The Biggest Black Hole In The Universe... Maybe

Universe Unveiled
2 followers
Nov 12, 2026 #Blackhole #universe
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedThis video examines the mystery of Phoenix A, a supermassive black hole in the Phoenix galaxy cluster. It explores the debate over its actual mass—ranging from 5.8 billion to 100 billion solar masses—and analyzes the galaxy's unusual ability to produce stars at a massive rate, challenging the typical \"thermostat\" behavior of central black holes in galaxy clusters.
The biggest black hole in the universe weighs 100 billion suns,
more than every star in our galaxy
combined. 100 Sun to Pluto distances would fit across
its event horizon, light needs over three
weeks to cross it, and on average it's thinner than air.
At least that's what the headlines say,
or maybe it's not the biggest after all,
none of that applies, and Phoenix A's record is
Pure baloney.
Actually, I'm still trying to figure it out myself,
so let's start from the top.
Weirdly, this place was found by a telescope
that stares at the oldest light in the universe,
nothing at all to do with black holes.
The South Pole Telescope is a 10 meter dish almost 3 kilometers up,
where the air is thin
and bone dry, and nights last for half the year.
Perfect for catching the cosmic microwave background,
which as you probably remember,
is the cooled down echo of the Big Bang, which
comes at us from every direction.
Here's the trick.
On its way to us, that light sometimes passes
through galaxy clusters, which are packed
with gas at tens of millions of degrees.
About 1% of those ancient photons trip over that gas
and change energy, leaving a tiny
spot on the map, a shadow.
It's called the Sunyaev-Zeldovich effect,
and it's one of astronomy's most elegant
You find the most massive things in the universe
and how they slightly smudge the picture behind them.
In 2010, one more shadow like that showed up
in the constellation Phoenix.
Just another shadow.
Catalog number SPT-CLJ2344-4243.
Then in the summer of 2011,
MIT's Michael McDonald pointed the Chandra X-ray telescope at it,
and his jaw hit the floor. It
It was the brightest cluster in X-rays ever seen.
About a thousand galaxies
Weighing up to two and a half quadrillion of our suns.
One of the most massive clusters we know of.
Its light takes about 5.8 billion years to reach us.
It left before there was an earth, before there was even a sun.
Our planet formed, cooled, got oceans, dinosaurs, and the internet.
And that light was still on its way.
The cluster was named Phoenix after its constellation,
and it turns out that name fit way better than anyone had planned.
To see what's off about Phoenix, well first,
let's learn about how clusters normally work.
A cluster is flooded with hot gas,
weighing trillions of suns, several times more than
all its galaxies combined.
That gas glows in X-rays, and anything that glows loses energy.
So the gas cools, and drains towards
the center where the main galaxy sits,
a giant that spent billions of years eating its neighbors
and gotten obscenely large.
Cold, dense gas is exactly what stars are made of.
Do the simple math
and that central galaxy should be churning out hundreds of stars a
year.
Astronomers looked and got nothing.
Central cluster galaxies are full of old red stars
that make maybe one new star every few
years.
They're literally nicknamed Red and Dead.
Retirees who've had their fun cluster after cluster.
This is the cooling flow problem,
and it's had astronomers scratching their heads for decades.
The gas is there, it has to cool, but no stars.
So where is all the cold going?
The answer that stuck.
The black hole in the center gets in the way. As soon as gas starts
raining down onto it, it fires back with jets,
streams of particles at nearly the speed of light.
The jets inflate giant bubbles in the hot gas
and send out shockwaves, and the gas
heats right back up again.
The black hole is kind of like a thermostat.
When things get cold, it turns up the heat.
The gas never cools, no stars are born,
and central galaxies stay retirees.
This rule held in nearly every cluster anyone ever checked.
Then McDonald and a team of over 80 people pulled together data
on Phoenix from 10 different
telescopes. In 2012, their Nature paper dropped.
Phoenix's central galaxy forms about 740 masses
of stars per year. 740.
Hundreds of solar masses per year. Exactly the kind of
A furious star formation that simple cooling flow models had predicted,
but that astronomers
had almost never seen in a galaxy cluster.
