The Wine Grape DNA Detective - Part 1 - Jane Anson The Wine Podcast E33

Wine Regions Revealed
5 followers
1 Video View·Nov 10, 2026
WINE-SEARCHER PRO 🍷
✨ Get 10% off a 12-month Wine-Searcher PRO subscription with the code ‘JaneWS’ at checkout. 👇
https://www.wine-searcher.com/get-pro... …
AI Generated·May contain errors
So we think that humans have domesticated grapes
for alcohol and not for food.
And as you know, around the berries, on the berry skin,
there exist yeasts responsible for fermentation.
Saccharomyces cerevisiae is naturally present.
So we think that it was starting to ferment.
And before it turned to vinegar, they have tried it,
get a little bit drunk, and they said, wow, we want to start again.
It's linked to inebriation.
Welcome to the Wine Podcast.
I'm Suzanne Mustacich and my guest today is the Swiss botanist and
grape DNA sleuth, José Villamont. Welcome, José.
Thank you for having me. So I had read recently
that you had been in Turkey,
which is where we first met all those years ago.
So let's start with your recent adventures.
What were you doing in the Taurus Mountains?
What were you looking for?
Well, it's true that we first met in Izmir, you and I,
at this fantastic digital wine communication conference,
which was really a founder event because many of my wine friends today
were met in 2012.
So it was a fantastic event.
And this is also where I met one of my favorite producers in Turkey,
not the one in Taurus, another one.
Seyit Karagazolu of Pasheli Wines.
We went to Thrace, northeastern of Turkey, in the European part,
where he found a lot of fantastic grapes.
One of those is Citalan, very interesting, the white wine.
And another one, we will talk about that later, is Colocco.
And I wanted to see where it had been found.
So that was my first part of the trip.
And then I went to.
Cappadocia to visit.
Which I love, it's so beautiful.
Fantastic.
To visit the area, I'm a fan of ungrafted vines,
Franc de Pied, in French.
I'm a member of the Association Franc de Pied,
founded in 21 by Loïc Pasquet.
I'm a member of the committee,
and our honorary president is no less than Prince Albert II of Monaco.
So, yeah, yes, it is.
And how did he become interested
in vines being planted directly in the soil
as opposed to grafted?
He's very much interested into wine and he's a customer of Loic Pasquet
because Loic Pasquet, as you may know, is the founder
and owner of Liba Pata, making the most expensive wine in the world.
So the Prince is a customer.
So they had a chance to talk and I have a chance
to know Loic not because I'm a customer of his wine.
Impossible for me, but because he's very fond of ungrafted vineyards.
And I was with Loic
and a group of friends from this association in Cappadocia.
We visited many wineries, Gelberi, for example, by Udo Hirsch,
who is rescuing old varieties
in villages where people don't know what they have in the vineyard.
We were with Cava Clidere, which is a much bigger company,
one of the biggest, one of the largest in the country,
who are also replanting varieties ungrafted.
And last part of the trip, I went to the Taurus Mountain together
with Burak Özkan, who created Lykia Wines, not far from Antalya.
And he's fascinated with old vines that are lost
in the mountain that have been maintained by local people as...
Table grapes, but as we are convinced, used to be wine grapes before.
um islamization of the area
so together with him we went grape hunting which means we are we are
trying to find the location where these old vines are still used
and they use it they use it as
married vines which means they have
been on purpose planted next to a tree so that the vine
naturally climbs up the tree and then people go climb
and and harvest the the grapes before to
to make wine today.
to eat them or to make a kind of molasses called Petsmek.
So we found a lot of interesting things
and this guy of Lykia Wines likes to come back
at harvest time, taste the grapes,
measure the acidity, measure the sugar and try to
identify which one is best suited for wine making.
And he already...
He has three or four wines in his portfolio made
from vines found in the nature.
I mean that's extraordinary.
I just have a question because we talk about domestication,
we'll get to that later, but isn't
this essentially how domestication we think started?
