crusty cups
and worn out sneakers are bad,
that's nothing compared
to what goes on behind the scenes in the back rooms of thrift stores.
If you go thrifting, I need you to shut up
and listen for just two seconds.
The amount of biohazards that I was exposed
to as an employee of a thrift store should
have been illegal.
There was a time that someone donated skates with dead rats in them.
I was told to pull them out with gloves,
wipe them down with Clorox and put them on the
floor.
And another time I was told to follow this guy around
and spray anything he touched.
I didn't know why until he left.
My manager told me that he was sticking his hand completely up his butt
and touching things.
I obviously had
to censor and cut off
that last video because
it was just too gross to
share in its entirety,
but how wild is it that people would donate trinket boxes full of teeth
Or their disgusting old panties.
You have to be really careful with the things
that you bring home from the thrift store.
And some of the hacks that I've used
in the past include if I'm ever buying wool items,
what I'll do is I'll take a Ziploc bag
and I'll put the wool inside of that Ziploc bag
and seal it and then put it in the freezer for at least 72 hours
or up to a week.
And what that does is it kills any residual moth eggs
or larva so that you're not bringing any of those pests
into your home and risking them eating the other wool coats
and items that you have.
I've also very successfully used things like OxiClean
to get tough stains out of both colored and white items.
I think the bigger takeaway here
is that people need to take responsibility
and throw stuff like that in the trash.
Instead of donating it to thrift stores and charity shops,
because not only is it filling
up secondhand stores with all of this junk,
but it's also wasting people's time, energy and money.
For example, just the other day,
I came across this article about a charity shop in the UK
that said that they spent a combined 70,000 pounds having
to sort through and deal with
With unwanted waste last year,
That included things like black moldy books
and fleece work jackets covered in dog hair,
dirty teddy bears, and more.
And speaking of avoiding responsibility,
I also see people using donation as a way to
stay on the hamster wheel of overconsumption
because I'll donate it sounds responsible,
right?
It sounds like you're doing something good for the world.
And donation can be a wonderful thing,
but sometimes it's really just a permission slip
for people to keep buying more and more
and more because they tell themselves they can
just dump their unwanted stuff
at the thrift store later to avoid confronting the real
problem of their spending habits
and asking the tough question of why are they bringing
so much stuff into their home in the first place?
And this problem is only getting worse
because the trend cycle is moving faster than ever
and these must-haves can end up dead, dated,
and dumped at the thrift store the week after.
Hello, let's count dead trends I saw at the thrift store today.
Giant Stanley Cups and Starbucks Cups.
Disney Tsum Tsums.
All of the LuLaRoe leggings.
Seriously, so many of them in basically every size.
Quilted Vera Bradley bags.
Early 2000s initial bags, rothies, and in this case fake rothies,
merchandise that has dabbing on it,
these giant fluffy slippers, squashmallows,
these even have the tags on them, and whatever this is.
I witnessed this firsthand recently
when I was thrifting for that butter dish that I mentioned
earlier, and when I was at the thrift store,
I came across a bunch of trendy water bottle brands
that were the must-have status symbol
not that long ago. Well, well, well.
We have Starbucks, Stanley, Hydro Flask.
Apparently, this is where all
of the water bottle trends have gone to high.
And mind you, all of the trends that were popular when I was growing up
still exist and are out there being sold
for a fraction of what they cost
back when they were the must-have item when I was a kid.
Things like Beanie Babies.
Barbie dolls, longer burger baskets, and more,
even though the cycle is going faster and faster,
the old trends aren't disappearing.
They still exist, whether that's in a thrift store or in
a landfill. But going back to clothes,
one of the worst overconsumption criminals are fast fashion
brands like Timu and Shein.
And it's even more horrifying when you read about how Shein adds
about 10,000 new items to their website.
every single day. And meanwhile,
environmental watchdogs have found that we already have enough
clothes on the planet to clothe the next six generations of people,
even if we never manufacture
another item of clothing. How scary is that?
And to add insult to injury, a lot of thrift stores,
I'm looking at you, Goodwill,
are putting these fast fashion clothes on the floor marked up
to be more expensive than the original retail price.
And I have seen certain secondhand stores come up
with really creative solutions on how to deal
with this massive inflow of fast fashion clothing,
such as allowing you to fill up an entire bag
of those clothes for $10.
But I think the best solution here would be to eliminate
or at the very least slow down our over consumption
of these fast fashion brands.
