Tech Jobs: Massive Job Cuts Now, Who's Next? | Eric Basmajian

Loan Hub
4 followers
#finance
#financement
0:00 - AI Layoffs: Is Your Job Safe?
2:01 - Why Hiring Is So Weak Despite Low Layoffs
7:03 - White-Collar vs. Blue-Collar Jobs: Who's Most at Risk?
11:36 - AI Productivity: Who Benefits From the Gains?
18:35 - Will AI Cause Structural Unemployment?
24:17 - Why Americans Feel Worse About the Economy
27:42 - Small Businesses Face Growing Uncertainty
33:59 - Why Young Workers Are Struggling to Find Jobs
37:51 - Fed Rate Hikes, 2027 Wage Outlook, and Housing Risks
AI Generated·May contain errors
People are afraid of is the structural unemployment where
these jobs just disappear from the economy.
The jobs that tend to be automated away first
are what seems like more of the junior roles
where the tasks are more automated and repetitive.
80 to 85% of the productivity gains are accruing to corporate profits,
and the remainder is accruing to real income gains
in the sectors that are generating the productivity.
Big companies are cutting staff in the name of AI. Again.
Microsoft just offered buyouts earlier
this week to as many as 60,000 workers.
Now, this is voluntary, so it's not technically a layoff,
but at the same time, American Express
is cutting 5% of its workforce to, quote-unquote,
prepare for AI.
Interestingly, weekly job disclaims are near
the lowest level since the late 1960s,
and employers added just 29,000 jobs in September.
How come there are so few people applying for job disclaims
Well, at the same time...
So few new jobs being added.
And ultimately, is your job safe?
Well, prices are up 3.7% from a year ago,
while paychecks are up 3%,
meaning real wage growth is stalling.
What happens then when automation
becomes even more prevalent?
Well, right now on CalSheet,
traders are predicting a 48% chance
that there will be more white-collar layoffs
in 2026 than in 2025.
If you agree with those odds,
a $50 trade could yield $94 if you're correct.
Our next guest will offer his outlook.
Stay tuned.
This video is sponsored by Cauchy,
the largest prediction market in the United States.
Unlike a sportsbook, you're trading peer-to-peer
on real-world events from economic data to political outcomes.
And the price moves based on public opinion, not a house.
Go to the link in the description down below
or scan the QR code here and use my code LIN.
Lin, L-I-N.
New users who use my code
can get $25 in app credits
when they trade $25.
Kaoshi is CFTC approved
and available in all 50 states,
including California and Texas.
Eric Basmajian returns to show once more.
He runs EPP Research,
where he forecasts the business cycle
and recession risks for hedge funds,
real estate firms,
and other investors.
Check out his research
as well as his great YouTube channel.
Links down below.
I'll put them there
so you can check it out.
Welcome back to the show, Eric.
Good to see you.
Good to be with you, David.
The housing market is also top of mind
for many people right now as mortgage rates
inch higher. So we'll talk about that today.
But let's talk about whether or not your job is safe.
By your job, I mean, you know, the people watching.
I know your job is safe, Eric.
Your job is always going to be safe.
We always need people, smart, bright economists like you.
Thank you.
Podcast.
Podcasters, I don't know.
Talk to me in five minutes.
Anyway, for now, your job is safe.
But everybody else's, like I mentioned,
60,000 people are eligible, according to a person
familiar with the matter, for a buyout.
That is Microsoft.
Microsoft now.
That's just one company.
What's the bigger picture right now with layoffs
and companies cutting jobs because of AI?
So we'll start with the broader picture
of what's going on with the labor market and
then maybe try and tie it into what's going on with the AI trends.
So what we see happening with the labor market per the data,
and the data not just being
one source like jobless claims, which you mentioned,
which I believe is actually a quite
good measure of the labor market,
but we have lots of different measures.
We have the...
Jobless claims data, we have the employment report
that comes out once per month, we have
the jolts from the BLS.
And when we triangulate all of these metrics,
what we're seeing across the data is that
the firing or the layoffs are pretty low,
really lower than they were before the pandemic,
just pretty a low level of layoffs
and layoffs are a specific thing as measured by the data.
And like you mentioned,
These Microsoft buyouts wouldn't be considered layoffs.
They essentially would be voluntary
quits if somebody took it and left.
This is all important because what the data is
showing is that the layoffs are very low.
But what they're also showing is that
Hiring is extremely weak.
