he conversation also explores what prison taught him, why he doesn't want to run Binance again, and how his view of success has changed after one of the most difficult chapters of his life.
Timestamps 00:00 State of crypto today 00:49 Why CZ stays bullish 01:52 What causes crypto winters 03:05 The next crypto catalyst 04:26 AI and crypto adoption 05:54 SpaceX and private markets 07:27 Crypto versus traditional finance 09:17 Regulation's next phase 11:38 Jamie Dimon vs crypto 13:01 Why stablecoins matter 15:12 The Michael Saylor debate 17:33 Why CZ wrote a book 19:20 Inside prison life 23:23 Life after prison 24:27 The next chapter
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI Generated
Changpeng Zhao (CZ) discusses the cyclical nature of crypto, the integration of blockchain with AI and Real World Assets (RWAs), and the evolution of global regulation. He reflects on his personal journey through incarceration and his shift toward philanthropy and education via Giga Academy, emphasizing blockchain as a foundational technology that will eventually merge with traditional finance.
All right, welcome to a new episode of Power Players with Brian Sazi.
I'm your host, Brian Sazi, and I have a special guest here,
someone that I've followed his career and background for a while,
but I've actually never seen him physically in person.
So this is the first time for me.
He's always become remote.
Changpeng Zhao, better known as CZ.
I know him as CZ.
Y'all who know and follow Bitcoin probably know him as CZ, too.
It's good to see you in person.
Absolutely. It's great to be here.
It's good to meet you in real life.
Likewise, likewise.
Let's talk about crypto first,
because that was the last conversation I had with you in November 2022.
Since that time, of course, you've seen the crypto boom.
It's become embraced by so many people,
even regulators, too, finally, of course.
Like, what is your thinking on the current state of play in crypto?
I think there's actually a lot of parallels.
Crypto goes in four year cycles.
So there's a lot of parallels between November 2022 versus now.
November 2022, if I remember correctly,
the Bitcoin price was about $16,000.
Actually, November is right post the FTX crash.
This is post Lunar UST crash.
That was in May 2022.
It feels like yesterday.
Yeah, it feels like yesterday.
And then I think early November was the FTX crash.
And then December, by the time we talk,
it's probably right on the bottom on that cycle.
So right now we're in what we call a bear market again.
Bitcoin dropped to $60,000.
So there's quite a lot of similarities in mood.
But if you look at the prices,
it's still three, four X higher than four years ago.
So I'm pretty optimistic.
I'm still very optimistic about the industry,
but we're going through a winter and the industry will recover.
The industry will continue to grow.
What causes these winters?
I actually think it's just my psychology.
Humans, you know, we either we overreact.
We either are given a large population of people of masses.
We are all rushing.
And then we create this like, you know, what do you call it?
Bubble or however you call it.
And then when and then we panic and then like we all sell like we over correct.
So while the industry may be growing like like this,
the prices fluctuate like that around around the value.
So I think it's just my psychology.
And then all this other news around it.
There's many things that are four year cycles.
The presidential elections are four year cycles.
Stock markets are either four or eight year cycles.
But stocks always go up, though.
I know, I'm just kidding.
But yeah, stock always go up because there's a lot of inflation.
There's always more money supply in circulation.
If you look at the pure price of stocks, but also like, no, economies grow.
There's more companies that do bigger things, et cetera.
So, yeah, stock grows.
But the same thing applies to crypto.
I think there's a lot more hype.
We're going to need more and more transactions and crypto blockchains
and new technology for money is not going to disappear.
It's a technology. Yeah.
At this stage in the game, what gets crypto out of a crypto winter?
I think, well, there is always going to be continued innovation.
There's cycles.
The winter will always come and go.
But the industry is growing.
This winter, 60,000, we think is really low.
Everyone's panicking.
But last winter, four years ago, it was 16,000.
So the industry is still growing.
I think we just need more applications, more use cases.
And I think more and more use cases are coming.
People are developing it.
And also newer industries actually help the blockchain industry.
Like everyone's really hot on AI.
But right now, today, AI doesn't transact for us.
AI can search for the cheapest ticket, the best ticket for us.
But today, it doesn't buy that ticket for us.
Very soon, it will.
And when it can, if AI companies want this transaction to work globally,
supporting crypto is actually the fastest way to enable global adoption.
Is that the next big unlock here, you think, for crypto?
Because for the past two years, it was
it's becoming more embraced by regulators.
That was a catalyst.
Well, now we've gotten past that.
Like, I think the whole industry is looking for this next big thing,
this big moment.
I don't know if that big moment happens.
You would know better than me.
But or is it more incremental?
