The student loan landscape is a mess — uncertainty, delays, conflicting headlines, and a whole lot of anxiety. Should you switch repayment plans? Are you eligible for PAYE? And how could political changes impact Grad PLUS loans and Public Service Loan Forgiveness (PSLF)? We’re answering real borrower questions and sharing practical steps you can take right now so you don’t get caught off guard by sudden changes. If you're feeling stuck, overwhelmed, or just unsure of your next step, this episode is for you.
Key moments: 00:00 Introduction 06:08 Should you switch to a new IDR plan or stick with SAVE? 13:19 Could an executive order eliminate Grad PLUS loans? 19:32 Can DOGE change access to PSLF or IDR forgiveness? 25:23 Taking time off for kids? Here’s how to manage student loan repayment during career breaks 32:43 What to expect with student loans and income recertification
Hello and welcome to another episode of the Student Loan Planner Podcast.
It's Travis and today we're going to talk about what, if anything,
should you be doing with your student loans right now?
There's all this, you know, uncertainty, all these concerns, questions,
fears, anxieties about what's happening at the moment with student loans.
And what do you do when there's still all this chaos and this big save plan
pause, you know, what, what can you actually believe right now?
So that'd be really good opportunity to turn to our listener voicemail line to
see what people are leaving question wise about that.
And so I thought we would take our first question about somebody who's wondering
if they should switch to the pay plan or not. So let's take a listen.
Hello.
I wanted to ask you if I am qualified
to be on the PAYE pay plan.
I was on the old IBR for a long time
and then I consolidated my loans in 2023
to qualify for the save plan.
I am currently on the save plan forbearance.
But I was thinking about moving from save to pay because
if I moved to the pay plan,
my years of payment would go down by five years.
I would be less making less payments on the pay plan.
But my problem is my student loans go to
2001, 2002, 2003.
So that's when I went to college.
So my loans are older than 2007.
I have been calling Nelnet to figure this out,
but they're giving me conflicting information.
They told me,
some of them told me that because my loans are
older than 2007, they're from 2002, 2003 and so forth,
that even though I consolidated my loans in 2023,
I still do not qualify for the pay plan.
And some other reps in Nelnet told me I do qualify.
And they said that when you consolidate your loans,
you are as if you were born again and you become a new borrower.
So I wanted to ask you,
do I do,
does someone become eligible for pay plan if they
consolidated their loans,
even though they have older loans from 2001,
2002, 2003 and so forth.
And would you recommend me switching from safe plan to
pay plan?
Would pay plan be a better option for a graduate
student like me who makes about $145,000
a year?
And so yeah,
please do an episode on this.
Thank you for your time.
Thank you.
Bye bye.
So that's a good question.
And I think that if you think about what the definition of being eligible for
pay is,
you have to be a new borrower as of October,
2007 and have taken out at least one loan after October,
2011.
So the second part of this borrower situation is true.
If you consolidate a loan after 2011,
that does count as a new loan.
So you would satisfy that condition,
but where this borrower does not satisfy the other condition is being a new
borrower as of October,
2007.
Now to be clear,
if you had paid off your loans and you take out a new loan and you didn't have
a loan outstanding when you became a new borrower after 2011,
or sorry,
after 2007,
then this person would have been eligible.
So for example,
if they had paid off their undergrad loans from 2001 to 2003 or four before
taking out their first loan after that October,
2007 date,
then they would be eligible for pay as you were.
And so that's kind of where it gets complicated.
Somebody can be eligible for pay if they pay off old loans and then take out a
new loan for the first time.
But this person didn't do that.
So that's why they're not eligible for pay as you earn.
So what does that mean functionally?
So remember that pay as you earn was essentially a strategy to
implement the new IBR program that President Obama crafted through the
legislation and the Affordable Care Act to get it opened up early to borrowers.
This was all part of the plan for,
you know,
new IBR was supposed to be eligible for new borrowers as of July,
2014.
That was part of the ACA,
you know,
partly because of just budgetary reasons,
they needed a lot of these provisions to take effect after certain dates that
the cost would be low enough for them to pass the law.
And you know,
the problem is that bill,
when you pass a bill that doesn't have benefits for many years from now,
it doesn't get you much of a political payoff.
So think about like the Inflation Reduction Act,
one of the big political criticisms of that law was that it was this big deal
that was signed by President Biden and it was just this big,
big legislative victory.