So what I'm going to show here on this chart, if you could see it,
is this Substack article I wrote on on layoffs and the job market.
So what we can see is that the layoffs
are very low per the jobless claims,
the data that comes out every week.
But what I want to draw everyone's attention to is this metric
that we calculate, which is the continued claims.
Per initial jobless claim,
so essentially what this is measuring is if somebody files
a jobless claim, how long on average
are they staying on those jobless claims?
A proxy for the re-uptake into the labor market or re-employment,
proxy for hiring essentially.
And what you can see is that the current level is 8.7 weeks
and it's been rising since 2023.
And it's higher than 88% of all readings since 1967,
including all the recessionary periods.
So the data is very clear in saying that layoffs are low,
but hiring is extremely weak.
So the trend that we're seeing
is perfectly encapsulated by Microsoft, which is
A lot of voluntary quits, a lot of retirements,
none of that gets picked up in layoff data.
So companies are sort of letting
their headcount right-size through attrition rather than layoffs.
They're going to let people early retire or retire or quit,
and they're just simply not
going to replace them.
And that's what we're seeing, broadly speaking, with the labor market.
So if you're an incumbent and you have a job,
Getting laid off is not super common,
but if you're looking for a job, it is particularly
challenging out there, and this situation
does fall disproportionately on the younger
workforce, people coming out of college,
because if you've never had a job before, you're solely
dependent on the hiring market, which is pretty weak at the moment.
That's the broad picture of what's going on in the labor market.
And then if we look at the types of layoffs that's happening,
specifically the tech sector,
I mentioned Microsoft, Amex as well,
American Express laying off 5% of its workforce.
You know, I'm somebody with a job.
I have, let's say, a savings in a 401k.
How concerned should I be is my question.
Well, it does depend on what sector that you're in.
And it is if you are getting laid off, which as a
Percentage of the entire economy is appearing
to be quite low based on the data. But if you are one
of those people, the hiring market
is more challenging than it has been historically.
So it may take longer to find a new job.
I mean, there are, of course, some pockets of
the labor market that have hiring and jobs in high demand.
But if we're just taking averages
and averages and averages,
if you are one of the people that does get caught up in a layoff,
The hiring market is particularly challenging.
Challenged relative to history.
So it will be more difficult to find a job, all things being equal.
Kaoshi has specifically more white collar layoffs in 2026 than 2025.
48% only.
So mixed.
It's not heavily skewed in one direction or another.
But it does specifically target white collar layoffs.
Are white collar jobs more at risk even today than blue collar jobs
with the advent of robotics?
And, you know, manufacturing at risk.
Yeah, this remains to be seen.
And this is definitely a situation where people
who are making the case that this time it's
going to be white collar jobs that drive the recession may be correct.
But to be perfectly clear,
this would be a this time is different scenario.
When you look at the labor market going back across history, all
Economic recessions, all downturns are caused by construction
and manufacturing. Those are the
volatile sectors. Those are the ones
that are interest rate sensitive. And those are the ones
that have multiplier effects.
So the way that downturns or recessions are caused is a tightening
of monetary policy impacts the interest rate sensitive sectors
of construction and manufacturing.
Those sectors have job losses and layoffs.
Those people who become unemployed
Put downstream stress on the rest of the economy,
like the services and the white-collar jobs,
which then only experience layoffs once there's
already pretty significant economic distress.
If you're going to make the case
that this time there's going to be no...
I mean, monetary policy
doesn't have a way
of impacting sectors
that are not interest
rate sensitive.
Just based on history and based on the way that the cycle works,
I would take the case that this
time is not going to be different
and any significant labor market stress would still
emanate from construction and manufacturing.
You are definitely seeing some changes in some of the
white-collar labor force,
but there's no evidence yet that those types of job losses are large
enough or significant enough
or have the multiplier effects to create a broader economic recession.
So I still think the
The key part of the labor market is going
to be those blue collar construction and manufacturing jobs,
which at the moment are increasing.
Yeah, increasing, I think, because of data centers.
I was talking to a real estate expert not too long ago,
and they were making the case that, well, in the U.S. at least,
it's difficult for construction companies
and home builders to actually fill positions because the data
center construction companies and sites have been so competitive.
With people, you know, everything from HVAC installers
to the actual construction crew themselves.
Yep, that's exactly what the data is showing.
Yeah, exactly what the data is showing.
So we're seeing a very small decline in residential construction jobs.
Those jobs are falling about 1% year over year, which is not that much.