And I recently did an entire video about
this that I will be sure to link up here for you
about something called the rule of five based
on a sustainable fashion rule of only buying a maximum
of five new items of clothing for an entire year
in case you're interested in finding out more
about that and trying to be more slow
and sustainable with your fashion consumption.
I'm sure this next one is going to be a little bit controversial.
And that is that the ability to go thrifting in and of itself.
has kind of become a privilege.
And I am so sick and tired of seeing all of these videos
gaslighting me about how I don't know what I'm doing.
And I just must not know that much about
thrift shopping if I can't find good things at the thrift store.
Because like I said earlier,
I have been thrifting for almost three decades,
which is longer than some of these influencers
that are making these thrifting videos have been alive.
And as someone who runs her own business,
teaching and coaching people about decluttering,
minimalism, and frugal living,
and who is a busy mom to two young boys who study languages,
are active in sports,
and who want to stay connected and have fun as a family,
I don't have hours upon hours
of free time every single day of the week that I can spend
driving around to different thrift stores
to sort through all of the garbage inside.
And especially because as a minimalist nowadays,
when I go to the thrift store,
I'm looking for very specific things.
And a lot of the times I have to walk out empty handed.
This is a PSA for new thrifters.
Nine out of 10 times, you are leaving the thrift store with
I think I get the most comments on my hauls just saying like
my goodwill doesn't have anything or
her goodwill must be really really good
and this is just simply not true. If you are new to thrifting
you have to go so often
because you are leaving empty-handed more times than you are winning.
I also want to point out that the content creator I just featured
is a home decor influencer.
And I think this is an important
and often undiscussed distinction that a lot of the
influencers you see finding these amazing things
at secondhand stores have literally made it their
entire job to go thrifting
and find cool things that they can show you on social media.
And they're literally spending hours upon hours each week
in order to do so,
which a lot of average folks don't have the time
or the flexibility to do.
Has thrifting in America become a privilege?
Hi, I'm Kate, and I have made a career out of
thrifting, upcycling, and sewing education.
And as someone who grew up in thrift stores out of
This is out of necessity.
This is a really hard concept for me to grasp,
but it's an important conversation that we need
to be having. Early in my content creator days,
a real life friend said something to me that I
have never been able to shake.
She said, you are so lucky you get to thrift. You are so lucky you
have the time to thrift.
Someone who grew up being bullied and made fun of her entire life
for wearing used clothes, this statement really
It really did something to me.
The truth is she's a single mom.
She has three kids.
She works full time and her kids are in sports.
When was she going to have time to thrift?
The reality of it is, is that it's
so much easier for her to come home after a long day
at work and sit down
and order things from a fast fashion website for cheaper than she'd
probably get at a thrift store and have
it delivered right to her house.
Thrifting really is not that accessible.
This is why I stopped thrifting.
Yeah, stopped.
This is like when the unemployed homie gets a job.
All of this might sound a little bit odd
considering I blew up off of thrifting.
Started this account making savers, goodwill bins videos.
But these days, you don't really see me doing that as much.
I'm here to tell you guys why.
I think shopping secondhand is great
and I've always been an advocate for it.
I always preach sustainability.
But if you are over consuming, how sustainable is it?
This was the crossroads that I was left at when I was starting Dijon.
Everything that I was previously buying, I was ultimately buying.
For no reason.
Now, if you're an OG, I bet you remember when I used to sell on Depop.
I had the New Method series.
I would buy all these clothes
and I would sell just stuff I didn't really like.
Once I developed more of a curation,
and that's such a buzzword on my phone.
When I found more of my personal style,
I ultimately could not find certain things at the thrift anymore.
Don't get me wrong, I think thrift stores
are great for building personal style.
When I feel like I finally developed it,
I just couldn't buy what I was looking for.
If I'm looking for certain fabrics like gabardine,
or if I'm looking for, you know, an old flannel that I'd like.
That part about him not being able
to find flannel actually hit me hard
because I recently
was looking for flannel shirts to try to replace
a favorite flannel shirt of mine that I had
owned for almost a decade that got a hole in it.
And when I tell you, I had to sort through.
dozens of shirts and either they
were so poorly made they had holes in them or the stitching was
bad or they were so thin that you could already see through them
and I knew they weren't going
to last that long. And going back to that guy's video
this brings me to another controversial
topic that constantly gets brought up
when it comes to thrifting which is this idea that
that resellers are the ones who are guilty for ruining thrifting.