Our perfectly lively Milky Way, by the way,
makes about one or two per year.
The previous record holder, Abell 1835,
made about a hundred, and even that was a fluke.
Phoenix steamrolled that record.
So, in Phoenix, gas cools into stars
as if there's no thermostat at all.
A galaxy that should be a retiree came back to life and went buckwild.
That's where the name clicks, a phoenix rising from the ashes.
Except a normal phoenix rises and flies off.
This one rose and started cranking out two stars every day,
roughly anyway.
So, the thermostat failed, and the thermostat is the black hole.
Why couldn't it keep up?
First, we need to know what kind of black hole it is,
starting with how much does it
weigh or mass for you nitpickers.
You can't put a black hole on a scale.
You can't even see it.
You weigh it by how hard it yanks on everything around it.
The most reliable way is tracking stars that fly close to it.
That's how we weighed Sagittarius A*
the black hole at the center of our galaxy.
Decades of watching stars whip around an empty spot,
mapping their orbits,
and calculating the mass, about 4 million suns.
Case closed.
The second way is for quasars,
black holes eating so hard they outshine their whole galaxy.
The spectrum tells you how fast gas is whirling around the black hole,
and that speed gives
you the mass.
That's how the famous Ton 618 was weighed,
first 66 billion suns, then with newer data
40.7, give or take about 25 billion suns.
With Phoenix, neither works.
At this distance, you can't make out stars near the black hole.
A galaxy 5.8 billion light years away
is a blurry smudge to any telescope,
and the spectrum has its own problem.
Phoenix's black hole eats like a quasar,
but it's hidden behind a thick layer of gas and dust,
including the fast gas right next to it,
the exact stuff you'd use to measure speed. So in 2016,
Brautkamp's group took a third route, modeling.
Fun fact, the paper was called Unveiling Gargantua.
Shout out to Interstellar.
The logic is simple.
The bigger a black hole,
the more it reshapes the very center of the galaxy over its lifetime.
How the stars there get spread out.
And the more energy it pumps into the surrounding gas,
creating all those jets and bubbles.
That energy isn't free.
To blast out that much, the black hole had to eat that much.
Tie the two together, run the models,
and Phoenix comes out at around a hundred billion
And maybe.
That's 24,000 times heavier, or more massive,
than the black hole at the center of our galaxy.
So that's where the headline,
biggest black hole in the universe comes from.
One catch, it's not a measurement.
model. Even the authors say this method has its limits.
Then in 2019, a Chandra press release on Phoenix casually mentioned
in a single line, the black holes mass 5.8 billion suns, not 100.
5.8, a 17-fold gap, like asking two doctors your weight
and hearing 80 kilograms and 1,300.
The release doesn't really explain where
that number comes from, it's just McDonald's
team's working figure.
Still a monster, over a thousand times heavier than ours,
but it has about as much shot at
biggest in the universe as we have of it right.
Honestly, nobody knows, and nobody can check directly yet.
For a comparison, in 2025,
scientists weighed the black hole in the cosmic horseshoe galaxy,
36 billion suns, and they did it the honest way,
by how its galaxy bends light and how
stars zip around it.
There's no more reliable number for a giant like that.
Count everything weighed by observation in any way at all,
and the record holder is
TON 618 with its 40 billion.
Phoenix A is a hypothetical champion,
the heaviest black hole on paper, its mass straight
out of a model.
But let's believe in that 100 billion for a minute,
we're here for the big stuff
after all.
A monster like that is wild.
An event horizon grows in direct proportion to mass.
Squeeze the Sun into a black hole
and its horizon would be about 3 kilometers in radius.
For a black hole at 100 billion suns,
it's about 300 billion kilometers, nearly 600 billion across,
3,900 times the Earth's sun distance.
To put that into perspective, Pluto orbits at about 40,
whether you think it's a planet or not.
Put Phoenix A where the sun is, and the entire
The entire solar system, Neptune, Pluto,
the Kuiper belt, all of it, would be rattling around
Deep inside the horizon, with room to spare,
light needs over three weeks to cross it.
Voyager 1, the farthest thing humanity has ever launched,
has been flying for almost
half a century and is only about 170 Earth-Sun distances out.
