Exploring Whistler's Venetian Etchings with David Dunlop - from Landscapes Through Time - #204

🎨 Landscape Painting - Stillness in Every Stroke
102 followers
Artist David Dunlop explores James Abbott McNeill Whistler's transformative 1879-1880 stay in Venice and demonstrates his dry point and etching techniques on copper plates along the Venetian canals. #JamesWhistler #DavidDunlop #Venice #Etching #Drypoint #ArtHistory #Printmaking #LandscapesThroughTime #FineArt #ArtistBiography
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedArtist David Dunlop examines the life and technical mastery of James Abbott McNeill Whistler in Venice. Following a bankrupting legal battle, Whistler transitioned from traditional portraiture to evocative, distilled landscapes. The video blends a biographical study of Whistler's \"art for art's sake\" philosophy with a practical demonstration of etching and drypoint printmaking techniques.
Coming next on Landscapes Through Time,
artist David Dunlop
explores Whistler's
unique dramatic views
of Venice.
This is Venice. I'm David Dunlop,
a landscape painter at the foot of the Ca' Rezzonico, the studio
and home of James Abbott McNeill Whistler in 1879.
Today it's a museum for 18th century art here in Venice
Whistler arrives here from London with a lot of ambition,
especially for an artist who was bankrupt.
In 1879, he'd just survived a very expensive trial,
a suit against John Ruskin.
He'd left angry creditors, angry friends,
angry patrons, and angry critics.
But Venice beckoned with promise,
the possibility of doing something new.
Whistler arrives here with very little money,
an advance on a commission from the Fine Arts Society in London.
He has 50 copper plates, a raft of brown pastel paper,
and a stock of wit, charm, and arrogance.
This is all he needs to begin here in a studio
and to describe the experience
of life in Venice from unique angles,
up close, a different point of view.
Whistler is following in the footsteps of Canaletto and Guardi.
They'd been seeing painters here a century before,
and Turner a generation before.
So many artists had tried and invented a new vision.
Whistler was going to measure himself against them.
He has new tools.
Photography is new to the time
and gives him the idea of the odd angles up close.
We're going to go look where Whistler looked,
through his eyes, his imagination, and with his materials.
How did he invent a new direction, a new vision?
We'll find out in this neighborhood,
his neighborhood, the heart of the Ca' Rezzonico,
on the alleys and canals around the corner.
James Whistler was prickly, vain, stingy, witty, and gifted.
He was born in 1834 in Lowell, Massachusetts, a factory town.
His father had been commissioned
by the Tsar in Russia to work on railroads,
and Whistler spent time in St. Petersburg.
After his father dies, when Whistler is just 15,
Whistler's family leaves Russia for London, and then the United States.
Whistler's mother, that austere lady in profile in her chair,
was adoring and relentlessly supportive.
She found him schools and jobs through family and friends.
She indulged his training in art, but discouraged it as a career.
Whistler entered West Point Academy at the age of 17.
He was expelled three years later by Robert E. Lee.
It was 1854, just before the Civil War.
His only success there had come in drawing.
One of Whistler's first jobs was drawing maps
for the United States government.
He transferred to the etching department after it
was discovered that he made sketches of his
colleagues and friends
and other drawings on the edges of those maps. Like Sargent,
Whistler was more European than American.
His European education in Russia had assured fluency
in French. In 1855, he leaves for Paris to become an artist.
In 1855, the art world centered in Paris
The Paris Salon was its focus.
He signed on with Charles Gleyre's studio in 1856.
This was the same studio
which just a few years later would incubate the Impressionists.
Monet, Renoir, Bazille and Sisley.
Whistler moved through
the avant-garde circles in both Paris and London.
And café life in Paris was particularly Whistlerian.
His friends enjoyed his wit, his singing and his painting.
They included Henri Fantin-Latour, Manet, Degas, Le Gros and Courbet.
Whistler, always uneasy with instruction and authority,
let his influences come as he found them,
whether as a sick child with the magical illustrations of Hogarth,
as a student copying an adored landscape by Turner,
or peripatetic traveler finding Dutch masters in Holland.
And Courbet, Velázquez, Delacroix, Manet, Corot in France.
His taste for the exotic was excited
by the new fascination for the Japanese.
He took their idea of simplified design,
distilled to the absolute minimum.
In 1858...
Whistler published a series of etchings.
He called them the French set.
They helped establish his reputation as an artist.
In 59, Whistler moves to London,
and the next year his painting, At the Piano,
was rejected by the Paris Salon
and exhibited in London at the Royal Academy Exhibition.
London, transformed and driven by industrial and artistic revolution,
suited experimental artists like Whistler.
Markets in business and art were changing.
The old constraints of moral purpose, accuracy, and polish
were giving way to daring romantic effects and visual ambiguity.
