Thrift Store EDC Challenge: Is It Actually Worth It?

The Reasonable Gentleman
17 Video Views·Nov 8, 2026  #EDC #ThriftStoreFinds #BudgetEDC

Can you build an everyday carry kit at a thrift store? Absolutely. But is it actually worth it? I visited two thrift stores and put together an EDC kit to see how the prices, tool condition, and selection stacked up.

Finding enough gear was fairly easy. The bigger question was whether I was getting good value—or paying close to new-tool prices for somebody else’s used tools.

Thrift shopping means working with whatever happens to be on the shelf. Depending on what you find, stores like Walmart, Lowe’s, or Dollar Tree may offer new alternatives at similar prices, with more predictable selection. Secondhand doesn’t automatically mean cheaper, and a bargain isn’t always the best tool for the job.

This is one experiment, not a final verdict on every thrift store. Your local shops, prices, and finds could be completely different.

There’s also another way to approach it: build a starting kit, then improve it over time. Keep the useful finds, replace weaker pieces, and see what repeated trips turn up. That could become a great kit—or an ongoing project that’s never quite finished. The question is how much time and money you want to put into getting there.

In this video, I walk through what I found, what I spent, and the tradeoffs behind building an EDC kit from secondhand gear.

Would you build a whole kit from thrift-store finds, or just shop for a few worthwhile pieces?

Lowe's Retail Challenge: https://youtu.be/5ZtOmvyKpZA?is=K7KSwFSg1xhV8QN9

Dollar Tree Retail Challenge: https://youtu.be/bYvBoe57bug?is=dXlDrlTPsutsLdvE

#EDC #ThriftStoreFinds #BudgetEDC