2026 Intermountain MLS figures for Ada County, where the typical builder home closed well above the typical existing home, and shows why one month of sales exaggerates that difference. Then she walks through three things to compare on any two houses: who you have to borrow from to get the full incentive, the limit your loan puts on what a seller or builder can pay toward your costs, and what the house actually includes on move-in day, from blinds to fencing to a finished yard. She also covers Idaho's written buyer agreement law and the first-visit rules some builders use to decide whether your agent gets paid. Whether you're relocating from out of state or selling a home you've owned for years, this is the math to run before you sign.
CHAPTERS 0:00 The $61,639 gap 0:54 The number to compare instead 1:50 Where every figure comes from 2:28 What a median can't show you 3:05 One month vs. the whole year 3:56 Why finished homes are sitting 4:28 Two example movers 5:30#1: Who you have to borrow from 6:05 What the builders' own fine print says 6:59 What federal rules allow 7:54 Two loan estimates, side by side 8:31 The question to ask the sales consultant 9:14#2: The seller concession limit 10:06 What an incentive can't pay for 10:49#3: What the house comes with 11:47 The model home is not your house 12:22 Pricing a fence and a yard 12:49 Being fair to the older house 13:24 How agents get paid 15:08 The first-visit rule 16:34 Selling next to a builder 17:00 Why people still choose a builder home 17:34 What I can and can't tell you 19:20 How both movers turned out 20:10 Final take
If you are moving to Boise, a new house
in Ada County costs $61,639 more than a resale house.
And in September of 2026, the median new home sold for $622,000.
$22,704 and the median resale home sold
for $561,065.
Now I earn my living selling both new
construction and resale but that $61,000 gap is one month of sales
and a year earlier it was only
$14,000. Builders are offering buyers tens of thousands in credits
but the biggest ones
And usually come only if you.
You use the builder's own lender.
And if you own here and are selling,
the builders near you are offering your buyers credits
you have to compete with.
So I want you to compare what I call the after credit price.
And that is the price of the house minus the credit
your loan will actually let you use.
Plus what the house is missing, like blinds or a fence.
And if you're moving here,
that number lets you compare a new house and a resale house
Fairly before a credit chooses your lender.
Now in this video, I want to give you three numbers
to compare and show you why your first visit
to a model home matters.
My team and I built the Treasure Valley Relocation Audit
to walk you through the real cost of a move to Idaho
before you even book a flight.
Now, if you live here and you are trading your house
for a new one or a bigger one,
use it as well to put both houses on one page.
Go grab it in the description.
It's free and a very useful tool.
But first, here is what that gap doesn't show you.
Every number in this video comes
from Boise Regional Realtors, a builder's own website,
and a federal rule or the Idaho law.
Now, I'm filming this video in October of 2026.
The report for last month,
September uses Intermountain MLS data and it shows the gap
is real.
I want you to picture two houses on the same afternoon,
one with the paint still drying
and one with a tire swing in the backyard.
In September,
the typical new home sold for about $61,000 more.
Now here is what the report cannot tell you.
A median is the price.
right in the middle where half the homes sold for more
and half sold for less. The report shows the
price on the contract
but it does not show how much money the builder gave back to the buyer
as a credit at closing.
So some of that $622,000 price may have gone right back to the buyer.
But we just cannot see how much from the report.
That is the first thing the credits hide.
They hide inside the price.
And remember that $61,000 gap
comes from only one month of sales
and that was back in September.
Now, if you look at all the sales
from January through September of this year,
the gap between the median new home
and the median resale home is 15,000.
$175. In September, only 244 new homes sold
in Ada County compared to 610.
resale homes. Now with that few of sales,
a handful of bigger new homes can push the middle
price up fast. So don't plan your move around $61,000.
I want you to plan it around the two
houses you are actually looking at.
Here's the part that matters more for your wallet. That same
says there were 1,051 new homes for sale
in Ada County at the end of September and only 955
resale homes. So there were more new houses
for sale than the used ones. So at September's pace,
the new homes would take 3.6 months to sell and the resale homes 1.8,
which is twice as long.
So when a builder has finished houses sitting empty,
that builder starts offering money.
And that is where the credits come from.
Now, let me give you two examples
to carry through the rest of this video.
These examples were created for this video.
They are not stories from actual clients.
In our first example, we're going to look at someone relocating here
in the spring and they have two houses on their list.
One is a new build at $620.
$522,704 with a flyer that says up
to $40,000 if they use the builder's lender.
And the other is a resale house at $561,065 that has a fence,
has the blinds, and a lawn
that has been there for years.
Now, in our second example,
we're going to look at someone who has owned a house in Nampa
for 15 years, and they want to sell it and buy a new home.
So let's find out where that $40,000 flyer comes
with strings attached.
All right, number one is the credit itself
and who you have to borrow from to get all of it.
Now, the National Association of Home Builders
surveyed builders across the country.
This past October and 65% said
they were using sales incentives.
43% said they cut prices,
which is the highest share in that survey
going back to 2020.
