'Andromeda Diaz and the Reasonable Doubt' with Emily Galvin Almanza

Fox - 2 Detroit
17 followers
Oct 24, 2026
AI Generated·May contain errors
episode of What Happens With Sid,
I would like to welcome an amazing author, public defender. She
knows anything law, so she's always great, and her books are amazing.
Emily Galvin Almanza. Emily,
how are you? I'm really happy to be here.
Thank you so much for having me. Well, thank you so
much for coming on. And so I just finished reading one
of your books about Andromeda,
and I actually love how you incorporated the name.
But before we kind of take a look
At a couple of your different books, tell us a little bit about
who you are, where you're from, and what really made you decide,
hey, I want to take what I've practiced
and put it into books for other people to learn.
Absolutely. So I am from just south of you. I'm from Iowa.
I grew up in Iowa and Wyoming. And before I was a public defender,
I was actually a kid who needed to be defended.
And I had my own contact with the criminal legal system and a judge
who really changed my life, as I wrote about in The Price of Mercy.
which was my first book.
But then as a young defender, you know, I was walking into rooms
with kids who were not that much younger than me,
who had done stuff that I myself had done
as a young person, except for that they were black
and brown in East Los Angeles, and I had not been.
And another thing I realized when I
was representing these kids was not only that
their conduct was being viewed through this lens of threat.
What threat did they pose?
Instead of the lens we should apply to children,
which is what potential do they have? What promise
do they have, right? I
also learned that many of them had not had their first contact with the
police when they were 13 or 14.
It had started much younger when they were seven or eight
and adultified and criminalized and stopped
and questioned and searched walking home from school,
which is a deeply affecting,
even traumatizing experience for a young person. There's
studies showing that kids can disengage
from school as rapidly as the next day following
police contact. So after I wrote The Price of Mercy,
which is for grownups, I really wanted
to write something that could help teach kids about their rights,
about the law, and also kind
of convey that unique mix of like critical reasoning
and empathy that defines public
defense. So kind of teaching kids how to think like a lawyer,
even how to think like a public
defender. And most importantly,
destigmatizing conversations about criminalization, arrest,
police contact, because when kids are not afraid
to share their experiences and talk about what
they're seeing and hearing and what's happening to them,
we can all do a lot more to protect our
children. Most people don't know this.
Most parents have a safety procedure for if there's a fire
or stop, look and listen when you're crossing the road.
But 90% of children waive their rights
if they're stopped by the police.
And false confession rates, particularly among kids under
14, are extremely high. So as parents,
we need our kids to be talking about this because we also need
to learn what they are facing in their daily lives
and before we and that kind of takes us
you know to the story of Andromeda which
and i feel like a lot of times in the world that we
live in nowadays when you're black brown
or just any minority anytime you see a cop you're just
kind of like on pins and needles because you can honestly just
be minding your own business walking
down the street or not doing any traffic violations
and suddenly you're stopped or you're being looked
at and so you just automatically get on edge
and especially with kids like that kind of puts a
preset in their mind, like don't trust cops,
depending on the kind of interaction that they
have, you know, at such a young age, because of course,
everybody knows kids are very impressionable
when they're young. So that kind of puts
a precedent in their mind. But I want to go back
into your book, The Price of Mercy,
to help viewers a little bit, if they're not familiar
with it, what it entails and what would you say is maybe one
or two lessons you would like for
readers to take away from that particular book?
Yeah. So my book is about my experiences as a
public defender inside the criminal legal system
and also my own firsthand experience with it,
not as a professional, but as a system user.
And I wanted really to give ordinary people
the full spectrum of not only everything I had learned as a defender,
but all of the data and
research that's out there about how badly this system harms us,
how far away from safety and
justice it takes us, how it's actually undermining safety
and undermining justice. And then the
second half of the book, the first half
of the book kind of depressing because i tell everybody
all the bad stuff um but it's like you know for people for readers
who are like oh i want to know
what's happening in the darkest corners like come
on in i'm gonna tell you but the second half of
the book is all solutions because i've spent
the last like nine years of my life building a program
that i co-founded called partners for justice where we enhance
and expand public defense across
the country and this work is simple we provide more help
for public defender clients with things
like housing and jobs and treatment support.
But that simple work in the last nine years has
eliminated over 16,000 years of incarceration.
And there's a lot of different programs like this
that have so much promise, so much data behind them.
Simple things like after-school programs
can decrease youth involvement in violent crime by 50%.
Something as simple as painting the
sidewalks, adding street lighting,
fixing up dilapidated buildings can drop youth homicides
by 75%. So there's all these really promising things
that make our neighborhoods nicer and
more livable and also keep us much safer.
I wanted every voter to know what's out there
so that they can ask their lawmakers for the nice things
that we are currently being deprived of by
tough on crime ideology. And now kind of switching gears
to Andromeda story, it's Andromeda Diaz and
the reasonable doubt. And it's a middle grade mystery.
I found myself very intrigued that I'm
not even in middle school anymore.
