Why Did a Six-Year-Old Emperor's Mother Sign the End of China-

This Ancient Chinese
4 followers
#Ancient Chinese
#Empress Dowager Longyu signed the documents that ended the Qing dynasty on February 12, 1912. Explore the final days of imperial rule.
#history #Ancient Chinese
AI Generated·May contain errors
It is the 12th of February, 1912, in the Forbidden City,
and a woman of 44 is signing away an empire.
The paper in front of her ends the Qing Dynasty, 268 years of rule,
and with it more than 2,000 years of emperors in China.
She signs it not for herself, but for a child of six, the last emperor,
who sits beside her and does not understand what is happening.
Her name is Long Yu, the Empress Dowager.
And this film asks how a woman who was never meant to rule
came to be the one who ended the empire and what the choice cost her.
To understand the signature, you have to understand the woman.
Yehe Nara Jingfen was born in 1868 into the Manchu clan
that had produced the most powerful
woman in China.
She married the Guangxu emperor in 1889 when she was 21 and he was 17.
For 19 years, she was his empress and he never loved her.
For three years, she was the dowager of a child emperor,
and she never ruled in her own name.
She had no children, no army, and no party of her own,
and yet the last act of the empire was hers.
But this film is not only about a signature.
It is about the life that led to it.
Long Yu was chosen as a bride to strengthen a clan,
married to a husband who did not want her,
and loyal to the aunt who had chosen her.
She watched her husband locked away on an island.
Watched his favorite die in a well,
and watched the empire fall apart around her.
And when there was no one left to decide, the decision fell to her.
The question this film asks is what that decision was.
A surrender? A betrayal?
Or the last act of care a dowager could offer
the family she had been given?
The bargain she struck is the spine of this film.
In exchange for the throne, the imperial family would keep its titles,
its possessions, and its home in the Forbidden City.
The child emperor would keep his title for life.
The family would receive four million silver taels a year,
the tombs of the emperors would
be protected, and the new republic would pay
for her husband's funeral and his tomb.
It was, by the standards of fallen dynasties,
a generous settlement, and it was bought with
the one thing the family had left to give, the throne itself.
Her life, in three dates, is short enough to hold in one hand.
Born in 1868, married in 1889, dead in 1913.
45 years, and almost all of them spent inside
the walls of the Forbidden City.
Yet those 45 years contain a marriage without love,
a husband imprisoned by his own aunt,
a flight from a burning capital,
two deaths in a single day, a child on the throne, a
revolution, and the end of an empire.
To understand how, we have to begin where she began,
as a daughter of the Yehenara in
the last years of the Tongzhi Emperor.
She was born on the 28th of January, 1868,
on the fourth day of the first lunar month
in the seventh year of the Tongzhi Emperor.
Her clan was the Yehe Nara of the Manchu-bordered Yellow Banner,
one of the great families of
the conquest elite.
Her father was Gui Liang,
a first-rank military official who held the title of a Duke of the
Third Class.
Her grandfather had held the same dukedom.
Her mother was a Lady Aisin Gioro.
Her personal name was Jingfen, Quiet Fragrance,
and she had an elder sister, a younger sister,
and two brothers. But the two names that mattered
in her family were not her father's,
they were her aunt's.
Her father's elder sister was the Empress Dowager Sixi,
the woman who had ruled China since the coup of 1861,
and who was the mother of the Tongzhi
Emperor. Her father's younger sister, Wanjin,
was the mother of the Guangxu Emperor.
When the Tongzhi Emperor died childless in January of 1875, aged 18,
Sixi placed her four-year-old nephew Zaitian
on the throne as the Guangxu Emperor.
He was the son of Prince Chun and Wanjin,
which made him Jingfen's first cousin,
and Sixi's nephew twice over.
The boy emperor and the girl
who would marry him were already bound together by blood,
long before either of them had any say in it.
In 1889, Cixi decided that the emperor had
to marry before he could formally take over the reins of power.
She chose her niece Jingfen to be his primary wife
because she wanted to strengthen the
influence of the Yehe Nara clan within the imperial family.
On the 26th of February, 1889,
Jingfen married the Guangxu emperor and became his empress
directly after the wedding.
On the same day, two consorts entered the palace with her,
the sisters Consort Jin and
Consort Zhen of the Tatar clan.
The wedding was, by the histories,
an extremely extravagant and spectacular occasion.
It began under a bad omen.