But then,
you know,
the average voter didn't really feel any impact because most of the money is not
going to be spent for a long time.
Most of the benefits are not going to be received for a long time.
So,
you know,
the idea behind pay as you earn was to try to get it out there early in the 2012
election.
President Obama gave a speech to University of Iowa graduating class and
basically announced the pay plan.
And it would have been pretty awkward if that graduating class had not been
eligible for the plan that he was announcing,
right?
And so that's actually why they crafted the plan to be available to new borrowers
as of October 20,
2007 was because the vast majority of the people in that University of Iowa
graduating class in class of 2012 took out their first student loan in 2008.
And so they needed the majority of these students to be eligible for this new
income driven plan.
Otherwise,
you know,
that would be kind of an awkward speech to give because you'd be announcing
something that didn't pertain to the audience that you're getting the speech in
front of.
So that's a little bit of fun history about how the pay plan came into being.
And it was the first plan that was ever derived from something called the ICR
statute,
the ICR authority of the department of ed.
So let's take a listen to some more questions now.
Hi,
good afternoon,
Travis.
I would like to thank you for listening to my voicemail.
I've been a long time listener.
I have a question.
So I'm currently in the safe plan.
I have about nine payments or so that did not count due to me being in the safe
plan and it being on administrative forbearance.
A question is,
should I go ahead and just wait until to see what the new
administration is going to do?
Or should I try to change into a new IDR?
I did take my first loan out before 2007.
So I took my first loan out in 2004 for undergrad.
So I don't believe I will qualify for the pay plan.
So I'm assuming the only one that would probably qualify for is the IBR.
So just wanted to know your advice or
guidance on,
should I just wait it out or should I go ahead and change?
Like I said,
I have about nine payments that is not counting on the
safe plan.
And I am in PSLF.
I have maybe about three years or so.
I'm out from PSLF.
It keeps pushing me back the date because of the payments not counting.
But I am still sitting in my ECF forms.
All right.
Thank you.
Bye.
So for this question,
I think that the answer is,
it depends,
which is never a good answer,
but let me explain why it depends.
So if you have a low risk tolerance,
let's say you have a very low risk tolerance and you really desperately want to
be out of your job as soon as possible,
well then I would definitely say try to switch so you can be done for sure as
soon as possible.
So IBR is statutory.
It's in the law.
PSLF is in the law.
So IBR plus PSLF is sure to work as anything.
I can't give you a hundred percent probability,
but I would say maybe 98,
99% probability.
The PSLF buyback program,
you know,
maybe that's like a two thirds chance to work.
And so if you think about what PSLF buyback is,
it's essentially,
you know,
the opportunity to think of all of these paused payments as counting,
but you just have to make it up later.
You have to make it up when you have 120 months of total qualifying employment.
So the big thing to do is to be,
you know,
certifying your employment,
making sure that the Department of Ed knows about all your qualifying employment
first and foremost.
And then when you hit 120 months of total qualifying employment,
then go ahead and submit for PSLF saying that you believe you qualify,
submit a reconsideration request and try to see if you can buy back those months
that didn't count.
Now in terms of if you should apply right now,
I think that the issue is,
you know,
what does your future hold?
Like would you have a hard time qualifying for IBR in the future?
Would it be difficult for you to get a partial financial hardship,
which means,
you know,
your required payment on IBR would have to be lower than the standard 10 year
plans for you to even be able to sign up for the plan at all.
So I'm actually seeing quite a few people who are at risk of this because
they're only eligible for the old IBR plan and you know,
they need to have a payment on IBR that's lower than their standard 10 year
plan or they can't get onto IBR at all.
Well,
if ICR is struck down as a legitimate plan,
which is very possible,
then the IBR plan would be the only game in town.
And then,
you know,
if you did not have that partial financial hardship to get onto IBR,
then you'd be up the creek without a paddle because you'd have no route to get
PSLF at all.
Now this is assuming the ICR plans get restricted by the courts.
I can't make a prediction on that.
I'm not really sure which way they're going to go on that,
but we know the IBR plan is safe.
So I think that,
you know,
the way I would look at it is if you're sure that you're going to have a partial
financial hardship,
no matter what,
if you're sure that you're going to stay in your nonprofit or government
employment,
no matter what,
then I think that I might be patient and just sort of weigh it out,
wait it out because you'll be able to switch onto the IBR plan later,
you know,
pretty,
pretty easily if you needed to,
they can't block you from signing up for IBR.