Now, here in the Treasure Valley,
as of this week,
Hubble Homes website advertises up to $40,000
in what it calls flex funds.
Now, these offers change.
every month so treat every number I give you today as a snapshot
and read the builders page
the day you go walk a home. Now here is the string.
Lennar's Boise page says it in its own words and I
quote
Financing with Lennar Mortgage LLC is always optional.
You can use any lender you choose,
though builder incentives like rate buy downs
and closing cost assistance are available
on select Boise homes when you do, end quote.
So you are free to use any lender,
but the money follows the builder's lender.
And CBH Homes does it a little differently.
Because it's October,
the fine print ties the offer to a preferred lender that CBH says it is
not affiliated with. So let me be clear about what the rules say.
Under the federal rules,
a company that sends you to its own affiliated lender has
to tell you about that relationship
in writing and it cannot require you to use that lender.
What it can do is make the discount
optional and only hand it to the people who say yes.
So nobody is forcing you, but the credit is
doing the convincing.
A credit is a one-time number at closing, but your loan is a number
that you live with for years.
If the builder's lender charges more on the loan than another
Other lender would.
Part of that credit comes back out of your pocket
a little at a time.
And if it charges less, then the credit is a real win
and you should take it.
Now, you cannot know which one it is
until you have a second offer to compare it to.
So here is my advice.
Get a loan estimate from the builder's lender.
And get one from at least one other lender you choose yourself.
A loan estimate is a three-page form
and the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau says
a lender has to give it
to you within three business days of your application.
It is the same form at every lender
so you can lay them side by side at your desk and compare
them line by line and the bureau
also says that credit checks from several mortgage lenders within
45 days count as one inquiry on your credit report.
Now I am not a lender and I am not going
to tell you which lender to use.
What I will tell you is the question that can catch people off guard
at the model home ask the sales consultant
if you use your own lender what is the best price
you will write on this house
then ask for that answer to be in writing now you have two
real offers one with the builder's lender
and one without and the difference between them is what
that credit is really worth to you before you fall
in love with a big credit there is a limit
On how much of it.
You are even allowed to use.
All right, number two is what I call the credit ceiling.
Now, the credit ceiling is the most your loan
will let a seller or a builder pay towards your costs
no matter what the flyer says.
For instance, on a conventional loan,
Fannie Mae sets that ceiling at three, six,
or 9% of the price, and the smaller your down payment is,
The lower your ceiling will be.
On an FHA loan, the ceiling is 6%.
So at $622,704,
3% is about $18,700.
That is our relocating buyer
who is putting a small amount down
so that their $40,000 flyer only lets them use
about 18,700 of it.
toward their costs.
And here is the second limit,
which can surprise people even more.
Fannie Mae says that these credits
cannot pay your down payment
and any amount that goes over your actual closing costs
gets subtracted from the price
when the lender does the loan math.
So a credit cannot turn into cash in your hand
and it cannot cover money that you were supposed to bring
to the closing table.
And even CBH's own October fine print
says its lender credit cannot go past
the maximum seller concession of 6%.
So if the credit is bigger than your ceiling,
ask the builder to move the extra off the price
and always, again, get it in writing.
Okay, number three is what the house comes with
on the day you move in.
Walk into a resale house that is 10 years old
and the blinds are up.
The fence is in and the grass has been growing for a decade.
Now, walk into a new construction house
and you might get all of that
or you might get the bare windows
and a backyard of just dirt.
It depends on the builder, the community, and the exact lot.
Lennar's Boise page says that blinds,
full yard landscaping, fencing, sprinklers,
refrigerator, washer and dryer,
are included but the same page
also says that features can vary by community and home site and
other builders have listed those same items
as things you can spend your credit on which means
they are not always in the base price of the home
so a credit that buys your fence is not a discount
it is just the builder paying for something
the resale house across the street already has.
Now here is what can also catch people.
The model home is not your house.
The model home has the upgraded floors,
the designer lights, and the finished backyard.
And your contract might not have any of those.
A relocating buyer toured a model home with a lawn
and the backyard lot on their contract is just dirt.
So you need to ask for the included features list
for your exact lot and read it before.
Before you sign and not after.
Anything that is not on that list
goes on your after credit price.
Two national cost guides put a six foot vinyl privacy fence
at roughly 30 to $55 a foot installed.
So if your backyard needs 150 feet of fence,
that is 4,500 to $8,200
before you have planted a single blade of grass.
So those are national numbers.
Go get two local bids before you write the offer.
Now, I want to be fair to the resale homes as well.
That 10-year-old house.
Does have a 10-year-old water heater, a 10-year-old furnace,
and a roof that is 10 years closer to
replacement. And on a new house,
you need to ask the builder what the warranty is that is written
into your contract because that is part of what
the higher price is buying. After the credit price
cuts both ways. And on a new house, you add what is missing.
This section is about how agents get
So I am going to walk through it slowly.
Slowly and simply.
Now, I am not an attorney and this is not legal advice.
So if your situation is complicated,
go seek out a real estate attorney.
Here is what Idaho law says.
Idaho Code 54-2084.