Is that people were growing
or where they're picking wild grapes and then they decided
that some are better than others
and then they maybe took a cutting or replanted? Do you think
that that's how it worked?
What we observed today in Taurus Mountain is not this because
The vines are superb, are very old.
Big trunks, they are like trees, but they are maybe 200, 300 years old.
Domestication occurred 10,000 to 12,000 years ago,
so it's a much longer time.
And together with Patrick McGovern,
late Patrick McGovern, who left us last year at age 80,
we went a few times together in the Middle East.
We went to Turkey, we went to Armenia, Georgia,
together to try to understand the domestication.
And we are.
I came up with the idea of the hermaphroditic hypothesis.
Because if you look at the flowers of a grape that is cultivated,
in each of the tiny flowers, you don't need a lens, you see it.
In each of the tiny flowers,
you see the stamen with the pollen and the pistil.
And the pollen goes on the pistil,
fertilization, babies, babies, I mean, berries.
There it is.
are formed and the babies are the grape seeds, the grape pips.
Okay.
If you look at a wild vine, Vitis sylvestris,
you have flowers that are 100% male and flowers that are 100% female.
And we have observed, together with Patrick McGovern
and other botanists have observed, in a natural population.
We found one really spectacular at the headwaters of the Tigris River.
We found it in 2003.
And I remember clearly, we were looking at the flowers,
it was the right time, and Patrick was 100 meters.
Patrick, Patrick, I have found one, I have found one.
And I had one vine of wild grapes that was hermaphroditic,
both male and female.
And this hypothesis that I made up is very simple.
If you are a Neolithic man or woman,
and you like to harvest the grape or to eat them,
and you want to plant it, to take cuttings,
taking cuttings has been done since ages.
You plant it in front of your cave or your whatever.
If you take a male, you will never have berries.
If you take a female and there's no male around, never have berries.
If you take, by chance, a hermaphroditic plant,
you have berries and you will want to keep this one.
So you will take cuttings or multiply from this one.
And this is the starting point of domestication.
It might have occurred.
It has occurred several times in different locations on the planet.
Do you think they observe the ones that
are making the grapes that they like?
Well, our hypothesis, the other one,
is the Noah hypothesis, and it's linked to inebriation.
Because if you look at the wild vine, it's growing up the trees,
it's very dangerous to climb and harvest it.
In the Taurus mountain, they are still doing it for molasses,
and some people have been seriously injured,
or even some of them have died.
So it's very dangerous.
You need to be very quick because you need
to get to the berries before the birds.
And the food supply is not really good.
You have a little bit of sugar, but wild grape vines,
we will talk about that, are very acidic.
The bunches are very loose.
There's not so much to eat.
But if you harvest them and you have harvested them in enough quantity
to put them in a crevice or in a wooden basket,
with the weight of the bunches, the juice would exude from the berries.
And as you know, around the berries, on the berry skin,
there exist yeasts responsible for fermentation.
Saccharomyces cerevisiae is naturally present,
so we think that it was starting to ferment
and before it turned to vinegar,
they have tried it, get a little bit drunk and they
said, wow, we want to start again.
Or they say, I have an illumination, I can speak to the spirits,
I can speak to the dead, and it becomes a ritual.
Maybe the second...
Maybe it happened that way.
Maybe it happened that way.
So we think that humans have domesticated grapes for alcohol
and not for food.
So you don't think that this was a selection for food
and some were better for food and some were better for wine?
No.
Initially, no.
Our hypothesis is for alcohol.
Then when they had a chance to domesticate it for different purposes,
they have selected.
By generation to generation, it's empirical selection.
They have discarded the ones that were too acidic
and favored the ones that were more sweet,
the ones with bigger bunches, bigger berries.
And this is the starting point of domestication.
Together with Patrick McGovern,
we had tried to identify where this happened.
23 years ago, and we published a paper saying
that it most likely happened for the first time
in southeastern Anatolia, southeastern Turkey,
close to Kurdistan, where I think you've been.