Now we have art for art's sake, art for the artist.
In London, his circle included Rossetti, Oscar Wilde, Thackeray,
Trollope, and Swinburne, and Pre-Raphaelites Hunt and Millais.
Whistler kept his ties to Paris over the years,
and his portrait of his first mistress and model,
Jo Hiffernan, was exhibited in the radical 1863 Salon de Refusé.
The crowds came,
and they laughed. They laughed at Manet, and they laughed at Whistler.
In 1871, Whistler produced the Thames set,
a new collection of etchings.
He also introduced a new way of thinking about art,
through his titles, nocturnes, symphonies, musical arrangements.
That alone was enough to irritate the critics.
And here now was an art of suggestion and evocation,
not precise descriptions,
art that felt like music, evoked sensations through
distilled arrangements of line, design, and color harmonies.
Whistler enjoyed a couple of major splashes in the art world.
His painting of the Scott philosopher Carlyle
and the painting of his mother
both went to public collections.
Portraits were a reliable revenue stream for Whistler,
like his patron Freddie Leyland,
who was also the owner of the Peacock Room.
Like so many artists from Gainsborough to Sargent,
Whistler grew weary of the
demands of portraiture. He turns to landscapes, a lifelong fascination.
In London, Whistler exhibited a series of new experimental paintings.
The eminent critic John Ruskin reviewed them,
and he reviewed them harshly.
He claimed that Whistler was a coxcomb
who had thrown a bucket of paint in the public's face
and had the effrontery to charge 200 guineas for it.
This sort of attack was such an insult that Whistler sued.
The libel trial would bankrupt him.
He won, but only a farthing.
He couldn't afford his house in Chelsea
or the legal fees from the trial.
The courts would auction his paintings.
Nothing could have depressed Whistler more.
Through friends in the Fine Arts Society in London,
Whistler received a commission,
a series of etchings to be done here in Venice.
They would publish them and exhibit them. The
Fine Arts Society had seen his London etchings
and they had been impressed. Those were more
meticulous and detailed than the more expressive
and evocative etchings that he would make in
Venice. The advance from the Fine Arts Society would afford Whistler
the chance to come here.
Escape to Venice, at least for a month or two.
That was the intention of the Fine Arts Society.
But Whistler always had his own agenda, and he stayed for over a year.
Coming here was a chance to begin again.
He first finds a little apartment above a shop in the Frari section.
Then, he moves to a new studio space in the Carrezzonico.
A year later, John Singer Sargent is going
to take a studio in the same building.
After that, he's going to move
to the Casa Jankovic across town near San Giorgio,
overlooking the entire city of Venice.
But while he has his studio in the Carrezzonico,
he's doing pastels and etchings,
and this is the neighborhood he does them in.
He'll do both horizontals and verticals.
He's brought with him from London a raft of paper,
different colors, brown, gray, blue.
He'd seen other people work on these papers.
He'd seen the works,
the watercolors of Turner on gray and blue, brown paper,
like the undertone of a painting.
He's doing something very different.
He, like Sargent, who arrives in 1880,
are looking for little intimate vignettes.
They're looking for some little slice of life,
quiet places, the back streets of Venice.
And this is where he found it,
right here on canals just like this one,
this Rio Barnaba.
Now etchings have become more popular.
Because of the work of Courbet, Delacroix, Manet, Corot and others
who were modernizing the whole idea of etchings.
That something that could reveal a quick sketch, a feeling,
rather than very precise topographic information,
which had been the tradition.
There were other artists who had experimented with etchings
to get something that was spontaneous, emotional and evocative.
Goya is one perfect example.
And Rembrandt, of course.
These are reproductions of some of those etchings.
You can see he likes the composition of a square in a square.
We go from light to dark to light.
It's a sequence he'll use in his paintings.
It's a sequence painters have used for a long time.
Velázquez uses it in Las Meninas.
And he just keeps the plates in a book with some of his tools,
like this burin, an etching needle.
And to keep the point on his burin sharp,
He puts little wine corks on the end to keep them sharp.
And when they're not sharp, he simply takes out his stone
and he has to continually sharpen his burin.
It's a tradition for people doing etchings,
or if you're doing a dry point, and he does both.
I'm going to show you how that process works in the dry point.
The plates are not very large.
The plate for the etchings has a resistant ground
and he scratches through the ground
and wherever he scratches, the acid will cut a deeper line.
In the dry point, we don't need the ground
because we're going to rub the ink directly
into these little incised lines.
When you're making an etching,
what you've done is you've made an image which will be
It will be reversed when you print it.
It will become a mirror image of what you've drawn.
He's been shopping for these special papers from old books.
That paper is what's going to be pressed onto this copper plate
when the ink is on the plate.
First you cut the plate, then you ink the plate,
and then you take the paper and press it to the face of the plate.
