Sauvignon Blanc might be the most commercially successful white grape on the planet, and it still gets treated like a guilty pleasure. One theory floated at this table is that it only gets a bad rap because it's popular, the same way people sneer at Moscato. So we lined up six bottles from three countries, two from each, poured them blind, and set out to find out whether the reputation is deserved or just snobbery.
It did not stay polite. The glasses ran from bright passionfruit and green bell pepper to heavy toasted oak, one that smelled more like sherry than fresh grapes, one that drank closer to Chardonnay, and one compared to purple Nerds candy and rainbow car-wash wax. Fair warning: put the kids to bed, because a few of the tasting notes get very adult. Buying calls swung from zero bottles to a full dozen, and price guesses went anywhere from $17 to $80 and beyond.
Play along. Grab a pen, guess the country, the price and the bottle you'd actually buy before the labels come off, then see how your picks stack up against ours.
Subscribe for more blind tastings where the label never gets a vote.
TIMESTAMPS 00:00 - Introduction! 01:05 - 2024 Dog Point Sauvignon Blanc 02:28 - 2023 Gilbert Sauvignon Blanc 03:54 - 2023 Rippon Sauvignon Blanc 05:20 - 2023 Francois Chidaine Touraine Sauvignon Blanc 07:01 - 2024 Mulline Modewarre Fume Blanc 08:19 - 2023 Francois Cotat Sancerre La Grand Cote 09:54 - Group Chat! 18:12 - Wine Of The Week!
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI Generated
Noah and his guests conduct a blind tasting of Sauvignon Blancs from Australia, France, and New Zealand. The session explores regional style differences, the influence of oak and aging, and the tension between commercial \"cookie-cutter\" profiles and complex, high-end expressions, ultimately determining which region offers the best quality and value.
Ew, that's crazy. That smells so artificial.
Oh man, I saw it already.
Sauvignon Blanc. Yep, very polarizing grape variety.
It's been widely planted in Australia,
of course its home is France,
and New Zealand has become infamous for the variety. So we're
going to try those three countries in a bit of a lineup,
two, two and two, as we've been doing
of late. Welcome to Bottle Shock.
My name is Noah, and just a fair warning here.
Put the kids to bed for this one because it gets a little bit
adult with some of our tasting notes.
It's a little bit cummy.
There's a little bit of cum to that smell.
Like that's true.
We are back for another week of tastings.
Let's see what's on the cards this week.
Sancerre advice for the savvy shopper. My goodness, that's a good one.
We're going around the world, Australia, France, New Zealand.
Part of the merit of blind tasting
is that I used to say that I don't like
Sauv Blanc and then I've tried some that I like and now I've had to
reassess my feelings about it.
Today we find out if that's all bullshit.
Look at it. It looks like Sauvignon Blanc.
Expect this six times over for the most part.
It's not as pungent as I would expect, like all
of these are going to be different sort of references of pungent.
Classic Savvy B smells,
really leaning down that kind of passion fruit pulpy kind of thing.
Far out, that smells like, yeah, hot wood passion fruit sort of energy.
Green bell pepper, it's sitting more in that vegetal aspect,
a little bit of passion fruit.
Wow.
What a great wine to start with.
Ripe, vibrant, Sauvignon Blanc acidity.
Yeah, I don't like that really green, tangy finish on the acidity here.
It's alright. It's perfectly pleasant. It's weird.
I don't know if it's something to do with the oak usage that's in it,
but it's so bitter at front.
Very, very vibrant. Honestly,
this wine gets such a bad rap because I think it's
just popular. I think wine people are technocratic and super nerdy,
and so therefore we all have to subscribe
to disliking the popular thing,
which is fine. I'm still going to go with French.
I'll have one bottle of that.
25 bucks a bottle for that.
38 bucks a bottle and I would buy 12.
I think it's actually like a guzzler.
Like it's a good wine to drink.