I've been there, yeah.
And this was our conclusion, but we had a few hundreds of samples,
and this was the best we could do.
Compared, genetically speaking,
I compared the wild grape vines with the cultivated.
Varieties, the most ancient ones, and Patrick was investigating
the archaeological sites of the area to see if we had found.
residues of wine in the in the jars
and in the archaeological artifacts. So that's what we did.
In 23, so 20 years later, a huge study was published,
I think, in Nature magazine,
run by Chinese people, surprisingly, but with,
I think, 134 authors, 2,300 something samples.
It was much bigger.
They had much more money than we did 20 years ago. And
Their conclusion by genetics,
they confirmed our first hypothesis that a domestication occurred
in southeastern Turkey, but also another one in Transcaucasia,
which is Armenia and Georgia.
And then they compared the roots,
and which is fascinating, the one that was domesticated in
Transcaucasia went through the northern part
of the Mediterranean to the Black Sea.
I mean, the generations reached...
The western part of the Balkans, Romania,
Bulgaria, a little bit of Hungary.
But then it stopped.
Genetically speaking, you cannot follow it.
And the one from southeastern Turkey gave table grapes
that you find in the Levant,
table grapes that you find in North Africa up to Morocco,
and also wine grapes that crossed Turkey, Greece.
Dalmatian coast, Italy, another route, France, Spain, and that's it.
So are they following trade routes, do you think?
Of course, which is fascinating
because if you look at the map of this study.
It's based on genetics,
but if you look at the trade routes of the Phoenicians starting
from Lebanon and colonizing all the Mediterranean,
from the Greeks who have founded Marseille,
for example, and all the routes
of colonization follow the genetic path.
So people are taking, when they're going on a ship or they're going
over mountains to go either to trade or maybe they're moving,
they're taking some of the plant material with them.
Yes. What we don't know,
and we will speak about a very recent research, what we don't know
is whether they were carrying grape seeds or cuttings.
And there's a big difference.
As I said, multiplying plants by cuttings has been known since three
or four thousand years.
Yes, we have.
We have stone drawing evidence of this knowledge,
not for grapevines but for other plants.
When you multiply your strawberries or your tomatoes, you do the same.
We don't know if they
were carrying the vine itself or the pips.
It makes a big difference because if you plant
If you have a Merlot in your house,
you take a seed of Merlot, you plant it, you will have
a plant growing, it will not be Merlot anymore.
It will be a child of Merlot.
It will be the next generation.
If you do it with wheat, for example,
the genetic of wheat is so narrow in terms of
diversity.
We say homozygosity in genetics, that you don't see the difference.
But grapes are very diverse.
We say heterozygous, just like us.
And I always say, let's imagine that I could get pregnant from myself
and I would grow my own baby and deliver the baby.
It would be surely a monster, but it would not be me.
It will be a new generation.
And you lose the qualities.
So if you want to keep the qualities of your Merlot
or the qualities of your Pinot,
you need to go through cuttings.
And I would like to know exactly when it started.
There is this recent ancient DNA research showing
by analyzing grape pips from France.
I think it's really interesting
because it just means that at some point,
what you're saying is somebody understood
that it was better to take a cutting
than to use the seed, the pip.
Yeah.
Again, there's extraordinary knowledge,
and that's what I was thinking of when you were talking about this
modern Turkish wine grower trying out with testing different grapes.
That same process is what was done thousands of years ago.
Probably, and I can imagine it.
If you plant, you have your favorite vine.
The wild grape vine is red-berried.
So let's say you have a red-berried vine, you want to keep it.
And you plant a seed, and the new plant is white-berried.
You're not happy with that.
You want to get back to the red one.
So the white grape is a mutation?
It is, yes.
So, yeah, it happened that way.
So varieties were selected for their capacities,
for their characteristics.
And at one point, we realized that it
was better to propagate them with cuttings.
