Scientists Tested an Emperors Hair 100 Years Later It Was Full of Arsenic

This Ancient Chinese
4 followers
#Ancient Chinese
#on an island in a Beijing lake. Less than a day later, the most powerful woman in China — Empress Dowager Cixi — dies too.
#history #Ancient Chinese
AI Generated·May contain errors
On the 14th of November, 1908,
in a small palace on an island in the middle of a lake in Beijing,
the Emperor of China died. He was 37 years old.
The next afternoon, less than a day later,
the most powerful woman in China died too.
She was 72.
For almost half a century, she had ruled the Qing Empire.
And for the last ten years, she had kept that emperor a prisoner.
The court announced that both deaths were natural.
The emperor had been ill for a long time.
The Empress Dowager was old.
It was a coincidence.
Almost nobody believed it.
For a hundred years, the question was whispered,
argued, and written about.
Was the emperor murdered?
And if he was, who gave the order?
Then, in 2008, a team of Chinese scientists opened
the emperor's remains to find out.
They tested his hair, his bones, and the clothes he was buried in.
And in his hair, they found arsenic,
at levels around 2,400 times higher than normal.
So the emperor was poisoned.
But that answer only raised a harder question.
Science can tell us how a man died.
Can it tell us who killed him?
To answer that, we have to go back to a three-year-old boy
who was carried to the throne in the middle of the night.
His name was Zaitian.
He was born in 1871, the son of an imperial prince.
His mother was the younger sister of a woman
who already controlled the Qing court,
the Empress Dowager Cixi.
Cixi had entered the palace as a low-ranking concubine.
She gave birth to the only son of the Xianfeng emperor,
and when the emperor died in 1861,
her five-year-old son took the throne,
and she became one of the regents ruling in his name.
Over the following years, she outmaneuvered her rivals
and became the real power behind the throne.
In January 1875, her son,
the Tongzhi Emperor, died at the age of 18.
He had no heir.
Cixi made a decision that broke the normal rules of succession.
Instead of choosing an adult from the next generation,
she chose her three-year-old nephew.
A child emperor meant that she would continue to rule as regent.
And so, in the middle of a winter night,
The little boy was taken
from his family's mansion to the Forbidden City.
He became the Guangxu Emperor.
He grew up inside the palace under Cixi's control.
He called her Dear Father,
a title used at court to emphasize her authority.
According to many accounts, his childhood was lonely and strict.
He was intelligent, serious, and physically frail.
In 1889, when he came of age, Cixi formally retired,
and Guangxu began to rule in his own
name. She even chose his wife for him,
her own niece, a woman who would later be known
as Empress Longyu. The emperor, by most accounts, did not love her.
He preferred a lively young
consort, known to history as the Pearl Consort.
It is worth pausing on Cixi herself.
Because the way she
is remembered shapes how we read everything that follows.
For much of the 20th century,
she was portrayed as a cruel and greedy tyrant
who held China back.
More recent historians have painted a more complicated picture.
A shrewd politician who survived decades of crisis,
who supported some modernization
when it suited her, and who held together
a failing dynasty longer than many thought possible.
But on one point, almost everyone agrees – she did not give up power.
And she did not forgive those who threatened it.
But even in retirement, Cixi remained the centre of power.
Officials still reported to her.
The emperor still visited her regularly.
And nothing important happened without her knowledge.
Then came the disaster that changed everything.
In 1894, China went to war with Japan.
Within months, the Chinese navy was destroyed,
and in 1895, the Qing empire was forced
to sign a humiliating peace treaty,
giving up Taiwan and paying enormous sums of money.
Japan, a country that had modernized in a single generation,
had crushed the old empire.
The young emperor was shaken.
He became convinced that China had to change or it would not survive.
In the summer of 1898,
he launched what history calls the Hundred Days Reform.
Influenced by reformers such as Kang Youwei,
he issued a stream of decrees.
Modern schools, a reformed examination system,
new industries, a modern army,
the abolition of useless government offices.
