The Ghibli Movie That Inspired Oppenheimer

Movie Review
40 followers
I really wanted to do an in depth analysis/video essay on the fascinating similarities between Hayao Miyazaki's 'The Wind Rises' and Christopher Nolan's 'Oppenheimer,' so I made an in depth analysis/video essay on the fascinating similarities between Hayao Miyazaki's 'The Wind Rises' and Christopher Nolan's 'Oppenheimer'...
Chapters :
00:00 Chapter O
01:16 Chapter I
07:53 Chapter II
10:59 Chapter III
13:04 Chapter IV
ALL RIGHTS FOR FOOTAGE & MUSIC GO TO STUDIO GHIBLI, UNIVERSAL, WARNER BROS., MARVEL STUDIOS.
#videoessay #film #studioghibli #anime #animemovies
AI Generated·May contain errors
What do you think of when I describe this movie?
A dramatized biopic set during the time period of World War II,
focused on an engineer who made a weapon that caused the death of thousands,
who has to struggle between the love of his work and basic humanity and morality.
Odds are if I told you that description with no context,
you'd probably think of one of the biggest movies of the year, Christopher Nolan's Oppenheimer.
But in 2014, The Wind Rises was released.
It is a dramatized biopic set during the time period of World War II,
about an engineer who created a weapon that caused the death of thousands,
who has to struggle between the love of his work and basic morality.
Upon rewatching this in theaters in August,
I realized its striking and ironic similarities to Oppenheimer.
There are like really strange superficialities,
like the fact that both of the main characters wear hats and smoke cigarettes,
and also both their wives are played by Emily Blunt for some reason.
But way more interestingly,
the deeper themes and the cultural response to both of these films are eerily similar.
But maybe even more interestingly, the two are complementary.
The flashy breakneck pace of Oppenheimer really screams the themes at the audience,
while The Wind Rises' gracefully slow and deliberate pace
allows the audience to sit with the themes.
More than Oppenheimer, The Wind Rises tackles a relationship between a human and a dream.
In The Wind Rises, we follow Jiro Horikoshi.
His one and only dream forever is to be an aeronautical engineer,
basically to create airplanes.
He has literal dreams about this, and it's also his life's aspiration and his goal.
And throughout the course of the movie, with his passion, his genius, and his dream,
he does achieve that goal.
But he is also portrayed as having his head where his planes are,
both in the sky and sunken into his designs.
He is almost a removed protagonist, one who does his job and lets life happen to him.
He has a good heart, but it seems that his work is what he lives for,
and nothing and no one else.
The Wind Rises, the movie's namesake,
is based off a poem by French poet Paul Valéry.
At the tail end of his poem, The Graveyard by the Sea,
Valéry loudly proclaims,
The wind is rising.
We must try to live.
After reading this poem in full,
it's really obvious where Miyazaki got his inspiration for the movie from.
The poem reads as a push,
a sign to not just stand there and let life pass you by.
At the start of the poem,
the narrator observes a calm, open ocean,
and meditates on his inevitable and ever-approaching death.
It sort of portrays the complacency we feel
when we're in situations that don't provide us change or emotional value.
But the waves pick up,
then the water crashes,
and the wind rises,
and the narrator realizes something.
Through the energy that the waves, the wind, the water provided,
he must try to live.
We must try to live.
Jiro Horikoshi's journey in this film
is a journey to finally have him ground himself in reality,
to land.
Jiro is so invested in his work,
so invested in these airplanes
that he is always in this sort of dream state.
He never gets his head out of the clouds
until he meets her.
This is Naoko Satomi,
Jiro's love interest for the second half of the film.
Naoko is ill from tuberculosis
and tries to recover before marrying Jiro,
but eventually she can't stand being apart from him
and she starts living with him without being fully recovered.
They marry, but Naoko eventually gets worse
and she leaves,
trying to get better again,
but eventually dying.
After watching this film so much
in so many different parts of my life,
my affection towards Jiro has really diminished.
Through this all,
we see Naoko at her worst,
still being the most accommodating and caring partner
that someone like Jiro could ask for.
But Jiro doesn't change.
He works through the night
instead of sleeping with his love.
He's racing towards the finish line of his dream
while his wife is racing towards the finish line of her life.
Some nights he doesn't even come home to her.
He's in the clouds.
Countless studies show that
a general lack of commitment
is one of the top reasons for divorce in the United States.
It's not always because of work,
like in Jiro's case,
but it can be.
And the point is that the reasoning is the same.