And that plate is rolled through with a big steel roller
and etching press.
The paper's on top.
And the paper is pressed very hard with thousands
of pounds of pressure per square inch onto this plate.
It's how Rembrandt did it. It's how Jacques Collot did it.
It's how engravings were made.
Some artists prepare their plates differently than others.
But having the right color
and tone to the paper was important to Whistler,
not only for the etchings, but also for the pastels.
He uses colored papers for those, too.
He'll make a sketch that is about the size of his copper plate.
Close. And then look for something that is very graphic,
something that is very strong
darks, very strong lights.
He takes liberties because, as he's told us time and again, it's
not the information that counts,
it's how I feel about it and how I arrange it. And
here he can arrange it without concern for color
because it's all just tone. So I'm going
I'm going to mark off some thirds.
Follow a rough scheme of pushing things out of the center.
I've got a square in a square moving back.
You see how you move from light to dark to light.
That's the principle.
And then anything silhouetted back in here
would easily be perceived of as a figure.
He'll scratch in dark lines.
We call it cross-hatching.
On to the copper plate and then you can see
the partial indications with the broken lines of textures,
steps perhaps, a part of a boat, something just like that.
Then tone can be hand rubbed in. We call that process
a monotype where each plate would be inked a little bit differently.
So, the information is not just kept
in the lines that are incised by the burin,
but the information is augmented by white tones of ink.
Now, I'm sitting pretty low, but I'm on the fundamenta,
on the pavement, alongside the canal.
Whistler liked to be in a boat down on the canal,
so that he would be looking a little bit up.
And I'm going to make this more of a monotype, so we can hurry
the process along, and you get a feeling of how they're created.
I'm coming past the midpoint with this square,
so it doesn't divide the picture in half.
Let me put this midpoint in marker.
You'll notice that I off-centered this square
of light inside of this rectangle.
Now there's some linear perspective lines, which I'll incise in here,
To allude to the way the space is heading back.
...to an eye level which is just above the floor here.
So ceiling has directionals that go this way.
And remember, he's very accomplished with linear perspective.
He'd studied how to draw at West Point under J. Alden Weir's father.
He's troubled by the fact that perhaps his evocation in paint,
pastel or drypoint and etching
It appears easy when in fact it's simply open
and suggestive and his design, his linear
perspective system, his use of color harmonies
and his arrangements are highly sophisticated
and distilled.
Whistler was an experimenter.
He introduced a new way of presenting art in galleries.
The light wall, with one painting next to another, next to another,
with lots of space, because he understood how we see,
how we pay attention,
and that you could elevate the importance
of anything by isolating it in space.
Some crosshatch lines.
The more lines I put down, the darker the territory here will become.
Now the dry point is a little harder because you push harder.
If it's the etching itself,
you only need to scratch through the ground.
And then, depending on how much acid you apply,
how deep or how fine the lines are.
And he would concoct different solutions of acid by diluting
the acid in different concentrations with water.
He has his lover, companion model, Maude Franklin,
who's with him at the Carro Razonico, sometimes etch the plates.
The copper is much more resistant,
even though it's softer than the steel of the burin,
which is why the steel of the burin is able to cut into the copper.
This little brief bit of fundamente, all aiming back here.
I myself have had the privilege of studying under some
of the greatest printmakers of the 20th century,
from the Atelier du Centre of Paris, like Sian Loy.
Picasso was a part of that group,
and they're all part of that tradition
of evoking a certain mood and quality of space and psychology
through prints, through tone, line, and shape.
Maybe an adjacent door frame, not the same height.
Variation. Not too much twinning.
Too much repetition of the same shape becomes boring.
And it's variation that sustains surprise.
Certainly Whistler was conscious of the need for surprise.
There's a lot of idiosyncrasy in the touch.
In trying to decide the authorship of etching plates,
we discern whether or not the artist was right-handed or left-handed.
Because I'm right-handed, you'll see a lot of this.
And if I'm left-handed, you'll see more of this.
And the orientation of the stroke
depends on the wrist that you're using.
Now, I'm not going to let there be two eyes and a mouth,
so I'm not going to put a reciprocal over here.
There's a lot of activity
as you build up a sensation of light and dark.
He wants to steer the image towards
Chiaroscuro, light and dark effects, mystery and space.
You see how I'm cropping out things,
the top of the window's cut off, the side of a window is cut off,
with just a few little suggested lines,
not continuous at all, discontinuous lines,
broken strokes like the Impressionists,
some old painted signage.
Now I have just done enough so that at this point,
We get to see what the image looks like before it's printed.
It will be different after it's printed.
Now, I'm going to ink it as he inked it,
and you will see how the image looked to him before printing.
To do that, we need some black etching ink.
The ink has a different viscosity than paint.
You can paint with it.
