The Unthinkable Is About to Happen to the Euro: Top Economist Warns

Global Finance News
11 followers
AI Generated·May contain errors
French police have fired tear gas at protesters
in Paris as thousands of demonstrators have
gathered across France in a day of action.
The interior minister said more than half a
million people had taken part,
angry about the cost of living and other issues. It's so
Meet Steve Keen,
the economist
who predicted
the 2008 crash
before it happened.
Back then, almost nobody listened.
Now France is on fire, families with two incomes can't make ends meet,
And Keen says the real cause isn't where anyone is looking.
I know this is going to be a shock for most people
because you're used to thinking
the government just takes money out
of your bank accounts. But this is partially
just a question of perception.
It is completely wrong at the level of the accounting.
Well in the previous video in the series I showed using
the empirical data the Euro has failed in
its stated objectives of achieving stability and growth.
Instead it has brought instability and
stagnation to Europe.
In this video I'll explain the chief theoretical lie behind its failure
and this is the belief that high government debt
and large deficits are the main dangers
that a market economy faces.
This is why the Stability and Growth Pact put limits on both.
It proclaimed that government debt should not exceed 60% of GDP
or deficits should be no larger than 3% of GDP.
Now, in fact, these rules are based on economic fallacies.
The belief that government debt is dangerous is false,
and this fallacy is the foundation of the Stability and Growth Pact.
It is what has led, ultimately, to this revolt by French students
against the destruction of the French education system
in the name of fiscal responsibility.
When you understand the full monetary system,
you realize that excessive government debt
is not the main danger that capitalist economies face,
and that a responsible government should
run deficits and then use the money it creates in the process wisely.
Now, in this video, I'll prove using my Revell software,
firstly, that governments must run
deficits.
They must spend more than they take back in taxation
if they are to create fiat-backed money.
And secondly, that a government deficit does not take money
from the public, as economic textbooks claim.
In fact, it does the exact opposite.
It creates money for the private sector.
Once you understand the system,
you'll know that if France is going to restore itself,
it has to leave the euro and restore the franc.
The government should deliberately run deficits
to create fiat-backed money,
and those deficits should fund, amongst other things,
A quality education for all students.
And my computer program, Revelle,
is the only program that lets you understand
the entire monetary system.
And since everyone in France needs to know this
at the current stage of revolutionary fervor by its students,
I'm making Revelle free to download for anyone in France.
Just go to Revelle's website,
which is marketing.revelation.net.
If you're in France, a download voucher will appear.
Fill out your details
and you'll be able to download Revel for free.
Now, you don't have to, but if you'd like to thank me for this,
consider making a donation via donateopen.com slash profsteveking.
Think of Revel as a monetary telescope.
It's what you need to understand the monetary system
in the same way that humanity needed the telescope
before it was able to understand the structure of the cosmos.
Now, for 1,500 years,
Before Galileo perfected the telescope, anyone who did not believe
that the Earth was the center of the universe was ridiculed as a fool.
The same applies now to people like myself and Richard Murphy
and Stephanie Kelton when we claim against
the conventional wisdom that government debt is not dangerous.
Now, today, we know, of course, that Copernicus was correct.
The Earth rotated around the sun.
But when he first put his alternative idea forward,
the vast majority of people were believers
in the Earth-centric paradigm, and they ridiculed him.
If the Earth is moving, then why isn't there a permanent wind?
If the Earth rotates, then why do things fall straight back down
when you throw them straight up?
If the Earth rotates, then why aren't we flung off the Earth
like children on a merry-go-round?
It took an invention to prove that Copernicus was right,
and that invention was Galileo's telescope.
It enabled the planets to be observed in detail
and not merely just through eyesight.
When it revealed mountains on the Moon and moons orbiting Jupiter,
the days of the Earth-centric vision of the universe were numbered
Now, the conventional economic models of money today are, frankly,
even more deluded about the structure of the monetary system than
the Ptolemaic model was about the structure of the universe.
At least Ptolemaic astronomers could predict where
the planets would be in the future.
Mainstream economists didn't see the global financial crisis coming
when that was the biggest event since the Great Depression.
Now, they're the ones warning about government debt being dangerous.
So I did see the global financial crisis coming,
and I'm saying that government debt is not dangerous.
But most people side with the mainstream economists.