Like tech companies are using crypto to transact,
and that suddenly is the next hot thing?
I think it's more incremental.
Also, like there will be little things that what people call the next thing.
You know, DeFi was hot for a while.
NFTs was hot for a while.
Meme coins was hot for a while.
But all of those things will come and they don't really go.
They stay, but they become less hot.
And I think AI payments will come.
I don't know when, but I would assume it's in a month, not years.
And also RWAs, real world assets, tokenization of other assets,
either financial or non-financial assets.
That's growing much faster than I expected.
So a year and a half ago, I thought it would go like,
I don't know if it's just hype or not.
But now it's like it's growing like a multi-billion dollar
asset allocations, et cetera, and it's growing pretty quickly.
So I think RWAs will continue to grow.
And we're pretty excited about that.
We're seeing that now, you know, you can trade AI company stocks
using crypto globally.
So which company, which country doesn't want their stock
to be traded globally by the global audience?
Before, you know, with SpaceX IPO, only Americans traded
and a few institutions around the world can, but you don't reach the masses.
Now with blockchain, you can reach the masses now.
So and we've seen fairly significant trading volumes on those instruments.
So I think all of those things are happening.
I'm pretty excited about RWA, stablecoins,
AI commerce, AI payments.
I can't help myself.
You mentioned the SpaceX IPO as someone who has led a very large company
in Binance, has seen a lot of different market cycles.
Well, what do you think about the just the excitement around this particular IPO?
It's a very unique moment.
And look, SpaceX is not alone.
It's OpenAI, Pinchly, Anthropic coming to market, too.
Well, SpaceX is unique in the sense that it's not just an AI company.
It's also an internet service provider company.
It's actually the largest internet service provider globally.
It works great. It's a great service.
It's fantastic. It's fast. It's cheap. It's reliable.
It's just higher quality than your cable.
So this is like this is 40 years after the Internet.
Well, 30, 40 years after the Internet.
So you can still build a very strong Internet
Starlink alone is a very valuable company.
They somehow merged XAI into it.
And we got merged twice.
We invested in Twitter and it became X, became XAI, became SpaceX.
So we kind of indirectly got rolled into there, which we're very happy about.
But, you know, it shows that you can still build a global ISP
30 years after industries matured, right?
So like ISPs were all the rage 30 years ago.
But now Starlink is really an ISP.
It just does it very differently. It's from space.
And then that was AI.
So I think like this one, everything Elon does is really crazy out there,
but also like tremendously respectable.
Can you imagine data centers in space?
That is wild stuff.
It's wild, but it makes a lot of sense.
Yeah, so it's cool.
Everything he does is really cool.
Everything we do is very boring.
Well, you know, this is also this is an exciting moment for the retail investor.
And the retail investor has really they've
they've come to embrace cryptocurrencies.
You know, they were one of the early community to embrace this technology.
How does this new this new supply of like these amazing tech companies, SpaceX,
OpenAI, like, do you see that competing like with the demand to own crypto?
I know. No, no, not not at all.
I think this is great for so crypto is not its own industry.
Just as like Internet should not be its own industry.
It's a technology.
Crypto should not should be just a technology
that that enhances financial financial tools, financial applications.
So exist.
There shouldn't be a tradified versus crypto kind of division.
The existing financial players, institutions
should use blockchain technologies and should adopt all the things
that's happening in crypto.
All the crypto guys should be providing all the services
that traditional financial guys provide, including like trading stocks,
including like loans, all this financial tools.
So it's just one technology that should be applied to a service.
And there's no division between crypto and try to fight.
In my opinion, there shouldn't be.
Right now, the industry is relatively new, so the new players
can tend to be lumped into crypto players, crypto platforms.
But there shouldn't be that.
That's a that's a that's a purely labeling division.
There's no reason why.
Well, for example, if you look at crypto platforms like Binance,
they provide loans to to to people.
They provide saving programs.
They provide a lot of payment solutions.
They provide like 40, 50 different financial products
to to retail users around the world using the blockchain technology.
Right. So there's no division.
So I think, you know, they should all merge together.
Is there a is there an another,
I guess, catalyst from a regulatory standpoint
that the crypto community would like to see?
Absolutely. I think, well, even today, the regulatory frameworks
are still early days.
You know, U.S. is still debating about the Clarity Act.
Most other countries are still waiting for U.S.
No, they're still looking at U.S. to to to to to copy their homework.
So we're still early.
I think the crypto regulations have a long way to evolve.
I think it's going to go on for multiple decades.
It's probably going to take 50, 70 years for things to mature.