Sort of mild job losses in residential.
But we're seeing very strong...
GAINS IN NON-RESIDENTIAL CONSTRUCTION.
OVER THE PAST YEAR, WE'VE SEEN OVER 100,000 JOBS GAINED
IN NON-RESIDENTIAL CONSTRUCTION, WHICH IS MOSTLY DATA CENTERS.
BUT WHAT THE DATA CENTER BUILDOUT, THE AI BUILDOUT IS CAUSING
IS IT'S CAUSING A MULTIPLIER EFFECT THROUGH EVEN MANUFACTURING SECTORS.
LIKE YOU MENTIONED, YOU TAKE DURABLE GOODS MANUFACTURING,
WHICH IS TRANSPORTATION EQUIPMENT.
Business equipment, you know, cooling equipment,
all that stuff that you mentioned, it's not
only the construction workers that need
to install that equipment, there's been a pretty
broad multiplier effect in the manufacturing of that equipment.
So manufacturing jobs in the durable goods
categories have started to increase over the
last six to eight months as well.
So that's the part of the labor market
that's actually doing quite well, which is, you know,
Broadly speaking, construction and manufacturing,
pocket of weakness in residential, but construction
and manufacturing broadly are doing pretty well.
That historically has been one
of the number one recessionary signals from the labor market
itself, which would be a downturn in construction
and manufacturing employment.
We don't see that at all right now.
We see the opposite, which is why, in my view,
recession risk in the very near term is low,
with the one watch area being residential construction,
because that area is still losing
jobs albeit somewhat mildly.
We're talking offline about AI productivity.
Can we just revisit that chart one more time?
Yeah, absolutely.
So this is a preliminary data.
If you could see this chart here, this is a...
This is preliminary data, so we take it with a grain of salt,
but what this is is a survey
from the Census Bureau.
And the Census Bureau surveyed AI adoption,
so what percentage of your industry is adopting
AI.
And the top three sectors that the Census Bureau identified
in their survey as AI adopters
were information technology, finance,
and professional services, things like accountants.
Of the top three AI adopting sectors,
I mapped their productivity trends as real output per
worker. You could see that at the end of 22,
so beginning of 23, there was a clear inflection
upwards in the productivity trend of the AI adopting sectors,
where the trend is much
more muted, pretty much just on pace
with normal history for the non-AI adopting sectors.
Now, what's interesting is that this stuff doesn't make it
into the broad aggregates
yet.
So if you look at broad aggregate productivity
growth, it doesn't look like it's changed
all that much because the top three sectors,
the top three AI adopting sectors, are only
about 15% of the workforce.
It's not that big.
Most of the economy still hasn't adopted AI.
Their productivity trends haven't changed.
And I want to be super clear
that there's some confounding variables here.
There was some over-hiring in 22.
Some of the increase in productivity could
be just right-sizing headcount, but I think
there's enough of a step function change
in the productivity of the AI-adopting sectors
that gives credence to the fact that there
is some productivity emerging from this technology
in the sectors that are adopting it.
Of course,
The sectors that are adopting it, technology,
professional services, finance, more computer
focused jobs, obviously are the ones
that probably have the most to benefit where the
technology stands at the moment,
where when you get into construction, manufacturing,
education, healthcare, maybe
a little bit more difficult on the adoption curve.
And perhaps we'll see the technology generate productivity
a little bit down the road.
But right now, we do see at least the early evidence
is suggestive that there is a real
productivity trend happening here.
Do you have any evidence to show
that productivity equals profitability?
Well, that's an interesting point.
So when there's productivity,
so people are circulating charts in a lot of different ways
on the productivity.
Some of it's revenue per employee,
which for a lot of software companies is going like
a hockey stick.
So those productivity gains.
Could accrue to the workers in terms of real income gains,
or they could accrue to more
profitability of the companies.
I don't have the chart with me on hand,
but what it looks like at the moment, since these
productivity trends have really started to increase,
is I estimate about 80% to 85% of
the productivity gains are accruing to corporate profits,
and the remainder is accruing to
real income gains in the sectors that are generating the productivity.
So for the most part, it's accruing towards corporations.
Corporate profitability,
which is not entirely uncommon in the early stages of a productivity
gain, because wages tend to lag.
They lag the business cycle.
It's more of a lagging indicator, wages.
So we're seeing some of the productivity emerge.
Some of the early signs are that it's
falling towards corporate profitability.
Corporations seem to be reinvesting a lot
of those profits back into more AI, at least
in these AI-adopting sectors.
