‘Credit Is Breaking’: Danielle DiMartino Booth on the Margin Call That Hit Gold

Loan Insights
4 followers
Nov 6, 2026 #finance #financement
#finance
#financement
00:00 Welcome Back to New Orleans
01:07 The AI Boom vs Shrinking Paychecks
03:01 Fed Hawks vs a Rallying Bond Market
05:11 Kevin Warsh and the Fed’s Family Fight
06:48 How Families Are Coping With Rising Costs
10:09 Inside the Private Credit Black Box
12:21 The End of Extend and Pretend
14:22 Recession Radar and the Jobless Claims Problem
16:19 Margin Calls Hit Gold and Silver
18:19 Stage Preview and Closing Thoughts
AI Generated·May contain errors
Kitco News on-site coverage of the New Orleans Investment Conference
is presented by Dakota Gold.
All right, welcome back to the New Orleans
Investment Conference here in beautiful
New Orleans, as we like to call it. I'm Jeremy Safran.
Now, AI spending, private investment,
AI pushed private investment, I should say,
up 9.4% in the third quarter. It's the biggest jump
since 2020. Now, your paycheck went the other way.
After inflation's wages fell about 0.6%
over the last year, pay has now trailed prices for two straight years.
And underneath it all,
Fitch now saying private credit defaults hit
a record 6.3%. Most of them
Don't look like defaults.
The Fed, of course, held on October 28th
and says it wants more information.
Now, my guest spent nine years inside
the Dallas Fed advising the president.
She knows how these numbers get read before the vote.
Danielle DiMartino-Booth,
CEO and chief strategist at QI Research, joining me now.
Danielle, good to see you.
In person.
In person.
I know.
It doesn't happen very often.
And, of course, it's happening on a day.
Well, we're both looking at our phones.
We've been looking at the terminal going, where are we going to land?
What is happening?
Obviously, there's a huge haircut on gold, the AI trade.
I mean, last time NASDAQ was down 3.4%, S&P 2.2,
correction territory in the NASDAQ 100.
Let's start with the two economies that we start to be seeing.
Because by your account, I mean,
AI spending is up almost, what, 30% a year.
And we've talked about this before.
I mean, wages after inflation are down.
So who's this economy working for?
Well, I think the economy is working for the billionaires
who are behind these hyperscalers,
and I'm not sure who else it is working for.
More than 100% of GDP growth right now is coming from
the AI trade. There's a defense kicker in there.
But again, it's always interesting to me when
people talk about data center construction. You get that initial boost.
to employment and then data centers don't need
a lot of warm bodies to keep them up and running
unless a computer breaks down somewhere.
So as far as the rest of the population, AI's not doing a
whole lot for it. And I'm a huge AI advocate.
I'm AI-ing my entire company right now.
I think you're not calling it super intelligence like Kevin Warsh did.
Yeah, well, you know, political pandering, me.
Let's get to some of your numbers.
I was reading your QI letter, which everyone should read,
and the real AI spending, like you put,
3.6 trillion in Q3, up about 30%, fastest record ever.
Wages three, you know, zero, six, negative on inflation.
So, I mean, take AI out.
What's left of this economy?
It looks kind of like an EKG that flatlines.
It's, um, they're, they're
There's really not that much left.
You have to.
Have a sense of sympathy for everybody who's being left out of this.
I mean, households are really struggling.
Are you struggling?
Nobody talks about oil prices when the Nasdaq's in meltdown,
but oil prices are still prohibitively high.
And you have to say, what's a family to do?
Yeah.
Yeah, it's interesting kind of talking about
the Main Street versus Wall Street, as we've talked about before.
And then I saw Richmond's Fed Barkin just said this morning,
he says that the Fed may need to lean against the AI investment surge.
So, I mean, should should the Fed be fighting AI spending?
Every single Fed speaker who we've heard from come out
of the gate defying forward guidance today has been in favor
of more rate hike, more rate hikes, more rate hikes.
While we're watching the two-year Treasury note come down to 2.57%,
I mean, it's been
quite a dramatic rally that is telling Fed policymakers,
catch me if you can.
If you try and tighten into this environment when...
AI investment is carrying the U.S. economy.
And when AI investment is largely being carried by debt being issued,
May saw no debt issuance over $3 billion, not a single bond sale.
September, same thing.
In those two months, we saw industrial production related
to AI spending contract.
So this is all being floated by more and more debt issuance
on a day when Anthropic finds out that
It may not get that investment grade rating,
which would be kind of catastrophic, all
things considered, because you don't want to be paying up,
what was it, SoftBank priced
a six and a half year paper at 9.75%.