So in that case,
I'd probably be a little patient.
If I was a,
you know,
first or second year attending physician,
my income is about to skyrocket.
I have a low tax return that I could use to get onto the IBR plan right now.
And I'm not sure if the pay plan is going to stick around for two or three more
years that I would need to get PSLF.
In that case,
I probably would give up my administrative forbearance,
try to apply for IBR to get onto it so that when my attending income is too high
to qualify for IBR,
at least I know I'll have the cap standard 10 year plan payment.
And then you're kind of locking in the ability to get the vast majority of your
loans forgiven versus potentially taking a risk of not getting anything forgiven
at all.
So those are some of the,
you know,
kind of examples of why this is kind of a very personal situation.
You really do have to think about,
you know,
your income,
your future income,
your spouse's income,
your filing status,
how close you are to PSLF,
your risk tolerance.
There's a whole lot that goes into it.
So that's an annoying answer,
but you know,
sometimes it depends is the most honest answer.
So let's take another question.
Hey group.
Thanks so much for your content.
You're really making a difference in people's lives.
Mine included.
My question is that when I log onto federal student aid,
I don't have any information under loans.
I can see on my dashboard that I have my big chunk of loans,
but when I click into the loans and look for things like my payment count,
nothing is there.
And I'm wondering if that's related to being under the service or Mochila,
we know how problematic they've been.
If you could please give me some insight on that,
that'd be awesome.
Thanks group.
So honestly,
sometimes I'm stumped.
I'm not sure why this is occurring.
I think that,
you know,
I would probably be patient.
I'd probably try to,
um,
you know,
I mean,
it's probably a waste of time to call,
but you might call and ask,
uh,
if you don't have any payment history on FSA,
I would probably submit a,
uh,
request to the Ombudsman of department of ed.
So I'd probably send a,
an email to Ombudsman,
um,
the Ombudsman email.
Let me see if I can remember that off the top of my head.
I think it is Ombudsman at ed.gov.
That's the email.
And that's,
if you have like no history at all showing in your FSA.
Um,
if you have no history at all showing on your Mochila,
your Nelnet or whatever service or that you're with,
I probably wouldn't worry quite as much about that.
The FSA stuff is going to be,
what's going to determine all the official,
uh,
you know,
kind of policies about when you're going to get forgiveness and all those sorts of
things.
Um,
so I would probably reach out to,
um,
to that group.
I think there's also a,
um,
phone number that you can call.
I believe it's 1-800-557-7394.
That is a student support center.
Um,
I remember we had a lot of problems back in the day,
um,
with people that were,
um,
dealing with this Fed loan problem where Fed loan never built at end of the,
you know,
the logic that alone can have more than a hundred thousand of accrued interest.
And so people that were getting over a hundred thousand of accrued interest Fed
loan,
like took it upon themselves to split the loan in two.
But the problem is,
is they never told department of ed.
And so department of ed was showing half of people's balance instead of all of
it.
And Fed loan was showing all of it.
And it was just like this embarrassing problem that just,
you know,
it was almost kind of like a Y2K bug.
They never anticipated the year 2000,
right.
It's pretty similar.
And so we just had to have people reach out to the student loan support student,
a federal student aid support center.
And escalate things.
you know,
to make sure that the records were right on FSA,
because if the records are not right on FSA,
then there's a good chance that they'll mess it up for the future.
If you ever got forgiveness.
So really weird problem.
I'm sorry,
you're going through that listener,
but um,
you know,
that would be my suggestion is,
you know,
reach out to that ombudsman email or reach out to the student support center.
So let's take a few more here.
Travis.
Thank you so much for your very informational podcast.
I discovered it about a year ago and it's been really helpful for me as I
navigate the very convoluted landscape of student loans.
My situation is that I'm in a graduate school program.
I'm reliant a hundred percent on grad plus loans because I've maxed out,
um,
the,
the regular,
um,
subsidized and unsubsidized loans.
Um,
so my question and my anxieties right now are centered around whether or not grad
plus loans are going to remain available throughout the Trump administration.
Um,
there has been talk,
um,
that they could go away.
And so I have two questions on that.