So that loop is ongoing right now.
In an ideal world, you know,
the gains continue to accrue and then it starts to fall towards
real income.
That part still remains to be seen, which,
you know, people are rightfully a little bit
anxious about.
Productivity, is that a precursor to...
Thank
More layoffs.
The logic here is that if I were a business
and I see that the productivity overall of
my firm has increased,
meaning I can achieve a higher level of output with my current staff
or perhaps just the same level of output with less staff,
then I would be inclined to cut
you.
costs if I'm only concerned about the bottom line.
Sure.
Yeah.
So there's a couple of different things here,
and I'll try and summarize a few key points
without dragging on too long.
There's a couple different ways that we have to look at the situation.
One, if we take the entire economy, is real GDP per worker.
So are we able to generate the same
GDP with less people, essentially?
Or are we able to generate more GDP with the same
amount of workers? That's GDP per worker,
and I think most people anticipate that going up.
But productivity is also measured by GDP per capita.
So not how many people are working, just how many people there are.
We also need GDP per capita to increase over time.
So the average income for all people to go up over time.
People are a little bit more skeptical about
that because they feel like AI is going to
cause the same GDP with a lot less people.
So GDP per worker would go up, but GDP per capita would stay flat.
Throughout history, technology has always yielded increases
in both GDP per worker and GDP per capita.
So if this technology is like all other technologies,
then there will be gains
in GDP per worker and GDP per capita.
But there's a scary phenomenon. It's
the creative destruction process in economics.
And the destruction part is
It's scary, and that's valid for most people.
The gains don't come in the same industries
that the workers generally are displaced in.
So if a company, let's say in the software sector,
sees large benefits in productivity
and they need to carry a lot less workers, yes,
those workers potentially will be displaced
from software.
And we don't always throughout history see
The increases in employment come in the same sectors, of course.
What happens is those firms
or the shareholders of those firms that are now more profitable,
they'll either reinvest that money somewhere else
or they'll consume the money if they're
the shareholders. And then the demand signal will open up
in another industry where those
people will come in. But there's a lag there.
There's some friction in the workforce there.
This could take time. And the economy does move through
a transient period of unemployment in
in that process, which is difficult for some.
And we've tried to put
in place some automatic stabilizers to account for that.
But that's that's the that's sort of the million dollar question is,
yes, we all can see the
the job displacement.
But in economics, you can't see what you don't know.
We can't see where the demand signal will come in the future.
And that's where the new labor market will open up.
And at the moment, people just see the job losses,
but they don't see the potential benefit
downstream.
And that's what's causing a lot of the issues at the moment.
I think that was probably a good opportunity.
Good time to revisit some of the textbook definitions
of unemployment we all had to
read in Econ 101, but it's useful
to understand as well for the audience.
So there's frictional unemployment where people leave
their jobs to go work for something
else.
I don't like my job.
I'm going to look for another job.
I'm a skilled laborer,
so I'm not going to be an employer for very long.
There's structural unemployment caused by massive changes,
structural shifts, automation being potentially one reason.
There's cyclical unemployment where it really depends
on the business cycle, recessions being one of them.
And then there's perhaps seasonal unemployment
if you're somebody working in a sector.
Let's say for leisure that relies on good weather in the wintertime,
you're not going to have, you know,
I know towns where I live where by the wintertime it's dead.
Anyway, what type of unemployment are we talking about here
when we're discussing exactly what you just said?
Well, when we're discussing the AI,
it's more of that structural type of unemployment.
So that construction and manufacturing,
that's the cyclical business cycle employment.
And really what we do at EPB Research is business cycles,
which is why we're always focused
on those construction and manufacturing sectors.
We're not really talking about seasonal unemployment here.
And for the most part, this is not.
The frictional unemployment,
what we're really talking about or what people are afraid of
is the structural unemployment where
these jobs just disappear from the economy.
That's always what's very concerning because you can see
and you can anticipate the jobs going away,
but you can't see the jobs that will be created.
To use probably an overused example,
we used to be a mostly agricultural society.
Most people worked on farms.
At that time, people couldn't see 10 years in the future,
15 years in the future and
all of the new industries that will emerge.
I do believe that if this technology does
yield legitimate productivity, jobs will be
displaced in those sectors, but new jobs will be created in the future.
But it is difficult politically to
to hold that position
because people want answers now about what the jobs will be,
and there's going to be people that get caught up in the transition.