And in the thrifting community,
resellers have kind of become this sub-niche when it
comes to making content around thrifting on social media.
And whenever I see resellers sharing their videos,
inevitably in the comments, there's
always going to be a ton of people
who are saying that resellers are bad.
Resellers are terrible people.
And their argument is that resellers are swooping
in and grabbing all of the good stuff.
And leaving everyone else to pick through the leftovers and junk.
But if you dig into the actual data and history,
I don't think resellers are the problem.
I think they're just a convenient scapegoat for a much bigger issue,
which is corporate greed.
What in the hell is going on at Goodwill?
My sister brought me to the one here at Ocala.
It's because of him.
Yes, this guy right here,
the president and CEO of Goodwill since 2019, who got his start
working at Lehman Brothers,
so we know how well that's going to work out, was the CEO
of Oakleaf Global Holdings for two years before selling it,
becoming executive vice president
of the company he sold it to, who worked for the...
Bush administration and the small business administration,
then became Bush's HUD secretary,
was CEO of a brokerage company,
was vice chairman of Liberty Advisor Group, a consulting agency,
before becoming president and CEO in 2019.
If we look at 2018's annual report, look at all of the
money that Goodwill gave to direct services to membership
and sponsored programs and grants.
Look at it. Then we get to the first full year that he was CEO
and he cut direct services to
membership by $25 million.
Because here's the other thing you have to keep in mind. Like we
mentioned earlier, thrift stores are not hurting for inventory.
They get more donations than they
can possibly handle or sell.
And a lot of that stuff still ends up in landfills at the end of
the day. Has thrifting in America become a privilege?
I'm very qualified to speak on this.
I wrote this, and I was in a couple articles
and stuff talking about this.
There's this, like, huge false scarcity argument going on, like,
oh my god, resellers are gonna buy everything,
there's gonna be nothing left.
But, like, this statistic is why that's wrong.
Consumers purchased 60% more clothing in 2014 than they did in 2000
and kept clothing for half as long.
That was 2014. I was not able to find an updated statistic,
but you can imagine that it's far worse.
There's an ass load more clothes to go through.
Like that's why resellers are there
is because there's more clothing
for more people to be putting up online.
Also the people who buy secondhand clothes online
would likely not go into a thrift store otherwise.
So resellers make secondhand clothing more accessible.
And while I'm sure there are shady resellers out there,
that doesn't mean that all of them
are necessarily bad apples.
In fact, I personally know a few resellers
who are doing amazing work.
Rescuing perfectly good stuff from dumpsters
and curbside on trash day and then putting in the work
to find someone who actually wants it,
making good money in the process, which is a win for them and
is also the added win of keeping those things out
of the landfill where they were already headed.
True story. Years ago, I used to work with this math genius
who was so smart he even had his own
TV show. And he once told me something that always stuck with me,
which is that in this world,
we don't have a supply problem.
We have a distribution problem. And at the time,
he was talking about food.
But over the years, I realized the same rule also applies to stuff.
It's not that we have a shortage of material goods,
because as we've already discussed,
even when it comes to clothing,
we already have more than enough clothes
to clothe everyone on the planet and then some.
But the actual problem is getting all of those
things into the hands of the people who actually want and need them,
which is why I think resellers
actually serve a beneficial role in solving that problem.
So maybe resellers
aren't ruining thrifting. Maybe they're just doing
their small part to fix a system that is already
broken because they redistribute things
from where they aren't wanted to where they are wanted and
needed. The next harsh truth I want to talk about
is how addictive thrift shopping can be. And this
is a tough one because thrifting has a reputation
for being a more ethical and sustainable form of
But just because you're buying something
secondhand, that doesn't mean that you're
not over-consuming.
It's really easy to convince ourselves
that buying more is okay at the thrift store because
it's cheap, it's secondhand, and hey,
we're doing a great job by keeping stuff out of
a landfill.
But thrifting can also be dangerous if taken to an extreme
or if you have an addictive
personality or struggle with compulsive shopping.
People are always like, you love thrifting.
I'm like, no, no, no, no.
I don't love thrifting.
I'm addicted to thrifting.
Okay.
I think I'm going thrifting every single day.
And people love to make jokes about
this and talk about how at least I'm not doing something
a lot more toxic than thrifting.