I mean, I think the official from six to seven on average in one year.
I mean, it's an incredible size.
And to your point, I mean, you know,
I've heard some people here say that the last rate
hike was just kind of a tweak.
It wasn't.
Well, it was a real boom for the...
Top 10% of Americans who have, you know,
almost all of the cash in more than $8 trillion in money
market funds. It's great.
They get to get a little bit more on their cash.
Everybody else. Is it good
for small businesses? Is it good for households?
Is it good for their credit card rates to go up?
Is it good for them to have a harder time buying
a car if theirs breaks down? You have to stop back
You have to sit back and ask yourself, who is Kevin Warsh?
Making policy for.
Yeah, yeah.
And to be honest, I mean, we haven't chatted since this Fed decision.
So, I mean, I'll ask you again, 10 minutes alone with Kevin Warsh.
You've got no cameras.
I mean, what are you asking?
What are you telling him in the room?
I'm asking him where his task forces are.
Has he lost them?
You
He's supposed to be looking for alternative data sets.
And yet when he's at the podium at this latest press conference,
know,
he's citing jobless claims.
Jobless claims cover one in four unemployed Americans.
So again, who is he speaking for when he
you.
is not even close enough to the backward-looking data
that he's referencing to understand what it's implying
for U.S. households, for small businesses?
And where is this alternative data task force?
Where's the inflation task force?
He looks at the percentage of inputs
to inflation that are rising by 3% or more.
That's falling.
And yet he's not paying.
He, he, he, he, he.
I would ask him why he's not paying closer attention.
And if he does know what's going on, why he's ignoring it.
Interesting.
Now, I mean, he called this a heck of a family fight.
Who's winning?
Well, given.
With unrestrained Fed speak and hard forward guidance being given
by these district bank presidents,
I'd have to say that the rest of the family is winning the fight
and that he might not even get through the front door on Thanksgiving.
Interesting. That dose of accommodation, I mean, you know, old news.
At this point.
It's dusty old news.
So let's talk about the paycheck.
I mean, those at home, I mean, they feel it, right?
Wages are losing to prices.
Consumer spending rose 3.8% in Q3.
I mean, where's the money coming from?
Well, the money's coming from, in many ways,
debt, even for households, as we see in the
falling saving rate.
And that 3.8% saving rate also represents,
in the aggregate, people who are sitting on
a ton of cash, who've got money,
who are not living paycheck to paycheck.
But even if you look at the composition of consumption
and what people are spending money
on, right there out in the lead is health care,
and then the rent, and then the utility
bill, and then what you have to put
in the gas tank, and then groceries.
If you look at spending on a discretionary level,
what the average household can spend on buying a new good or paying
for a new service when they can't afford to get on the airplane,
there's not much left over.
So even though we're seeing strong consumption,
part of that strong consumption is based on people's...
Being, having to pay for the roof over their head,
having to pay for health care if their kid gets sick.
These are things they have to buy.
You know, and the private employer health costs, too.
These have increased.
I mean, it's 6.5, 6.4 percent in a year,
matching the highest level since 2005.
You know, I was listening to Barkin today.
He says consumers are proving creative, right, as to when they spend.
And I actually think that Barkin is more
of a centrist compared to some of the more hawkish.
Right.
District presidents,
he's a little bit more grounded than others are, but at least he's
acknowledging the creativity.
I mean, buy now, pay later can get you all kinds of things.
Well, I was going to say, I mean, what is that? Because, I mean,
what does creative mean on a family budget?
Right. Well, I mean, you're seeing
an explosive record percentage of Americans who are rolling
over old car debt into the new car loan when they get it.
I mean, they're upside down the
And the minute they drive off the lot,
And I don't know what creativity is going to do for them in the end.
And I brought up this health care thing,
and it's because the health costs are rising.
And is that where the raises went when we look at this data?
Oh, in many ways, because if you look at just wages and salaries,
that's not where the needle's moving.
It is with health care.
And, you know, with companies fighting margin pressure,
which they are, it's not that input prices are not going up.
The producer price index is real.
And yet, if you listen to consumer-facing companies like Whirlpool,
like Sherwin-Williams, like Home Depot,
they do not have the pricing power
because consumers do not have the purchasing power.
So they're having to eat it in their margins.
If their health care costs are going up at the same time,
the only thing that they have left to do is cut costs.
And cut costs is a very polite way of saying fire people.
Yeah. And here we are, of course, wondering what's happening.
I've been watching the market split,
what's going to happen in December.
Meanwhile, I mean, if you're a family with a variable rate credit line.