But this is the way that the economy kind of evolves over time.
But it feels like it's
happening on a big scale, or the fear
is that's going to happen on a big scale,
that structural unemployment.
That's really what we're talking about with this AI.
But tying it back to what we do at EPB is business cycle research,
which is why we're
focused on construction and manufacturing.
In this moment, as a result of a lot of this AI build-out,
we're seeing accelerations broadly
in construction and manufacturing,
low layoffs in construction and manufacturing.
That puts the near-term recession risk in the economy pretty low,
which makes us inclined
to be less concerned about
Big, large, sustained declines in the big,
broad indexes, equity indexes.
Now, going back to the initial claims
that are pretty low by historical standards,
is that because, are you seeing any evidence of that happening
because people are taking part-time jobs
and gigs so they don't need to file for claims,
even though, like you said earlier, hiring is also quite low?
Yeah, I'm really glad that you asked that,
because that's one of the pushbacks that I
receive most often, is that the jobless claims data
is perhaps not picking up on people working
gig jobs or thereabouts.
Let's talk about the jobless claims data for a second.
The jobless claims data is picking up people who are fired,
laid off from their job, and
then they file a jobless claim.
So the claim gets picked up when it's filed.
If you don't file, then you won't get picked up.
They've done surveys asking people why you file
or why you don't file, and some people
are suggesting that people aren't filing
because the benefits are so low.
All of the surveys have that at about 10%,
so people are not filing because the benefits
are so low, only at about 10%.
That's not really a primary cause of why people aren't filing.
The largest reason why people aren't filing
by the surveys is that they feel that they'll
But they'll get a job fairly quickly.
And it ends up being about 80% feel like they'll get
a job within about five weeks. So I'm not
going to go through the hassle of filing if I'm going
to find a job in a couple of weeks. That's
the largest surveyed answer about why people aren't filing.
If someone goes to work,
Part-time, we have other metrics in the Household Survey
of Employment that show part-time labor.
Also, if somebody is fired from a job,
but they do not file a jobless claim, they'll
be picked up in the JOLTS layoff rate survey.
And that's equally as depressed as the jobless claims data.
So if you don't file a jobless claim,
you still will get picked up in the JOLTS layoff
rate.
And we're seeing those two surveys corroborate each other,
which is evidence that the layoff
rate's low.
To your point, we do see a little bit of evidence
of part-time employment as a percentage of
the total creeping up, or multiple job holders rather, excuse me.
So there's some evidence that people are perhaps getting two jobs
or three jobs, two part-time
jobs or three part-time jobs, as opposed to one full-time job.
So there is a trend of that, but largely speaking,
The concept of jobless claims not giving
an accurate reading of the layoff situation in
the economy doesn't appear to be borne out
by any of the data that we can triangulate.
There's some uptake of gig economy work,
but in that case, you are employed, you're not
unemployed, and that would show up
in multiple job holders or part-time.
Those aren't really out of whack based on the data.
Okay, before we go back to your research,
you have some interesting research on interesting
charts rather on the demographics for age,
but this is the Michigan Consumer Sentiment
Index, lowest of all time.
Is there a relationship between how consumers
are feeling based on their sentiment versus
the realities of the labor market?
I would suspect that the sentiment survey partly reflects
their current employment status
and their outlook for employment.
Yeah, the sentiment surveys have been declining
and in my view is this is mostly a function
of real income.
So real income and this is this ties
into a little bit of the low hiring environment.
So when the...
When the labor market's very robust and you have a lot of hiring,
that also coincides with a high
quits rate, is what it's called.
So if you have a job, you voluntarily quit the job
because you're pretty confident you can go find a new one,
perhaps at a higher pay.
What we see in the labor market now,
at the risk of being repetitive, is very low layoffs,
but hiring is very low, which means quits are very low.
Because people don't feel confident
that they can leave their job and go find a new one,
so I'm just going to stay put.
But that fear about not being able to find a new job
also ties back to wage growth and sort of your bargaining
power, where if you feel that the labor market's very cold
and you don't want to quit and go find a new one,
your employer generally gets the same sense, too.
So they're less likely to give large increases in pay.
So there's a leading relationship
between the quits rate and hiring rate and wage growth.
So while layoffs are low, hiring and quits are low,
which is tying back into relatively
low wage growth.
We're seeing wage growth in the 3% to 4% range.
But if inflation is in the 3% range,
that means real wage growth is coming in at about 1%.