I'm going to say this is from New Zealand.
I'll grab one bottle if it is $23.
I just don't need this wine.
All right, we're really turning up the degree of oak here as well.
It's not like oaky, but there's just
a lot more stuffing going on in this wine.
Oh, yum.
Okay, good use of oak here.
This is what I'm also really enjoying, oak use in Sauvignon Blanc.
I think it just rounds out texturally.
It has this like lovely kind of light-bodied feel to the wine,
but then it's like slippery textural finish I really love.
If I was guessing, this would be like
in a Gewurztraminer sort of lychee kind of space
in terms of what the nose is giving me.
This could be a ringer for French.
I mean, look, I would be surprised if this is not French. And
if it is not French, I want to know. I want to buy you.
I want to drink you. Absolutely delicious.
Mineral. Great little oaky frame here. Great drive.
Upfront fruit sweetness. Actually reminds
me of New Zealand done really well.
Like this reminds me of a Fumé Blanc style. It's pretty
good. Yeah. It has the very sort of fruity nose, which I'm about.
Compared to the first one, I'm much happier drinking this.
I'll have three bottles of it.
I would pay more for it.
I think that a $35 investment into that wouldn't go astray.
Like underripe pineapple, that passion fruit character's there.
There's a nice like stone fruit richness.
There's that nice vanilla, almost like a custard kind of feel.
I think this is sunset.
I will happily grab 12 of this.
I'd happily pay 80 bucks.
I'd go around about 40 bucks and I'd buy six to 12.
I could be convinced.
Ew.
Immediately I'm not enjoying the smell of this yet.
Wow, okay, there's a bit going on here.
I think it's seen some age, there's some bottle age here.
A little bit more oxidative.
Yeah, like sherry fortified thing to it
that the other two didn't quite have.
It smells more like wine that's been made from sultanas
than it does wine that's been made from fresh grapes.
Yeah, there's a stink, like dried fish character, it's like bataga.
It seems to be very intentional, I don't think it's a mistake.
Oh yeah, that's the sort of Sauvignon Blanc
that's made me go hang on a minute,
I've been lying. Wow, really well made wine.
Just starting to go over the edge of being too
too old to appreciate primary fruit
but too young to really showcase tertiary development.
There's a nice savoury edge on the palate though.
It actually tastes really good.
Like it's got a nice leesy character too.
I'm not overly stoked on this.
I'd give two bottles.
It was like 40 bucks.
This is in that sort of teenage phase, I guess.
For that reason, I'd probably pay a little bit less
for it like 35 bucks and I'd buy three.
I have a dozen of that.
I would happily pay 40 bucks a bottle for it.
I think it's from New Zealand
and it's gonna be really, really embarrassing.
If this is like the straight up
and down NZ style that I always talk about not liking
and then put in these circumstances and taste it blind,
I like it more than the other two.
All right wine number four.
All right so look a lot of lees work here. So there's definitely
this sort of impact of yeast this sort of autolysis
and all sorts of other stuff going on.
Smells more grown up when we're doing a bracket like
this where it's like Australia, New Zealand
and then France and France is the old world country
and I just smell something that's kind
of like woofy and I'm like that's got to be from the old world.
Kind of orangey like ripe peach
apricotty kind of character this is cool.
Now we're getting to the style of Sauvignon Blanc that I like.
Especially in terms of complexity.
When Sauvignon Blanc starts to push towards something that would
make you go, is that Sauvignon Blanc or is that Chenin Blanc?
I think that's where we're sort of
in this nice little sweet spot. Oh yum! Oh yum!
Orangey, tropical, textural. Relying less on the
grape variety and thinking more about the style
of wine that's being made from that grape. So
It doesn't taste exactly like Chardonnay
but to me it's in that category and I like those
sorts of wines so this is like the tick.
This is the style of Sauv Blanc that I'm looking for if
I want something that's got a little bit more money
and time put behind it in the winery.