They think by analogy to household debt,
that since a household which spends more than it earns
can go bankrupt, then so can a government.
This is why I invented Revel.
Amongst its many features is the capacity to show
an integrated picture of the financial system.
Using something that most people think is boring,
which is in reality as revolutionary in economics
as a telescope was to astronomy.
Double entry bookkeeping.
So this shows you Revel's interface with a few godly tables loaded.
And now I'm going to go through and do the accounting
to show what actually happens when
the government runs a deficit.
Now, I know the very thought of accounting, most people fall asleep.
But once you understand double-entry bookkeeping,
you will know that the Eurozone obsession
with minimizing government deficits is a monumental mistake.
So I'm going to take you through step-by-step,
outlining the most basic operations of the
government levying taxes.
And since I know from experience how foreign
this way of thinking about money is for most people,
even though it's obviously very straightforward for me,
I'm going to take it very, very slowly.
Of course, I know I often get criticised for going too fast,
so here's the opposite for you.
Well, if this video has alerted you to the fact
that what you thought you knew about economics is wrong,
you'll thoroughly enjoy the free book bundle
that has been requested by over 5,000 people already.
It's worth $50, but it's free right now.
Click on the link in the description or go to stevekeen.com
and click on the black button and fill in your information.
In about 60 seconds, you'll get the free book bundle.
And after that, if you want to study with me personally
and use my proprietary software, Revel,
There'll be an invite to join that course as well.
I'm going to start with something that everyone,
from raving anti-government free enterprise advocates on the right
to revolutionary Marxists on the left, simply has to agree with.
And that's that taxation takes money out of our bank accounts.
So in Revel, this undeniable fact looks like this.
Here we have taxation.
So tax dollars per year are taken out of bank accounts.
And that obviously reduces the net worth of the...
For households and firms, and notice that means a minus tax up here.
What's the balancing item at the level of the banking system?
Because for double entry bookkeeping,
all entries must sum to zero in terms of this
equation that assets minus liability minus equity must equal zero.
So I've got to put another entry here,
and it happens to be minus tax in the reserve
column.
Now, why does it happen?
Why is it reserves that fall at the level of the banks?
It's because at the level of the central bank,
funds are being transferred from reserve accounts
to the treasury's bank account at the central bank.
And that, of course, increases the net worth of the treasury.
So I hope it's obvious from this level
that taxation takes money out of private bank accounts
and transfers it to the treasury.
Now, what about the opposite operation of government spending?
Now we have spending,
and that obviously takes funds out of the treasury account.
And reduces the net worth of the treasury.
Those funds increase what's in reserves.
What increases reserves increases deposits.
And therefore, spending increases the amount
of money in private sector bank accounts.
And makes the private sector better off.
I know this is going to be a shock for most people.
Because you're used to thinking
the government just takes money out of your bank accounts.
You can't see the government putting money.
into your bank accounts.
But this is partially just a question of perception. We all see our
tax returns. We all see the money coming out
of our accounts for paying taxation. We don't see
the government spending money buying goods
and services off the private sector. We don't see
government employees shopping at supermarkets
and realize those funds go to the cashier and so on.
But fundamentally, the accounting tells you
if the government spends more than it takes back,
in taxation, then it increases the amount of money
in private bank accounts. Whereas economic
textbooks and the concepts that modern day politicians learnt
when they were students
and are now imposing upon the Eurozone, they learnt the exact opposite.
They get taught that
government spending takes money out of the private sector.
It is completely wrong at the level of the
accounting. Now, Revelle doesn't just let you see
the structure of the system, it also lets you model it
So I'm going to rapidly build.
A model now saying, what is the impact
of the government running a deficit on the private sector?
Let's add some of the elements here.
So I want to see what happens with deposits, reserves,
spending and taxation, and the Treasury's accounts.
I'm going to use a very simple trick that has
been used by economists from one extreme
of political economics to the other, from Milton Friedman to Karl Marx.
At some stage, they've all used a model
in which GDP is generated by the turnover of
existing money.
So if I multiply deposits by the velocity of money, I then get GDP.
Next, I'm going to relate the level
of government spending and taxation to GDP.
So I'm going to argue there's a spend rate
that gives you the spending and a tax rate
that gives you the taxation.
Now, of course, the gap between spending and taxation is the deficit.
I want to show the deficit as a percentage of GDP.
So that's the complete model.