The first is,
could he eliminate them through an executive order or would this be something
that would have to go through Congress and legislation through Congress?
And I'm curious if so,
what the anticipated timeframe might be for that.
Uh,
the second question is if worst case scenario for me happens and the grad plus
loan option grapples,
loans are eliminated.
Um,
would that take effect right away?
And how might that impact,
um,
students who are currently in the middle of a program and taking out grad plus
loans?
Like,
I don't think I'd be able to finish my program.
So it causes me a lot of anxiety and stress.
So just curious about the answers to those questions.
Thank you so much.
So the current proposal on the table from house Republicans is that they would
phase out the grad plus program starting in 2025 and that it would be fully
phased out in 2028 and the prosper act in 2017 that was proposed.
So it was,
it was another sort of party line,
a proposal to eliminate grad plus what they said in that bill was anybody who is
enrolled in a graduate program as of a certain date would retain access to grad
plus,
and then the grad plus loans would be fully gone by,
you know,
the time somebody was finished with their program.
Now the new language they're suggesting is,
you know,
fully phasing it out in 2028.
I think that's probably because,
you know,
obviously president Trump would no longer be in power in 2028 so they probably
want to make sure they try to phase out the grad plus program in full before the
end of his terms.
That's my guess on that.
But you know,
I would take some comfort.
First of all,
that the grad plus elimination would have to be legislative.
It can't be done through executive order.
Grad plus is in the law.
It was a law passed in around 2006 timeframe.
So grad plus and parent plus,
they are in the law.
The uncapped borrowing of those programs are in the law.
And yeah,
you'd have to wait and see for legislation with the reconciliation bill that
Republicans are going to come out with in the late spring probably.
And I do think that there is more momentum behind capping and eliminating grad
plus and parent plus than there ever has been before.
But keep in mind that these proposals are pre-contact with lobbyists.
And what I mean by that is this would have a really negative impact on borrowers
that are in programs that cost a lot of money,
but it would also have a far more negative impact,
frankly,
on universities that depend on this money to fill their budgets.
And we last time saw that,
saw this proposal defeated by a very interesting political coalition of big,
famous schools of big football programs combined with HBCUs.
That was the coalition that defeated this.
When it was proposed in the Obama administration,
you had sort of the big football schools hitting up,
you know,
a lot of more Republican senators.
You had a lot of HBCUs heading up more,
you know,
like,
you know,
Obama administration officials and such in this like diverse coalition of
university interest groups blocked the elimination of the grad plus and parent
plus programs.
It was actually proposed by president Obama in some capacity at least.
And so,
you know,
I think that if I was in a program already,
I'd feel very comfortable knowing that grad plus is going to stick around until
the end of it.
With the exception of anybody who,
you know,
is maybe in their very first year of their program,
there's a chance that,
you know,
maybe it gets eliminated in 2028.
If that were to happen,
I would anticipate the universities would use some creative accounting to try to
make sure that people borrow all the grad plus loans a little bit early before
the program is shut down because they'd have the very strong interest in doing
so.
So,
you know,
I would only worry about grad plus loans going away in my mind if you did not
have,
if you were not enrolled in a program yet,
but you'd like to be.
So if,
if you want to be enrolled in a program,
you know,
I think that,
you know,
I don't think they're going to pass a budget reconciliation bill with lightning
speed.
So I would anticipate maybe the cutoff date could be programs that start this
fall,
might be cut off from grad plus for the future,
but maybe they won't be,
maybe the programs this fall would be the last programs that be eligible for
them.
And I think that if,
you know,
if you were to see like a July 2025 end date for grad plus new grad plus
borrowers already are not already enrolled in a program,
frankly,
what all the super expensive dental schools in the Northeast would do and other
programs like it.
I think they would just enroll people like June 27th,
right?
So I think that there'll be a lot of workarounds for whenever they do do
something with grad plus if they do it at all,
because they only have a three seat house majority.
So let's take a few more questions.
Hi,
Travis.
My name is Sam in Houston.
Thank you for all the work you've done.
I have two questions.
The first is that you've spoken a lot about what the Trump administration can or
cannot do to affect student loans.
But what comments do you have about what the doge could do?
I am increasingly concerned that they are going to prevent or change access to
PSLF or IDR forgiveness,
things like that.
The second question is that I've tried to contact Mahua through email and phone
several times to discuss switching from an administrative to a processing
forbearance.
