Can you build an everyday carry kit at a thrift store? Absolutely. But is it actually worth it? I visited two thrift stores and put together an EDC kit to see how the prices, tool condition, and selection stacked up.
Finding enough gear was fairly easy. The bigger question was whether I was getting good value—or paying close to new-tool prices for somebody else’s used tools.
Thrift shopping means working with whatever happens to be on the shelf. Depending on what you find, stores like Walmart, Lowe’s, or Dollar Tree may offer new alternatives at similar prices, with more predictable selection. Secondhand doesn’t automatically mean cheaper, and a bargain isn’t always the best tool for the job.
This is one experiment, not a final verdict on every thrift store. Your local shops, prices, and finds could be completely different.
There’s also another way to approach it: build a starting kit, then improve it over time. Keep the useful finds, replace weaker pieces, and see what repeated trips turn up. That could become a great kit—or an ongoing project that’s never quite finished. The question is how much time and money you want to put into getting there.
In this video, I walk through what I found, what I spent, and the tradeoffs behind building an EDC kit from secondhand gear.
Would you build a whole kit from thrift-store finds, or just shop for a few worthwhile pieces?
We are back with another review
and today we're going to be doing a cool little thing
kind of part of the retail series but side adjacent.
So without further ado let's hop
right to this review because today we're going
to be checking out not if you can build an EDC kit
at a thrift store but if it's economically feasible
or if it's just worth it at all.
So let's see what we ended up going with.
I had to go to two stores so keep that in mind.
Thank
You might not find everything in one trip
at the first store that you go to, so that might be a
barrier to entry for this whole thing from the beginning.
you
So that being said, I got the case.
and i got one item inside at one thrift store
very
and i got the rest at another
so i got all the price breakdown too
so that's really part of the experiment
right to figure out how much it costs
much.
this is the vessel we went with i got this case logic
i assume this is some kind of camera case from the 90s maybe like um
it might even hold like your your front part for the camera
or accessories or maybe just your
digital camera itself but it's like uh it's like a pull-out module
and it has like some kind of
shoulder straps here so kind
of cool 90s you know case logic something you'd buy at best buy in the
90s um i don't think that's like reflective
or anything like that it's got two outer you
know pouches it's got a little little zipper one in the front
and the larger main compartment
So let's check out what I ended up putting in here
which happens to be the one that I got
with this pouch. So this is the knife
that we ended up going with from the Franklin Mint.
It's just a knife. I got this out of the case.
This was $10. It's just a folder knife. It's got
the 57 Bel Air. I got this and the case at a Goodwill
and I've been sitting on it for a little
It's been a little while now going, I need to make a video with this.
So what I ended up doing was I went out
and I got everything that's inside the case.
So I was like, let's see if we can make an actual kit at a thrift store
or thrift stores
and see if it's actually worth it.
So that's how this kind of evolved, if that makes sense.
So the two things you see on the table right now were got together.
And then everything else from here
on out was got at another thrift store.
But it was Goodwill.
So it was the same franchise, if you will.
So here's the scatter pattern.
Boom. Everything that I ended up getting at the Goodwill.
So here it is. Let's start off,
I guess, I don't know, we'll start off on top here.
So I ended up grabbing this
Petzl little headlamp here. It's an, what is it?
Not iridescent. Not halogen. I forget.
I forgot the name of the old style bulbs,
but that's what that is right there.
um
And it turns like that to just turn it on and turn it off.
Pretty simple stuff.
Probably like from the 80s or early 90s.
It even comes with an extra bulb.
Now, I ended up using tools in this kit
to take off the headlamp strap, because I was
just using it as a flashlight for the kit,
you.
not necessarily carrying around a headlamp
everywhere I go that's like, you know,
ready for climbing, you know what I mean?
There's the screw that basically is the hinge
that connects this together so that you have
this, so I just took this off.
It's like IP6 rated, I think it is.
It says it somewhere around here.
Um, and it's got, you know, put some batteries in there.
Like I said, it's, uh, it's got a nice steel on the top here
and it works great for a flashlight.
So pretty cool.
Nice little headlamp there.
Like I said, from Petzl.
Um, I'm, I guess I could put this with this,
even though it's not really part of the kit.
Maybe I'll just put it up top adjacent.
Eh, screw it.
We don't need it.
It wasn't part of the kit.
I'm just showing it because it was there.
If you would now.
Next up is, we got some improvised tools here, as you can see.
The first one, maybe let's do all the tools right now.
So, I got this tool, and we got this tool.
Ended up grabbing this.
That being said, here is the tools that I ended up getting.
Now, I got the tools in a grab bag, which is kind of cool.
These are the three tools that I picked out for this particular kit.
I've got some needle nose pliers right here.
Cutters, you know, it's got insulated grip.
Nothing too crazy.
Thrift store pliers, right?
We have a really small stubby slotted right here.
You know, old school style, wooden handle,
painted multiple times with some kind of varnish
or something.
And then we got lastly for the tool that I have
for this kit is this little multi tool
It's got a Phillips here and it's also got some wrench ends here
Which is actually kind of nice little paddle now
as a bonus for this kit. I ended up getting two more
Because these five tools came in a little bag that said grab bag now
We'll go through all the prices
and I'll show you everything how it originally came
After we kind of pull everything out of here.
