You know Raphael's two little angels from mugs and postcards. But they sit at the bottom edge of the Sistine Madonna — and the mother and child above them seem troubled by something we can't see.
Follow Raphael from the court of Urbino to the Vatican: the careful preparation behind a tiny early painting, a solitary figure in The School of Athens who is absent from his surviving full-size drawing, a courtly ideal of effortless grace, a last painting that was really a contest, and a death at 37. Then see how the Sistine Madonna, painted for the monastery church of San Sisto in Piacenza and now in Dresden, became a model of perfection — why a group of young painters called themselves Pre-Raphaelites — and what changes when we put the painting back in its church.
Did you know these angels came from this painting? Where did you first see them?
0:00 You Know These Angels 0:55 A Borrowed Beginning 2:47 Ease Has to Be Practised 4:21 The Faces on the Wall 6:58 Sprezzatura: The Art of Hiding Effort 8:50 A Race, and a Death at 37 10:48 How Raphael Became the Rule 12:47 What the Madonna Was Facing
School of Athens cartoon photo by Christelle Molinié — CC BY-SA 4.0 Stanza della Segnatura photos by 0ro1 — CC BY-SA 3.0 San Sisto, Piacenza photo by Mongolo1984 — CC BY-SA 4.0 Terrain: Mapzen Terrain Tiles (AWS Open Data) with data from SRTM, GMTED2010, ETOPO1 and other sources
AI Generated·May contain errors
You've seen these two on mugs, stamps and postcards.
Two bored little angels, chins in their hands.
But they come from the bottom edge of an altarpiece,
and the people above them are not relaxed at all.
This is Raphael's Sistine Madonna.
Raphael made everything look this easy.
It wasn't.
At the top, a curtain rod and its rings.
At the bottom, a ledge where the angels lean.
The whole picture is staged as a vision,
Appearing as a curtain opens,
and the mother and child stepping out of it don't look calm.
So what work lay behind that ease?
And what do we lose when we copy the result without its context?
We'll see the preparation behind a painting,
the faces missing from his drawing,
the hands that helped him, and a death at 37.
And at the end, we'll go back to the church to see what that mother
and child may have been facing.
Raphael was born in 1483 in Urbino,
a small hill town with one of the most refined courts in Italy.
His father, Giovanni Santi, was the Duke's painter and a poet as well.
Raphael lost his mother when he was eight and his father
when he was eleven, but he wasn't left on his own.
An uncle, a priest, raised him,
one of his father's collaborators kept working beside him,
and the court's connections kept opening doors.
Over the next few years he worked across central Italy,
Urbino, Città di Castello, Perugia,
back and forth across the Apennines.
Then Florence, from about 1504, and in 1508 Rome.
In Perugia, the most admired painter of the region kept a workshop,
Pietro Perugino. Whether Raphael
was ever formally his pupil is still debated,
but for a few years he painted very much like him.
This is Perugino's Marriage of the Virgin,
and this is Raphael's from 1504.
Same story, same plan,
a domed temple on a stepped platform and the wedding in front.
But Raphael pushes the temple further back
and makes it rounder with many more sides.
The crowd bends into a curve and the paving pulls your eye up the steps
through the open door to the sky beyond.
He didn't invent this composition.
He borrowed it.
And kept adjusting it.
In Florence, two giants were at work,
Leonardo da Vinci and Michelangelo.
From Leonardo, Raphael took a shape,
figures locked together in a pyramid,
joined by glances and touch.
Here it is in Leonardo's Virgin and Child with Saint Anne.
And here in Raphael's Madonna of the Meadow, painted around 1506.
Was any of this easy for him?
One of his early biographers said no.
Giorgio Vasari wrote Raphael's biography a generation after his death.
He says Raphael abandoned his early manner only with great difficulty.
And that, to learn from Michelangelo,
he was changed from a master once again into a disciple,
forcing himself, with incredible study,
to do in a few months what usually takes years.
That's praise, written later,
but even this admiring biographer didn't call him effortless.
Now, one of his earliest small paintings, The Dream of a Knight.
A young knight sleeps beneath a tree.
One woman offers him a book and a sword, the other a sprig of flowers.