Crossing Phoenix A would take it more than a thousand years.
Divide this black hole's mass by the volume inside its horizon,
and the average density comes out about 600 times lower than
the air you're breathing now.
Sure, it's not some thin gas in there.
The mass is arranged completely differently.
Still, on average, this giant is thinner than air. Isn't that wild?
And the bigger the black hole, the gentler its edge.
A small one, a few times the sun's mass,
would rip you apart long before you ever reached
the horizon.
Your feet would get pulled harder than your head,
and you're stretched into a noodle.
That's what's commonly known as spaghettification,
or in Asian countries, what they call spaghettification.
Okay, they don't call it that, I'm just kidding.
Anyway, at Phoenix A's horizon,
the difference in pull between your head and feet is tiny.
You'd cross it and feel absolutely nothing.
No flash, no jolt.
At some point, there's just no way back,
and you don't even know it.
How long until you hit the center?
For a black hole this size, at most, about 18 days by your own clock.
Two and a half weeks of falling, alive and well,
with time to grab lunch, and wonder
what on earth possessed you to do that.
Closer in, the tidal forces do grow,
and the ending is the same as anywhere, just delayed.
Last thing, black holes don't last forever.
According to Hawking, they evaporate,
but incredibly slowly, and the bigger they are,
the longer they live.
A 100 billion sun black hole would need something like 10
to the 100th power years, that's
a 1 with 100 zeros after it, a googol,
before it exhales its last breath.
Next to that, the current age of the universe is a rounding error.
When the last star burns out and the last galaxy falls apart,
Phoenix A will still be there, hanging in the dark, in no hurry at all.
This is where physics gets nervous,
because it's not clear how anything gets this fat.
A black hole grows by swallowing gas.
Not a straight dive in, but through a spiraling disk,
that glowing doughnut you see in every
picture.
In 2015, British astrophysicist Andrew King worked out
that this kind of growth has a
ceiling.
A disk can only survive out to a certain distance.
Beyond that, gas clumps under its own weight and breaks up into stars.
The black hole also has an inner edge.
Inside it, gas stops orbiting and just falls in.
The bigger the black hole,
the farther out that inner edge.
But eventually, it can reach that zone
where the gas is already turning into stars,
so the disk disappears, it has nowhere left to live,
and the black hole stops getting fed.
By King's math, the ceiling for a typical black hole
is about 50 billion suns, but spinning,
At the absolute limit, it rises to about 270,
but that's a truly extreme case.
100 billion is twice the usual ceiling.
Growing that big through a disk only works
if it's spinning almost at the limit.
Otherwise, it must have gained mass some other way.
Option one, mergers.
A cluster's central galaxy spends its life eating its neighbors,
each with its own black
hole.
Those sink to the center and merge with the main one.
There's no disk, so King's ceiling doesn't apply here.
But reaching a hundred billion that way takes a lot.
A lot of meals.
Option two is bolder.
Black holes over a hundred billion suns have their own category,
slabs, or stupendously
large black holes.
Yes, that's a real scientific term.
One idea where they come from,
instead of starting from stars, they're born as huge
primordial black holes in the first moments after the big bang.
That means they didn't need to gain it all through a disk.
Heavyweights from the start, but it's just a hypothesis.
Nobody's ever found a single primordial black hole.
And option three, the boring one.
If the 5.8 billion suns number is right,
the black hole never hits the ceiling and there's
nothing to explain.
Disappointing, but science doesn't owe us a good show.
Whatever it weighs, the original question still stands.
Why did that thermostat that keeps new stars
from being born break down?
In 2019, McDonald's team combined data from Chandra,
Hubble, and the VLA radio telescope.
The black hole does have jets.
They shoot out both ways and inflate two bubbles in the hot
gas. Chandra sees them as dark gaps in the X-ray glow.
So the black hole is doing its job,
just weirdly. Draped along the edges of those bubbles,
like a sheet over an air mattress,
Are long filaments of cold gas, about 10 billion suns worth,
that's exactly where the stars are being born.
Back in 2017, the ALMA radio telescopes spotted molecular gas
in those filaments, and that
kind of gas only exists when it's frigid, about 10 kelvins.