I can guarantee you that 70 years from now, people are still debating
about this little nuance, that little nuance, about this new feature,
new product.
So it's never going to be perfect.
It's never like I think we still debate about even security regulations today.
Right. Whether we should report earnings quarterly anymore.
Yeah. Yeah. Yeah.
So so like, no, this is what that's what like that's like a 90 year industry.
So I think it will continue.
Regulations are usually slow.
They need industries to mature and they slowly adjust to it.
And they they're very event driven.
Like whatever happens, there was something.
Well, there's new regulation to cover that so that it doesn't happen again.
So, yeah, so I think we'll continue to evolve.
I think we just we're still pretty early.
But now U.S. is leading, which is great to see.
And when U.S. leads, everyone follows.
So whereas if a smaller country, you know, pioneer something,
the rest of the world may or may not follow.
But when U.S. leads, it's good.
It's now we have like we have coherence.
Everybody does the same thing.
So which is great to see.
How are the regulatory frameworks different overseas?
Like how have we pulled ahead of some other countries?
I think U.S., there's way more discussions.
There's also way more debates.
There's a lot of news, which is good for something that's really important.
Right. And U.S. is more focused on like reasonably more way.
I think that's almost a bit too much focus on stable coins,
whereas other countries are much more focused on tokenization.
Like how do you tokenize national debt, national bonds?
How do you tokenize rare earth minerals?
So all of these other countries are looking for ways to develop their economies.
U.S. is too, but U.S. is really much more focused on the U.S.
dollar interest rates, the banking sector.
So U.S. has a more developed financial sector, which is understandable.
But I think U.S. leads
overall in crypto regulations by far now.
What side are you on?
I'm sure you're watching the world wars between Jamie Dimon and Brian Armstrong.
Which team are you on?
I don't really want I don't really pick a team.
I'm a crypto guy.
So I kind of want to be on the crypto side.
I think what's but I want to be on the consumer side.
So I think we should give the maximum benefits to anyone,
any business who wants to pass on the benefits to the consumers
should be allowed to. Right. So that's the capitalist way.
If a company like if stable coins, right, you give you give U.S.
dollars to me, I put it in the bank.
I issue stable coin, I give it to you.
This money generates interest through the bank or by U.S.
treasuries. The business should be allowed to pass that interest to you
to the extent that, you know, the business stays afloat.
And but again, I but I think this but that's a very simple,
simplistic understanding of it.
I think there's a lot more nuance to to the debates.
I know there's a lot more.
Maybe these two just need to get in a ring and fight it out.
They set up a UFC tent right beside the White House.
They put Brian Armstrong in there with whoever else.
I would pay big money to watch it as a financial media geek.
I would pay big money to do that
on the stable coin front.
I'm glad you mentioned stable coin, because every credit card company
and payments company that I know is telling me about stable coin.
Is stable coin going to be that big to support everyone
in doing something with stable coin?
I think so. I think stable coins are going to be pretty big.
Stable coin is really a new form of fiat money.
Ten years ago, when stable coins were starting,
I didn't understand it.
Again, I felt like this thing couldn't work.
Me too.
Like, who would use a stable coin?
But it did find an intermediary between fiat currency
and crypto and blockchain, right?
Now, Bitcoin back then was highly volatile.
Many people cannot use Bitcoin because of volatility.
Many suppliers, they buy stuff in US dollars
and their profit margin may be only 10, 20 percent.
So they cannot use a currency that fluctuates like 20 percent a day.
Whereas, no, the stable coin fills that gap.
And also, stable coin solved a problem where in the early days,
banks did not want to work with crypto exchanges or crypto businesses.
Stable coin solved that problem.
And also, to wire money through banks, if you want to send money from a US bank
to, say, I don't know, a bank in Singapore or a bank in China, if you want,
it takes days and weeks and a lot of procedure.
With stable coin, it's one address.
Doesn't matter where the recipient is in the world.
It goes instantly.
So it does leverage the advantages of the blockchain technology.
So, and yeah, stable coin, is it that big?
If you look at the industry, the two big businesses sort of in the industry,
exchanges and stable coins today, right?
So stable coins are pretty big.
And I think both businesses, stable coins have not tapped the true potential.
They're not hit the ceiling, right?
So stable coin today is what?
200 billion maximum market cap?
That's not that big in the grand scheme of things.
I think, again, still grow like a couple of thousand times a minimum.
So, yeah, so I think there's a lot of potential for that.
And there's a lot of and we're only talking about the US dollar stable coin.
Today, that's 99% of the stable coins in the crypto industry.
But it should be every currency should have their own stable coin.
I should have multiple of their own stable coin to see which one's good.