But you really took the things that you've learned
when you were practicing law
and kind of not really dumbed it down, but you put it in a way
where kids, even me, and I'm almost 30,
can like grasp and understand and learn new things. Like
I've learned new things with the law, you know,
like when it comes to kids and if they're in a
room with a cop and an adult,
a lot of times they don't know that they can ask for maybe their
parent or a lawyer because they see the law that's in the room
and they automatically waive their
rights and i love the characters that you had in in the book
and andromeda you know she was
she had all these different you know she had
a wild brain where she had all these different ideas
and danny was just kind of like okay you know just like going
with the flow and you had humor in
there as well because i loved how danny was stuck
on noah you know throwing the frog and i was just
like oh this book was so well put together
so tell viewers a little bit more about Andromeda's
story and why you felt it was so important to kind
of put it in a perspective for young kids to learn
yeah so Andromeda and Danny go
to a school it's like any other school I love I loved writing this
book because there's no there's no villains
in it there's no like bad guy who's doing stuff at the
school like there's a bunch of grown-ups
who are working under the incentives and pressures that
grown-ups work under
and their friend benji is accused of a crime in the school context and
andromeda and her best friend sort
of feel like something's wrong with this accusation and they
want to find out what really happened they want
to possibly use andromeda's defense skills that
she has soaked up from living
with her public defender parents um to protect a friend so to
start with i really really love empowering kids i love books
that accurately rely on the fact that
kids are capable of so much more than we realize
and kids understand so much more than we realize
and they can do so much more
so books that really hand the reins to a kid character to do some wild
stuff i'm so here for that and andromeda
is absolutely that kid um actually in book two that
comes out next year andromeda is going to get
into real criminal court on a real felony case she's
going to real detention centers like she's she's doing the thing
so what i loved about writing this
book is you're right like as a mom i'm one
of those moms that like mixes zucchini and black
beans into various desserts.
And with the writing, like I'm kind of doing the same. There's a lot of
humor. There's a lot of jokes.
There's a lot of mystery and adventure, but also, you know,
I teach law students. I teach at Stanford law school
in the winter quarter. I'm giving these
kids stuff that is for like young attorneys,
like basic trial training skills. Like if your kid
reads this book, they're going to know what
a subpoena duces tecum is. And I love that.
I actually, I think that kids adore having niche knowledge
that their parents don't have.
Yeah. I gave it, I remember, to one test reader who was 11,
and he was dropping that subpoena
duces tecum stuff on his mom for the next four days.
And when I go give talks to kids in
schools, the level of their knowledge amazes me.
I got a question about exceptions to the judicial
warrant requirement for police to enter your house
from a fifth grader in Iowa last month.
So we don't realize how much our kids are listening.
They are paying attention to the news.
they hear what's happening all around us they have
a lot of legal questions and when you open
the door and you say here take this knowledge I'm going
to fold it into a story about a case
and by the time you read this you're going
to be able to handle a case just like this
it's very empowering for them and I think that it's
also good for them in the long term to know
what they're capable of yeah and I love like the little doodles
and you know like pictures it was
almost like a diary in a sense you know like how she created a list
when she was you know putting
her facts together you know before she went
and talked to the vice principal and just everything
about the book made it fun like i said i'm almost 30
and i was entertained with it and learned
things you know myself when it comes to laws
and different things like that and i think it's very
important to you know put that kind of information
in a way that kids can learn because their brains
are like sponges like anytime they can grasp something you know
or like you said like how he
was dropping the words and you know anything
to make them feel like you know i know something that
you don't you know like that's our goal
and especially when kids because nowadays we're in a
literary crisis like kids don't want to read there's
so many banned books that's going on
nowadays so it's like how can we get these this information
into the hands of kids and so you are
actually going to be here in michigan
um coming up soon on the 28th at schuler books so tell
everybody a little bit about this upcoming event yeah
so i'm going to be at schuler books in the
evening 6:30 p.m. on the 28th, I am really really excited I'm gonna come
and talk about the book
but whenever I go and talk about the book I'm
also totally there to give legal information
and legal trainings and know your rights trainings to kids
so if you are a parent and you're like
if all of your conversations about policing have been survival based
or if you're a parent and
you've had the luck to never have had to have
a conversation about police with your kids
come on over, we will talk about safety together
um we'll talk about the real facts about how many
kids give up their rights exactly as you describe.
And we'll talk about the impact that kids can have
once they're empowered with this information.
So it's a little bit about the book. It's a little
bit about Know Your Rights.
It's going to be, I guarantee you, your kids will have fascinating
legal questions if you just let them ask whatever
legal questions they have. That part is always
really, really fun. And then I think, you know,
the best feedback I've gotten from parents is that
kids gobble this book up in like 24 hours.
So maybe there'll be a kid or two. It's a quick
read, it's I tried to make it really hard to put down
so there might be some kids there for whom
we can talk about what they've already read
and I really really love writing empowering notes to
kids in the book so if you got a book please
bring it over if you want to get a book there
obviously they're going to be for sale I would really love
to turn your children into obnoxiously
empowered legal professionals yeah
and Emily before I let you go is there anything else that
you would like to say to fellow watchers and book readers out there?
Yeah, I think that we're in an
interesting moment.
And this book tour has been really illuminating for me about how much
destigmatizing conversations around
the criminal legal system can empower our children. One out of
three Americans has been arrested, just like me.
And the more we talk about it, the healthier the
conversation becomes because kids can share
the things that have been in the back of their minds
that they haven't wanted to ask.
I can't tell you how many times I've had a kid say, hey, my dad got
arrested. Can I ask you about it? Yeah.
These are conversations our children want to have. We
shouldn't be shying away from the subject matter
or treating it as different. Teaching our kids
about their rights is a safety process that we and parents can,
as parents, can engage in. And
I'm really excited to help make that conversation comfortable.
Well, Emily, thank you for what
you're doing, you know, sharing your knowledge for adults,
like for instance, in The Price and
Mercy, and then also for, you know, kids in Andromeda Story.
And I can't wait to read book
to you know when that one comes out
and thank you for taking the time to come and chat with me and
fellow book lovers out there we greatly appreciate it thanks
so much for having me it's great to be
here