A little bit of creaminess.
I'll have another dozen of that and I think that that is now a
$60 bottle of Sauv Blanc and I would probably go to around about $50.
$5, maybe even $60 a bottle for this,
and I would buy twelve.
It reminds me of very good Loire,
but in a ripe year.
Delicious, $12.
Give me $12.
I'm happy to pay another $75 here.
This is awesome.
**** yeah, I want some fish and chips right now.
Absolute mix-up
on this one.
This is pretty straight up and down fumé blanc.
It smells like a smokestack.
Oh yeah, this has got this green peppercorn,
classic New Zealand kind of thing going on.
It reminds me of an old wooden boat somehow,
like handmade wooden boat.
It's really...
Toasty. It is really quite peppery.
I really don't like that. Something about it that's like
tomatoey as well. Look, I think this is Australian.
There is a bitterness on the back palate. Because
Australia is so hot and warm,
Sauvignon Blanc gets ripe really quickly in terms of sugar content.
This is a seafood wine for sure.
It would go really well with seafood, but like drinking it
without the seafood, I don't like how it tastes sort of thing.
That jalapeno character is just dominating on the palate
and it's kind of bitter and spicy and I
don't like drinking it. Zero bottles.
I really don't like this like I think it should be like
$17. I just don't like this wine.
So for that reason six bottles. I mean if I'm buying a nice
bottle of wine to have with dinner
and blah blah blah it's sort of like that $50 mark is what I'm
sort of looking to spend. So I'd only buy one bottle of this.
I'm not a big fan. I would like
to know what the market is for this but it doesn't really appeal to me.
Now one number six. Let's end
And on a strong note here, come on.
Ooh, savoury.
****, that's crazy.
That smells so artificial.
That's fun, huh?
That's really fun.
Chemically, but I really like the smell.
That's one of those smells that's like,
damn, it's not what you'd expect a wine to smell like.
Like purple nerds.
Like fake grape.
This is immediately reminding me of Sancerre.
This is immediately giving me like Francois Cotat vibes.
Yeah, this is like the most vape-like of all of these wines.
And I think vapes, I've heard that vapes taste quite yum.
Dad watches these.
Has...
Stuff in it that would make me say it was French
and it could well be.
I love that laziness.
Tangy lime juice characters.
I think it's a really good pair.
I'd love this with food.
I think this is just such a classic Sancerre vibe.
And it is a really interesting smell.
I don't think it's an offensive smell.
I think it's a great wine.
Commercially viable, yummy,
and I'll pay like 28 bucks a bottle for it
and I'd buy one.
Honestly, I'm sure someone like Henry,
this is like totally his bag
because like what an amazing smell.
But it's kind of good.
I'll have one bottle of it and I reckon it's 20 bucks a bottle
or if it's really expensive that's
hell funny. I really love this. 12.
I think this is Kouta and I think this is going to be like 160
bucks and I really like it.
I'm pretty sure wine number two and wine number four are my favorite
maybe even wine number one to be honest.
Let's see what the other guys think. Alrighty.
Sauvignon Blanc,
a variety that I think has a bit of a stigma around it now,
despite it being probably the most commercially
successful grape varieties in the world.
Dude, keeps the lights turned on, staff bills paid.
Yeah, not here, not here at all,
but it's a short and swift down the road, 100% yes.
It's like, they look at it as like, hey,
this is the way we fuel the fun stuff that we do.
So it feels like it's got the reputation
that Moscato had as well as being like,
oh, you like Moscato, oh, you like Sauvignon, whereas now I'm like,
**** yeah, I like Moscato.
I'm not convinced that I like Sauvignon Blanc yet.
Yeah.
I...
I'm becoming so much more enamoured
with Sauvignon Blanc as time goes on, actually.
I'm actually re-approaching the variety and just going,
this is actually delicious.
I love the weight and the almost watery, slippery texture that it has.
Definitely does that.