And then they should all be transacting on-chain.
And when that happens, and it will happen when that happens, not if.
When that happens, the FX rate will be determined 24 by 7.
On the blockchain.
So the FX market will shift.
So I think all of that will happen.
Do crypto investors just need to stop following the likes of a Michael Seller
and every minute move he is making and just focus on the bigger picture?
The bigger picture is are some of the things you're telling me here about.
Absolutely. Absolutely.
So, look, I think Michael Seller is doing something really fantastic for crypto.
And he's very influential.
He's led the charge in many respects.
It's good.
But, you know, the guy sells 32 bitcoins and Bitcoin crashes.
You shouldn't be reacting to something like that.
Yeah. So, look, at some point, the guy has to pay dividends, right?
So he sells 32 bitcoins.
That's like, what, like 0.001% of what he's holding.
And the market reacts.
But first of all, we cannot definitively say that the market crashes related to that.
It's just the timing was coincidental.
But, yeah, I think the crypto market, they're a bit like this is mass.
I mentioned earlier, this is mass psychology.
They try to latch on to things and certain things just go viral.
And then everybody reacts.
It's just human nature when it's just mass psychology.
So it's unfortunate.
But I think I agree with you, which is, look, we've got to look at the bigger picture.
And the bigger picture is the money in the industry will continue to grow.
The economy, the human economy is going to continue to grow.
The AI economy is going to continue to grow.
There's going to be a lot more demand for money, for any financial tools.
So the financial sector will continue to grow.
And this is a new technology for fintech.
So this industry is going to continue to grow.
Given the amount of Bitcoin that
strategy now, I always try to call it micro strategy, strategy now owns.
Are they a systemic risk to the Bitcoin market if that doesn't work out like they planned?
No, I don't think so.
I wouldn't call it a systematic risk.
But they will have impact.
So if they want to sell everything quickly, then they will have impact on market price.
But I think the market is pretty decentralized.
Even if they hold, I think that they're around one percent, right?
Even if they hold five, 10 percent, the market will be able to absorb that.
It's just like short term.
Yeah, there will be a market price impact.
But that's opportunity for many investors who are long term driven.
So I think people worry about the price.
But whenever people are going to understand, no matter where the price is, they're always buyers.
So when you're selling at a low price, other people are buying.
So there are opportunities for other people.
You recently wrote a book, right?
And that was the other subject of this, too.
What made you write that? Freedom of money.
Freedom of money. Yeah.
So I was bored when I was in prison.
So I started writing a book from prison.
And then for me, I thought it was a long time.
But I had a four month sentence, which is relatively short.
It felt very long for me.
But then I also thought that was a good turning point in my life.
And then, yeah.
And then so I spent like almost a year and a half after I got out and it's published.
I also think there's many wrong narratives about negative narratives
about crypto, blockchain, Binance, CZ, the whole industry.
And the book is really a very simple reading, very simple language.
I cannot write. I don't know fancy words.
So it's a very simple language in my true words,
how I saw the evolution of crypto and my personal experiences.
So for anyone who wants to learn about crypto, I think that's at least one view.
I'm not a super early adopter, but, you know, I got in around the end of 2013.
So still relatively early
by when we look back now.
So I just wanted to share our story with with people who are interested.
You know, we were, you know, Yahoo Finance was one of the earlier places
to talk to you and get to know you.
And, you know, I like I told you before, I got to talk to you many times
during the rise of Bitcoin to see like what you went through
during that whole ordeal.
It was it was hard for me to separate the same.
This is something I've talked to.
I've gotten to know at least remotely, never physically seen in person.
Were you so day one, you walk into prison.
What was do you get treated differently because of who you are?
Like, what is that like?
Yeah. So actually, luckily, I was not treated differently.
I was treated just like anybody else, which is great.
I was really worried that they would recognize me
and they would treat me differently.
And many of the major news outlets like the Wall Street Journal, Bloomberg,
they reported like I was going to be I was going to be the richest person
to ever to go to U.S. prison.
And that doesn't help me. Right.
So at the time, my consultants, my lawyers were like this.
You're probably a primary target for extortion.
So like that psychological, that psychological uncertainty
was actually much, much heavier to deal with than the fiscal aspects.
The fiscal aspect wasn't great.
You know, you strip naked on the intake.
You know, they check everything and they let you in.
And the conditions are pretty bad.
Just like you see on TV, check everything there.
They're the whole process.
The whole process at all.
Yeah. So like, yeah.
So you go in strip naked.
You show your tongue, show your ears
and then you show up on the lift your balls, turn around,
spread your butt cheeks, cough, the whole thing.