As I submitted an IDR application a month or two ago to switch off of save to
old IBR.
And I keep getting stock replies that don't answer my question and are more
confusing than helpful.
And no one has really addressed this point.
I know that it's up to the servicer to do so,
but can we influence this in any way?
And what suggestions do you have if we're not actually getting answers to
continue to try to push for qualifying payments for PSLF?
Thank you.
I love our listeners because y'all always ask really good questions.
So I think that the doge piece of things,
I think that they've already cut about a billion dollars from department of ed
from like research activities,
which is not technically its core function.
So that's their first assault on it.
Also ending,
you know,
any programs or putting any employees involved in DEI efforts at department of
ed on administrative forbearance or administrative forbearance.
Forbearance,
look at my brain,
not functioning.
Administrative leave,
you know,
Freudian slip there guys.
So I think that the thought process on doge and what they could do.
So keep in mind that they will try to target something in department of ed and
it might take time.
And there's actually a lawsuit trying to slow them down.
The California student borrower,
California,
I think it's like student association for higher education,
uh,
you know,
universities in California,
they,
they filed a lawsuit trying to block doge's access to the federal student loan
system and borrower information citing,
you know,
privacy concerns that they didn't want doge accessing their private information.
This is,
you know,
I mean,
it's,
it's hard to know what,
what your strategy should be.
If you were trying to stop doge from,
you know,
finding a lot of stuff out about the student loan system,
because it's sort of like if you,
I mean,
it's sort of like by trying to slow down their access,
it almost makes them want to look at it more.
That makes sense.
Now,
obviously,
you know,
if you want to stop their access,
then we can't not do anything,
I guess.
So I'm not really sure about the strategy behind it,
but I just know that that's a lawsuit that's been going on where they've tried
to slow down access from doge to the student loan data.
I think though that they're going to log in and they're going to find some things
that are going to be pretty shocking.
And it's not that hard to think through what they would find,
right?
I think that they would look at the student loan data.
They would look at the total volume.
They would look at how many people are in forbearance.
They would look at,
you know,
the interest pause with save plan forbearance.
They would look at how many people are making payments and what the payments
are.
I think that they're going to see that,
you know,
a huge number of people have a very small payment,
right?
That the people have not recertified and several years since in many cases,
but because of the COVID pause and the Biden policies of extending the IDR
recertification date.
So in terms of what doge could do to student loans,
I think that the most you know,
the biggest impact I think,
frankly,
would just be forcing IDR recertification really early,
possibly forcing a lot of people off the save plan forbearance,
forcing people into IBR,
something along those lines.
I think that they could also,
you know,
try to put a pause on some of the changes to PS left that
president Biden made some of the things like making PS left definitions a little
bit more flexible.
For example,
maybe they try to order a halt,
maybe a temporary halt to,
you know,
PS left processing while they redo some of the eligibility rules around the
edges.
So for example,
maybe it's going back to the employer definition full time instead of,
you know,
the 30 hours a week requirement,
for example,
but this is all speculative.
I mean,
with the doge stuff,
I think the issue is nobody truly knows this is all very uncertain period.
And so we just have to stay tuned,
but know that,
you know,
the reason why,
from my understanding that they were able to so quickly attack USAID was because
it was created via an executive order.
I'm not an expert on USAID.
Just want to have that disclosure out there,
but that's my understanding is,
well,
if you create something via an executive order,
you can undo it with an executive order.
And you know,
the,
even that is held up in the courts,
right?
So I think with department of ed,
the good news for borrowers that are worried would be that department of ed
stuff is a way more in the statute than,
you know,
something like USAID is.
And you might say,
well,
you know,
the CFPB is in the statute and look what they did to the CFPB.
Well,
the CFPB simply says something around the lines of,
well,
the director of the CFPB can basically just draw on funds from the federal
reserve kind of whenever it wants.
And so their theory is,
well,
that means that they can undraw on funds from the federal reserve whenever they
want.
And that means they can just refund all the money that funds the CFPB.
Since Congress doesn't fund it directly.
Well,
therefore there's no money to operate the CFPB.
So yes,
they will,
they will try to look for loopholes like that to try to apply things to
department of ed.