Now, 1% is still positive, so it's likely a positive trend.
But what really matters to
people is the gap between what they expected
and what they're currently realizing. And over long
periods of time, people generally grow accustomed
to about 2% to 2.5% real wage growth. And for
And for several years now, we've been getting...
on average, about one.
So there's a one and a half percentage point gap between what people
expect over the long run and what they're getting. And that doesn't
show up year to year. But when you start to compound
that four years in a row, five years in a row, six years in a row,
that gap between where you thought you'd be and where you are is 10,
12, 15 percentage points different.
And then people feel sort of a decline in their standard of living.
And it makes them feel generally pessimistic about the environment.
And that's the situation that we're in today.
And it's very perplexing because, you know, the layoffs are low.
But because the hiring market is so weak, the quits rate is weak.
People don't feel confident in the labor market.
Wage growth is.
positive but low, most of it's being swallowed by inflation.
And this is leaving people in a
situation where they're generally employed
at a real wage growth that's pretty depressed.
So you're employed, but you're really
not feeling like you're moving ahead very much.
And it makes some of the big ticket items like housing
and durable goods like cars
very unaffordable. And that's what's keeping
the sentiment surveys very depressed.
So yeah, even though you're probably not unemployed,
you're not feeling great about
your finances either, is what you're saying.
That makes a lot of sense. I want to talk about
how small businesses are operating, what they're planning.
I actually spoke with the director of the
Research Department for the NFIB, Holly Wade,
and we went over the latest findings here.
Current job openings of the member survey, 32% only.
Plans to increase employment, net 17%.
Plans to make capital outlays, 22%.
Now, historically, these are a little bit low,
but the key that she was making with me is that this year has been a...
Very uncertain year.
In other words, what made this report unique
from September was that people, small businesses
have been feeling more uncertainty than in prior years.
Now, uncertainty doesn't necessarily mean we're in a recession.
In fact, actually, if you look at the uncertainty index
that comes in later in the report, you
can see that actually during recessions,
the uncertainty goes down because people know
for a fact they're not doing well.
Um, it's, it's, it's in this kind
of limbo period where it's like, I don't know if the
economy is going to grow.
I don't know if I need to, you know, lay people off.
I don't know what tariffs are going to do.
Um, so can you comment on what small businesses have been planning
and, um, the data you've
looked at the small businesses do account for,
I think, 45% of the, um, uh, GDP and
something close to that in terms of, um, employment as well.
Right.
Yeah.
Well, well, you said it right there with,
with tariffs as one of the explanations, but
But broadly speaking,
A K-shaped economy is what people are calling
this now to describe certain households that
are doing well and then a large percent
of the population that's not doing well.
The same concept is applied to the business world where most
of the industries, the major
industries are seeing larger and larger concentrations.
Healthcare is an obvious example, big technology is an obvious example.
Big, massive firms are taking up larger and larger shares,
while smaller firms are increasingly
having more difficult time.
This is related to things like tariff policy,
which has been quite erratic, but it's more
emblematic of the fact that the government has grown
in size quite big with all developed
economies around the world.
So the biggest advantage that you can have is a close relationship
with the government or lobbying efforts to get insights on regulations
and tariffs and waivers and all this type of stuff, which causes more
uncertainty for small businesses that disproportionately don't have
that access compared to larger companies that.
Tariff policy is not a huge concern for them
because they are able to sort of anticipate what's going on,
get the key access, have these, you know,
really large integrated supply chains, which they control largely,
as opposed to someone who's beholden to all of those factors.
So, I think this largely just speaks
to an increasing industry consolidation where there's
more industries that have few very large players and then an overall
Large increase in government size across all developed economies,
which makes gaming government policy
an increasingly large part of doing business.
And that's more difficult for smaller businesses than it
is for larger businesses. Tariffs being one key example.
Tariffs were floated at 20%, 30%, even as high as 50%.
And what we ended up seeing
was the effective tariff rate moved from about 2.5% to about
11%, and it's already come back to about 8%.
So these huge policies were floated,
then they were taken back, and then the price of
coffee beans went up, so they took the tariffs off,
and it's been largely erratic.
In my view, more emblematic of just the encroachment
of government into economics makes things
more difficult as opposed to a little bit more free market.
But I think most developed economies are pretty far past that.
But just on the prospect of being replaced by automation,
I guess it really depends on
the sector, right?
My question is...
Would it be safer if I were working
for a small business versus a large business?