Six weeks before the wedding, on the 16th of January,
1889, the Forbidden City caught
fire, and the Gate of Supreme Harmony burnt down.
By tradition, the Emperor's wedding procession had
to pass through that gate, and it could
not be rebuilt in time.
So Sixi ordered a tent built of paper and wood in its place,
of exactly the same height
and width as the gate, with ornamentation
so similar that people who walked through
the inner palace every day could
not at first tell the tent from the gate.
And the wedding went ahead on the appointed day,
through a gate made of paper.
Many people at court believed the fire was a bad omen.
The marriage that followed gave them reason to think so.
The marriage was cold from the start.
The Guangxu emperor detested and ignored his empress,
and favored consort Zhen.
The empress was left on the outside of her husband's affections,
in a palace where a wife's standing was her husband's favor.
The marriage produced no children.
And in a court where a son was an empress's
security, that silence mattered.
Zhen herself did not last in favor.
Sixi first regarded her kindly,
but when she found that Zhen had overspent her allowance
and meddled in political appointments,
she demoted her and placed her in the cold palace.
The record gives us the structure of this household.
It does not give us the Empress's feelings about it.
Above them all stood Sixi.
The Emperor had formally taken power
on his marriage in February of 1889,
and Cixi had retired to the Summer Palace.
But everyone at court knew she still held the reins.
The empress's place in this court was the place her aunt had given her,
beside Cixi, not beside her husband.
The histories record that she reported
her husband's every action to Sixi,
that she spied on the emperor for his aunt.
The film presents this as the histories record it, not as a scene.
But it is worth holding in mind,
because it explains everything that follows.
When the emperor tried to take power for himself,
his wife was not on his side.
In the summer of 1898, the Guangxu emperor tried.
Advised by the reform scholars Kang Youwei and Liang Qichao,
he issued edict after edict from the 11th of June,
over a hundred of them in 103 days,
to modernize the empire, its institutions,
its army, its schools, its examinations,
on the model of Meiji Japan.
The program was called the Hundred Days Reform,
and for a hundred days it looked as though the young emperor
might finally become a ruler in more than name.
His empress had firmly opposed the program.
When the crisis came, she stood with her aunt.
On the 21st of September, 1898,
Cixi staged a coup with her allies,
took back the government,
and put the emperor under house arrest.
Seven days later, on the 28th of September,
six of the leading reformers,
Tan Sitong, Kang Guangren, Lin Shu, Liu Guangdi,
Yang Shenshu, and Yang Rui,
were beheaded at Caishikou in Beijing without trial.
They are remembered as the six gentlemen of the reform.
Kang Youwei and Liang Qichao escaped abroad.
The emperor's attempt to rule had lasted 103 days,
and it had cost six men their lives.
It had also cost him the last of his freedom.
From the 19th of September, 1898, the Guangxu Emperor lived on Yingtai,
the island pavilion in the Lake Palace of Zhongnanhai,
west of the Forbidden City.
The drawbridge to the island was raised every evening at dusk.
He would remain there, a prisoner in a gilded cage,
for the remaining ten years of his life.
His empress remained in the palace,
in the Zhong Kui Palace, one of the six eastern palaces.
A wife whose husband was a prisoner a short walk away,
and whose loyalty belonged to the woman who had imprisoned him.
The record gives us no words of hers about those ten years.
It gives us only the arrangement and the silence.
Two years later, the crisis came to the capital itself.
In the summer of 1900, the Boxer Rebellion brought
the Eight-Nation Alliance marching
on Beijing, and in August, the court fled west to Xi'an.
Cixi, the Guangxu emperor, and the empress among them,
traveling in carts and on foot,
dressed as commoners, leaving the capital to foreign soldiers.
The foreigners looted the palaces, the city burned,
and the court that had ruled China
for more than two centuries was reduced
to a column of carts on a dusty road west.
It was the lowest point of the dynasty's long decline.
The rulers of China, running from their own capital,
the empress who had been chosen to
strengthen a clan,
was now fleeing with the clan's ruin on her back. As the court fled,
the emperor's favorite died.
Consort Zhen, the woman he had loved and the empress had been
measured against, was thrown into a well in the Forbidden City
and drowned. The accounts differ
on whether Sixi ordered it, and the film will not settle the question.
The record does not settle it
What is certain is the shape of it.
The woman the emperor loved, dead in a well,
on the day the court ran from Beijing.