And I've come across a lot of videos like that,
as you can see right here.
And speaking as someone who has addictive personalities
that run in my family, I have witnessed this firsthand in my family and
And more and more, I'm starting
to see people opening up about their thrifting addictions
and mental health experts who are bringing this to light.
I'm an addictions and mental health therapist and a thrifter.
And here's why I think that thrifting should
be studied by addiction medicine.
So I was noticing how I feel anticipation and the anticipation
before I go thrifting, antiquing, estate sailing, whatever.
is oftentimes greater than the reward
of getting the thing in and of itself.
This is called the dopamine cycle.
So basically whenever you feel a stimulus,
so the stimulus can be something related to the behavior.
Hey, somebody posted this really cool
thing they thrifted, or it can be unrelated.
Hey, I'm just having an off day. I woke up on
the wrong side of the bed.
The next thing that you do typically is you seek outside yourself
I'm
um, quell that feeling going on inside.
starting
You anticipate what it is that you need and you
start feeling like, oh, I'm going to look forward to this.
This pleasurable feeling that I'm getting
just from thinking about doing that thing,
to
thrifting in this case, is hyping me up and
speak
making me feel better. And then you pull the trigger.
So you go and do the process behavior.
now.
In this case, we're talking about thrifting.
And then you get the reward by buying the thing,
which then creates a memory and habit formation,
which then puts you back into the cycle
or firmly establishes the cycle.
And I've even seen people talking about how thrift shopping
is like a form of treasure
hunting or gambling because you never know what you might find
and you never know when you're
When you're going to strike out or strike big,
and this is like gambling, this is.
Kind of what keeps the addiction going
of thrifting is you just never know when you're
going to hit a jackpot and hit big.
So it kind of just gives you this like your conditioned response
that I'm going to go, I'm going to go,
I'm going to go. And at some point.
I'm gonna hit big. And a lot
of people treat thrift shopping as an excuse to continually
chase dopamine hits they would otherwise be getting at Target
or the mall or wherever
and rationalize the behavior
because spending five dollars here and ten dollars there
feels a lot more innocent than dropping two hundred dollars
at the mall. Switching from
buying too much at the mall to buying too much
at the thrift store doesn't fix the underlying issue.
At the end of the day, thrift shopping is still shopping
and buying secondhand stuff
can still clutter up your home
and leave you broke just as easily as buying everything
brand new can.
And if you want to hear my best tips on how
to thrift like a minimalist so that you can
save money while still avoiding overconsumption,
be sure and go check out this video that I've
linked up here for you.
And finally, the last subject that I want to touch
on might just be the darkest part of thrift
shopping of all, which is that thrift shopping
in and of itself inherently forces you to face
harsh truths about life and your own mortality.
Just like with the previous point and how a lot
of people turn the addictive nature of thrift shopping into a joke.
I've also seen a lot of people joking about this topic.
I'm at a point in my life where like I might
be able to afford a Breville toaster.
Maybe, maybe, maybe.
So I'm excited, but then it did occur
to me like if it really is that great,
I guess there's a chance this could be my last toaster.
Dang, that's heavy.
I'm not ready for all that.
I'm just trying to make my dino nuggets crispy.
Now you got me contemplating my mortality.
Like the saying goes, sometimes you have to laugh
so that you don't cry because if you
go thrifting, at some point you're going
to come across fine china sets, collections of
cat figurines and keepsakes
and other things that bring a tear to your eye.
Oh my gosh, I'm struggling to not cry right now just talking about it.
Gosh darn it, Marissa, get a grip!
These are things that someone once budgeted and saved money for,
or were gifted at their wedding,
or made as a DIY project for their children
that they treasured, protected, and thought they'd keep forever.
Until one day, the finite amount
of sand left in their hourglass ran out.
Whether we make the decision ourselves
or if someone else has to make it for us, all
of us are going to have to face the truth
that no matter how much stuff we accumulate,
we don't get to keep any of it at the end of our lives.
Oh, I need a sip of tea.
Obviously, this is something that I've struggled with a lot as someone
who lost my parents and
whose grief turned me into an emotional hoarder.
But along my over 10-year journey to declutter,
let go, and become a minimalist,
I've completely changed my relationship with stuff. And if you
also struggle with this, be sure
and go check out one of these videos that I've linked over
here for you, or I'll see you next week. Until then, take care.
Bye-bye.