Microsoft and many others have the flexibility,
I guess, of cutting off thousands of people.
And...
They're OK. If I were a small business employing only a few employees,
every person counts.
And so the friction that I, as a business owner, would incur if I
were to lay off one person in anticipation of replacing him with AI,
well, I still have to suffer some operational loss before I do that.
And so unless I'm very certain that I will have productivity gains
or it's already happening.
I'm probably not going to lay people off just because of AI.
And we're seeing that in some of the survey testimonials at the NFIB.
What do you think?
Yeah, I think that's absolutely fair.
And I think it just is a little bit more beta. Some of these
things are a function
also of just how the business is doing itself. So if the business
is losing share to another business that's using AI,
then some of those decisions have the luxury
of waiting for the productivity gains.
So I think you get pressure from both ends sometimes. But
largely speaking, there's just higher uncertainty
across small business in all aspects. And
It's not super surprising that there's
a high degree of uncertainty now.
I think the most interesting part of the chart
that you mentioned is that uncertainty drops
during recessionary periods.
And I think that's, again,
a confirmation of the fact that while times are uncertain,
people don't know what's going on.
People are just kind of hitting the brakes.
Hiring is very low.
That's another symptom of high uncertainty.
I'm certainly not going to expand operations
at the moment if I really don't know what's
happening.
I'm just going to kind of hit the pause button, hit the brakes.
Sometimes, that leads to an accumulation of profitability
because they maybe could
have expanded if they were doing well.
I think this is just largely a good indicator
of what's happening in the economy right now.
I think all these data points
are tying together better than I think most people are giving
credit for.
This is a very important chart.
It says here, weak hiring is hitting younger workers first.
What are we looking at?
And ultimately, if I were a young person between the ages of 16 to 24,
or just right after university, what should I do to prepare myself
for the reality of current labor market conditions?
Yeah.
So this was part of our labor market piece,
which highlighted the low hire, low fire situation.
And the hiring market.
Is more impactful for younger workers because they exclusively
are interacting with the hiring market if you're coming out of college
and what we saw was the unemployment rate
for younger workers increased 300 basis points
when the labor market was slowing down from 7% to over 10%.
But it only increased less than one percentage point
for people over 25 generally more incumbents. And then we've seen
a little bit of a tightening of the labor market this year and it's
you know, helped both age brackets,
unemployment rates come down in both areas. But what we're
generally seeing is when the hiring market is really weak,
that disproportionately hurts
younger workers, which is a problem for society at large.
But if you were a younger worker,
Thank you, Parker.
you know, I would probably imagine
that having AI related skills would probably be
It would probably be...
Probably be at the top of the list, but then you know,
it's hard to look out too far in the future
because like that structural unemployment
We don't really know
But in this very moment, there's a pretty
Strong construction and manufacturing markets.
So there there probably would be some opportunities there
Yeah.
So that's that's an interesting area to look at as well
But you know, we we do see a lot of people going
to college with anticipation of going into you know technology
finance or professional services,
those are the heavy AI adopting sectors. So change is happening
first and fastest there. I guess it also speaks to the fact that yes,
there's low hiring, it doesn't
mean no hiring absolutely at all.
And I guess if employers if employers are prioritizing hiring
hiring people age 25 and over
who presumably have experience over training new grads with
little experience, what does that tell you?
In a few sentences about the state of the labor market?
Well, again, it speaks to the fact that the jobs that are being,
again, this is all early
evidence, but the jobs that tend
to be automated away first are what seems like more of the
junior roles where the tasks are more automated
and repetitive versus someone that may come
in with a high degree of skill that using
an AI tool can do the job of several junior
people.
with one person. So that's a pretty big structural problem for the future
when you think about it, because of young people, and I'm making
a generalization, obviously, young people still can find jobs,
maybe just, you know, maybe less than before.
But if young people who prior to this AI boom,
had no difficulty finding jobs, entry level jobs now
are struggling to find entry level jobs, they can't be trained.
And so they can't be hired as an experienced
person if they don't have that experience to begin with.
And so the question is, what happens, you know,
in five, 10 years to the labor market for young people?
Yeah, that's a key point.
And, you know, another confounding variable here is that...
One solution, if you can't find a job,
is to lower your price and just accept jobs at
lower wages.
But a lot of the younger cohort is graduating college
with lots of debt that was expecting
to earn a certain salary,
and they may not be able to command that salary, which is another
problem in and of itself.