His father had used this same old choice,
between virtue and pleasure, in a long poem for the court,
a poem he called A Vision Seen in Sleep.
Even a picture this small began with a full-size drawing.
Its outlines were pricked with rows of tiny holes.
The sheet was laid over the prepared panel,
then dabbed with a little bag of charcoal dust.
The dust passed through the holes,
leaving dotted outlines on the panel underneath.
Technical study of this panel shows it
was transferred in just this way.
But careful planning didn't lock the picture. After the transfer,
Raphael kept drawing freehand and changing things.
The woman with the flowers got a more modest dress,
and a stream with a little bridge became
a crossroads with three horsemen.
Study, planning, transfer, and still second thoughts.
That's what this ease was made of.
In 1508 Raphael arrived in Rome, he was 25,
Pope Julius II was remaking the Vatican and he
handed this young man from Urbino a room in his own private apartments.
Letters from the Urbino
court probably helped, so perhaps did
the Pope's architect Donato Bramante, who also came from near
Urbino. This room is usually thought to have been the Pope's library.
Its walls are about knowledge,
Theology, Philosophy,
Poetry and law.
On the philosophy wall,
Raphael painted what we now call the School of Athens.
Plato and Aristotle stand at the center,
with the thinkers of the ancient world
spread across the steps around them.
In Milan, something remarkable survives.
Raphael's full-size drawing for this fresco,
almost three meters tall and eight meters wide.
It's a careful finished drawing of the figures,
fine enough to show a patron.
But the architecture is missing.
No arches, no vaults, just the figures, and the steps they stand on.
So let's lay the drawing over the wall, just where the figures are.
On the steps in front, the drawing is empty.
On the wall, a man sits there alone,
leaning on a block of stone, writing, lost in thought.
He's usually identified as the philosopher Heraclitus,
and for a long time, people have
seen in him the face and build of Michelangelo.
At that moment, Michelangelo was painting
the ceiling of the Sistine Chapel, a short
walk away.
According to Vasari, Bramante had the keys,
and let Raphael in to see it while Michelangelo
was away.
Michelangelo never forgot Raphael.
In 1542, 22 years after Raphael's death,
in a bitter dispute over a tomb, he wrote this.
All the disagreements between Pope Julius and me
came from the envy of Bramante and of Raphael, of Urbino.
And Raphael had good reason. What he had
of art, he had from me.
That's one side of a quarrel, written long afterwards, but it tells
He tells you how the rivalry felt to him.
The right-hand edge.
Here, look at the men at the very edge of the crowd.
A man in white stands beside a young man in a dark cap,
looking straight out at us.
According to Vasari, that young man is Raphael himself.
The finished wall holds both the figure traditionally read as his rival
and the painter himself.
The drawing shows a change in the foreground.
At the edge, Raphael makes himself part of this gathering of minds.
One of Raphael's friends from the Urbino court
was Baldassare Castiglione, diplomat, courtier, and writer.
Raphael painted him around 1514, soft greys and blacks,
a calm face, hands quietly clasped, nothing in its strains.
In 1528, Castiglione published the Book of the Courtier,
a guide to how the perfect gentleman should behave,
And he gave a name to the quality he admired most, Sprezzatura.
A certain carelessness that hides the art,
so that whatever is done or said seems to come
without effort, almost without thought.
He was writing about courtiers, not painters,
but later viewers found the same quality in Raphael.
The labour hidden, only the grace
left showing. There's also a famous letter,
said to be from Raphael to Castiglione,
in which the painter says he works from a certain idea in his mind.
It wasn't printed until 1554, and in 1994 the historian John Shearman
questioned whether Raphael really wrote it.
Meanwhile, the real Raphael was busier than ever.
By the late 1510s, his work spread from frescoes and altarpieces
to portraits, buildings, and the care of Rome's ancient ruins.
He couldn't do it alone, and he didn't.
Assistants like Giulio Romano
and Gianfrancesco Penny didn't just fill in color.
They helped to design.
For the Sistine Chapel, Raphael designed ten great tapestries. Seven
of the full-size cartoons survive in London.
And the engraver Marcantonio Raimondi turned
his designs into prints that traveled all over Europe.
Artists who had never been to Rome
could now study a composition by Raphael.