Heaps of acid, can be really aromatic.
I think it works really well with oak.
I think it's just a delicious.
Great.
Oh, you got a dozen of this.
I got a dozen of this.
One at once, awesome dude.
I, there is absolutely nothing wrong with this.
There is like, it is completely inoffensive.
It's exactly that cookie cutter, you know, style.
Look, if I'm paying 60 bucks a bottle for it,
I'm probably gonna be a bit annoyed,
but like at 30 bucks, 12 bottles.
I'm going to serve that up to my mom.
She's going to be very happy.
I think there's enough of a joyous,
I guess, passion-fruity, pineappley,
orange juice kind of tang to the wine that makes it agreeable.
I just don't need it in my life.
I just will never...
Like, go to a bottle shop and buy that.
First time I, like, so tasting it again now, that all makes sense.
First time I looked at it, the passion fruit is so intense on the nose
that I thought it was, like, hot oak.
Yeah.
Like, I thought it was, like, what the ****?
I said French, too much oak for me, which I don't think it has now,
but it's got a super intense nose.
I was one for 25.
I was one for 23.
Dude, 12 for 30.
Any stabs at place?
I went New Zealand for this.
I went New Zealand as well.
Yeah, I went French because I thought it was old oak.
Brodie, what do we got?
Oh, it's dog point!
Sauvignon Blanc from New Zealand, Marlborough Sauvignon Blanc,
but this is as good as that style gets.
This style can get really bad, but for $27,
I think that's pretty well priced.
Dog Point is probably New Zealand's greatest
Sauvignon Blanc producer, I'd say.
This is looking a lot leaner than I've seen in typical.
Well, this isn't, this isn't the barrel of fumé style.
This is like, that's the, it's like section 44 or something.
That's a bit more premium and that's ******* awesome.
Donate it.
I'm not in a rush to pick that up.
I'm going to rush to pick up this next wine, though.
I love this.
I could be convinced.
I had 6 to 12 on this.
This is my wine on the line-up.
I love it.
Interesting.
I absolutely love this wine.
I would have guessed that was like a muscat variety based on the nose.
I do like the nose a lot.
Cool, huh?
Texture, man.
That's what I'm loving about 70 bucks, the way that feels in my mouth.
I agree with Noah.
This is my second favorite of the entire line-up.
Awesome.
$40.
I was at $12, but I'm happy to pay $80.
I was $3 for $35.
I thought it was from Australia.
I went sunset.
I went kiwi.
We are in Australia, this is Gilbert Sauvignon Blanc from Orange,
this is 30 bucks, that's delicious.
That's 30 bucks? Jesus. That's awesome.
Well done Gilbert. This is the joy of Sauvignon Blanc,
people are kind of sketchy about it,
like growers are still charging a really approachable price
and people are doing stuff like this to it,
making it really tasty. I love that. That's
such a good wine. We're back to the bipolar thing,
I don't particularly enjoy this as well.
This is either like bottle age or sealed under cork
and the cork's maybe not great.
This is where it picked up for me.
Oh!
This is where I'm like, that's probably French, I'm sorry.
I was 35 and 3, I just, I found it a little tired.
It's missing that sort of like poignant sort of thing
that Sauvignon Blanc does like really well, that punchiness.
I thought it was New Zealand, I thought I'd get
a dozen of it and I'd spend 40 bucks a bottle.
It was 2 for 40.
3 for 35 in French.
And you think French.
I was in Oz here.
We're back in New Zealand.
This is a Rippon Sauvignon Blanc.
50 bucks, 50 bones from Otago.
Kind of paying the Rippon tax here,
but we're soaked on skins, two days on skins,
then on lees wild ferment in tank and old oak.
I feel good about that.
Yeah, I'm good about that wine.
Fair enough.
I get that.
I think it's cool, but I just don't need it for 50 bucks to be perfect.
Nah, sorry.
We're back, though.
We are back.