And one correction matters here.
The story that Zhen was punished for supporting
the emperor's reforms is wrong on the documents.
She had already been demoted for overspending
and meddling before the reforms began.
The court returned to Beijing in January of 1902,
and the long, quiet years began.
In those years, two Western women spent time at Cixi's court.
Princess Derling, who wrote Two Years in the Forbidden City,
and the American artist Catherine Carl,
who wrote With the Empress Dowager.
Both of them recalled the Empress Jingfen
as a gracious and pleasant figure.
It is almost the only first-hand judgment
of her character the record gives us,
and the film uses it as such.
Not a verdict on her politics, but a memory of her manner,
from two women who actually met her.
Derling had been a lady-in-waiting at Cixi's court,
and Carl had painted the Dowager's portrait.
Both of them saw the empress at close quarters,
at meals and in the palace halls, and both
of them remembered her kindly.
The quiet years stretched on, 1902, 1903, 1904,
1905, 1906, 1907, 1908, an empress without
a husband's love, without children,
living in the Zhangtui palace while Cixi ruled and
the empire decayed around them.
The reforms Cixi had crushed in 1898, she now pursued herself.
Too late and too slowly.
The court grew older, the emperor grew weaker on his island,
and the empress grew into middle age with nothing
to show for her rank but the rank itself.
She was forty years old, and her life,
by every measure the court understood, was already over.
It is worth pausing on what she did not have.
She had no son, and in the king court, a son was an empress's future.
She had no husband's favor, and favor was an empress's present.
She had no party of her own, no generals,
no ministers who answered to her.
What she had was her name, her clan, and her aunt's trust.
The histories do not tell us whether she wanted more.
They tell us only what she did with what she had.
She stayed, she watched, and she waited.
And in November of 1908, the waiting ended,
in a single day that changed everything.
On the morning of the 14th of November,
1908, the Guangxu Emperor, 37 years old,
complained of stomach pains
and tingling in his hands at the Hanyuan Hall on Yingtai
and died before the physician arrived.
The official cause was a sudden illness.
Sixi herself was gravely ill,
but she had just enough time to name a successor, and then she
died on the 15th of November, aged 72,
about 22 hours after the Emperor, two deaths in a day.
The emperor who had been a prisoner for 10 years,
and the aunt who had kept him a prisoner,
both gone within a day of each other.
The emperor's death has been argued over ever since.
A century later, in 2008,
a team of Chinese researchers examined hair and clothing from
his tomb and found arsenic at levels hundreds of times above normal,
261 times the level
found in his wife's hair,
and concluded that he had died of arsenic poisoning.
The tests could not say who gave him the poison,
or when, or whether anyone ordered it.
The popular account says Cixi poisoned him before she died,
so that he could not outlive her and undo her work.
That is a theory, not a finding,
and this film will not present it as one.
What the record proves is the poison, it does not prove the hand.
Before she died, Cixi named the next emperor,
not a son of Guangxu, he had none, but his nephew,
Puyi, the two-year-old son of Zaifeng,
Prince Chun, the emperor's younger brother.
Puyi had been born on the 7th of February,
1906, in his father's mansion in Beijing.
On the evening of the 13th of November,
1908, the household was in turmoil.
His grandmother had fainted.
The servants were weeping,
because the child had been summoned to the Forbidden City,
and no one would say why.
He was two years old, and he was about to become the Emperor of China.
On the 14th of November, 1908,
Jingfen was honored as Empress Dowager Longyu.
Longyu, meaning auspicious and prosperous,
having no children of her own, she adopted the infant
Puyi as her child, and Sixi, before she died,
left one last instruction about the woman she had made.
The court would never again allow women to serve as regents,
but Longyu, as the leading respected
figure, must be consulted on all major decisions.
It was a strange inheritance. The aunt who had
ruled through men for half a century forbade women from ruling,
and then made her niece the
the one woman no one could ignore.
On the 2nd of December, 1908,
the two-year-old Puyi was enthroned as the Xuantong Emperor,
in a ceremony he was too young to understand,
carried to the throne weeping by his father.
His father, Zaifeng, Prince Chun, served as regent.
Long Yu remained the leading figure
of the court and was consulted on all major decisions,
but she was inexperienced in politics,
and the real business of government
ran through Zaifeng and the generals.
The empire now had a dowager of 40,
a young regent, and an emperor of two.
It had three years left.