It's en primeur season right now.
And this episode is brought to you by Ideal Wine,
specialists in fine wine and auctions.
They're based in France with over 25 years experience shipping
the finest Bordeaux all
around the world, including the US, the UK,
and all over Europe, as well as Hong Kong,
Singapore, Korea, and more.
And international clients can enjoy six months
of complimentary storage in France
for all en primeur purchases over €3,000
so you can ship when it suits best.
Ideal Wine have kindly given a special discount
that is only available for Jane Anson podcast
listeners. You can enjoy 50 euros off your first
en primeur purchase just by using the code
Jane Anson. And do sign up for the website to receive alerts
when the wine you want is released
and enjoy personalized advice from their very experienced team.
There's more information and
some terms and conditions in the show notes below.
So let's get on with the podcast. Absolutely.
Thank you, Ideal Wine.
Okay, so talk to me just about Kalorko,
which is identical to ferment in Hungary.
So that means this grape variety from Turkey
made its way to Hungary, and were they then...
I think it happened the other way around.
I think it came from Hungary, it came from Tokaj to Turkey.
It came the other way.
Yes, of course.
Of course, because I think it's rather recent.
We're not talking about 10,000 years ago.
We're speaking about 300 years ago.
And the discovery started with Seyit Karagazulu of Pashaley Wines,
who made me try his Colorco wine in 2012 in Izmira.
And I said, wow, that's fantastic.
And every year I got one or two bottles of it.
And it reminded you of something that you tasted in Hungary?
No, not at all.
No, no, no.
It's not possible.
You have no hint.
And your brain will never say, oh, this looks like Furmint.
And then they are very different for other reasons.
But at some point, I said, Seyit,
We need to know what this Colorco is.
And also you see the land and other Chalkarase, et cetera.
So send me the leaves and I will do the DNA profiling, which I did.
And at first, I thought it was a mistake in my lab.
But it couldn't be a mistake because during this DNA session,
I had no Furmint in the lab.
But anyway, Colorco matched Furmint.
2017, when I said, we need to start again next year,
take another sample, we had to go back to the old vineyard.
It's almost impossible, take another sample,
another sample, same, 100% Furmint with the DNA.
So we started to think, how could this happen? How could this happen?
It's been cultivated in this area since at least the beginning
of the 19th century, 20th century, almost abandoned in the 60s.
and rescued by Seyit in 2005.
So this Kolorko was an old supposedly local variety on the brink of
extinction when Seyit rescued it.
So we contacted Istvan Szepsy Junior who is one of the most
famous winemakers and the son of the most famous winemaker in Tokaj,
Istvan Szepsy Senior.
To try to understand, and he gave us an idea,
we had to look at Francis Lakocsi who was
Thank
prince and the general of the army
who was trying to defeat the Habsburg and defending Tokay area,
and his family was the biggest
vineyard owner in Tokay. And when he lost against the Habsburg,
he had to flee from Tokaj and he had
to.
already connections with the Ottomans.
So he ended up in Tekirda. Tekirda is not far from
Istanbul, two hours from Istanbul and in the western direction.
And it used to have a Hungarian name, Rodosto.
That's interesting.
So it had a Hungarian population.
So there is no document,
but we are convinced that this guy had to run away from Tokaj.
I think he first went to France, then to some other place,
and ended up in Tekirda, where he stayed for 18 years.
So I don't think he traveled in all these different regions with vines,
but he had contacts in his homeland, Tokaj.
And he probably...
Sent a letter, bring me some cuttings of Furmint,
and he planted it there.
This is the story, but we have
no idea why they gave it the name Kolorko.
Does that word mean anything else?
Is it like a root for something else?
No.
No, they don't know.
So we'll never know.
Maybe it was the name of a friend of his or something,
or maybe who knows what it was.
Yeah.
It could be the name of a guy.
It could be...
The name of a place?
We've forgotten the name now?
Yeah.
Or somebody who had a mispronunciation
of something that was written down.