When you choose to commit to someone,
that carries weight.
It carries responsibility.
You are choosing to be there in times of need,
to care,
and to carve out a significant amount of time for them.
And if that sounds scary or impossible,
you might not be ready.
Jiro Horikoshi was not ready.
Love, as unpredictable and scattered as it may be,
takes effort to maintain.
A romantic relationship requires constant effort from both sides
to love,
to care,
to understand wants and needs.
And there's this idea that stems from centuries of chauvinist marriages
that a man simply needs to work in a marriage
to provide for his one wife and two kids,
and that's enough.
Think of the fundamentals of a 1950s marriage
that you learned in high school history.
These marriages place the man in a position
to only care about his work
and really just financial security,
not his wife
and not really his kids.
Another thing that's really interesting about 1950s marriages
is that the divorce rate was only 0.25%,
so that shows that wives had to be forcibly complacent to this standard.
There is no question that women wanted to get out of these marriages,
but they didn't really have a choice at the time,
and subconsciously that has been passed down
throughout generations and throughout the world.
The idea that an initial burst of love
or even a contrived circumstance
is all you need for a marriage,
something that is reinforced by most films.
How many times is a man granted a woman's body, heart, and soul
after a single interaction or one fateful meeting?
There is no work put in by the man, only lust.
This is also an idea in Western religion
through the love cures all and love endures all mindset.
I would agree that love is one of the most powerful emotions
that can endure a lot,
but when it's portrayed in a religious sense,
it also implies that love doesn't necessitate care or action.
Again, the magic and unpredictability of love
does not grant you reason to be negligent.
Anyway, since women are at large
really watered down in cinema as people,
this magic spell of lust
or this magic moment that they experience with a man
is usually enough for them in most movies,
which is obviously extremely unrealistic.
But this is where The Wind Rises differs from its peers.
Though Naoko does fit the standards of a 1950s woman
in purely superficial ways,
Hayao Miyazaki's fully intentional feminism
shines through this green.
Naoko is caring in a way that doesn't make her a housewife,
but a woman who is so infatuated and in love with her partner
that she will do anything in her power to make him happy.
Not because society is forcing her to,
but because she needs to for herself,
for her love for Jiro.
But Naoko is also a woman who knows really what she wants
and what she needs, in this case, when to leave.
So she does leave Jiro without a trace,
not because of lost love, but out of self-respect.
So taking this all into account,
it's hard to see Jiro as anything else
but an uncaring husband.
His ground-level love for Naoko is undeniable,
but he is emotionally dry and inexperienced.
He doesn't know how to show his love,
or maybe he doesn't have time to show it,
but that's also no excuse.
The waves were picking up in his life.
His wife was sick.
Her cough was worsening by the day.
The wind was rising, but Jiro sat there at his desk
looking at airplane designs
while Naoko slipped through his graphite-covered fingers.
The downfall of so many relationships
comes down to not putting in the time.
Not putting in the time could be a lack of communication.
It could be infidelity.
It could be a simple case of lost love
because there's just no time being put in.
So dreams are dangerous.
They are something you can get lost in.
They are an unmatched motivator.
But as much as they are a motivator,
they are also a distraction from real life.
Jiro's story in this film should be a sign
to not wait idly by for things to happen to you.
It's classic Carpe Diem thinking
that you learned in high school English.
Seize life or it will pass you by.
When the wind rises, take a step back and try to live.
But beyond all of this, dreams are dangerous
in a different way.
More than The Wind Rises,
Oppenheimer portrays the guilt that comes
with getting lost in a dream
to the point where your morals are questionable.
There's really no reason for me to get into the moral dilemma
that J. Robert Oppenheimer faced in real life
or in the movie because it's been covered to death.
Basic idea though is that
when does genius become dangerous?
When does innovation actually make the world worse off?
You've probably formed your own answer by now
and that's not for me to tell you.
But what's way more interesting to look at
is both of the directors of these films.
Christopher Nolan is not so subtly comparing himself
to Oppenheimer.
Though an iconic filmmaker for other reasons,
Christopher Nolan is mainly known
for his Batman trilogy, at least financially.
Those films, whether you like it or not,
were the start of an irreversible,
unchangeable shift in the landscape of cinema.
After those films, superhero movies
were not low-budget jokes.
They made everything else look like a joke, financially.
And it's impossible to ignore the effect
that superhero films have had on the industry in general.
This is another thing I do not need to go deeply into
as there are so many other essays
explaining this exact same thing.