The reign was given the name Xuantong, the proclamation of unity,
and the edicts of the new reign went out in the name of a child
who was still learning to speak.
The regent's first great act was a mistake.
In January of 1909, Zaifeng dismissed Yuan Shikai,
the strongman general who commanded the Beiyang
army, the only modernized army in northern China,
and sent him into forced retirement.
Yuan had been Sixi's man, and the man the reformers had turned
to in 1898, and the man the court feared.
Zaifeng removed him, and the court believed the danger was gone.
It was not gone. It was waiting, in retirement,
for the empire to need him again.
Within three years, it would,
and the price of his return would be the throne itself.
On the 10th of October 1911, the new army garrison in Wuchang mutinied,
and the mutiny became the Xinhai Revolution.
The soldiers took the city, set up a military government,
and sent telegrams to every province
asking them to follow.
Province after province seceded.
Eighteen provinces in the south and center by the end of December.
The revolution had taken the leaders by surprise.
Sun Yat-sen himself was in the United States,
raising money when it broke out.
But it did not need its leaders.
It had the provinces, and the provinces had stopped obeying Beijing.
By the end of December, eighteen provinces had
declared themselves free of the Qing government.
And the empire that had ruled China since 1644
was shrinking to the capital and the north.
The court, in panic, turned back to the man it had dismissed.
In early November, Yuan Shikai was recalled
from retirement and made prime minister,
and his Beiyang army marched on Wuchang.
It retook Hankou on the 1st of November and Hanyang on the 27th.
And then it stopped.
Yuan was negotiating with the revolutionaries in secret
while his army held its ground.
On the 3rd of November, the National Assembly forced Zhaifeng
to promulgate the 19 Articles of Constitution,
which took the Emperor's power to act by edict away.
The throne was losing its powers before it lost its existence.
Yuan Shikai now held the empire in his hands,
and everyone at court knew it.
On the 22nd of November, he persuaded the court
to give him complete authority over all government matters,
except those of the imperial household.
He had the army, he had the assembly,
and he had the ear of the revolutionaries in the South.
The court had nothing left
but the child on the throne and the woman beside him.
The regent, Zhaifeng, had no answer.
The dowager, Longyu, had no army.
And Yuan had made it clear, without ever saying so outright,
that the price of his protection
was the throne.
On the 6th of December, 1911,
Yuan orchestrated Zhaifeng's resignation as regent, and the
conduct of court affairs fell to the empress dowager, Longyu.
The regency that had run since December of 1908,
first Zhaifeng's, then in the last two months hers,
now rested entirely on a 43-year-old widow
who had never governed anything larger than a household.
She was, by the lists the court kept, the regent of China.
In practice, she was the last person
standing between Yuan Shikai and the throne,
and Yuan Shikai was the last person standing between
the throne and the revolution.
Puyi remembered the moment in his memoir.
One day, in a room of the Mind Nurture Palace,
the Empress Dowager Longyu sat on a kang near
the southern window, wiping the tears
from her eyes with a handkerchief.
In front of her, kneeling on a red carpet,
was a stout old man with tears streaming down
his face, Yuan Shikai.
The child emperor sat beside her, bewildered,
not understanding why these two adults were
crying.
It was the only time Puyi ever met Yuan Shikai,
and the last time Yuan paid his respects to
the dowager.
What frightened Long Yu most, Puyi wrote,
were the words in Yuan's memorial.
The navy had revolted entirely,
the nation was unprotected, and delay in abdication might
lead to a fate like that of Louis XVI
and his family in the French Revolution.
Long Yu called a meeting of the imperial council
so that the royal family could reach a decision.
On the 17th of January, 1912,
a conference of princes met at the palace to discuss the
abdication.
The family, Puyi wrote, was shaken less by the allusion
to Louis XVI than by Yuan's sudden reversal of loyalties.
The man who had posed as the monarchy's defender
was now pressing for its end.
Her father, Zai Feng, said nothing through all the council meetings
and went home afterwards to hug his children.
The decision, in the end, was left to the woman
who had been given the throne to protect,
and she had no army, no money, and no allies left to protect it with.
On the 12th of February, 1912,
the 25th day of the 12th moon, in the third year of the
Xuantong Emperor, Longyu issued three edicts.
The first was the abdication itself, on Puyi's behalf,
transferring the mandate to the people
of the Republic, and giving Yuan Shikai full authority
to form a provisional Republican
government.