We are back.
This is my wine of the line-up.
This ----'s on wine number one.
I am more than happy to go with you guys.
This is delicious.
This is a very, very good wine.
This is everything that I want,
which is getting it as close to Chenin Blanc as possible.
Yeah, pretty much.
Just give it that glossiness.
Give it that richness.
Oh, so bloody tasty.
Yeah, to me, that's a wine that if you put it in front of me,
it falls into the good
Of course.
Of what it sort of feels and tastes like.
That lick of like vanilla there is just perfection.
And restrained like it's not over the top.
Everything's just.
That's lovely.
Yeah.
All day.
Very confident here.
All right, French shits on wine number one.
I'll get a dozen of it for 60 bucks.
12 for 75.
12 for 55 in French.
Here we go.
Yeah.
It's $150.
Touraine Frenchie for $35 buckaroos.
That is delicious.
That rules.
That is excellent.
Come on, man.
Just come on, man.
That's that.
$35.
See, there's bargains to be had.
That's a good wine for $35.
Such a good wine.
You could drink.
You could pay a lot more money
and drink wines that don't taste as good as that from France.
100%.
Especially from, yeah, exactly.
There's an import.
That's just such a good value.
That's actually a wine I would consider having at a bottle shop.
I can't even.
I bring myself to admit that a Sauvignon Blanc should absolutely be...
No, but that would confuse the hell out of people.
People wouldn't call that Sauvignon Blanc.
It's delicious.
Now, we are not back anymore.
This wine sucks.
I hate it.
This is a seafood wine, man.
This would be nice with seafood,
but I agree that there's no way that I would drink it.
This is a lot of toasty oaks.
That said, six for 50.
Be cool with fish.
None for 17.
One for 25.
Man, sorry guys.
Was it Australia?
Sorry, yeah.
This is Mulline.
I got that right.
This is...
I'm sorry.
Sorry, Ben and Ben.
I'm sorry.
I love your wines.
Not just this one.
I'm really sorry.
Yeah, just that jalapeno thing was just not doing it for me.
I just don't like that.
Text
Texturally, it's nice, but yeah, I just don't want to drink it.
We love you.
You'd be sick with fish.
I still got six of them.
I'm about it.
And to finish off, we're back as well.
This sucks.
Oh, yeah.
No, I didn't like it.
Nah, this was...
You were like all about it.
Yeah, it's Cotat, bro.
You reckon it's Cotat?
It's Francois Cotat.
Like, the only time I've seen
Sauvignon Blanc look like this is Cotat.
It's that lazy, nutty, savoury thing.
Literally slippery texture.
Oh, I'm all about it.
It smells like the splatter wax
that you can use at car wash.
It's the one that's all rainbow colour.
It's a little bit cummy.
There's a little bit of cum to that smell.
Like, that's true.
It's true.
Be an adult about it.
It's a normal part of life.
Grow up.
It smells a little bit like cum.
Not exactly, but like a little bit.
Yeah, I don't recognise it as a quality wine.
Neither.
Me neither.
One for 20 bucks.
I thought it was from New Zealand.
I thought it was Marlborough.
I thought this was that.
12 for 160.
Wow.
You've called Cotat before.
He's familiar with the smell.
He knows.
He knows it really well.
So it's going to be that way.
Francois Cotat, La Grande Cote, 169 buckaroos.
One of the most hyped producers in all of Sancerre.
I wonder why.
------- French bullshit is what that is.
I'm all about it.
That's me.
That's mine.
Yummy.
It's so weird.
Like, it's such a weird wine.
Are we on that Touraine from wine line-up?
Touraine from wine line-up.
That was awesome.
The French know what they're doing.
Yeah, that's really good.
I also really loved that Sauvignon Blanc too.
I think that was really, really good.
Total mention.
Yeah, France wins Sauvignon Blanc.
We're all still learning.
We'll get there one day.
But until next time, see you then.