But Marvel and DC have taken up a lot of space
for low-budget films, have reduced so many actors
to just being known for one character,
and have had such a large cultural explosion
that it's impossible to open Instagram
or Twitter or YouTube without seeing Spider-Man
on your homepage.
Visual effects artists are worked to the bone
to pump out a dozen Marvel movies a year,
and writers are unable to live
due to a lack of residuals from streaming services.
You know, maybe some of this wasn't inevitable,
but Nolan definitely played a role
in at least accelerating superhero movies in cinema.
Nolan aided something that couldn't be stopped,
a chain reaction that, in the eyes of many,
destroyed the world of cinema.
So is it obvious the parallel that Nolan is making?
Oppenheimer created something that was revolutionary,
grand, and by many accounts, absolutely incredible.
But he also shattered the lives of thousands,
put hate in the hearts of millions,
and put fear in the hearts
of every single person on this planet.
Similarly, Nolan created something revolutionary,
grand, and on many accounts, absolutely incredible.
But were his creations good for movies
and the people who work on them?
Is it egotistical to project oneself
onto who many would call
one of the greatest scientists who ever lived?
I personally would say no.
Nolan isn't trying to say, I'm literally him.
He's using the film and the character as an allegory
to explain his own guilt to a wider audience
in a digestible way.
Similarly, Miyazaki shows the exact same thing
in The Wind Rises with his depiction of Judo.
Miyazaki is largely known
as the godfather of animation in Japan
and maybe even the world,
but Miyazaki has publicly stated
his distaste for Japanese anime.
Broadly, he has a problem
with how it portrays humans unrealistically.
He talks especially about
how modern anime fetishizes women
and, like many Western films,
dumbs them down for use by men.
This is everything that Miyazaki stands against,
but he was also one of the first steps in creating it.
Miyazaki just wanted to create
beautiful human animation,
but he also started something that he could not stop.
But as always, the cycle keeps on repeating.
Though The Wind Rises was heavily acclaimed,
it was also heavily caught up in controversy.
Essentially, it boiled down to many seeing the film
as morally repugnant.
There were sentiments that the movie dismissed
Japan's role in World War II
and ignored acknowledging the lives lost
because of their own actions.
Americans were largely angered
by not portraying the lives lost overseas
as well as the bombing of Pearl Harbor,
but Americans were not the only one
who thought this film was morally out of line.
Japanese nationalists have painted Miyazaki
as unloyal as he argues for pacifism,
paying reparations to women in China and Korea
for being sex slaves during World War II,
and completely denouncing Japan's reasoning
for going to war in the 40s.
In an interview, Miyazaki stated that Japan
caused trouble throughout the entirety of East Asia
and ultimately brought destruction to itself.
But Miyazaki did not make this movie
to denounce Japan's war crimes.
This film is about Jiro Horikoshi
and his moral dilemma.
It's about airplanes.
It is about what happens when your head
is so far up in the clouds
that you can't see what's below your feet.
It's about the danger of dreams
and the importance of love.
Miyazaki wanted to create something beautiful,
but the fallout was not something he asked for.
And more similarly, Nolan faced the same response.
A large portion of the Japanese audience
and some American audiences
felt that the film brushed past the reality
of the situation that it presents,
the struggle of the victims of this bomb,
and rather it focuses the audience
on the plight of the creator
of this weapon of mass destruction.
This issue is so nuanced,
but I believe that Oppenheimer's status
in pop culture has made these arguments very valid,
with, I'll say, unofficial merchandising
and its release alongside Barbie
making it feel a bit weird.
But the same that goes for Miyazaki
goes for Nolan.
Nolan was making the film he knew how to make,
telling the story he wanted to tell about himself,
because that's where stories come from.
He was simply projecting himself onto that screen.
And it was successful.
It's almost at a billion dollars now,
but its moral standing is up for you to decide.
So the eerie similarness between these two films
was really fascinating to research,
especially how these directors
put themselves onto the screen
and much of the audience didn't even realize.
And funnily enough,
these genius filmmakers who created this thing,
both caused fallouts that they did not intend to.
It's just like Oppenheimer's story,
like Jiro's real life story,
and the story of these two movies happened to them.
It's really incredible how all this repeated
and also really ironic
how these two films portrayed two sides of the war,
but with the same exact theme
and essentially the same exact response,
just on opposite ends.
I really hope you enjoyed watching this video.
The Wind Rises is one of my favorite films like ever.
So I was just really happy to make a video on it.
Yeah, I hope you learned something
and I hope you like and subscribe.
And yeah.