Now, what I want to see is what happens in this model
when the government runs a deficit
to deposits, to reserve accounts,
and the treasuries account at the central bank.
Now, I can run the model and see what happens
if the government runs a deficit versus when
it runs a surplus by having taxation greater than spending.
So if you start at spending and taxation being the same, nothing happens.
If spending is greater than taxation by 1% of GDP or 2% or 3%,
the money supply grows
and so does GDP.
But if the government thinks it should cut out
the deficit by increasing the tax rate,
then ultimately it causes the economy to go down.
It declines, the amount of money is being reduced,
economic activity is being reduced
as well.
So the government should normally spend more than it takes back
in taxation and that creates
money which enables the economic activity of the economy to grow.
So what the Eurozone rules are doing
is reducing the capacity of France to produce.
It's not increasing it,
it's not fiscal responsibility, it's fiscal stupidity.
Now one thing you might think that I haven't covered yet
is the issue of government debt.
In this extremely simple model,
but in fact I have because as you can see from this chart,
the deficit pushes the treasury into negative at the central bank.
Its account goes into overdraft
and that is a form of debt,
but it's nothing like an overdraft for a private entity.
An overdraft is a real problem for a household or firm.
If your bank account goes negative,
then your bank can point blank refuse to honour any payments you try to make.
Out of that account, and there's nothing you can do about it.
If it lets you go into overdraft,
then your bank will charge you a penalty rate of interest.
And if your debt gets too high for the bank's liking,
it can initiate bankruptcy proceedings
against you and take your assets away.
So overdrafts can be useful,
but they're also extremely dangerous for private entities.
Now, none of this applies to the Treasury and the central bank.
For starters, the Treasury owns the central bank.
If it wants an overdraft,
it can compel the central bank to give it one.
And this actually happened during COVID
for some governments around the world when they
wanted to spend right away
and didn't want to waste time going through the system they
currently have of requiring private bond sales to occur first.
Secondly, the Treasury doesn't face
the penalty interest rate problems that private borrowers
face.
In fact, in most countries,
the Treasury does not pay interest on bonds owned by the central
bank at all.
Either that or any income the central bank makes
is ultimately remitted to the treasury anyway.
But it does look bad if the creation of money
for the private sector by the government
pushes the government's account at the central bank into an overdraft.
Now there is, as it happens, a very simple solution.
The treasury can sell bonds to the central bank
and the central bank can give the funds needed for the deficit
and that prevents the government's account
at the central bank from going into overdraft.
So I'll add that now to the model.
Now we have bond sales to the central bank,
and that gives sale revenue to the treasury,
but it also creates a liability for the treasury,
which are these bonds that are owned by the central bank.
That increases over here.
It increases the assets and the liabilities
of the central bank at the same time.
And now we can say, what does that sale equal to?
If the sale is equal to the deficit,
and we now run this model again,
And also graph.
The bonds that are now owed by the central bank
and obviously are a liability of the treasury
and I run this model again starting from spending being equal
to taxation. Nothing happens. If the
government spends more than it takes back in taxation
then the government's account at the
central bank, the treasury's account, remains non-negative.
It doesn't go into overdraft.
The bonds owned by the central bank rise,
as do reserves, and the economy grows as well.
And if the government makes the mistake of believing that it should
be running a surplus instead, that actually reduces economic activity.
It's not what you want to have happen, but this is what lies behind
the malaise of the euro in general and the malaise
that has led to the decline of French education to the stage
at which students are willing to take to the streets to fight it.
Now, the students...
are doing the right thing.
They need to take the fight to the state,
which does not understand how money is created
and imposes a system which actually reduces
the welfare of the private sector as well as the government.
Direct sales of government bonds to the central bank
are banned in most countries, not just the Eurozone.
But these bans have been drafted by people
who do not understand the monetary system.
There is nothing in the accounting which prevents
these sales from taking place.
And if they do, then government debt remains entirely within
the government system.
So how can it be a problem?
The real problem is that people
who don't understand the monetary system are in charge.
Now, if the French Revolt is going to overcome
the real problems that France faces, then
it has to overthrow these false models of money as well.
These are the real source of the decline
in the quality of the French educational system.
In the next video on this series,
I'll show how the current system, which forces the Treasury
to sell bonds to the private sector,
is actually the worst possible way of managing government
spending.