But I think that,
you know,
when it says 35 times that the secretary of education shall offer income driven
repayment programs and they define,
you know,
IBR explicitly as a very specific type of repayment plan,
there's not as much wiggle room there for them to,
you know,
try to impact things.
As to the second question about what can you do after,
you know,
having asked for a processing forbearance to try to switch plans.
So the processing forbearance,
keep in mind that's at the complete discretion of the service or the servicer
can do whatever it wants there.
And it's up to 60 days on the processing forbearance,
which means that they wanted to make it shorter.
They could.
And the processing forbearance counting for PS left and IDR,
that's also a Biden administration rule.
That's not in the statute.
So this is something that if Trump wanted to,
you know,
pause,
you know,
things for a little bit to undo that over a process of months,
he could.
Right.
So I think that,
you know,
kind of being uncomfortable with uncertainty is the only path here.
You know,
if you know that you want to get on the IBR studentaid.gov slash IDR,
then make sure you apply in the manage repayment section.
And then you also have to specifically state you want to be on the IBR plan and
not the one that says,
let my servicer choose.
I think anybody who's selecting,
let my servicer choose on their IDR plans right now is just sort of choosing to
be in purgatory.
Because from my understanding,
the servicers are not even processing those.
You know,
they're just only processing ones where people explicitly state what plan they
want to be on.
I've also seen some problems with people applying for pay who essentially like
they don't get their forms processed at a minimum amount of time.
And then they get switched over to a processing forbearance while they're
waiting.
And then they get switched into some sort of additional administrator
forbearance after they haven't finished processing the pay forms.
So I think all the servicers are just kind of hoping for some sort of court
ruling or executive order to get more clarity as to what they should be doing
with their job.
I think department of ed staff,
the new administration hasn't fully staffed it up yet.
We still don't have a secretary of education.
So you know,
you kind of have to have all those people in their seats confirmed to start
telling the servicers what to do for us to really see any action here.
Keep in mind,
the servicers really do look to the FSA group and say,
what do we do?
What do you want us to do?
And they're looking for direction from department of ed.
And right now,
of course,
the department of ed is just chaos.
There isn't anybody really making decisions over there.
So you have to have actual decision makers to see any movement in a lot of this
stuff.
So let's take a,
let's take one more question.
Hello,
I'm an engineer.
My wife is a public school teacher with about six out of 10 years of qualifying
payments for PSLF using the payee program.
And we file taxes separately.
If she takes a few years off from working to have children and we continue to
file taxes separately and she remained on the payee repayment plan indefinitely,
can she continue to file a tax return as married filing separate,
even with no income for income verification purposes?
And what are payments go to zero as long as her married filing separate tax
return shows no income.
I understand she wouldn't be earning qualifying payments until she returns
to having qualifying employment,
but I want to make sure my income will never affect her monthly payments or
payments are currently zero per month while making qualifying payments,
which is why we never signed up for the safe plan.
But we expect that to change soon with the upcoming income verification
deadline in a few months.
So the answer to this one is a simple,
yes,
you can remain on the pay program indefinitely.
If you are not working,
you just have to make sure that you continue filing your IDR recertification
when you're asked for it.
And you know,
if you are not getting any credit towards PSLF,
I think the question would be,
how sure are you that,
you know,
that she would go back to full-time work in the not-for-profit or government
sector,
right?
Because if you were positive that she would be going back,
well,
then she could just decide,
well,
I just want to use forbearance instead and not have to take that big tax hit,
which will be a temporary hit when you file separate.
You can amend your old returns up to three years in the past and get any excess
taxes you paid for filing separate return deal.
But that's a little bit of a process.
It takes a while.
You know,
most people would be paying some professional services fees to a tax preparer
to do that amendment for them.
And so when you,
depending on what your income is,
let's say you have a $200,000 income and you know,
she has a $0 income.
That could be a pretty substantial,
several thousand dollar penalty.
So the question would be,
you know,
do you have the stomach for it?
Do you want to do that?
Is this really like probably two or three years taking offers that longer than
that?
And then,
you know,
if it's longer than it might as well,
might as well stay on the pay plan and just try to continue building credit
towards 20 year forgiveness,
just in case,
you know,
she decides to,
you know,
go back to work part time or maybe in the private sector or,
you know,
does it,
does it end up in a job that gives her credit that actually results in like the
PS left type forgiveness.
So that's a good question.