This December rate hike, I mean, what should they do before that?
You know, it's very difficult to say
or suggest what American families can and should do.
I mean, we're seeing it.
We're seeing it in multi-generational household formation.
We're seeing it in record percentages
of adults living with their parents.
They're doing what they can,
but that certainly doesn't make it satisfactory.
Yeah, absolutely.
And people feel it.
I mean, it comes back to private credit, too.
Fitch put private credit defaults at a record 6.3%.
Proskauer, a law firm that tracks these senior loans,
has it at 2.41 and falling.
I mean, whoa.
Look, anybody, even Fitch, and Fitch has been at the forefront of this,
I don't think that we can say with certainty what the distress is,
what these default rates are,
into a black box into which regulators have no view.
So it's hard to say.
I mean, just this week, the organization that regulates the 51,
including Washington, D.C., insurance regulators, had to step back.
On saying, we need for you to limit the amount
of private credit in your portfolios
because there was such pushback from the rating agencies.
So we're not even able to try
and better regulate into private credit when efforts are made.
Who knows what the distress really is?
I think, Boruch, when he was talking about AI,
and I don't have the exact tweet or quote here,
but he was saying something about the cracks.
He's starting to see things form in cracks.
I mean, is this what we're talking about here?
He's watching this carefully?
And he should be watching it carefully because,
again, we're only seeing AI spending surge
when there's a surge in debt issuance related to AI.
Thank
And I dare say, I think there's an election coming up here.
We're in the in-between, folks.
We're in the in-between right now.
Well, if there is a blue wave, then the risk is very real,
you
that there could be more pushback against building data centers
very
and the economic growth that comes with that,
the spurt of construction workers
much.
and what it brings to communities, including higher utility bills.
Thank you.
Politics can be a very real, tangible factor affecting economics,
and we should be attentive to that.
I don't...
48 hours ago, I was saying
that the markets hadn't priced in political risk.
Today, I'm not so sure that markets are not beginning to price in.
political risk. Yeah, you have to continue
as obviously this is developing and continuing
with the gold price too. And I have to ask you,
I mean, borrowers obviously pay interest
with more debt or push the due date out.
I mean, is it the extend and pretend?
Well, it was extend and pretend.
But if you look at commercial real estate, which has been kind of
the bastion of extend and pretend, lenders have said no more, no muss.
So they're forcing
losses to be recognized. And what we need to appreciate,
and the reason I bring up commercial
real estate, is if there's one portion
of the loan book that is compromised, then lending
standards are going to tighten for other types of loans
that banks make, including to U.S. households,
including to small businesses.
And so we have to be attentive to that. And we haven't even
begun to talk about corporate America needing
to refinance a lot of its debt, to say nothing
of Uncle Sam. And I mean, you know, who owns the debt?
I mean, is your pension, is your insurer?
And wouldn't you like to know, especially if it's your insurer,
that that insurer may have, you know, the assets tied
to what they presumably owe you in an offshore reinsurer?
You know, that Proskauer or that law firm that I just talked about,
it says that defaults among software borrowers are rising.
Is AI eating, yeah, is AI kind of eating,
you know, the company's private credit lent too?
Oh, AI is trying to find debt wherever it can.
I mean, AI has been trying to tap
the commercial mortgage-backed securities market,
the asset-backed securities market,
in order to get funding for data centers,
which are markets that are just too small.
They're too small to absorb the level of debt,
and they can't provide construction loans either.
But AI is looking everywhere they can to get debt.
Only 18% of hyperscalers' debt is on their balance sheets.
That means, you know, the other 82% is in off-balance sheet vehicles,
which we used to talk way back in the Enron days.
Yeah, yeah. I'm not feeling vindicated,
but we have been talking about this for a while.
We have been talking about this for a while.
It can't be too big of a surprise to some folks watching.
Now, talk to me about GDP.
It grew 3.4% in Q3. Inflation's running 3.6%.
What does your recession radar say right now?
My recession radar says that growth outside
of what's being spent on structures and everything,
goodwill, everything feeding this AI frenzy, which is very real.
I mean, the debt being sold amounts to, what, $200 billion this year?
I mean, there's real money pouring into this.
But outside of that,
you don't see a whole heck of a lot of dynamism in GDP, even if
You know, isolate consumer spending being relatively strong.
Again, what are they spending on essentials?
You know, we talked a little bit about those jobless claims, right?
Oh, my gosh.
Lowest since mid-July, your favorite.
1969, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah.
And the fact that we're cited them, it just got under my skin, Jeremy,
because only one in four unemployed Americans
are collecting unemployment benefits.