Yes. Good. Eric, what happens to the labor market once
the Fed raises rates, presumably in December, if the odds
are correct from the markets and we have one hike by December?
Sure.
Well, every incremental tightening
of monetary policy will slow the economy more than if
they didn't do the tightening.
But where we stand right now per our assessment
of the economy is that the leading indicators,
excluding the residential construction sector,
but broadly speaking, our basket of leading
indicators is improving and corporate profitability
remains pretty strong across all corporations.
Therefore, the economy is likely to be able to withstand.
Higher interest rates here in the short term,
we will get to a point where they tighten policy enough
that we start to see those leading indicators come down,
the labor market starts to re-weaken,
and we go back towards potentially the recessionary process.
But I don't see that on the immediate horizon
the next couple of quarters, the next six months.
So my view is that even if the Fed does
raise rates in December, which they likely will, the economy still has
some time to be able to digest that without the leading indicators
and early sensitive parts of the economy rolling over.
What I would be looking for is the Fed
to continue tightening monetary policy,
and then we'll eventually see
that monetary policy tightness transmit through
residential construction, manufacturing, broader construction.
And if we start to see the labor
market and the associated industries really weaken there,
then you'll know that the economy is
likely headed towards another recessionary scare,
potential recessionary pocket. But I'd reiterate
I'll reiterate that that's not currently, I think in the,
In the forecast over the next couple of months here.
Finally, what is your forecast for real wage growth?
Yeah, real wage growth,
even though the economy does have some positive momentum, the economy
is dealing with, in my view,
structural factors that are keeping wage growth down.
Most of that is due to the extreme indebtedness
of the government sector and all of the secondary
and tertiary effects of what happens
when you have a large indebted government sector.
And I don't just mean debt to GDP.
I mean...
I have a post on my Twitter covering basically three ways
of looking at the government, which
is total debt to GDP, the deficit as a percentage of GDP,
and then raw government spending as
a percentage of GDP.
Government spending tells you just kind
of how involved the government is.
The deficit tells you whether it's funded with taxes
or funded with debt, and then total
debt kind of tells you the accumulated deficits.
The U.S. government is pretty.
Pretty weak spot on all three of those metrics.
Not as bad as France, which we're obviously seeing
a lot of issues at the moment.
But when the government gets this big across all three of
those metrics, it creates a lot of negative externalities.
And one of them is this depressed
real wages across the private sector.
So I don't think even though we have some positive cyclical
momentum, we have any real proposals to escape any
of these deeper structural issues that
In my view, emanate largely
from the government sector just being way too big.
We've well crossed the diminishing returns point where government
is actually quite beneficial
to the economy in small sizes initially.
It gets to the point where it becomes somewhat neutral,
and then it gets to the point where
it becomes a detriment.
And I think that most developed economies
are at the point of government size and intervention
that's a detriment.
I think we're certainly there.
So I don't think we'll escape those issues.
We're going to deal with some structural issues
on real wage growth, despite the fact that
That cyclically, we have some positive momentum right now.
Good. Excellent overview.
Anything else you're covering right now for your own research,
your own channel that we should be aware of?
Yeah, the biggest issues that we're following
are that watch point of residential construction.
Like I said, we view that the economy has some
positive cyclical momentum right now. And the
one area to watch, which is generally the area to watch,
is that residential construction housing
sector. And I'd remind the audience that as far as business cycles
and recessions are concerned,
it's not home prices you should be watching.
It's the actual residential construction activity.
That's what's tied to jobs.
That's what has the multiplier effect.
It's weak right now, but it's not weak enough
to offset the strength we're seeing
in non-residential construction and manufacturing.
So the relationship between all of those sectors
there is really what we focus on mostly.
That's what we've been writing about recently.
So at the moment, we still see some positive signs,
but we're watching that area pretty closely.
OK, great.
We'll put the links down below, Eric.
Where can we follow you?
You can follow me on all socials at EPB Research
or epbresearch.com and you can find all the
information there.
Highly recommend everybody to check out EPB Research,
and if you don't have time to read the reports, well,
find time, but also check out his YouTube channel.
That's a great channel where he summarizes a lot of his findings.
Good stuff, Eric. Thank you for joining us once more.
I'll speak to you next time. Take care for now.
All right. Always appreciate it. Thanks, David.
And thanks for watching. Please do like and subscribe.
Use my code LIN, L-I-N, when you sign up to Kaoshi.
Remember, new users who use my code get $25.
When you sign up and trade $25,
link down below or scan the QR code here.