We're going to transition here to now talking about just the,
Trump slash Musk battle over department of ed and just some thoughts that I have
about it.
Keep in mind these,
you know,
recordings that you heard were all people that went to studentloanplanner.com
slash voicemail.
So if you want to ask your own question about something chaotic happening with
student loans,
just go to studentloanplanner.com slash voicemail.
And we'd be happy to answer your question live on one of our future podcast
episodes.
So studentloanplanner.com slash voicemail.
Now let's transition to talking about the Trump,
Musk Doge war over department of ed.
Okay.
So if you have the world's richest person sending people over to department of
ed,
combing through their data files,
and that's been a focus of theirs for a while,
and they have people embedded at the top floor of department of ed and you had
house Democrats go over,
March over to the front door of department of ed demanding to be allowed to
enter to have a meeting to discuss their concerns about department of ed being
dismantled.
You know,
all of those things understandably create concern and worry and anxiety,
right?
So like I do think that history matters here,
you know,
department of ed,
they tried to abolish it in the Reagan administration.
They failed to do so.
The higher education act talks a lot about the secretary of education with the,
especially with the amendments that have been,
that have been done since then,
right?
That's all the amendments to the higher education act put in,
you know,
the secretary of education shall.
And when you think about like the student loan program,
the student loan management of everything with the department of ed,
like they can't just move that to the treasury department or some other
department without some sort of legislative approval.
And it would have to be some sort of,
you know,
probably have to have bipartisan support.
I say probably because everything seems so uncertain these days,
but it certainly to me seems like,
you know,
moving student loans to a new outside agency or something like that is just not
on the cards.
Now I like to really think about the politics of stuff when I'm thinking about
how likely something is to happen,
right?
So I don't know if you guys have seen the stuff about the NIH funding,
the grant funding getting,
you know,
maybe indirect costs getting slashed,
right?
That's creating all this worry in the university community.
You know,
my wife applies for a lot of these grants,
you know,
sort of as a full disclosure.
So she's really worried about a lot of this,
this stuff.
A lot of our readers and listeners are,
you know,
researchers or have,
you know,
either applying for research grants themselves or know people who are.
So there's a lot of worry about that.
And what did you see in the media when we started seeing,
you know,
a lot of the talk about cutting back on these programs?
One of the people that spoke up was Senator,
I believe Brit from,
I think that's her name,
from Alabama.
You know,
she was the person chosen to deliver the response to the State of the Union
that was sort of you could say,
mocked by Scarlett Johansson and SNL,
if you remember that one.
So she's a very much a member of the,
you know,
MAGA coalition.
And,
you know,
she was expressing,
you know,
extreme concern over University of Alabama at Birmingham because UAB is one of
the top recipients of these types of NIH grants and research grants that fund a
ton of research and,
you know,
top professionals in that community,
in that hospital system.
And she's speaking up for continued funding for that.
So I think that what we're hearing right now is the honeymoon period where,
sure,
let's just take a wrecking ball at all these things,
right?
But what we have not really seen yet is any of the political pushback.
And that's really the context that I wanted to encourage people to think about.
So a lot of these,
you know,
slashes or reversals,
whatever,
again,
you know,
they're going after programs that they can go after with executive orders because
it's potentially legal to go after them with executive orders for the things that
they can't fully end the executive order.
They're trying to put on funding freezes and halts to spending,
right?
But notice that they can't stop it permanently,
right?
So I want to be thinking about the context of all these different things.
Let's say that they issued a order halting all PSLF application reviews tomorrow.
Should you panic?
The answer would be no,
because they can't do it permanently at most.
I think they would be able to do it for maybe a couple months if they even tried
to do something like that,
which I don't think they will.
And you know,
why is that?
It's because when you have a house majority that's three seats,
you have a lot of frontline members in moderate swing districts that are very
concerned about winning reelection.
Like any politician would be.
And you know,
if you think about you know,
behavior of politicians in swing districts that are worried about reelection,
what do they do?
They prioritize their local interests when they have the ability to do so.
And I think that there's a lot of universities out there,
a lot of hospital systems out there that you might hear publicly.
There's a wrecking ball going to NIH or department of ed or whatever place,
but like behind the scenes,
you know,
these local representatives of different interest groups are going to be
fighting fiercely for their institutions to not be affected.
And that's why I would not be super concerned yet about what's happening with
department of ed,
with doge and other things.