Says a buyer is not represented by a brokerage
unless they agree to it in a separate written document.
And it says representation cannot be assumed
and it cannot be created by just a conversation.
Picture yourself walking into a model home
on a Saturday by yourself
and spending an hour with a friendly sales consultant.
That is exactly what our second example,
the person selling their Nampa house to buy new
to do. That sales consultant works for the builder.
And unless you have signed an agreement
with a brokerage, nobody in that room is representing you.
Idaho law also says that
a buyer agreement has to spell out what you would owe,
if anything, and how the agent gets paid.
And since August,
17th of 2024, the National Association of Realtors rules
have required agents working with buyers
to sign a written agreement
before they tour a home with you.
That same change means a seller can no longer post an offer
to pay the buyer's agent on the MLS,
which is the listing system that agents share.
So a seller can still offer to pay it,
They just don't post it there.
And commissions are not set by law.
They are negotiable.
So who actually pays on a new bill?
Well, many builders have programs to pay the buyer's agent,
but each builder writes its own rules
and the rule that can catch people
is usually the first visit.
Toll Brothers agent page says your agent must register you
at the time of your first visit to the community.
And Lennar's broker policy says your agent must,
you on your first visit to the community,
whether it is in person, self-guided, or virtual. And CBH
Home says the opposite,
that an agent does not need to register you or come on any visit. So
three builders in this valley have three different rules.
At a builder with a first visit rule,
if you walk in alone the first time,
the builder may not pay an agent for you at all.
Even if you hire one later, now,
if the builder will not pay your agent's pay comes from whatever
your written agreement with them says,
which can mean it can come from you. So here is how I handle
it before we tour anything new
or resell how my brokerage gets paid is written down in an
agreement you have read and signed.
And if you have already visited a community on your own,
Tell your agent which ones before you go back
so they can read what those builder's rules are.
These builder policies can change at any time.
So read the current one before you walk in.
Now, if you've owned a home here for years,
there is a part of this that can feel unfair.
And I do want to talk about that.
If you are selling a house you have lived in for 15 years,
you are not just competing with the house
next door. You are competing with a builder
that can hand your buyer tens of thousands of dollars
and a finished backyard.
Now, after all of that, I want to tell you why people still choose new
because there are good reasons for new construction.
There is something about being
the first person to turn the key for the home.
Also, nobody else has cooked in the
in that kitchen nobody else has picked the paint
and on a summer evening half the street is outside
planting something and everybody is asking each other
who they used for the fence. And with more
new homes than resale homes for sale in Ada County this fall a buyer
who knows the after credit price
does have room to negotiate.
Now let me be honest with you about what I can and cannot tell you. I
I cannot tell you whether new or resell is the
The $61,000 gap is real
for September, but your gap
is the after credit price
of one
house against the other.
with two loan estimates on your desk.
If you are planning a move here to the Treasure Valley
and you have a new build and a resell home on your list,
book a strategy call and we will build
the after credit price for both of them.
If you already visited a model home on your own,
book a strategy call before you go back
and we will help read that builder's first visit rule.
If you own here and you're selling
while new homes go up all around you,
Book a strategy call and we will price what your house is
against what those builders are actually offering.
And if you are a local trading your house for a new one,
also book a strategy call and we will put your sell
and your purchase on one timeline.
Bring the builder's flyer, the listing for the resale house
and any loan estimates that you already have.
We will not tell you which lender to use
and we will not give you legal advice,
but you will leave knowing
which questions to go to the builder,
which to go to the lender, and which to go to an attorney.
The booking link is in the description.
Now, if you're not ready for a call,
still go grab that Treasure Valley relocation audit in the description.
Put both your houses on one page tonight.
It's free and a very useful tool.
Here is how our two examples turned out.
Our relocating buyer got a loan estimate from the builder's lender.
And one from a lender they chose and laid them side by side.
Then they asked the builder to move
the part of the credit above their ceiling.
off the price and they got the answer in writing.
They also priced the fence and the backyard with
two local bids and for the first time they
were comparing two real numbers instead of
just a flyer and a listing.
In our second example the Nampa owner signed a buyer
agreement before that Saturday visit
so the first visit rule was never a question.
And they priced their own house
against the after credit price of the builder a mile away,
not just the number on the sign.
Now, neither one of them got lucky.
They just asked before they signed.
So the next time a flyer hands you a big round number,
take it home and write the after credit price underneath it.
If the two numbers are close, you found a real deal.
And if they are not, you just saved yourself.
from a surprise.
If you've lived here for years
and you are watching new streets go in,
your house still has something no builder can install,
a yard that has had years to grow in.
For some of you, a new house with a lender already attached
is exactly right, and that's great.
For some of you, the 10-year-old house with the tire swing
is a better deal, and that is okay too.
Either way the after credit price is the number
that tells you the truth. I want you to picture
the first night in the house you chose knowing exactly what you paid
for it and why. And I want
you to love the same Idaho that I do.
I want you to love it from a house that you chose on purpose.
I'm Rachel and I don't want you to be blindsided by the fine print
on a new house and I'll see you in the next one.