Etching ink is stiff,
usually.
If the ink isn't to your liking and you want it thinner,
you can thin it with plate oil and oil, like linseed oil, and turp.
But if you put turp into it, the ink will dry before you get to print.
So if I thin the ink, it gets grayer.
You can also see how it's sticky.
It's more like a very stiff honey.
And you would work up the ink with the oil and your spatula, like that.
Kind of like putting icing on a cake.
We can rub the ink on in a variety of ways.
With the rubber roller or absent a rubber roller.
Just put it on with my fingers and hand.
And then start removing that ink later.
First, rub it in.
And the process of hand wiping is where...
The etching or the dry point can convert into a monotype where you
really have one singular effect because of the way it's wiped.
So if you were to buy, let's say, an etching of Rembrandt's,
you'll pay a lot more for one that is a lifetime pull
because that's one that his hand manipulates the tone
and the lights and darks, especially the subtle ones.
There are later pulls, but they're not worth as much.
A fraction, because they don't have his participation
in building the lights and darks as you're
going to see me do here.
And the ink is going to catch inside of the little incised lines.
Now Whistler would design where he wants to put those lights
and darks after he's inked
it one time, takes a look, and rolls it through a press.
They call that a state, a first state, a second state.
He'll return to London with 50 of these.
Ready for further work or printing and some he prints here.
There's a gentleman artist in Venice while he's here,
Bocker, whose press he will use. It's a small press.
After I've gone in multiple directions to make sure my ink
is being pushed into those little lines, I can remove that ink
and I can remove it with a cloth, which is what he did,
and later with the palms of my hand, subtly building up the tones.
Artists who are very good at
Monochromatic painting, or tonal painting,
became very good at printmaking.
Today, in a studio, you might be using a fabric called tarlatan,
very coarse, and you crunch it up and soften it.
And Whistler may have used that as well.
Certainly we know he used different materials, and then hand.
It removes the ink, and that's what you're doing,
is you're revealing the light by removing the ink.
And where I've scribed lines...
And I'm going to let my paper towel look
as though I've scribed
many more lines.
Some territories are discreet with their edges
and other areas are blended.
I'm using my incised lines as a template
for finding the shadows.
I think I see why Whistler loved this,
because you can already see you're working
from a position of absolute mystery, darkness,
and finding some clarity, finding some light.
But stopping before you have real clarity and legibility.
So you sustain mystery.
It's as though you're working backwards.
Most people think of adding paint to create their image.
Here, you add the light through a process of discovery.
The more I wipe,
the brighter the metal,
and the lighter it will be in the print.
The women in his life include Joanna Heffernan,
Jo, who would later go on to become Courbet's model,
...and companion, Maud Franklin,
a companion of 14 years, and eventually Beatrice Godwin.
This marriage occurs when he is still living with Maud.
He just didn't tell her he had gone off
to marry a younger woman, Trixie.
Maud joins Whistler for his time here in Venice.
She calls herself Mrs. Whistler, but was not invited to social events,
to dinners with Browning, his friends, mentees, or
other colleagues and friends. The same was a problem for Joe,
who raises Whistler's illegitimate son, Charles.
He's not her child, but a child of a maid of Whistler's.
However, Whistler calls
the boy an infidelity of Joe's.
You would expect artists like Goya or Turner
who understood the printmaking process or
Rembrandt to have their oil paintings follow
a process that was similar to the printmaking
process and that is the process
of discovering light out of the darkness.
Just one more little beam.
He's always trying to push away from tradition
and distinguish himself as different.
Not only because of its novelty and a way of establishing an identity,
but he also thinks it's a way
of discovering new frontiers in art, new designs.
We've got the boat, we've got steps,
we're going in, you're getting the sense of this,
you're seeing how the light is discovered at the back.
We go from the dark to the light to the dark. This light is coming.
The glare of that light, the reflection on this light,
is the sort of thing that the
Greeks would use in the Peloponnesian War to blind their enemies.
We don't want to go that far, so let's take
the tape off and see how this looks.
The next plate you're going to see is what
this sort of image looks like after it's run
through a press.
It looks very different, especially in reverse in the lights and darks.
The feeling of the copper is gone because now he's on paper,
and you'll see why he likes
It makes that old yellowed paper to be reminiscent
of the beautiful tone we have on the copper.
Venice was a fertile laboratory for Whistler,
as it had been for Turner, Canaletto, and Tintoretto.
Coming here was a chance to begin again.
The Fine Arts Society exhibit.
It's going to be celebrated as one
of the major achievements in printmaking history,
but it begins here, on this canal in Venice.
I'm David Dunlop. I'm a landscape painter.
Funding for
Landscapes
Through Time
was made
possible
by the
following.
On the next Landscapes Through Time,
artist David Dunlop explores Whistler's panoramic views of Venice.