And that's what every time when you have a visitor to before and after.
It wasn't a one time thing.
It wasn't that it wasn't a one time thing.
The first time you go through it, I was OK with it.
You know, but it's not a it's not a pleasant experience for anyone.
And also, like for me,
I'm the only person who ever went to U.S.
to a prison for a single violation of a banking secrecy act,
which is a registration failure.
So but it is what it is.
It's what under the bridge.
I concluded that chapter.
Also, writing the books really helps conclude now.
Therapeutic. It's kind of therapeutic.
It kind of like, you know, put to rest that chapter.
And now we're looking at a new chapter.
How did you how did you survive day to day?
How did you plan out your day?
Because you imagine it got around like, hey, well, look who's here.
So, yeah.
So people know I was like, no, the word the word of mouth passed around.
People know I was I'm a rich guy, but people are still polite.
And in prison, they put you in groups by ethnicity.
I was put into a group with two or three other Asians, plus like
two or three Native Americans and plus two Hawaii and Hawaiians,
Pacific Islanders.
So they put us in this little group.
So we were like a group of six out of the 200 people in this unit.
But once you're in a little group, you kind of look out for each other.
You make friends everywhere.
And other people don't didn't bother me.
And everyone's friendly.
So in prison, everyone's a bit edgy.
Like you kind of kind of fall.
What did you feel for your life day to day?
No, no, there was not.
I don't think at any point I feared for my life.
I was going in. I was a bit worried.
I was really worried if there was any extortion attempts.
But once I got in, there wasn't.
And I was in a small group.
I didn't fear for my life.
But what I feared more was when they say four months,
am I really going to get out in four months?
Right. You don't even know if you were getting out in four months.
There's a lot of uncertainties.
There's a lot of people who because I'm not a U.S.
citizen, once technically, once I finish my prison sentence,
the standard procedure is to give me to ICE,
Immigration Enforcement, Customs Enforcement.
And I heard stories of other inmates who go through ICE,
like they spend a year in ICE detention center waiting for deportation.
But for me, I want to get out the minute I get out.
But the standard procedure is for ICE to handle that.
And but there's many, many ways to sort of get not exceptions,
just sort of get the process that's optimal for you.
For me, it's very, very clear.
I'm leaving the minute I get out.
So but there's a lot of uncertainties.
The other uncertainty is
given how anti-crypto the last administration was when I was in prison,
I don't know if they were going to
latch on some other charge, even though they said they wouldn't.
But that was uncertain to me.
So there was a lot of ups and downs.
I detailed this part in a lot of detail in my book.
So for anybody who wants to know about it, check it out.
Yeah. How did you
how do you reacclimate to yourself
or just get readjusted to the world when you got out?
So interestingly, even with only four months in prison,
it took me a few weeks or maybe a couple of months
once I got out to recalibrate.
For the first couple of months, I didn't really meet that many people.
It just took a while to sort of slowly get used to it.
And then, you know, I look forward to see like, what can I do in my life?
What's interesting in my life?
I actually don't want to go back, you know, running Binance, et cetera.
Like that's a that's the last chapter.
I just thought, you know, I should do something that's impact
that has positive impact.
And I want to I want to be in a situation when I'm 70, 80 years old.
When I look back at myself, I want to be happy with myself.
I want to say I try my best.
So I care less about legacy, what other people think after I die.
I just want to be happy with myself
that I made a positive contribution to the maximum extent I can
close to the maximum extent I can.
So I try my best.
How do you how do you imagine spending the next 25 years?
Well, I think the pursuit of that mission.
Sure. So I think
investments is one way to do it.
I think investing in impactful funders like the world changing technologies,
et cetera, and that has a very high degree of failure.
So many, many of our investment will fail.
But hopefully we'll invest in a few of those that will be extremely successful.
And then the free education platform I'm working on, Giga Academy.
I think education is very fundamental.
So this Giga Academy has 500,000 kids registered now.
At the beginning of the year, six months ago, it was only 100,000.
So it's growing pretty exponentially.
So that means there's a very strong demand for free education platforms.
And then I spent the other time like I coach funders
who wants to who wants to view me as a mentor.
So I have conversations with maybe a dozen, half a dozen funders at different times.
And then I also advise a few governments on their crypto regulatory policies.
So for governments who wants to value my opinion, I'm happy to give my opinion.
Well, it's it's good to reconnect with you.
Absolutely. Thank you for coming down here.
And I look forward to let's not wait another four years.
I appreciate it. Absolutely.
Thank you for having me.
All right. That's it for the latest episode of Power Players.
We'll talk to you soon.