Padres are Forced Into An IMPOSSIBLE Financial Decision...
Nov 15, 2026
AI Generated·May contain errors
The Padres are in desperate need of starting pitching.
Five of their starters have left for
free agency. Those five made 91 of the team's 162 starts this season.
More than half the starts from
a 91 win team just walked out the door.
But here's the important question.
Are you going to spend all of your money on a top
of the line ace or are you going to spread
the money across two arms to fill two different holes?
The expensive option is Tariq Skubal who
finished this season with a 2.72 ERA across 158.2 innings.
His ERA plus which adjusts for ballparks
and sets league average at 100 was 155.
The Padres staff as a whole had a 3.98 ERA this season.
That's 1.26 runs higher than Tariq Skubal's.
And nothing under those numbers says he got lucky.
His expected ERA, which grades the contact hitters made against him,
was 2.94, right next to the real one and in the 90th percentile.
His FIP, which only counts strikeouts, walks,
and home runs, was even lower at 2.51.
Hitters averaged 87.1 miles an hour off the bat against him,
and only 34.8% of those balls they
put in play were hit hard.
And with that, his record was 12-7 with 186 strikeouts. He struck
out 30% of the hitters he faced, which is the 91st percentile.
Plus, he did it with velocity too,
as his fastball ranked in the 85th percentile.
Hitters also missed on 31.7% of their swings
Which is the 90th percentile.
He also did not walk a lot of batters at 4.4%,
which makes him the 99th percentile in baseball.
That's only 27 walks all season.
One for every 6.9 strikeouts.
And hitters chase 36.6% of his pitches outside the zone,
which is the 97th percentile.
He doesn't hand out free bases,
and he gets hitters to swing at pitches that make them look stupid.
His whip was below one,
which means fewer than one baserunner an inning from hits and walks
together. And since 2000, only four pitchers have qualified
for the ERA title while matching him on
ERA, strikeouts, and walks.
They are Justin Verlander in 2022, Clayton Kershaw in 2017,
Roy Halladay in 2010, and Jordan Zimmerman in 2014.
He finished just 3.1 innings short
of the 162 he needed to join them.
But his 26 starts are only one rotation spot,
about 29% of the actual 91 starts the Padres need to replace.
That still leaves 65 of them to fill,
and by our math, about two more rotation spots worth.
Now let's take a look at his projected
contract through MLB Trade Rumors.
MLB Trade Rumors projects Skubal at nine years and $425 million.
That works out to $47.2 million a year.
But with his reputation as good as it is,
he is number one on the MLB trade rumors list
of the top 50 free agents.
Skubal is the best, obviously, no doubt about that.
But he's going to cost a contract
of two mid to top tier pitchers just for one player.
And the Padres need a lot of arms this offseason.
So if Scooball costs as much as two good pitchers,
what do two good pitchers look like?
Well, here's Trevor Rogers.
He just finished his season in Baltimore with a 4.03 ERA.
His ERA plus was 101 right at league average
and just under the Padres staff of 103.
But those surface numbers make him look
a lot less than he actually was.
His expected ERA was 3.60,
which is almost half a run lower than the real one
and in the 72nd percentile.
His FIP was even lower at 3.45.
His record was 10 and 11, but under it,
the parts he controls looked a lot better than the ERA.
The runs came from runners scoring behind him.
He stranded 69.3% of base runners this year after 84.2% in 2025.
This year, he got bit by the home run bug a little bit too.
8.8% of his fly balls left the park after the 5.5% he had last year.
His average balls in play was 0.297.
Close to normal, so hitters weren't squaring him up more.
And hitters hit the ball hard 36.2% of the time against him.
Barely more than against Skubal.
Barrels, the most damaging contact,
came on 6.8% of the balls hit against him,
next to the 6.7% against Skubal.
And he still only walked 5.6% of hitters,
which puts him in the 92nd percentile.
So that's four strikeouts for every walk,
by our math, where Skubal had almost seven.
Hitters chased 35.6% of his pitches outside the zone,
which is close to Skubal's 36.6%.
And his fastball averaged 93.8 mph this season.
He threw 169.2 innings with 157 strikeouts.
With those strikeouts, he struck out 22.5% of the hitters he faced,
which is right at the 50th percentile, so average.
Hitters did miss on 24.4% of their swings against him, 46th percentile,
so he gets his outs more on contact than Skubal does,
who's more of a strikeout guy.
He made 30 starts, which is about a third
of the 91 the Padres need to replace.
Of course, which is four more than Skubal made.
The year before, he did have a 1.81 ERA,
but his expected ERA was 3.41,
which was nowhere near the real one.
He threw 109.2 innings that year,
which is about 60 fewer than his season,
so the 1.81 came in a smaller sample size.
MLB.com wrote that the 1.81 was likely never to last.
And this year, the strand rate came back down to normal.
And put those two seasons together,
and his expected ERA since the start of 2025 is 3.52.
