Ever wonder why you can’t resist a good sale, even on something you don't actually need? In this video, we break down the psychology of spending and expose the anchoring effect, a powerful cognitive bias that retailers use to trick your brain into overspending. From Amazon Prime Day to restaurant menus, businesses intentionally manufacture fake "original prices" to make you feel like you're winning a deal.
Learn exactly how price anchoring works, why pricing strategies failed when JCPenney tried to stop them, and, most importantly, how you can fight back to save your money and declutter your life.
Subscribe for more insights on intentional living and smart spending.
--- My new book, Uncluttered Faith, is out now everywhere books are sold.
--- Most popular videos:
3 Things to Buy to be Happier, According to Science • 3 Things to Buy to be Happier, According t...
Top 10 Things to Declutter Right Now • Top 10 Things To Declutter Right Now
--- You can read more tips in my book, Things That Matter: Overcoming Distraction to Pursue a More Meaningful Life.
Read hundreds of articles on decluttering and owning less on the Becoming Minimalist blog.
---
TIMESTAMPS 0:00 - The Multi-Billion Dollar Prime Day Phenomenon 1:54 - What is the Anchoring Effect? 2:43 - Two Reasons Price Anchoring Works on Us 5:04 - The Famous JCPenney Pricing Failure 5:57 - Real-World Examples of Anchor Pricing (Retail, Menus, Software) 7:11 - 6 Steps to Overcome the Anchoring Effect & Stop Overspending
ABOUT THIS VIDEO: Do you ever wonder "Why do sales work so well on me?" You're not alone. The human mind uses mental shortcuts (heuristics) to make decisions. When you see a crossed-out price tag, your brain "anchors" to that first high number, making the sale price feel like an automatic win. Written by Joshua Becker, this video explores how to recognize retail manipulation, ask the right questions before buying, and reclaim control over your shopping habits.
This past summer, Americans spent more
than $26 billion during Amazon Prime Day.
Now, for those of you who don't know,
Prime Day is a highly publicized, several-day sales
event where Amazon slashes prices
for a whole range of products on their website.
That $26 billion spent is a record high.
In fact, that number is 9% above last year,
which had already set a record on its own.
And I assume the numbers will be similar for Black Friday,
which is right around the corner.
Americans, it seems, cannot resist a sale.
But have you ever wondered why?
Why are sales so common and why do they work so well on us?
What is it exactly about a discount,
even on something we don't need, that compels us to buy?
Well, there's a reason sales work so well.
It is called the anchoring effect.
And every one of us is influenced by it.
So the more we recognize it and understand why it works on us,
the sooner we can begin to fight back.
In fact, once you know it, you'll see it everywhere you go.
The reason sales work
so well on us is because of something called the anchoring effect.
Anchoring is a well-documented cognitive bias in psychology.
You see, the human mind has a tendency to grab
the first piece of information it's given
and use that as the reference point for everything else that follows.
Because it's impossible for us to know everything about everything,
we subconsciously look for mental shortcuts
and cues to help us make decisions.
And because of that bias, the very first price we see on a product
often becomes the reference point, the anchor.
that we use to make further decisions concerning it.
Essentially, the first price we see becomes our default
assumption on what an item is worth and the standard for every price
that follows.
So a store shows a blender that costs $99, but it offers it to us
on sale for $59. Our mind locks in onto
that first number that we see, $99.
And so immediately, without consulting any other information,
$59 feels like a win and
a great deal.
After all, it's priced cheaper than the product must actually be worth.
Now, there are two reasons this method works so well.
First, anchoring works so well
because it is impossible for us to know what everything
is actually worth.
We don't know what it costs to manufacture a blender,
ship it across the country, stock it on a shelf,
and pay the staff standing next to it.
Much less do we know whether that blender is crafted with a specific
quality of components or workmanship
and how much that should impact the price.
I mean, how much really is a blender worth?
And the same is true of a jacket or a mattress,
a skillet, a pair of shoes, a set of headphones.
So when the tag says that this costs $99,
we have nothing to argue with and we let the
price tell us the value.
But the second reason anchoring works
so well is we simply take the store at its word.