Yeah.
I think that that's relevant to think about now.
I think that there,
you know,
there will be changes.
There's no question in my mind,
there will be changes,
right?
If you know,
we had,
you know,
the reversal of the PSF rules back to what they were before.
If we had,
you know,
IBR is the only payment option.
If we had,
you know,
slower processing of loan forgiveness or,
you know,
auditing of people's income information,
right?
I mean,
I think a lot of these things that could bite people are just like things that
are written into the rules.
So for example,
if you have an S corp,
right,
you have to include all sources of taxable income when you recertify your
student loans.
The easiest way to do this is if you're a business owner is just to give people
the tax returns that reflect your AGI.
You don't have to have any question marks about that,
right?
Where I think people could get in trouble would be if,
you know,
you only provide pay stubs when you have,
you know,
six figures of income from your K one and your,
you know,
dividends and your interest from your investments,
right?
The interesting thing to know about what the Biden administration did is they
removed language on the IDR application stating that all sources of taxable
income had to be accounted for in the recertification,
but then they didn't remove it on the paper form.
So if you want to talk about just ridiculous management of the student loan
system,
that's mixed messaging on the online application.
They just say you can recertify using,
and I'm not making this up.
They said,
you know,
you're paced up.
Then they said things like a letter from your employer,
a bank account statement,
like,
you know,
smoke signals from a pigeon from the world war one era.
I mean,
I'm joking about that last one,
but it was really kind of like the Biden administration saying,
we don't give a bleep about,
you know,
recertifying income.
We just want it to be as easy as possible so that everybody can go into IBR more
easily.
And you know,
if some high income positions get a really low payment that they shouldn't get
because we make it super easy to recertify income,
we don't really care.
That's really the Biden administration's position on,
on income recertification.
They kept pushing it off and off and off and never ever required people to
recertify their incomes simply because they didn't want people's payments to go
out before the election makes sense politically.
Right.
Trump administration,
do they have that same concern?
No,
he's not up for reelection again.
And I think that they in general view like higher education as sort of part of
the political opposition overall.
Right.
Which is why I think that you also see,
you know,
them going after places like USAID,
you know,
CFPB,
Department of Ed,
they're going after those kinds of places first because that's sort of like the
low hanging fruit in the highest percentage of people that probably in their
minds are not part of the political coalition.
So it's easy to easier to go after those groups.
But then you get this back channel influence campaign from people with specific
interest groups they represent,
like Senator Brett of Alabama fighting for UAB and other places like that around
the country.
And then everything gets moderated and made a lot less,
you know,
a lot less of a change.
That's just politics,
right?
How stuff kind of tends to work.
So it's kind of like a long explanation of,
do I think that we're going to see changes with Doge and stuff?
Yeah,
sure.
I do.
I think that recertifying income is one of the first changes I expect I'll make
at some point.
I expect ending the save plan,
forcing people onto some other repayment plan is one of the big changes we'll see
coming at some point that also could happen from you know,
the federal lawsuit that still hasn't been ruled on yet.
So hopefully that helps.
I know that this is an uncertain time and just keep in mind that if you're in
the safer brands getting 0% and you're not losing ground in the sense of the
loans,
at least not growing.
And in terms of your payments,
like for the future and counting for PSLF,
well hopefully you like your job and you'd be doing your work anyway,
regardless of PSLF.
If that's not the case,
if it's not true that you need a plan for not doing your job and still handling
your student loans in a responsible,
good way,
which is a very common reason people book consults for us is because they want to
leave their not-for-profit or government job,
but they don't want to wait around for PSLF and they need a plan for that.
That's actually a pretty doable plan.
You just have to think through implications of forgiveness in the private
sector.
And some people,
you know,
want to get PSLF,
but they want to get it as fast as possible because they want to have more
options around their employment being full-time or,
you know,
switching careers if they want to,
et cetera.
So I,
again,
I know it's stressful time.
If you want to relieve some of that stress,
one great way is by asking questions that we can feature on this podcast.
So if you go to,
again,
studentloanplanner.com slash voicemail,
ask your questions.
We know that this is a scary time,
but it's a time that we can hopefully help a lot of our community have a
lower stress and lower anxiety and more happiness in their lives.
So thank you so much for listening to the student loan planner podcast until
next time.
I'm Travis.
Have a great rest of your week.