The second called on all officials
to keep the peace during the transition.
The third contained the Articles of Favorable Treatment.
The edict was published on the 15th of February.
The child had turned six five days before,
on the 7th of February, and he had been emperor for three
years, two months, and ten days. The terms were these.
Puyi would keep his imperial title for life
and be treated with the honors of a foreign monarch.
The imperial family would keep its
possessions and keep its titles.
It would stay in the Forbidden City for the time being and move
later to the Summer Palace.
It would receive four million silver taels a year. The imperial
imperial mausoleums would be protected and looked after.
And the new government would pay for the Guangxu emperor's funeral
and the construction of his tomb.
It was, by the standards of fallen dynasties, a generous settlement.
The French king Yuan had warned her about had lost his head.
Her family would keep its heads, its home,
and its income, and lose only the throne.
The Qing dynasty, 268 years from 1644, was over.
And with it, more than 2,000 years of emperors came to an end.
On the 1st of January 1912,
the Republic of China had already been proclaimed at Nanjing,
with Sun Yat-sen sworn in as its first president,
and Sun had agreed to give the presidency to Yuan
if Yuan could bring about the abdication.
On the 10th of March, Yuan was sworn in as
provisional president in Beijing.
The abdication edict itself is now kept in the Capital Museum
in Beijing, a single sheet of paper
in which a dowager gave away an empire.
Longyu remained with Puyi in the Forbidden City.
The child was still treated as emperor inside the
palace, by the courtiers and eunuchs
who had never known anything else. A small court,
keeping its ceremonies, inside a republic.
The eunuchs still bowed, the edicts still went out
in the child's name, and the family still lived
as though the throne were only sleeping. But
outside the walls the republic was already governing,
and the Forbidden City had become an island inside it
A year after the abdication, on the 22nd of February, 1913,
She died in the Forbidden City after an illness.
She was 45 years old.
The popular histories say she was consumed by guilt
and depression after signing the abdication,
and that she could not face her ancestors.
The record gives only an illness, and this film will not go beyond it.
She signed the paper, and a year later, she was dead.
At her funeral, the Vice President of the Republic, Li Yuanhong,
praised her as the most excellent among women.
Yuan Shikai, now President of the Republic,
ordered the national flag lowered to half-mast for three days,
and officials to wear mourning for 27 days, and a public memorial
was held in the Hall of Supreme Harmony for three days.
Her coffin was carried by train from the Forbidden City to her tomb.
She was the only Chinese empress whose coffin was transported by train,
and she was buried in the Chong Mausoleum of the Western Qing tombs,
beside the Guangxu Emperor.
She was given the posthumous title Empress Xiao Dingjing.
Two verdicts survive her, and they do not agree.
The popular histories call her ugly and cowardly.
A woman with a wide forehead and swollen eyes,
a wooden look, a cowardly character.
Too plain to be loved, and too weak to rule.
And they blame her for losing the empire.
The republic that took the empire from her praised her at her funeral,
as the most excellent among women,
and mourned her with flags at half-mast.
The first verdict is a later retelling,
written by men who never met her.
The second was spoken at her coffin,
by the men who had taken her throne.
Neither is the whole truth.
The record, as always, is thinner than either.
So what was she?
She was a bride chosen to strengthen a clan,
a wife her husband did not love, a widow at
forty, and a dowager handed a child and a collapsing empire.
She was loyal to the aunt who chose her,
even when that loyalty cost her husband his freedom.
And in the last two months of her public life,
she made the one decision no one else would
make.
She traded the dynasty for the family, the throne for their lives,
their titles, their home, and their income.
It was not a victory. It was not a betrayal.
It was a bargain, the last bargain a dowager could strike
with the only thing she had left to give.
The Chong Mausoleum still stands in the western Qing tombs,
among the hills of Hebei,
where she lies beside the husband who never loved her.
She was born in 1868 and died in 1913,
a girl of 21 who married an emperor.
An empress of 19 years, a dowager of three, and a regent of two months.
She never ruled China.
She never needed to.
In the end, she was given the empire to dispose of.
And she disposed of it.
Not with an army, not with a plot, but with a signature.
On a winter's day, the Forbidden City.
On behalf of a child of six.
That is the empress dowager at the end of an empire,
not the woman who lost the throne.
But the woman who signed it away, and lived just long enough
to be buried beside the man she had signed it for.