That's about minus 263 degrees Celsius.
Meanwhile, the gas surrounding
these bubbles is millions of degrees hot.
Think about that, gas just 10 degrees above absolute zero,
draped across a landscape,
A million degree hellfire.
The team's explanation for this.
The jets scoop up gas from the center,
carry it outwards, where farther from the black
hole it cools faster than it can fall back.
The black hole that normally stops gas
from cooling is hauling it off to cool.
Something similar is suspected in other clusters,
but nowhere near on this scale.
Here the thermostat got wired backwards.
It's an air conditioner now.
According to the team,
the black hole used to be too small for its galaxy, with
outbursts too weak to heat that whole swamp of gas,
so the gas started cooling.
But here's the catch.
Their calculations assume a black hole weighing 5.8 billion suns,
not 100 billion. And if that much bigger estimate is correct,
well then the whole explanation becomes a lot less convincing.
Why couldn't such an enormous black hole keep the gas hot?
That is still an open question.
But the black hole is growing, and its outbursts with it.
Sooner or later, turbulence, shock waves,
and sound waves from the jets will heat the
gas and the starburst will end.
Phoenix will go back to being red and dead.
Once the black hole quiets down,
the gas will start cooling again, and a round it goes.
You can even see traces of the last round,
old bubbles farther out, inflated about a
hundred million years ago.
So, the black hole has flared up before.
It looks like this galaxy lives in cycles.
It dies and comes back.
And suddenly, the name Phoenix seems
pretty darn appropriate, doesn't it?
It dies and rises from the ashes,
only to do it all over again.
But for a long time, this story had a missing link.
The hot gas had been seen millions of degrees in X-rays.
The cold gas too, 10 kelvins.
But the warm gas in between,
what the hot gas has to pass through on its way to the cold,
nobody had really seen that.
Hubble caught traces of it in 2015, but where it was and where it came
from was anyone's guess. Without that link, a question remained.
Either the cold gas really
is cooling right there in the center,
or neighboring galaxies falling into this giant
just dragged it in and the whole cooling story falls apart.
It's like finding raw dough and a finished pie in your kitchen.
Did it bake here, or did someone bring it in from next door?
To know, you'd have to catch the oven running.
In July 2023, the James Webb Space Telescope's MIRI instrument,
which sees in the mid-infrared,
was pointed at Phoenix.
The team was looking for glowing neon at around 300,000 degrees.
At that temperature, neon atoms lose five of their electrons
and emit light at a very specific
wavelength. And that's exactly the kind
of warm gas the scientists had been looking for.
And the neon was glowing everywhere,
clumps and filaments of warm gas stretching across
the whole field of view, like a neon sign the size of a galaxy's core.
For the first time,
scientists could see the entire process unfolding, hot gas cooling
into warm gas, then cold gas,
and eventually forming new stars, all in the same galaxy,
Something they'd never seen before, the oven's on.
Pie is homemade.
So much gas is cooling there that there's cold gas to spare,
more than the galaxy can
turn into stars.
No neighbors need it.
Bake stars from its own ingredient.
The paper came out in Nature in February 2025.
McDonald summed it up honestly.
What's happening is now understood almost completely.
Why it happened here and not in other clusters, meh, nobody knows.
What are you going to do?
Every cluster goes through this phase,
is just short, and we only caught it here.
Back in 2012, McDonald guessed it might be around 1% of the time,
or maybe Phoenix took
a path other clusters never take,
making it the one and only freak of its kind.
So where does that leave us?
The biggest black hole in the universe might not be the biggest.
It might be a hundred billion suns or 5.8
and nobody can check directly yet.
But one thing's beyond a doubt.
A galaxy that should have died long ago came back to life
and is pumping out two stars a day. And it looks like it's getting help
from the very black hole that,
according to every textbook, should have finished it off.
And this light is almost six billion years old.
We're seeing Phoenix as it was before we
were even on the drawing board.
Has that starburst burnt out since then?
Has the black hole won?
Has a new cycle begun?
None of us will ever know.
If the cycle really does repeat, sooner or later,
something there will rise from the ashes again.
It seems to be the one thing this galaxy is actually good at.