So, for now, you just kind of have to imagine that this came
with some extra stuff, which is kind of neat.
I have two extra ones.
This one's actually kind of cool.
This is an old-school Stanley Handyman,
made in the USA, which is really nice.
And this, I believe, is paired with this one, like the wooden handle.
Very similar, just a larger version of it, which is cool.
Cool. So I actually ended up using
this little stubby to take the, um, pencil.
A little head lamp, I guess you could say, mount off.
You saw me take this out.
This is a nice little six foot tape measure right here,
which is pretty cool.
So, Made in the USA, pretty neat.
Nice to get cool stuff like this secondhand.
I love secondhand tools.
Secondhand tool stores are pretty neat.
It would be neat to do a video in a secondhand tool store.
So we got a tape measure.
Next up we got was a kid's compass.
Now this was only purchased because I wanted the mini golf
pencil. So we harvested the golf pencil.
We'll put that up there. The compass was just extra.
I used it to store the golf pencil.
Um, I.
Packed it in this kit just to kind
of illustrate it where I can use it for storage.
It's not really taking up too much room for the kit
by just me storing it in the normal compass.
Am I using the compass? No.
So for the video itself, again, this is how,
I mean, it was like a super cheap compass,
and I'll show you how that came as well.
But the golf pencil was an absolute score
because the other choice I had was highlighters.
So highlighters.
Um, was the other writing implement.
So what did we choose to write on?
Well, I got me a nice, here, we'll pull this out.
I got me a nice little pack of index cards.
So the index cards, um, came as a hundred count.
So I just took a grip out of the index cards and said,
that's what we use to write on.
You know what I'm saying?
We're not publishing this stuff.
So it's, you know, we're just writing stuff down,
have some index cards.
I saw some carabiners.
And I ended up grabbing this Black Diamond one,
which is a climbing carabiner.
I live in the high country, so I'm at 7,000 feet.
And stuff like this, fanny packs,
Petzl headlamps, carabiners,
you're going to find that stuff
out of the thrift stores where I'm at.
So that being said, I said, let's grab this.
And I'm going to use this to, here, let's do it this way,
to store the index cards.
So I thought that was a neat way
to kind of hold the index cards
because it keeps them from...
Sliding around and it kind of gives a frame to the pouch.
It gives it a little bit of a frame and what I was storing in
Here. Oh this little thing must have came off
of the tape measure because that is
It's a 10-foot tape measure from
This fell off micro something or other.
It's a 10-footer. So that's good
I said six foot so because that's usually what a six foot size is
So this is actually packing more of a punch than I originally
Anticipated pretty cool
Next up we got was this, it looks like it was a freebie probably,
maybe Military Star is something,
because we have a lot of military in my area,
being near Colorado Springs, so Military Star
might have been something that went on here,
and I'm going to guess Discover donated a bunch of
these. So you get the charging cable,
and you get the power brick, which is nice. Thought that was
a neat little thing to have in this kit,
which for me personally, having something modern tech
tech like this and not just have like hand tools.
having a kit like this.
Usually you don't find stuff like flash drives unless they're brand new
or hard drives or anything like that because it's like
the data I don't know for some reason thrift
stores just don't handle that stuff
and they get them off the shelf and throw them away. That being
said too the other two things that are very difficult
to find are first aid because most of
the time it's used it gets broken open
or whatever you don't see it really on the shelves much.
The other thing is combustible things.
So like some kind of fire implement,
unless it's like a brand new thing,
like maybe like a torch lighter,
I don't know, to light a candle or something like that, maybe.
And it was donated in the original packaging, maybe.
But odds are you're not going to find first aid
or a fire implement at a thrift store.
So that being said, it's not in this kit.
So last thing in the main pouch,
I ended up grabbing a paperback.
So we got a Western here.
Pretty nice, again, everyday carry.
Something to read in downtime.
Pouch, pretty nice.
In this little pocket here, the last pocket,
I ended up grabbing something.
You're gonna laugh when you see this,
because this is something from a time
where we basically were scared to touch things,
or people were.
Not saying I was, but...
I grabbed this for this kit. It's perfect.
A brass little pull push thing for getting into
buildings and touching keypads if you don't want
to touch things that other people have touched.
So solid brass, as they say, or it could just be dyed stainless steel.
It looks like it. Over time,
it probably got that way.
I don't know if it started out that way, but that's just a relic
from the past. It's a goofy gag thing to throw in here,
and I just had to throw it in here.
Uh, it's perfect.
Absolutely perfect for this little build.
So this is a, um, I'm going to guess maybe
a camera lens bag now that I'm looking at
it.
It could be a camera bag.
Like you just slide the camera in here,
but it could also just be a camera lens bag.
Cause it's kind of like just a dump pouch.
I mean, that's how I see it.
And you can put your extra lenses in this little top part.
That makes sense to me, but it also makes sense that this,
you could just slide a camera
in here and probably put some light, you know, what were they?