Right, yeah.
Because they can't.
It's only 25% of the unemployed because benefits don't cover the rent.
And, I mean, Microsoft's offered buyouts to about 60,000 staff.
So, I mean, are white-collar jobs next?
Is this the beginning of that?
It's the continuation of that,
because we've seen one wave of buyouts after another.
Skydance, at the beginning of this week,
had it not been for Microsoft,
the buyouts that Skydance offered at the beginning of this week
would have been notable,
but they were a drop in the bucket compared to Microsoft.
But then that merger's not...
Completed yet. I mean, well, the synergies extracted
from that massive merger have yet to be extracted
I mean, how long can they I mean hiring is obviously slow,
but layoffs are kind of low as they call it
How long does that last?
Ask me on Monday, because if this situation in the market continues
and you have the top of the K
get nervous, all bets are off. Yeah. And let's talk about what we're
seeing in the market. Obviously, gold down,
silver down, AI trade down. We talked about
it off the top. I mean,
no one knows where this is going to end, but is a lot of this
being a margin call? I mean, we're seeing a lot of...
It is going to be a margin call when you
You know, your technology holdings, when they spring a margin call.
You're going to go where you can find liquidity.
I mean, you're not going to.
You're going to be forced to go where you can to find liquidity.
It is troubling to see how precious metals are behaving.
And you would think that this would be a buying opportunity because if
what is happening in the stock market is happening in the stock market,
that means it credits in even more distressed territory.
And when you have an...
Upset in the credit markets, one of the few places to hide
is precious metals, as long as the history of mankind goes back.
It's been interesting watching it sell off with AI
and the whole trade, too, right?
And that tells you margin call.
Right.
I know you're going to hit the stage here,
and we only have you for a few minutes.
You're a popular lady here at the show.
But just in the brief moments you've been here,
I mean, what's the sentiment, right?
I mean, people come to you and say, what's happening?
Well, a lot of people say thank you because a lot of people want to.
Even though most people at an investment conference would
be protected from what the bottom of the K is experiencing,
they know people, and they have relatives,
and they want to hear the truth.
And so most of the reaction here is, thank you.
Yeah. Have you been surprised?
I mean, gold still fell about $135 on a day bond yields fell.
I mean, that correlation, does that fit the story?
Sorry.
Not if bond yields are falling because credit is breaking.
Yeah.
It starts in the credit, huh?
It always starts in the credit markets.
Always, always, always.
And, you know, we've been talking for the last several weeks.
Gee, those triple C high yield spreads have broken north
of a thousand basis points.
Isn't that a red flag?
And you're like, apparently, yes, it was a red flag.
Now, this is going to air after you're on stage.
So just tease us a little bit about what you
want to talk to the audience about today,
specifically going into now.
So I want to defy this idea that inflation is broadening in.
In scope. I want for people to understand
that the sources of inflation are shrinking. I want
for people to understand where we are in the bankruptcy cycle,
which is at recessionary levels.
Thank
This idea that just because business spending has risen means
that corporate America is in good
shape. That's false,
given how many companies are going bankrupt day after day after day.
you
Yeah.
Last one to you. I mean, obviously,
you spent nine years inside the Dallas Fed.
so
What's one thing, how the Fed really works,
that would kind of surprise our viewers?
much.
Well, I think most of the public knows by now
because we've gotten used to dissents.
For years, dissents were rare.
And now, prior to any Fed meeting, we just go,
will it be one, two, three, or four?
It's become a parlor game.
That tells you...
How potentially not polite the family fight is.
Are you going to wait to deploy
into this and just see where it lands first?
See what the kind of correction looks
like before putting new capital in?
Well, I would say this much.
There are a lot of good opportunities out there
because prior to tech beginning this meltdown,
which could reverse on Monday for all we know,
but prior to this,
Most of the stocks have been really beat up in the broader indices
to the extent that any of them have nice fat dividends
You might begin to tippy-toe in
I like it. You heard it here. All right, Danielle DiMartino Booth,
I've got to let you get over there. I kept you for five minutes longer.
Of course, CEO and Chief Strategist over at QI Research,
and as well, the Daily Feather on Substack. It's been great.
And I go to it before coming over here with the data.
Good to see you, Danielle.
Good to see you.
Appreciate it. All right, for all of us here at the New Orleans
Conference in New Orleans, of course, I'm Jerry Zappin for Kitco News.
We've got great guests coming up all week long. Stay tuned.
Kitco News on-site coverage of the New Orleans Investment Conference
is presented by Dakota Gold.