We assume that $99 is what the blender is worth
because why would they print a number
that wasn't true?
It's like we figure in the back of our minds they did
the math on the value of the blender,
The real cost plus a fair markup.
So the sale price must mean we're winning
because even buying because we might even be buying it
below what the store itself it rarely occurs to us
that the first price exists only to make the
second one look good. We trust the tag so we trust the sale.
Retailers know this and they
price accordingly.
That original number the one with the line through it
It's oftentimes a price that no one was ever meant to pay.
The MSRP gets set high on purpose,
or the compare at dollar amount on the tag is looser still,
sometimes pointing to a price that the item never actually sold for.
To carry this even further,
some products are made specifically for outlet stores,
designed from the very beginning to display a higher original price
that they never actually charged for the item.
If there's any doubt about how persuasive an anchor price can be,
look at what happened
to JCPenney.
In 2012, in a well-documented decision and well-studied,
I might add, the company decided
to stop running sales.
Instead, they decided that they would mark everything
at the lowest possible price from
the start when they first put it out on the rack.
And guess what?
People hated it.
Sales fell by billions in a single year,
and the plan was almost immediately scrapped.
Without the anchoring effect to persuade people
to think they were getting a good deal,
people stopped buying, even though the prices were better
for every item from the very beginning.
And of course, once you see it,
you will see price anchoring everywhere you look.
Almost every product on Amazon these days,
whether it's Prime Day or not,
has a list price crossed out with a new lower price next to it.
Black Friday sales will do the same.
Kohl's, I think, runs perpetual sales.
A higher list price is manufactured specifically
to make the current price look like a deal
and savings. But it's not just retail stores that do this.
Restaurants might put a wildly expensive steak
at the very top of the menu
just to make everything else seem a little more reasonable.
Websites offer $179 value, but you can get it for just $29 today.
Software and streaming sites show three plans side by side,
often pricing one really high to make
the middle option appear to be a better deal.
All of them are designed to part you
from your money based on the anchoring effect.
So now that you know it and you know what it is,
let's talk about how to practically overcome it.
Because we can take back control
and we don't have to be influenced by sales.
Here's how.
Number one, see the anchoring effect
when it's happening and call it what it is.
The next time you're in a store
and you see anchor pricing used to manipulate your decision,
just call it what it is, out loud, to yourself, if that is helpful.
I think they're just listing this higher price
to convince me to buy this item.
We tend to have an adverse reaction to being manipulated.
So if we can identify what's happening,
we're less likely to fall for it.
Number two.
When it comes to our shopping,
start with the only question that matters.
Before you look at any sale or discount,
ask yourself, do I really need this?
After all, if you didn't need it yesterday at full price,
you don't need it today just
because it's on sale.
Number three, don't look at the discount.
Look at the price you will be paying.
We don't buy things with money.
We buy them with hours from our life.
So rather than looking at what you are saving,
look at how much you will be spending, how
much you will be giving up,
how much of your life will be spent on this purchase, and is
it worth it?
Number four,
remind yourself where sale shopping has gotten you.
If shopping for deals has served you well, then keep it up.
If, on the other hand,
shopping for deals has resulted in a house full of clutter,
Or financial discontent.
Decide that the practice is not serving you well.
And number five, never let a sale tell you what you need.
Let me repeat that.
Never let a sale tell you what you need.
If you entered a store
or a website with all that you needed to live just fine yesterday,
don't let a for sale sign
or a clearance rack convince you that you need something today.
And number six.
If you want to overcome the anchoring effect in your life,
ask, what if I don't?
Always remind yourself of the opportunity that can
be found in not buying the item by asking,
but what if I don't buy this?
What could I use the money for if I didn't buy it?
Is there something more meaningful
and longer lasting that I could spend my money on?
And if so, choose what is better.
No matter how good of a deal, the anchoring effect applies that it is.
We're never going to escape sales.
Prime Day will return, so will Black Friday.
The clearance rack and the next bright red tag
while pushing a shopping cart is right around the corner.
But we don't have to be incorrectly influenced by them.
We can always take back control of our shopping and our lives.