Compact flash cards back in the day.
If I put a compact flash card in there.
The reason why I don't think it's a camera bag and I think it's
a lens bag is I don't think there's a pouch big enough for the power.
Like, back then, power was a thing.
There was usually, like, a brick that you put your little battery into,
and you usually have to pack both those.
So those together with the camera, usually it's,
like, implied that those need to be stored together.
That's why I think it's a lens bag, so pretty cool.
I found a lens bag. I think that's pretty awesome.
Now let's check out the prices. So here's the
picture that I took of everything before
I cleaned everything up and took all the
tags off of everything.
So it came out to about 53 bucks, um, before tax.
$3.99, so I paid $4 for the power bank, $1.69 for the index cards, $3
for the tape measure, $1.99 for the paperback, it was like bulk thing,
$1.69 I paid for the Black Diamond beener, which was a phenomenal deal.
Probably $15 to maybe $20, depending on where I can sell that at,
but yeah, that's a nice little flip if you're in the flip game.
The 57 Bel Air knife was $10 from the case.
Thankfully, they didn't put a sticker on that
and ruin it or mess it up.
Moving on here to the next row,
we paid $3 for the CaseLogic little,
we're gonna say, lens case.
$1.99 for the brass germ key is what they called it.
Here's the grab bag.
So it was eight bucks,
and I got all those tools in there.
So I think that's a pretty good deal, actually.
If you're looking to buy tools secondhand,
that's actually not too bad of a deal.
The Petzl headlamp, we sprung for the big bucks at $8.
And then lastly, we had the compass from Pen+Gear for two bucks.
So pretty cool.
I'm glad I was able to take that picture and then clean everything up.
I think it was easier than me trying to leave everything on there.
I started peeling the labels off of these things
and I'm like, holy crap, hang on, wait.
Let me take a picture of this and then I'll just print it out
so I have like just a record of like
how much I paid for everything. So about 53 bucks.
Now the answer to the question for this whole
thesis on this video is this, is it worth it?
I don't think so personally. I really don't think
so. If you're looking to, if you're looking
to build a kit, don't go to a thrift store.
My, these are my observations. First things first.
The tools are going to be like literally bottom of the barrel,
like the worst tools you can
possibly buy for the most part.
I mean, these tools have been through the ringer. They have
been picked through multiple hands.
Like how many people do you think have touched these tools and
was like, oh, I want this. Oh, this is garbage.
So at that point, by the time it ends up on the
shelf, all the employees have seen it.
All the people have seen it on the bulk scale. Yeah.
So that being said, you're getting the bottom
of the barrel tools and the price that you're
paying, you could probably go get some new stuff over
at like the Dollar Tree or Lowe's.
Me personally, I would take the 53 bucks
and just go over to like Lowe's and buy a knife,
a multi-tool and a flashlight and just call it a day.
Don't even buy the pouch or go buy their little,
their cheap fastener bag and throw those three
tools in there.
Um, and then I would just skip most
of this stuff personally. That would, that's my opinion.
If I was to give someone advice, I would say, don't even go here.
And if you're looking to do
like an extreme budget kit, just go to the Dollar Tree,
go to the Dollar Tree. I built an insane kit.
for 36 bucks. If you want to see that video,
go check that out down below. And if you want to go
see like my Lowe's video where I went to Lowe's
and built an EDC kit there and see how much that
costs, I'll leave a link down there as well.
Both those links will be down in the description. Check
those out. Dollar Tree was like 36 bucks
and I built an insane kit there. And I got to like
splurge. I got to buy stuff that was not in the dollar section.
It was in the $5 and up section
Um, anyway.
That being said, I wouldn't recommend going
to the thrift store to use them.
The big wins from this kit, in my personal opinion,
the Black Diamond, the Black Diamond
beater, the Petzl headlamp, and the 57 Bel Air knife,
and probably the 10-foot tape measure.
Those are some pretty good wins.
The tape measure is actually really nice.
Very nice.
Not that sticker's off there. It's not fractional. It doesn't lock.
But it is 10 foot. I don't know
if it will go out all the way to 10 feet.
Here, let's see. And still retract, but we're going to find out.
There's the absolute end.
Disconnect, insert nail, insert nail or match in round hole
of disconnecting this tape. Cool. Let's see if it retracts.
It doesn't retract on its own.
I have to kind of feed it, but so maybe not a full win, but
Still, nonetheless, I don't know if it's supposed to spring retract.
It might not have been a feature.
Since it doesn't lock,
it might actually have some kind of non-spring feature,
because that could be a nightmare, actually, if it doesn't lock.
So that could be intentional,
the fact that I have to feed it through that.
It's an older tape measure, but nonetheless.
I think that's a win.
That's a cool form factor for that, personally.
So those are my picks.
Let me know yours down in the comments below.
And let me know, is there other stuff I could
have picked up for this particular kit?
I mean, again, it all depends on what's there
on the shelves when you get there.
So it's something you cannot plan out.
So the fact that I could put a kit together like this,
you let me know down in the comments below.
If you like this video, give it a thumbs up.
Want more content like this, subscribe
for more, and have a great rest of your day.