MLB Trade Rumors projects him at five years and $115 million,
which is $23 million a year.
That's a little over a quarter of Skubal's projected total.
And MLB Trade Rumors ranks him second on its top 50,
right behind Skubal.
But there is a catch.
Baltimore gave him a $23.15 million qualifying offer,
and he has until November 17th to take it.
That one-year offer pays almost exactly what
his projected deal pays per year.
So the gap is about $150,000.
So if he turns down his qualifying offer and signs somewhere else,
the team that signs him gives up draft pick compensation.
For the Padres, MLB trade rumors list that cost as their second
and fifth highest pick in next year's draft.
Plus $1 million in international bonus pool money.
But Rodgers is a solid pitcher.
He was hurt by some bad luck,
but he isn't anything that'll blow people away,
fans and hitters alike.
If these Padres breakdowns help you follow the offseason,
hit subscribe.
We're almost at 6,000,
and every single one of you guys who hit subscribe
helps us get to our goal.
Then there's Tyler Miley,
who went 7-10 with a 3.99 ERA this season.
That's almost exactly the 3.98 ERA the Padres staff put up as a whole.
His ERA plus was 103, which is a little better than league average.
His expected ERA was 3.95, which is the 56th percentile.
So what you saw is exactly what he was.
And his FIP was the same as his ERA at 3.99 as well.
Hitters averaged 89.6 miles an hour off the bat against him.
The hardest contact of these three starters.
And he struck out 137 while walking 46,
which are solid numbers without anything
that really jumps off the page.
And that's about three strikeouts for every walk,
the fewest of these three starters.
His strikeout rate, 22.3%, was close to Rodgers' 22.5%,
and he walked 7.5% of the hitters he faced, which is 64th percentile,
the most of these three starters.
Hitters chased only 28.9% of his pitches outside the zone,
which is the 31st percentile,
and missed on 22.9% of their swings.
His WHIP was 1.24, about one more base runner
every four innings than Skubal allowed.
He's not going to overpower anyone.
His fastball averaged 92.8 miles an hour, which is the 23rd percentile.
That's a whole mile an hour slower than Rodgers.
The bigger question with Miley is how often he's on the mound.
He threw only 12.2 innings in 2024.
In 2025, that rose to 86.2 innings with a 3.18 ERA.
And this year's 149 innings were the most
of those three seasons by a long shot.
He made 27 starts, which is one more than Skubal.
That's 30% of the 91 starts the Padres need to replace.
MLB Trade Rumors projects him at three years and $54 million,
which is $18 million a year.
That's less than half of what Rodgers
is projected to get over two fewer years.
And MLB Trade Rumors ranks him at 14th on its top 50 free agents.
He can't get a qualifying offer this winter,
so signing him costs no draft pick.
And at $18 million a year, he'd cost about $5 million less than
the one-year offer Rodgers is sitting on.
So Motley is as advertised, a fine back-end rotation type arm.
And when he's healthy, he's good to eat innings and to get some outs.
Don't expect him to wow you, but he might be nice for the right price.
But put those two cheaper arms next to the expensive one.
Rodgers at $23 million a year,
plus Motley at $18 million, comes to $41 million a year.
Skubal alone is $47.2 million a year,
so the pair costs $6.2 million less every single season.
That saving is about a third
of Motley's projected salary every single year.
And this season, the two of them made 57 starts against Skubal's 26,
which will be 63% of the 91 starts the Padres need to replace.
Against this season's stats,
Skubal's projection alone cost about $1.8 million a start.
Rodgers and Motley together come to about $719,000 a start,
which is less than half as much.
They threw 318.2 innings between them as well to Skubal's 158.2.
So by the inning,
it's about $298,000 for Skubal against about $129,000 for the pair.
But on the other side of it,
Skubal's ERA was more than a full run lower than either of theirs.
His 2.94 expected ERA was also a full run better than Motley's 3.95.
Over the full deals,
that's $169 million for the pair against $425 million for Skubal.
And if you're curious, that's $256 million less on the books.
And that deal ends sooner as well,
because Motley would run three years and Rodgers five,
while Skubal runs nine total years.
So combined, the two deals will run eight years,
which is one fewer than Scooball's alone.
So the choice comes down to this,
to quality in one spot or coverage in two spots.
And there's a third path too.
Wait with Rodgers' answer on his qualifying offer due November 17th.
So here's how I would break it down.
Scooball would be such a nice addition to this team,
but he's only going to fill one
of the many holes we have on this team currently.
The two other players, while they're not great,
are going to fill more holes than what Scooball has,
especially financially and just player-wise.
Scooball is one player, they are two.
So then here's the important question.
Should the Padres go all-in on Scooball,
spread it on Rodgers or Mali,
or wait for other deals?
You let me know in the comments down below,
and thank you guys so much for watching.
Please subscribe.
Have a great day.