Ease had become something you could copy.
Rome talked about Raphael's private life, too.
This portrait is known as La Fornarina, the baker's daughter.
On her armband, a name, Raphael of Urbino.
Legend says she was his lover, Margherita Luti.
Officially, he was engaged to a cardinal's niece,
Maria Bibbiena, and never married her.
His last great painting was another contest.
Cardinal Giulio de' Medici ordered two altarpieces for his cathedral
At Narbonne, in France, one from Raphael,
the Transfiguration, the other from Sebastiano del
Piombo, with drawings for some of the figures supplied by Michelangelo,
the Raising of Lazarus.
Both sides knew they were being compared.
Their letters show them watching each other
and borrowing.
In both, a crowd presses in, pleading for a miracle. In Raphael's,
Christ rises above them, out of reach.
Then, in the spring of 1520,
Raphael fell ill. Vasari's version is the famous one.
After a night of excess, he came home with a
violent fever and his doctors, not knowing the cause,
bled him when what he needed was strength.
In 2020, a group of Italian doctors proposed another explanation,
perhaps a lung infection made worse by the bleeding.
He died on Good Friday 1520. He was 37.
According to Vasari, the Transfiguration was placed at the
head of his body, in the room where he had worked.
And the sight of that living picture,
in contrast with the dead body, broke the hearts of all who saw it.
A week after his death,
the two rival paintings were shown side by side in the Vatican.
He was buried, as he had asked, in the Pantheon.
His friend Pietro Bembo wrote the epitaph,
Here lies Raphael. While he lived, nature feared to be outdone.
When he died, she feared she too would die.
Back to the Sistine Madonna and that curtain rod at the top.
For a long time, nobody could see it.
At some point, the top of the canvas had been folded over,
and the rod only came back when
the painting was restored in Dresden in 1826.
Why Dresden? In 1753, the monks of San Sisto,
short of money, sold their altarpiece to Augustus III,
King of Poland and Elector of Saxony.
It was taken down that December,
Packed upright in a crate and carried north through the winter.
On March 1754, it was unpacked in Dresden's Royal Audience Hall.
The story goes that the king pushed
his own throne aside to make room for it.
From then on, it was treated as a model of perfection.
Writers like Johann Winkelmann praised it,
and academies across Europe taught Raphael as the standard.
And the two angels at the bottom began a life of their own, in prints.
And later on...
Cards, tins, and mugs. Copies did real good, too.
In the 1840s, writers like Anna Jameson
used cheap printed pictures to bring art to readers
who would never see Dresden or Rome,
many of them women. Something is gained when a picture travels.
Something can also be left
behind. In London in 1848, two young students,
William Holman Hunt and John Everett Millais,
talked late into the night about the old masters,
And condemned Raphael's transfiguration.
Hunt attacked its pompous posturing.
Other students mocked them.
Then you are pre-Raphaelite.
As Hunt remembered it years later, he and Millet laughed.
And agreed the name must be accepted.
Here is what Millet painted instead.
A carpenter's shop.
Wood shavings on the floor.
A boy with a cut on his hand.
Yet even they still honored Raphael's tapestry cartoons.
Their target was less Raphael himself.
So let's put the painting back where it began.
Not the Sistine Chapel in Rome, but San Sisto,
a monastery church in Piacenza, in northern Italy.
In 1512, Pope Julius II had just brought Piacenza under papal rule.
For its Benedictine monks, Raphael painted this altarpiece.
Saint Sixtus, the church's patron,
his face often thought to recall Julius himself,
and Saint Barbara, whose relics the church also kept.
In 2020, the museum in Dresden hung
the painting opposite a choir screen,
topped by a crucifix, as it may once have stood in San Sisto.
Stand where the painting hangs
and turn the way the mother and child are looking.
In this reading, they face the back of the cross.
If so, look again.
The angels look up at the mother and child,
but the mother and child look out, past us,
toward something we can't see, and they look afraid.
The vision arrives already knowing what is coming.
The ease was real.
It took study, careful preparation, rivalry,
and other skilled hands to make it.
Copies carried his art to people who could never see the originals.
But take just these angels, and much falls away,
The mother, the child and the fear in their faces put them back
and the sweetness carries a different weight.