And so Furmint, I'm convinced that it does originate from Tokay
because the genetic diversity within
the grape is very important in Tokay
and non-existent in Turkey.
And also in Tokay, you have color mutations.
There is a pink version of Furmint that does not exist in Turkey.
So when you have...
Biodiversity that is important in any organism usually
is the place where it originates.
Let's talk a minute about France.
You've written a book about French varieties.
You're the co-author of The Groundbreaking Wine Grapes
with Julia Harding and Jancis Robinson.
Now, in France, researchers have recently
analyzed 54 archaeological grape seeds from
sites across France going back to 2300 BC to the Middle Ages.
And they came up with some interesting discoveries,
one of them with the Pinot Noir.
So what was your thoughts?
Well, I love that kind of studies.
I'm really sad to not be part of it anymore.
I tried again with Patrick McGovern in 2003.
He gave me grape seeds from Armenia dated 2200 B.C.
So they were 4,200 years old.
And I think he had six and he gave me two.
I took to the lab, brand new lab, because you want
to avoid contamination because there's a little amount of DNA.
I tried my best more than 20 years ago,
and I could not extract enough DNA from that.
So I'm very happy that some people managed to do so at the moment.
The technique that we have today is much more efficient
and precise than what we were doing 23 years ago.
And these people from France analysed these grape pips and you need
to be lucky because these grape pips need to have been preserved.
A waterlogged, as we say,
in a humid environment, if possible, underwater.
If your grape pips were eaten
and then thrown in a fire and carbonized,
they will keep their shape, but the DNA is completely gone.
So they were lucky to find enough grape seeds that were well-preserved.
And their finding was really fascinating because they had evidence.
Of the use of wild grape vines,
2,000 or 3,000 BC they were already using wild grape vine,
which is not a big surprise.
Domesticated varieties appeared during the Iron Age,
800 to 600 BC, and then
also they were able to find different grape pips having the same DNA
at different periods, which was evidence that they had
been propagated vegetatively by cuttings.
And I think the oldest evidence for cuttings is 600 BC.
I don't have all the numbers in my head.
You can find the original paper in Nature.
And what is for sure, they found in Valenciennes, north of France.
They found a grape pip that is 100% identical to Pinot Noir,
dating back to 600 years.
Isn't that extraordinary, though?
It is extraordinary. It is absolutely fascinating.
It shows that Pinot Noir has been cultivated at least since 600 years
and has been propagated vegetatively.
I think it's much older than that.
Maybe it's 2,000 years old, but we have no evidence.
I was going to ask you about ancient clonal propagation
and the movement of grapes across vast regions,
mountain regions, the sea.
Obviously, it goes with colonizers, it goes with trade.
But what do you think this tells us about us as humans
and our connection to wine?
So, as I said, we believe that the first reason
for domestication was alcohol.
But then, in regions like Turkey, today,
this molasses, pekmez, is bringing me, it's,
It's more, it's sweeter than honey.
So it brings energy.
It brings food.
So then it becomes like calories, perhaps.
When you're starving during the winter,
if you have pekmez, it might help you survive.
So maybe it was a way of communicating
with the spirits or with the dead or whatever,
but also a way of surviving in the winter.
And they are still preparing these molasses
or they're preparing long branches of...
That's
the end of
part one.
We'll see you back here for part two.
This podcast is produced in partnership with Wine Voices,
brought to you by Wine Searcher,
the world's largest online wine and spirits database.
With WineSearcher Pro, you can see all the search results,
guaranteeing the lowest prices,
and you can unlock powerful tools to search,
compare, and discover more about the wines that
you want. And right now,
you can get a 10% off a 12-month pro subscription with the code
JaneWS at checkout. That's JaneWS.
It's just a little thank you for being part of our Wine
Voices community and for tuning in here.
Follow the link in the description to begin your journey
with WineSearcher.
And thank you.
Please come back for the next podcast.
That's right.
See you then.