In about a hundred days, he tried to transform an empire.
The reforms frightened the old elite.
Officials who would lose their posts, conservatives who feared change,
and many people around Cixi turned against them.
And the reformers began to fear
that the Empress Dowager would stop them.
According to many accounts, the reformers made a desperate plan.
One of them went to a general named Yuan Shikai,
who commanded a modern army near the capital,
and asked him to help them move against Cixi's allies.
What exactly was said that night, and what Yuan did afterwards,
historians still debate.
But within days, the plan collapsed.
On the 21st of September, 1898, Cixi returned to power.
The reforms were cancelled.
Several of the reformers were executed, others,
including Kang Youwei, fled abroad, and the
emperor was taken to Yingtai,
a small palace on an island in the lake west of the Forbidden
City.
He was still the emperor, he still performed ceremonies,
but he was never again allowed
to rule.
For the last ten years of his life, he was a prisoner.
In 1900, during the Boxer Uprising, foreign armies marched on Beijing,
and Cixi fled the capital, taking the emperor with her.
Before they left, the Pearl Consort, the woman Guangxu had loved,
was drowned in a palace well,
according to the most common account on Cixi's orders.
If you have watched our earlier file about her, you know that story.
When the court returned to Beijing,
the Emperor went back to his island.
Now we come to the last weeks of 1908.
By then, both the Emperor and the Empress Dowager were ill.
The Emperor had suffered from chronic illness for years.
His medical records, which survive in the palace archives,
describe a long list of complaints.
Cixi was in her 70s,
and in the autumn of 1908 she became seriously ill as well,
and that created a terrifying problem for many people at court.
If Cixi died first, the emperor would be free.
He was still young enough to rule.
He might bring back the reforms,
and he would remember who had betrayed him in 1898,
and who had kept him locked away for ten years.
On the 13th of November, Cixi named a new heir,
the emperor's two-year-old nephew, Puyi.
On the 14th, the emperor died.
On the 15th, Cixi died.
Puyi became the last emperor of China.
Three years later, the Qing dynasty was gone.
For a century, the rumours never stopped.
Some said Cixi had ordered the Emperor's death,
determined not to let him outlive her.
Some blamed her favourite eunuch, Li Lianying.
Some blamed Yuan Shikai, the general who many
believed had betrayed the Emperor in 1898
and who had the most to fear from his return.
Even Puyi, the last emperor,
wrote in his memoirs about a story he had heard from an old eunuch,
that the emperor had been reasonably well just the day before he died,
and that his condition changed suddenly
after he took a dose of medicine.
Another story was passed down in the family of a Qing official,
who claimed he saw a eunuch carrying a bowl
from the Empress Dowager's residence
and was told it was yoghurt for the emperor.
Not long afterwards, he heard that the emperor was dead.
These were stories, gossip, memories, family tales.
For a hundred years, there was no way to test them,
until scientists decided to try.
The emperor's tomb lies in the Western Qing tombs,
southwest of Beijing.
In 1938, during years of war and chaos,
robbers broke into it and stripped it of its treasures.
Decades later, in 1980, archaeologists entered the tomb,
cleaned it, and examined what was left.
The emperor's coffin had been damaged, but his remains,
including his hair and fragments of his burial clothes, had survived.
Hair is a remarkable witness.
As it grows, it records traces of what has entered the body,
almost like a diary written in chemistry.
A single strand can show whether a person
was exposed to a poison over months or all at once.
In the early 2000s,
a team that included researchers from the China Institute of Atomic
Energy and forensic experts
from the Beijing police began a long investigation.
Using techniques such as neutron activation analysis,
they examined strands of the emperor's hair, centimeter by centimeter.
They tested his bones. They tested the clothes he had been buried in.
The results were announced in November 2008,
almost exactly a hundred years after his death.
The emperor's hair contained enormous amounts of arsenic,
around 2,400 times higher than in normal hair.
Now, a scientist has to ask an obvious question.
