US President Donald Trump has announced the execution of Fort Hood shooter Nidal Hasan will not be accessible to the public via livestream. The plan was announced by Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth last week, and received criticism from across the political spectrum. Hasan - an army psychiatrist - was convicted of killing 13 soldiers at a US military base in 2009. His death sentence will be the first US military execution by firing squad since the end of World War Two. Chapters: 00:00 Trump: No livestream of Fort Hood shooter’s execution 00:44 DW correspondent Benjamin Alvarez Gruber reports 01:04 Why did the Trump administration reverse its original decision? 02:57 Significance of a pushback by retired army officers against Trump and Hegseth 04:41 Does potential public visibility of capital punishment allow conclusions about the current US government?
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI Generated
President Donald Trump has canceled plans to live stream the firing squad execution of Nidal Hasan, a convicted military shooter. The decision follows intense bipartisan criticism and opposition from high-ranking military officials, who argued that broadcasting the event would be barbaric and could turn the killer into a martyr.
Well, U.S. President Donald Trump says that the Pentagon will not live
stream the firing squad execution of a convicted military base shooter.
Now, the execution of Nidal Hasan, who gunned down 13 people
at Texas' Fort Hood back in 2009, is set for December.
Trump canceled the planned live stream after bipartisan criticism
and after Vice President J.D. Vance said that he would not watch it.
Earlier this month, Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth said
the former Army major's execution would be made public.
The Department of Defense confirmed that it would be live streamed.
No other country is known to live stream judicial executions.
All right, I want to go now to our correspondent,
Benjamin Alvarez Gruber.
He's on this story for us.
Benjamin, the president now says that only immediate families
or relatives of Hassan's victims will
be allowed to watch the execution in person.
Why this reversal?
So there was, as you just mentioned, a huge criticism,
not only from military, from former military,
but also bipartisan criticism, pushback against this plan
that was announced by Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth.
But you mentioned that J.D. Vance, the vice president,
was asked, and he said, I would rather not watch it.
So there were many questions surrounding this planned livestream
of this execution set for the start of December.
Indeed, it shows that there was not a collective
or thought approach by this administration.
They waited for a couple of days, but now we got this announcement,
a lengthy social media post by President Trump.
And indeed, the executions here in this country, there
is a very tight entry requirement to actually see those executions.
So close family members, journalists, witnesses.
And there was fear that this might have unintended consequences,
that they might lead other people
to actually commit several of these crimes.
several or be kind of inspired
also by this attack in Texas that you mentioned there or that he might
even look as a martyr with those pictures
and those videos basically being streamed worldwide
on Wednesday we saw dozens of retired admirals
and generals publish an open letter opposing
the plan to live stream this execution
and they wrote that the live streaming and i'm quoting here
turns what should be the solemn
and grave punishment of a member of our society
for committing the most serious crimes into a carnival
for the enjoyment of voyeurs and spectators.
How significant, Benjamin, is this pushback against the president
and his defense secretary, Pete Hegseth?
It is very significant to have members, former members of the military,
72 retired generals, admirals, military officers,
sending this letter for the Pentagon
is very significant they called this live stream the
idea and i quote a barbaric abuse of authority that would
also turn this mass killer into a
martyr and also the fact that they
are active military members that were already seeking an
exemption from participating in this execution show
that they were against the idea from the
beginning, once it was actually mentioned
by Defense Secretary Pete Texas.
What is important here that we also need to mention,
they are not against the capital
punishment in this case, against the conviction,
but they just were concerned about what image
this would project, not just for the United States,
also for the military that will conduct
this execution in early December,
but also that there might be others inspired and there
might be additional attacks on US citizens.
So it's very remarkable not only that they decided
to make this publicly to voice their
concerns and that adds up to the criticism,
bipartisan criticism, from both Democrats
and Republicans once this plan was announced by Texas.
And Benjamin, the fact that a live streamed execution
was even considered, what does that
tell us then about the notion of justice
and punishment within the halls of power in the
United States? So I think we need to be careful
to not over generalize by this idea. We don't know
how many people came up with this.
Secretary Hegseth said this during an interview with the U.S.
media. This has never happened before.
We don't know where this idea came from. And by getting
these immediate reactions,
I think Vice President J.D. Vance commented on it briefly after this
idea was first announced,
but it shows this debate that happened afterwards, show that
there are mixed reactions, not only to the live streaming,
but also of the idea of the
death penalty itself.
There are concerns, transparency,
accountability also on the public, and it shows when we look
at the United States that these discussions are happening,
not only about the fact that
this idea of the live stream that has now
been cancelled by the US president, but the
fact, what does it actually make of a society
that has a death penalty in place?
Yeah.
DW's Benjamin Alvarez Gruber with the latest tonight from Washington.
Benjamin, as always, thank you.