Could this be natural?
Arsenic was used in some traditional medicines
and could be present in the environment.
So the team made comparisons.
They tested the hair of Guangxu's wife,
Empress Longyu, buried in the same tomb complex.
Guangxu's hair contained more than 260 times as much arsenic as hers.
They tested the remains of a Qing official from the same era.
Guangxu's levels were more than a hundred times higher.
They compared the pattern with a person
who had suffered long-term arsenic exposure.
It did not match.
And then they found the most revealing detail of all.
The highest concentrations of arsenic were not in the hair itself.
They were in the clothing, especially around the stomach area.
As the body decomposed after death,
the poison had seeped from the stomach into the fabric.
The conclusion was clear.
The Emperor had not died of a long illness.
He had died of acute arsenic poisoning.
A large amount of arsenic had entered his body in a short time,
shortly before he died.
After a hundred years, the rumours were confirmed.
Guangxu was murdered.
But here is where the science stops.
Arsenic can tell us how the emperor died.
It cannot tell us who put it in his food or his medicine.
And it cannot tell us who gave the order.
So historians return to the old question with new certainty.
The first suspect is, of course, Cixi herself.
She had the motive. She knew she was dying.
She had spent ten years making sure
the emperor could not undo her decisions.
Many historians, including a senior official
of China's National Qing History Project,
have argued that she must have been behind it.
In the closed world of the inner palace, they say,
no one else could have arranged the death
of the emperor without her knowledge.
The second suspect is Li Lianying, her powerful chief eunuch,
who had every reason to fear what
the emperor would do to him after Cixi's death.
The third is Yuan Shikai,
the general who had been accused of betraying the emperor in 1898.
If Guangxu returned to power, Yuan's career,
and perhaps his life, would be in danger.
Puyi's memoir pointed toward him.
And Yuan's later life gives the suspicion a strange edge.
After the fall of the Qing,
he became the first president of the new Republic of China.
And in 1915, he tried to make himself emperor,
founding a new dynasty of his own.
It collapsed within months, and he died in 1916.
The man many suspected of killing the last reforming emperor
ended his career trying to become an emperor himself.
There is one more possibility that some historians raise,
that several people with the same fear acted together.
Or that someone acted in Cixi's name,
knowing what she wanted, without a direct order from her.
In a court where a nod could be enough,
the person who decided, and the person who acted,
might not have been the same. The evidence cannot settle this.
The arsenic proves the crime.
The motive points strongly toward the Empress Dowager and her circle.
But there is no written order, no confession,
and no witness who saw the poison being added.
And everyone who might have known the truth died long ago.
What the evidence does tell us, very clearly,
is something about the man at the center of the story.
For most of his life, Guangxu was an emperor in name only.
He was chosen as a child so that someone else could rule.
He tried to change his country,
And for a hundred days he did, then he was locked away on an island.
Even his death was decided by others.
And the woman who ruled over him for 33 years
did not trust that he would stay powerless even after she was gone.
So what did historians find
when they looked closely at the death of the Guangxu Emperor?
They found a boy who was placed on the throne at three,
so that his aunt could keep ruling.
They found a young emperor
who tried to modernise China in a hundred days
and who paid for it with ten years of captivity on an island.
They found a hundred years of rumours,
a bowl of yoghurt, a dose of medicine,
a frightened general and a loyal eunuch.
And they found,
in his hair and in the clothes he was buried in, arsenic,
thousands of times above normal, proof that the rumours were right.
Remember the picture we started with, two deaths less than a day apart,
and a court that called it a coincidence.
It was not a coincidence. It was a decision.
Science has shown us how it was carried out.
The name of the person who made it remains locked inside
the Forbidden City with everyone who knew it.
In the next file, we stay in those last years of the Qing dynasty,
with the woman whose hair the scientists used as a comparison,
Empress Long Yu, the wife the emperor never loved.
Three years after his death, she signed the document
that ended more than 2,000 years of imperial rule in China.
